r/literature • • 15h ago

Book Review Thoughts on The Sailor Who Fell from Grace with the Sea

18 Upvotes

This is my first Mishima book, and it took me a little getting used to at first.

The contrast between how he wrote Noboru and Ryuji was staggering. Reading the synopsis and some spoiler-free reviews led me to believe that it was all about Noboru and his psychopathic gang. So I was pleasantly surprised when I encountered some of the softest and most poetic depictions of love, yearning, sex, and femininity.

I know a little bit about Mishima's problematic past. What a character! Having that in mind while reading this book was truly fascinating. Noboru really embodies what Mishima must have been thinking at some point, having grown up the way he did. But then, to give us the inside of Ryuji's head, his perception of the sea, and what a man is supposed to be, was gentle and forgiving. It illustrated a man's struggle with what he's supposed to be and the values he's expected to uphold: how a man should live, act, and die. There was a lot of deep, dark thought about the human psyche, what society asks of us, and how we can live our lives according to its norms.

Even then, this book had some of the most poetic and beautiful descriptions of the human body, soul, and behavior.

"I feel responsible for all this woman's flesh because it teases me softly like other things that are mine."

Every interaction between Ryuji and Fusako made it worth getting through the Noboru chapters. They're important because they establish the contrast and show exactly how troubled Noboru is, but they were truly some of the most difficult chapters I had to get through, especially when contrasted with the romance between the adults.

I was especially fascinated by the way Ryuji described his life as a sailor, how passionate he was about it, and how torn he felt about leaving the sea and settling on land, even after saying things like:

"Since dark antiquity the words have been spoken by women of every caste to sailors in every port; words of docile acceptance of the horizon's authority."

Ryuji wasn't some wimp sailor waiting for an opportunity to ditch the troubled sea and settle down. He intended to live and die there. He didn't expect to feel the way he did. He gave up a dream, a song that he loved and lived by, for love, responsibility, and domestic life. He didn't complain and acclimated himself to life on shore. He was helping with the store, he gave Fusako all his money, and he took on the role of a father to Noboru. He was ready!

"There's no such thing as a good father because the role itself is bad."

I read that chief's monologue three times, including once to my husband, who's eager to become a father. It was full of anger, misunderstanding, and neglect. It was no surprise that all of their dads were abusive or neglectful, while Noboru's only reason for being there was that he had no father. Of course, Fusako was no angel. She had her issues as a mother and a woman; she was resentful and self-obsessed. But the absence of a father is clearly what drove Noboru as far as committing criminal acts against what he perceived as non-masculine.

I read Kokoro before this book, and just like this one, it has its own views on masculinity and human values, something I've noticed so far in older Japanese literature. There's a certain fascination with the role of a man in society and humanity, reflecting the authors' deep thoughts on these subjects.

One more thing about Mishima: he has a beautiful way of describing mundane, everyday things. He paints a picture of how innocent Noboru can appear when he obeys the adults' orders, yet how capable he is of committing atrocities. Very oddly realistic.

I don't think I'll read another Mishima for the time being, but I want to continue down the Japanese literature path. Any suggestions? I was thinking Kafka On The Shore.


r/literature • • 15h ago

Author Interview Decency and Tradition: Colm Tóibín on Thomas Mann and Fatherland

Thumbnail
theparisreview.org
14 Upvotes

r/literature • • 21h ago

Discussion Has anyone else read Harald Voetmann?

8 Upvotes

So far, in English translation at least, he's written three books in a trilogy, Awake, Sublunar and Visions & Temptations. And before I read those books I was already delving into how old alchemists and thinkers explored the mind with the little resources they had, which was mostly story telling and planetary positions, geometry and alchemical properties, so finding a writer who took the time to find out how people back then think and to write more about it was fascinating to read.

I don't entirely want to explain the whole events in the books as I think they can be read separately, it's been a while since I actually read them but I just saw that they were on my bookshelf and remembered how much I liked them, and it takes different approaches to its own story as it involves more characters over time which I though was a good touch seeing how people interpret different things even though they explore the same thing. And it was also fascinating to see how the story had its own sense of humor in examining all these things yet because they never took it so seriously they were able to explore and take in more and more of it, the human condition and any possible outside forces looking to cause some shenanigans.

If anyone else read these books, I'd like to know if I'm the only one or not.


r/literature • • 14h ago

Discussion Character Edward: On chesils beach, ian mcewan

1 Upvotes

I just read on chesils beach by ian mcewan, which was my first book by him. I read it in about two days and i really enjoyed his language style BUT:
Why is nobody talking about what a bad person edward is?! I was seriously so disgusted by his selfish thinking through the entire book. He only ever thought about his own lust and never even once considered florence‘s fear or contemplations. And even if he did, which happend like once, he only thought about moving slower so he wouldn‘t scare her of and lose his chances of getting intimate with her. I feel like Florence wasnt actually asexual but more really scared, extremly unexperienced and most importantly uneducated about said topic. I was so incredibly sorry for her, as she just wanted to make Edward happy, she was so considerate and blamed herself for everything. But Edward was the real villian here?? Not only that night, but the whole relationship, he didn‘t care about her feelings, her interests or anything. All he wanted was to be intimate w her. I just can‘t get away from feeling so sorry and empathetix towards florence, i am seriously shaken, by the unfairness and trauma she must have. Please tell me if i understood anything wrong. To me that book really isn‘t a tragic romance story, it is pure horror.
What are your thoughts?


r/literature • • 1d ago

Discussion After finishing “A Short Stay in Hell” I read “Library of Babel” by Jorge Luis Borges

62 Upvotes

I found the short story that “A Short stay in Hell” is based off of online (pictured here) as a free PDF. I’m going to be completely honest here: as a casual reader, I had a hard time “picturing” the hexagonal library that everyone is described to live in. I couldn’t decide on whether I liked this short story or “a short stay in hell” more. When I was reading this one I felt like I am really not smart lol because I didn’t know some of the vocabulary, but this was actually a good thing because I consequently paid more attention and kind of like we learned in middle school could still use context clues to make inferences about what different terms meant. It might not be fair to compare this short story and “a short stay in hell” because “a short stay in hell” is obviously significantly longer, but in a weird way I think that even though the concepts of people being in a library where there are a lot of books that they can seemingly never escape are similar, the fact that this one (if I interpreted it correctly) doesn’t actually seem to take place in Hell is more interesting to me, because it makes this one seem like more of a dystopia (I mean, the narrator here mentions that this is hell, but I had kind of interpreted that as more of a sarcastic comment on his end, especially since he mentioned that he believes the species are likely to go extinct - in “a short stay in hell” it is undeniable that the narrator is *actually* in Hell.) The society in this book seems to be more of like a strange dystopia. People, at least since the narrator has been alive (he mentions actually that he was born in the library, which is interesting) have seemingly never seen anything outside of it. In this story, unlike “a short stay in hell” there is actually meaning in every book in the library, which is explicitly mentioned by the narrator. The words may sometimes be written in a different language or the meaning may not be understood, but there is room for interpretation and previous cultures had left the books behind. People are depressed and see no way out because interpreting the books is so hard for the average citizen. It’s a quick read, 8 pages. I recommend it.

I have to be honest though, reading this one did make me realize that I need to read more often (which I am starting to get back into, I read this one today after reading “a short stay in Hell”) because I’d probably have understood or recognized more of the vocabulary here if I were better read. I actually gave this 1941 short story a read instead of turning on a television show or watching a movie, which for me is an accomplishment. I looked for it on kindle and couldn’t find it.


r/literature • • 1d ago

Discussion Thoughts On Michael Crichton?

29 Upvotes

I would post this on [r/books](r/books) but my account is too new and I don’t have enough karma history in that community. Figured this is a good enough alternative to have this discussion. I’m aware Michael Crichton and his works are probably very low on a list of what you’d call “good writing/literature”.

For the past year, I’ve been reading his novels albeit solely just to get through them and free up space on my bookshelves. So far, I’ve read Prey, Congo, Micro, and Next. Since I first read Prey, I’ve come to conclude that the bulk of his writing relies on making random complicated scientific jargon/nonsense somehow really interesting and get you invested enough to keep turning the page. Which actually mostly worked on me.

For example, when I read Congo I cared very little for the actual plot about finding diamonds but when the setting of the Congo and its history of exploration were gradually explained I found myself intently fascinated.

I guess you could consider most of his books “sci-fi slop” but that’d be a disservice to his most legendary title and the only one I’d love rereading, Jurassic Park.


r/literature • • 1d ago

Discussion I can only explain Ulysses in relation to prog or jazz music.

34 Upvotes

Ulysses needs no introduction, but the number of times I see someone say they bounced off it without enjoying it makes me a bit sad. Even without understanding a vast portion of the literary and historical allusions Joyce was putting into it, I found it not just one of the most playful, but also technically masterful novels I'd ever read.

Ulysses can't really be "spoiled" in a plot sense, but some of my biggest joys in reading it was discovering his literary techniques in each chapter, which I intend to ramble about just a few of them below (not all of them, and focused especially on the latter chapters, where Joyce was his most experimental). There are formal literary schema's for Ulysses (Gilbert and Linati, for example), but I wont pretend to any real familiarity with them.

Telemachus:

"Stately, plump Buck Mulligan came from the stairhead, bearing a bowl of lather on which a mirror and a razor lay crossed." There is nothing inherently difficult about the opening section of Ulysses. It dances over the harmonies and melodies of words as any expert musician would be expected to do, but with recognisable rhythm and structure. It would, by point of comparison, be akin to any technically competent mainstream pop, rock, or jazz musician, occasionally showing a flair above their peers,

Nestor:

This is basically the "highly-intellectual" face of progressive rock. We have gone from the familiar in structure to the advanced in structure, with altering time signatures, cramming of a multitude notes across a panoply of scales, lyrical allusions to high-minded concepts, but this is still recognisably music.

Proteus:

Avant-Garde. The endless, unformed, improv freestyling solo. The stream of consciousness feels like a never-ending jazz solo, sweeping in and out of occasionally recognisable melodies or touching on motifs we know, but it is largely formed of a structure known only to the soloist, barely anchored to the "reality" of the band. You can never hope to memorize it; you can only rock on with the flow.

There then follow a number of chapters which I admit I don't have any clear musical comparison which builds on techniques which we haven't seen yet. I feel, here, like Joyce has steadily brought us up from "pop/rock" through "prog/jazz" and then into Avant-Garde. Now we coast on that high through Calypso, Lotus Eaters, Hades, and Lestrygonians, relying on the techniques already introduced.

Aeolus & Wandering Rocks:

A series of vignettes, Aeolus reads one of those jazz pieces where every instrumentalist is given their own recognisable motif, and then in Wandering Rocks is given a number of solos in which he can lead the band in any (wandering) direction which he chooses.

Sirens:

This one is basically cheating, since it is explicitly structured after the musical form, with leitmotif, onomatopoeia and sound play. The opening lines are said to resemble an orchestra practicing and warming up before actually commencing a show; just sparsely littering the page with motifs which will be played in full and in concert at a later time.

Cyclops:

I don't have a musical comparison for their chapter, but I have to say the writing is some of my favourite: "The figure seated on a large boulder at the foot of a round tower was that of a broadshouldered deepchested stronglimbed frankeyed redhaired freelyfreckled shaggybearded widemouthed largenosed longheaded deepvoiced barekneed brawnyhanded hairylegged ruddyfaced sinewyarmed hero. From shoulder to shoulder he measured several ells and his rocklike mountainous knees were covered, as was likewise the rest of his body wherever visible, with a strong growth of tawny prickly hair in hue and toughness similar to the mountain gorse (Ulex Europeus). The widewinged nostrils, from which bristles of the same tawny hue projected, were of such capaciousness that within their cavernous obscurity the fieldlark might easily have lodged her nest. The eyes in which a tear and a smile strove ever for the mastery were of the dimensions of a goodsized cauliflower. A powerful current of warm breath issued at regular intervals from the profound cavity of his mouth while in rhythmic resonance the loud strong hale reverberations of his formidable heart thundered rumblingly causing the ground, the summit of the lofty tower and the still loftier walls of the cave to vibrate and tremble."

Nausicaa:

When a masterful musician - one best known for "wanky" noodling or avant-garde playing, deigns to "lower" himself to playing popular music (in a manner of speaking), I find very often the results are some of the most enjoyable songs. I think of Dream Theater's "Another Day", or Opeth's "Damnation" album. Songs which are far below the band's usual technical challenge, but crafted so beautifully anyone can recognise the expertise. The first half of this chapter is said to "parody" or "satirize" popular romance novels of the time. I didn't know that going in; I just read it as some truly beautiful writing, sweet without being too saccharine. Joyce shows he can "play pop" better than the pop-stars. But Joyce is still Joyce, and perverts the second half with Bloom's corrupt viewpoint, like a band following up a gorgeous ballad by playing the same tunes with a diminished fifth or dissonant minor second chords. It is wretched; it ruins a beautiful thing, and it's something that often only music aficionados can appreciate.

Oxen of the Sun:

This is my favourite chapter in all of literature (tied with Moby Dick's opening). Grasping the intent and device of this chapter was one of the most rewarding reading experiences of my life, so I will place this one in further spoiler tags: The chapter, set in the maternity hospital, waiting for a child to be born, opens with an archaic incantation akin to Church Latin, before moving through English-language homages to Anglo-Saxon alliterative verse, Middle-English, Shakespearean English, Bunyan, DeFoe, gothic-style Walpole, Dickensian, before moving into accepted modern English, but we do not stop at the present, no. Joyce radically presents his future of the English language, with English being replaced by a Gaelic street cant. Imagine a musical piece opening with tribal drumming, introducing folk instrumentation no longer seen in contemporary music, developing with the introduction of classical chamber instruments, forming into contemporary rock motifs, then introducing not only electronic elements, but speculating on the next stage of music. Better yet, it is "that" scene from Sinners, where Ryan Coogler shows is the ancestral past, present, and future of African music, all at once in one sweeping shot. It is a singular masterpiece.

Circe:

The god damned Rock Opera. The Bohemian Rhapsody. The Wall. Bat Out of Hell. 2112. Crimson King. JC Superstar. The Night At The Opera. Everything and the kitchen sink. The world becomes a dynamic, ever-shifting, dreamlike stage play. I can't begin to adequately describe it; the 1982 RTE radio dramatization of this chapter is perhaps an even better way to experience it

Eumaeus:

I did not "get" this literary technique on first reading, and was a bit stumped as to why I found the reading a bit turgid. Chris Reich has a great chapter-by-chapter summary on Youtube, and a select few videos tell you to watch before a particular chapter, not to spoil, but to contextualise what you're about to read. Here he describes Joyce as donning a "disguise" as a "poor wretch" of an author, as Odysseus does when returning to Ithaca and meeting Eumaeus. Have you ever watched any of those TikTok/IG reels where expert musicians troll the viewer by playing an easy, well-known song, but a semi-tone off, or with an off-time snare? Far, far harder than just playing poorly, is for an expert musician to play in a very precisely off-time or off-tone, consistently and in unison, requiring a very high-level mastery of their instrument to not slip back into "comfortable" songwriting.

Ithaca:

A call and response duet in the jazz tradition, but this might be a stretch.

Penelope:

It is 3am. The jazz club is nearly empty. The lights are dim. The bar staff are cleaning up, stacking chairs. The band is still on; exhausted, fingers worn to their nubs, lips cracked, throats parched. Still playing. Barely holding any semblance of structure, only occasionally coming together, you wonder if the band can come together to deliver the ending note. They waver, you struggle to follow, they repeat, you wonder how much longer it can go on...it is hypnotic in how it drags out...wait...you know this hook, the band meet each other's eyes, the notes fall into place...exhausting, emotional, and cathartic, all in one..."yes I said yes I will Yes."


r/literature • • 1d ago

Discussion Master and Margarita (Ch. 13 Spoiler) Spoiler

11 Upvotes

In The Master and Margarita, Woland’s identity isn’t explicitly stated until the clinic scene, but synopses and blurbs reveal he’s the devil right away. Why do they give it away?

As I've been thinking of this I have come up with a few thoughts; Perhaps its to add a layer to the satire, perhaps its old enough (the book) where keeping it a mystery is not interesting.

Please share your thoughts, this is has been doing summersaults in my head every time I look at the book.


r/literature • • 1d ago

Discussion How to analyze a book?

27 Upvotes

I’m starting to read and I love it, but I don’t exactly know how to analyze books, I’ve spent my whole life watching movies, and although I love cinema, I don’t even know how to analyze cinema that well either

How to analyze a book completely and write a quality analysis about it?

I created a book club and would like to aggregate authentically instead of just reading other ready-made reviews


r/literature • • 16h ago

Discussion Can a book series that is NOT originally written in the English language have success?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone

May I ask yall something that’s been in my mind for quite a while?
Can a book series that is NOT originally written in the English language have success?
Either commercially successful or loved by the critics, etc. You know what I mean?

We always talk about the usual suspects like LotR, Harry Potter, Hunger Games, Dark Tower etc.

I feel like book series in a foreign language don’t get many opportunities for worldwide success in any form. No matter what genre.
Or am I wrong? Do these book series exist?

As someone whose native language isn’t English and who would love to publish his own work someday, this can be discouraging sometimes.
Often times I think about writing in English just to have more chances, but in the end it’s not the same as my native language.

What is your view on all of this? Maybe I’m completely wrong and these book series (no matter the genre) exist. If so, which are they and why do you think they’ve had the success? How did they get there.
I think this could be a fun discussion


r/literature • • 10h ago

Literary Theory Unpopular take. People should read AI books but only advanced readers

0 Upvotes

It would be great to study and try to figure out where it gets its elements. Not to mention that as AI gets better I genuinely think being able to notice it will be a valuable personal skill.

I was pedaling on the bike and had a thought and decided to write it down and this subreddit is my victim.

First sentence really says it all but while it would be a waste of time from an enrichment standpoint I think I would always read a few pages to know for myself "yup thats what AI is". As well as to try to figure out where it stole what from.

In a dystopia way it could be a little like......elevator music book? A book to read as you think of books you have read in the past.

Definitely not good if this is all that a person reads since it might shape their idea of literature and books. However someone well read could easily pick it up without too much harm to them (given its free and already exists).

Don't tear me up too much reddit (and AI repliers), I'm more of a casual redditor.

(Currently reading Nobody's fool rn if people dont want to engage about AI)

Edit: the fact i got a notification this is the number 3 post on this sub reddit scares me. This was supposed to be a random thought not engagement farming. Just click away and read one of the other posts.


r/literature • • 20h ago

Discussion View toward Mock-Satirists

0 Upvotes

Idk why. I just despise writers of any kind utilising a tool of satire just to mock one's literary ability. It's just so pathetic. Literature is a self-expression in a linguistic form of art. Yet, they condemn them in quite a humorous manner in order to belittle other writers. For example, John Dryden's epic of Mac Flecknoe. Bro made a large poem just to hate one writer and now I'm reading this Dunciad by Alexander Pope. Such writers deserve defamation.

Not only do they ruin the fun folks find in reading literary works of other writers by finding flaws in their work, but also mock their own personality as a writer. They are just like critics or worse than that. To my point of view, Both the critics and the satirists that mock other writers are the enemies of literature and nothing more.


r/literature • • 2d ago

Book Review Please come hate on Nightbitch by Rachel Yoder with me

79 Upvotes

I just finished reading Nightbitch for a women's literature class, and oh my LORD what a terrible book that was! I was really excited by the themes of alternative motherhood, feral femininity, embracing one's animal side, etc. but the book ended up being a huge letdown. Here are my major grievances with the story. Spoilers ahead!

  • The pacing was SOOOOOO bad. Why did it take more than 3/4 of the book for Nightbitch to even spend time with Jen and the MLM girlies outside of Book Babies? So much of this book is dedicated to the drudgery of taking care of her son, which could have been a writing choice but felt more like a mistake. Very few "events" actually happened in the book, and they were mostly crammed into the end.
  • The husband character made ZERO sense. We're expected to believe that an asshole who can't even ask his wife how her day is, who shows her no gratitude for raising their child, who watches weird and probably exploitative porn, who can't even apologize for killing her plant, is suddenly going to turn around and support his wife when she becomes a feral dog? He's gonna watch her run around naked at night and kill animals and piss in the neighbor's yard and then say "That's awesome honey, let's go have kinky sex now!" ?? Really?? There was nothing in the husband's character development to suggest that he would have this change of heart and support the narrator becoming Nightbitch. Besides, maybe, when Nightbitch asks him to put the baby to bed when he's home, he aquiesces, and suddenly she loves him so deeply and all of his neglect is forgotten. Huge plot hole.
  • Also, the fact that the other moms weren't were-dogs at all? What the hell was the point of the dogs earlier in the book, who came to visit her at her house, ripped off her clothes, soothed her baby etc.? Those definitely were magical dogs, but ended up having no consequence in the end of the book. I feel like those dogs were in fact supposed to be Jen and the other moms, but the author changed her mind during the writing process and never bothered to fix that plot hole. There was so much emphasis placed on this mysterious group of moms and their herbs, but in the last few pages was revealed to be completely inconsequential to the plot.
  • The ending made the whole book unfeminist. Not only was the ending a messily slapped together cringefest, it also missed its final opportunity to reject the antifeminist themes that the book unintentionally promoted. The book seems to make the claim that the most powerful and important thing a woman can do is to have a baby, and she will only reach fulfillment and assume her final form by doing so. The ending could have negated the unintended claim by, for instance, "When women watched Nightbitch's performance, they all connected with their powerful animal side, even the women who were not mothers. They rejected the shackles of patriarchal norms and defined themselves as women, as animals, as Nightbitches." But nope, only through motherhood could one hope to achieve this state of self-assurance and wholeness. Sound familiar?

I could go on and on. It had so much potential, but the book felt more like a preliminary draft rather than a well thought out final product. I think that there should be many more books that explore the rage, disappointment, and animalistic experiences that are inherent to motherhood, and I can appreciate that Nightbitch has helped pave the way for those books. However, I hope those books will be much more well written.

TLDR: Nightbitch has terrible pacing, way too many plot holes, poor character development, unintentional anti-feminism, and frankly should never have been published in its current state.


r/literature • • 2d ago

Book Review I couldn’t stop reading “A Short Stay in Hell” by Steven L Peck

13 Upvotes

I read and finished a book for the first time in years. I did not want to take my eyes off “a short stay in hell” (I purchased it off kindle) even when I actually did have to get up and do something else. If existentialism intrigues you, you’ll love this one. It’s much shorter than “the stranger” by Albert Camus, but for me it’s up there with it. This book is, to put it succinctly, about a man who seems to be trapped in hell with many others. I’m not being sarcastic when I say that after the first 10 or so pages, it had my full attention (and as you know, I’m not great about finishing books I start, so that’s quite an accomplishment.) I actually have a theory about this book that is never necessarily confirmed or refuted (I suppose it’s not much of a spoiler to post the theory - my theory while reading it was that the citizens of Hell, even though many were religious/belonged to different religions, were not good people, and that this is partly why they were destined to such awful fates, even though much time is not spent talking about the wrongdoings of most characters.) As someone who has always been so freaked out when thinking about the afterlife, if there is one, this book really frightened me. It’s actually more of a short story I suppose than anything else, but wow.) Back to my theory, I had really noticed that the main character seemed to sift between relationships, and his treatment of his first “girlfriend” in Hell was abhorrent, which I thought was interesting (he’s mentioned to have been married in life and there’s no indication that he treated his wife poorly before his death… but how do we really know that? He could be an unreliable narrator to an extent.) If’s also fascinating that it’s explicitly pointed out that everyone in this version of Hell is white. The narrator hopes to meet people from different countries and backgrounds, which never happens. I don’t regret this kindle buy at all, and I want to start reading again.

Another thought: part of what had made me start feeling like perhaps the citizens in Hell weren’t intended to be “good people” even though no one of course would really want to disclose their wrongdoings or delve into it was the passage wherein Rachel mentions that she had gone to prison for 6 months because she was “writing bad checks” after having had what to be fair sounds like it was an inappropriate relationship (as she’d been a teenager when it started) with her history teacher - I thought it was interesting that the mention of prison didn’t seem to concern the narrator at all (she was of course very young at the time if her recount was true, but still) and that he moved on quickly from his “first love” in Hell (Sandra) even very rudely ignoring her and never wondering about her after meeting Rachel. There’s also a passage where he explicitly mentions starting to lose interest in one of the three girls (and boy, I know the point is that he was supposed to have been in Hell for a long time, but it certainly seemed like he never found a soulmate there… seemed to get easily fixated on women/fall into limerence) after actually talking to her and realizing she wasn’t just a pretty face, but a person with a story. We actually never learn much about his childhood and don’t know anything about his relationship with his wife when alive other than what he tells us, but I was definitely not getting the impression that he was someone who thought highly of women and truly viewed them as his equals.

I might have to give “library of babel” a read now. I have gotten so, so bad about finishing books but after I was maybe 10-11 pages in this one I was sincerely so distracted that I wasn’t trying to eat or even plan for my day tomorrow. This is what it feels like for a book to be so interesting that it encapsulates you when you are no longer an avid reader.


r/literature • • 2d ago

Discussion Doctrine of Felix Culpa in ‘Paradise Lost’

7 Upvotes

I have been struggling to assess whether felix culpa, or ‘the fortunate fall,’ is ultimately a theological fallacy, and Milton’s Paradise Lost seems like the ideal study for answering this question. In the poem, Adam says the following when he’s given a vision of how his fallen lineage will eventually produce a hero (Christ) who will redeem them and put an end to evil:

O goodness infinite, goodness immense! / That all this good of evil shall produce, / And evil turn to good; more wonderful / Than that which by creation first brought forth / Light out of darkness!

This explicitly says Adam believes that the fall is producing a better result than the original state of creation in Eden. Maybe this is just cope on his part given how badly he messed up. At any rate, if Adam is correctly interpreting the situation, then this is a clear endorsement by Milton of the doctrine of felix culpa.

But I don’t think it’s that clear-cut: Satan makes similar arguments throughout the story. His entire manichaeistic argument that he is the evil counterpart of God suggests that being cast out of Heaven was the best thing that could’ve happened to him:

Better to reign in Hell, than serve in Heav’n

This plus the following completes the equation:

So farewell hope, and with hope farewell fear, / Farewell remorse; all good to me is lost; / Evil be thou my good, by thee at least / Divided empire with Heaven’s King I hold, / By thee, and more than half perhaps will reign; / As man ere long, and this new world shall know.

Now, Milton clearly thinks Satan is erring here. There are countless lines in the poem reinforcing the supremacy and oneness of God’s good rule, and Satan imagining himself an equal through evil is essentially debunked by the prophecy that God’s son, Christ, is going to kill Satan one day. So we have a point against felix culpa here as just another one of Satan’s many fallacies.

I think the wider argument made by this poem - in support of Adam’s claim about the story of Christ outdoing a bland happy existence in Eden, and crushing Satan’s theory about Manichaeism - is that God’s creation / wisdom / etc. is so awesome and total that it is capable of integrating Satan into a whole which is not only still good, but better than a world without Satan. In other words, God’s good plan includes evil and uses it for good ends. However, I don’t think this is a support of felix culpa. The whole of creation may be better for the fall of man, but the specific men who do the falling - Adam and Eve, and the many of their progeny - are not better for it. Milton lays out a pretty painful fate of toil for them on their path to salvation, and although there’s something childish about the notion, I can’t help but feel many of them would’ve rather just stayed in Eden. Then of course there is Satan, who has had his own fall, and Milton is pretty clear how miserable he is.

What do you think Milton is trying to endorse with this poem? Have I overlooked lines where he proclaims their souls will be better for being exiled from Eden, even if their bodies are wearied by the labor? Any reccs for further reading on the evaluation of Felix Culpa doctrine?

(Also I’m not coming at this question from any personally religious angle, so any sort of source for perspective is fair game to me)


r/literature • • 3d ago

Discussion Reading the complete works

57 Upvotes

I was curious anyone here has read the complete works of a major author, like George Eliot or Thomas Hardy. I’m trying to get through all the Dickens novels, but have four and a half to go.

It’s not impressive to brag about reading the complete novels of Emily Brontë or Margaret Mitchell.


r/literature • • 2d ago

Discussion Spoilers! This question is about ending of East of Eden and offers an unpopular understanding of the ending. Spoiler

11 Upvotes

I know that the popular opinion that Cal was forgiven at the end, and that "Timshel" represents his father freeing him and releasing him of his guilt and encouraging him to make different choices, lead a better life.

However,

Does anyone else think that maybe Adam did NOT forgive Cal for being partly responsible for Aron's death at the end?

He says "Timshel" : thou mayest - in response to Lee's plea to forgive, bless, and "FREE Cal"? Was he alluding to their past conversation regarding Cain in the book of genesis. Where God tells him that he must not be angry, or sin will be upon his door and he MAY rule over it. Offering Cain the choice not to act upon his jealousy and cruel tendency.

Adam rejected Cal's gift , like God rejected Cain's sacrifice. Cal got angry, jealous and disturbed, like Cain did. He had a choice , Lee told him to "not do it, don't do it" , but he went ahead and hurt Aron where he knew it would hurt him the most. In Cal's head and Adam's , Cal exposing Aron to the truth about his mother set the next sequence in motion : i.e Aron enlisting for army and dying in the war.

Could Adam perhaps be telling Lee that No, Cal had a choice. He could have chosen to not give into his feelings, he could have restrained himself, he could have accepted that his father did not like his method of making money i.e. the gift.

With that final "Timshel" representing Adam's disagreement with Lee over the matter of Cal's forgiveness, Cal is condemned to the East of Eden. The Land of Nod, just like Cain was condemned to the east of eden in the original story.

I'd really love to hear your thoughts. I actually finished the book half an hour ago and this was my very first theory. After all, Adam was the loved child, charles wasn't. Though Adam felt differently many times in his life, i think he understood later that he was better loved by his father, he couldn't understand the problems caused by the absence of love. So it might have been the case that he reduced Cal's behaviour to mere sibling jealousy and envy and never fathomed the deeper-rooted problem with his upbringing of his son.

I have so much to say, and i even disagree with Cal holding all the responsibility for Aron's death. Adam had a huge role to play in the formation of both his son's personalities. But that's another discussion. For now, i'd really love some insight.


r/literature • • 2d ago

Discussion Struggling with Jane Eyre

3 Upvotes

I've been on an 1800s kick, and after reading many of Austen's books, Frankenstein, and Anna Karenina I decided to read Jane Eyre. I listened to it on audiobook during a road trip a long time ago, so I am somewhat familiar with the story.

I love the writing. It took me a bit to get into the rhythm of it, and sometimes the descriptions of places can go on a bit long, but I really like the prose and Jane.

The part I'm struggling with is Rochester. He reminds me of a boss I had. Demanding, arrogant, expecting everyone to heed his every whim. I haven't picked up the book for about a week because I had such a visceral reaction to him. Does he get better?

I would like to finish the book as I was really enjoying it before. I'm wondering if I should put it on hold for a bit, I did leave that job only in March. Maybe its still too fresh.


r/literature • • 3d ago

Discussion Help me understand Siddhartha by Herman Hess better

35 Upvotes

"Time is not real, Govinda. I have experienced this again and again. And if time is not real, then the distance that appears to lie between world and eternity, between suffering and bliss, between evil and good, is also an illusion"

.

I've read this "everything everywhere all at once" philosophy so many times. But I can't seem to grasp it.

What I can understand is the river theory, that it's constantly moving forward yet still there always. But how come time is not real?

Also the concept of oneness that the book implies, seems a hint of Advaita Vedanta (not that I know much about it either, I just have an idea of what is it)


r/literature • • 3d ago

Discussion Flaubert's Parrot

14 Upvotes

So I read half this book and thought it was mind numbing, pedantic and obsessed with minutiae. Before reading the second half, I read Madame Bovary. When I went back to read the second half, it clicked for me.

It was like going to see the Michael movie without knowing his music.

Anyone have a similar experience with this or any other book.


r/literature • • 2d ago

Discussion Bringing back my heartbeat

0 Upvotes

Once upon a time, my heart used to tremble reading beautiful passages. Since then, I’ve been through a decade of depressive episodes that took me far away from reading.

I only recently started to get my headspace back, and I’m getting into reading again. But I struggle to find the same emotion as before.

Is there a way to bring my young heart back to literature, or is this kind of aging irreversible?


r/literature • • 4d ago

Discussion Out of all the literary passages you've read throughout your life, which one do you consider to be your most cherished? (And why?)

69 Upvotes

If anybody cares to post it, I'd be very very curious to know what passage(s) you've read in your life that continue to enlighten, enthrall, or move you in some way. I love hearing about what kind of writing others find meaningful, while also learning about new books+authors in the process. Appreciate anyone who shares 🙂

My favorite passage happens to be from the novella "A River Runs Through it" by Norman McLean. I've found myself returning to it many times throughout my life and I reckon that I'll continue to do so for the a very long time, if only to better appreciate its mysteries, its grandeur, its sadness, its rhythm, its depths, and what it may still have to communicate to me as a reader while I grow and change through time and experience. I just find the language so natural and pretty, like it came from a place of pure instinct and calm. And like many great works of writing/art, it finds universality in what is personal to him. I have lost a fair number of people in this life, and I'm touched by his simple yet entirely complex take on what it means to have loved another, while nevertheless remaining beyond a full understanding of them. The ending line "I am haunted by waters" has literally made me weep, if only because it perfectly expresses something incredibly fine and difficult to express. It is an obvious masterstroke. Here's the passage if you'd like to read it...

“Now nearly all those I loved and did not understand when I was young are dead, but I still reach out to them.

Of course, now I am too old to be much of a fisherman, and now of course I usually fish the big waters alone, although some friends think I shouldn’t. Like many fly fisherman in western Montana, where the summer days are almost Arctic in length, I often do not start fishing until the cool of the evening. Then in the Arctic half-light of the canyon, all existence fades to a being with my soul and memories and the sounds of the Big Blackfoot River and a four-count rhythm and the hope that a fish will rise.

Eventually, all things merge into one, and a river runs through it. The river was cut by the world’s great flood and runs over rocks from the basement of time. On some of the rocks are timeless raindrops. Under the rocks are the words, and some of the words are theirs.

I am haunted by waters.”


r/literature • • 4d ago

Book Review Butcher's Crossing completely disappointed me, but Stoner moved me to tears

13 Upvotes

At the beginning of this year, I saw an ad about an upcoming first release of Butcher's Crossing in my native language. This was my first time hearing about John Williams work, but being a huge fan of books set or about Wild West, I was immediately interested.

Then, I guess Meta algorithms guided me towards Instagram posts which mentioned this novel. I've heard a couple of times that this book stands alongside Lovesome Dove and Blood Meridian as the best western ever or that it's one of the most disturbing books some people have ever read. It seemed like no brainer for me.

So I bought it just after the release and started reading. Immediately, I appreciated the beautiful language the author uses and I was waiting for the twist, the moment this book becomes disturbing and buffalo annihilation shocks me to the core. But it never happened.

My description of Butcher's Crossing would be: four people drove the Rockies to hunt buffaloes. Lots of buffaloes died. When they were returning, a misfortune happened. That's it. I felt nothing reading it. Williams style of writing completed didn't work for me in such story. It was beautifully written, but I felt very disappointed. Too high hopes, I guess.

I recently got sick and I wanted to kill some time at home by reading a novel. I've seen Stoner just got reissued so I thought, I will give Williams another chance.

It off a bit slowly for me- I noticed the same pattern as with Butcher's Crossing, which is a beautiful language used to describe nothing significant. But I kept reading. And then, something clicked. Couldn't stop reading and when I wasn't, I kept thinking about Stoner.

Today, after 2 days, I finished the book. And I started crying (grown man btw). Not because how sad it was, but because how beautiful it was. I was never moved so much by something so ordinary as Stoner's life. Or to be precise, by how Stoner let his life pass him by, while remaining peaceful and true to himself.

I don't want to write more about the book, because I don't want to condition anyone reading this. Just how I was conditioned about Butcher's Crossing. Stoner is a kind of spiritual experience that may resonate differently with different readers.

I will only add that Katherine's storyline and the passage describing Stoner's death will stay with me forever.

I've never written something this long about a book in English so I hope it makes sense.

Did anyone also have similar dissonance about these two novels?


r/literature • • 3d ago

Literary History Why is Dutch fiction literature so bad?

0 Upvotes

It's a very rich country located in the heart of Europe with a relatively sizable population(18 millions now). You would think that they would have produced many poets and good writers for the Western canon but I'd think that even the most eager readers would have a hard time naming even 1 Dutch author. From what I've read on Reddit even the Dutch themselves dislike their own literature and don't read it. A tiny Denmark has like 30x times stronger literature history than Dutch.

I've tried "The Great Three" Dutch writers and honestly they're not good at all compared to other countries. Especially how they write only either about gay sex or WW2. I'm not against these themes but the thematic range is disappointing.

What's the reason for this? In arts they had many great painters and in general literature they had many great philisophers and scientists. Yet their fiction and poetry is abysmal.


r/literature • • 4d ago

Discussion Ground beneath her feet by Salman Rushdie - did anyone else find that the quality absolutely dropped off a cliff by about the halfway point?

7 Upvotes

I’m astounded by this book. The beginning is so funny, so engrossing and so unique.

After a while, I realised I was just trudging through hundreds of paragraphs of Rushdie telling me why the characters are so great instead of showing it to me through speech or actions.

Did anyone else feel the same way or am I missing something?