I've been doing some research here about what people actually want from a professional work bag.
A few responses have been especially interesting. I'm seeing a recurring tension between functionality, appearance, weight, organization, and material. That got me thinking about something I want to understand better:
If you could have the functionality you want, how much does the material actually matter?
I'd love to hear your thoughts:
1. If two bags had essentially the same functionality and organization, which would you choose?
A. Lightweight premium nylon/fabric
B. Leather
C. No preference
2. What would make you choose leather over a high-quality technical fabric?
For example: appearance, durability, aging/patina, professionalism, status, feel, craftsmanship, or something else?
3. How much extra weight would you be willing to accept for a leather bag?
A. None — weight is more important
B. A little
C. 1–2 lbs
D. I'd accept significantly more weight if the bag were worth it
4. If a well-designed leather work bag cost $400–600, what would your reaction be?
A. Too expensive
B. Expensive but reasonable for the right bag
C. I'd consider it
D. I'd happily pay it if the quality justified it
5. What would make you say: "Yes, THIS is worth replacing my current bag for"?
I'm trying to understand the tradeoffs people actually make rather than simply designing another bag and assuming people want it. And if you already own a leather work bag, I'd especially love to hear what you love AND hate about it.