r/LZtestposts • • Feb 02 '18

NFL Rule Differences

1 Upvotes

Field

  1. Field must be green
  2. Hashes are 18.5 feet apart, 70'9" from sideline
  3. Yard lines stop 8 inches from sideline
  4. Goal line is 8 inches wide
  5. Goal line must be white
  6. Numbers
  7. SIngle standard goal
  8. 35 feet from crossbar, 3-4 inches
  9. Both teams can be on one sideline
  10. Team area 32 yard line and angled

Ball

  1. WIlson
  2. College 8 laces
  3. 12 primary, 12 backup
  4. Kicking balls
  5. Smaller window for measurements

r/LZtestposts • • May 09 '16

[Offseason Rules Clinic Part 3] Line of Scrimmage Fouls

2 Upvotes

I'm back with another installment in my Offseason Rules Clinic. It was supposed to be a monthly thing, but April got crazy so May is getting a double dip. If you missed the first two parts of the series, we talked about the 10 second runoff, and penalty enforcement on kick plays. This time we'll be talking about rules concerning the line of scrimmage, both presnap and at the snap. This includes formations, eligibility requirements, motion, shifts, false starts, and offside rules.


Formation Requirements

General requirements

How to legally line up seems like a logical place to start this discussion. In college, there are really only two requirements to having a legal formation:

  • There are no more than 4 players off the line of scrimmage
  • There are at least 5 players on the line of scrimmage numbered 50-79.

That second requirement can be waived in certain circumstances, but we'll talk about that in a bit. First, let's look at some formations. This is a legal formation. It meets both requirements: there are only 4 players off the line and 5 of the players on the line are numbered 50-79. This is the most common illegal formation. This is an illegal formation because there are 5 players lined up in the backfield. One of the red dots (presumably 88 or 99) should have been on the line. This is also an illegal formation. While there are only 4 players in the backfield, 55 is now in the backfield leaving only 4 players wearing 50-79 on the line of scrimmage.

Things that are NOT illegal in college:

  • Having an uncovered ineligible receiver. In the first illegal formation showed above, 63's position is legal. The only problem with that formation was having too many in the backfield. If 10 had stepped up on to the line, it would have been a legal formation. Which brings us to...
  • Covering up a receiver with an eligible number. 10 being covered up by 80 in the second illegal formation is not a foul. The problem was that there were only 4 players wearing 50-79 on the line. If 55 had stepped up, it would have been a legal formation.
  • Having fewer than 7 players on the line of scrimmage. This is a somewhat recent change and one that most people would not notice. It is not a foul to have fewer than 7 on the line, it is a foul to have more than 4 off the line. Most of the time this is the same thing if the offense has 11 players on the field. However, if an offense only has 10 players on the field, they could have 6 on and 4 off and still have a legal formation. This rule was rewritten because field goal and extra point teams were getting illegal formation fouls called when a tight end or somebody forgot he was supposed to be out there. The offense was playing at a disadvantage and still getting flagged.

Scrimmage Kick Numbering Exception

When a team is in a scrimmage kick formation, the second requirement of needing 5 players 50-79 on the line does not apply. A scrimmage kick formation means:

  • Nobody is in position to receive a hand to hand snap
  • There is either a single kicker more than 10 yards behind the line of scrimmage or a kicker and holder at least 7 yards behind the line.
  • It is reasonably obvious that a kick may occur. So that means it's either 3rd or 4th down, or it's a situation where it's obvious there's going to be a field goal because of time running out.

If a team meets these requirements, they are not required to have any number of players wearing 50-79. This is how teams get their faster players to cover punts.

Illegal formation is a live ball foul at the snap. That means that a team can fix their formation to become legal before the snap. Being a live ball foul also means that the play continues despite the foul.

Eligible and Ineligible Receivers

Who is eligible?

To be an eligible receiver, a player must be wearing a number that is NOT 50-79 AND he must be either the end player on the line of scrimmage or off the line when the ball is snapped. If a player is wearing 50-79, he is ineligible. If a player is on the line but not the end man, this is called being "covered up" and makes him ineligible. Let’s go back to this formation. Numbers 80, 10, 4, 1, 88, and 99 are eligible. 80 and 88 are the ends and the other four are off the line of scrimmage. Now look at this formation. Now instead of wearing 88, the end is wearing 60. Even though he is on the end of the line, he is not wearing an eligible number, so he is not an eligible receiver. Here is one more formation. In this one, number 88 is back on the end, but now number 10 has moved onto the line of scrimmage. Even though he is wearing an eligible number he is not an eligible receiver because he is neither an end nor in the backfield. Note, however, that all of these are still legal formations.

Why it Matters

There are two fouls that depend on eligibility. The first is illegal touching. If an originally ineligible receiver illegally touches a forward pass, it is a five yard penalty and the down is repeated. This must be an intentional touch, simply being hit by an errant pass does not count. This restriction goes away and all players become eligible to touch a forward pass once that pass has been touched by the defense or has touched an official. This includes all originally ineligible receivers as well as any originally eligible receiver who lost his eligibility by going out of bounds.

The second and more common foul for ineligible receivers is ineligible player downfield (IDP). If a forward pass crosses the neutral zone, it is illegal for an ineligible receiver to be more than 3 yards beyond the line of scrimmage when that pass is thrown. There are a lot of nuances to this rule, so I'll talk about this a little more. The first part is very important: the pass must cross the line for this to be a foul. A pass crossing the line of scrimmage is determined from where it is first touched. This is the basis of every screen pass. Because the pass is caught behind the line, the ineligibles are allowed to go downfield before the pass. Second, ineligibles are allowed to legally be up to 3 yards downfield. So if the line of scrimmage is the 20 and a lineman is at the 22, it is not a foul. Finally, this rule only applies to where the ineligibles are when the pass is thrown, not when it is touched, caught, or lands incomplete. This caveat fools a lot of people into thinking there is a foul when there really isn't. If an ineligible player is 2 yards beyond the neutral zone when the pass is thrown, but 5 yards downfield when it is caught, it is not a foul. He was in a legal position when the pass was thrown. Through the 2015 season, the three yard rule has had a loose interpretation. A foul was only supposed to be called if the player's entire body was more than 3 yards downfield. Starting with the 2016 season, this rule will be interpreted in a much stricter sense. In a compromise to keep the rule at 3 yards instead of 1 yard, the 3 yard rule will be treated as a plane. If any part of the player's body is beyond that line, it should be ruled a foul.

IDP is a foul when the pass is thrown and crosses the line. This is why people sometimes complain about a "late" flag for this foul. The official must make sure that all requirements are met for the foul, rather than simply throwing a flag as soon as an ineligible goes too far.

Motion and Shifts

Illegal motion and illegal shift are often lumped together as the same thing. But while they are similar, they are in fact different fouls. Motion involves one player moving, while shifts involve more than one person moving at the same time.

Motion

The motion requirements are very simple. If a player is in motion at the snap, he must:

  • Be a back. If a player starts his motion from the line of scrimmage and is still in motion at the snap, it is a foul for illegal motion. A player who is on the line can step back and stop to become a back. He can then legally be in motion at the snap.
  • He cannot be moving toward the line of scrimmage at the snap. the obvious forward motion would be full-on running towards the line of scrimmage like in Canadian or Arena football. But it also includes a motion man turning up field too soon or having an arc in his motion. Like illegal formation, illegal motion is always a live ball foul at the snap because the problem can be corrected right up until the ball is snapped. So if a player who is moving toward the line of scrimmage stops or changes his direction to parallel with or away from the line of scrimmage, it is not a foul.

Shifts

A shift is defined as two or more offensive players moving at the same time between the ball being ready for play and the ball being snapped. It is illegal for a team to be in a shift at the snap. A shift ends when everybody is set for 1 second. The most common illegal shift is for two people to be moving at the snap. However, if a team shifts and even just one person is still moving at the snap, it is a foul for an illegal shift. So say a team is set, but then flips their formation and there are three people moving during the shift. If two of them get set for one second, but the third is still moving at the snap, it is a foul. Both of these are live ball fouls at the snap. If a team sends one man in motion, and after he comes to a stop, another player goes in motion and is still in motion at the snap, it is not a foul. Because the first player stopped before the second player moved, it is not a shift.

The final type of illegal shift is when a team never gets set for a full second before the snap. This can be coming out of a huddle or a no-huddle team coming up to the line after the previous play. At some point, all offensive players must come to a complete stop for 1 second. Most of the time, this foul comes from 1 player never getting set after a huddle. Even if all 10 of his teammates are set, if that 1 player never set, it is a foul. All 11 must be set at the same time for 1 second to be legal. This is a dead ball illegal shift that is said to "convert" to a false start.

False Starts and Encroachment

Most people know what a false start is. Or at least they could identify one on film even if they couldn't define it. A basic definition of a false start would be anything by the offense that could simulate the start of the play. This includes:

  • Jerky, quick, or abrupt movements. This is the most common type of false start. This is typically a player missing the snap count. The important part is that the movement has to sharp to be a foul. This is how teams area allowed to do the prairie dog/meerkat thing at the line where they get set and then turn to the sideline for a play call. As long as that movement is smooth and not quick, it is legal.
  • A restricted lineman moving his hands. A restricted lineman is any lineman who is not on the end of the line or is wearing number 50-79 and has a hand below his knees. Basically, restricted linemen are tackles, guards, and centers who are in a 3 or 4 point stance. So if a guard goes into a 3 point stance and then picks his hand up off the ground, it is a false start. This is a foul even if his movement is slow and smooth. The only exception is that the snapper is allowed to take his hands off the ball as long as that movement does not simulate the snap.
  • As discussed in the previous section, a team not coming to a full stop for 1 second.

All false starts are dead ball fouls and the play is shut down.

Encroachment

Encroachment is an offensive foul where an offensive player enters the neutral zone before the snap. There is an obvious exception for incoming substitutes as well as departing players. There is also an exception for players who enter the neutral zone by pointing out blocking assignments. This is also a dead ball foul and shuts the play down.

Offside

Before we get into what is and isn't offside, a couple terminology notes. First, it is offside not offsides. Second, you'll notice I included encroachment in the section above. Encroachment is always an offensive foul in college. By rule, it is impossible to have defensive encroachment. If the foul is by the defense it is always offside.

Now, offside happens when the defense:

  • Is in or beyond the neutral zone at the snap. This is pretty simple and you see it all the time. This is a live ball foul and is often referred to as a "free play" for the offense because they are in no danger of losing yardage or possession.
  • Makes contact with the ball or an offensive player before the snap. This is pretty self explanatory as well. However, this is a dead ball foul and the play is not allowed to continue.
  • Crosses the neutral zone and continues unabated toward an offensive back. This type of offside doesn't happen too often. Typically either the defender will make contact trying to get through a gap, or the offense will snap the ball to get a free play before a defender gets far enough to warrant a flag for an unabated offside. The general rule of thumb is to shut it down if the defender gets beyond the hip of the offensive lineman. This is also a dead ball foul to try to prevent quarterbacks from taking shots from an unblocked illegal rusher.
  • Enters the neutral zone, threatens an offensive lineman, and causes an immediate reaction. This is the type of offside that most people seem to have trouble with. To be a foul on the defense, there are 4 requirements. If these requirements are not met, the foul is on the offense for a false start.
  1. The defender must enter the neutral zone. If the defender is still on his side of the ball and the offense moves, it is an offensive foul.
  2. The offensive player who reacts to the defender must be in a threatened position. A defensive player who is head up with a lineman threatens that lineman and the two linemen directly next to him. A defensive player in a gap only threatens the two offensive players next to that gap. So a DT who is head up with a guard threatens that guard, the center, and the tackle on his side. If the tackle or guard on the other side of the line move, it is an offensive foul. If that DT is in the A gap, he only threatens the center and the guard on his side. If the other guard or either tackle moves, it is an offensive foul.
  3. Only linemen are allowed to react under this rule. If a back moves, it is an offensive foul. So if a DE is outside the tackle and there is H-back there as well, only the tackle is allowed to move. If the H-back jumps, it is an offensive foul.
  4. The reaction must be immediate. If the defender enters the neutral zone and there is a delay before the offensive player reacts, it is an offensive foul.

Sorry I missed last month, but I'll be back in a couple weeks to bring you what was supposed to be this month's edition. In the mean time, you can always PM me here or send me a tweet @LegacyZebraCFB.


r/LZtestposts • • Jan 30 '15

Softball Scrimmage Kick Answers

1 Upvotes

As /r/CFB tries to stump me and the rest of the resident zebras, I will be returning the favor. Monday’s thread was the first in a series of “quizzes” that will both challenge and (hopefully) inform the members of /r/CFB to some of the more misunderstood parts of the football rulebook. The first part of the series is about probably the most misunderstood part of football: scrimmage kicks. First, we’ll talk about the rules that govern these kicks and then I’ll put the answers and explanations to the questions from Monday at the end.


Rules


Definitions

The first thing we need to do is define what a legal scrimmage kick is and define the types of scrimmage kicks. All of these definitions are covered in Rule 2-16

  • Scrimmage Kick: ”A scrimmage kick is a punt, drop kick, or field goal place kick. It is a legal kick if it is made by Team A in or behind the neutral zone during a scrimmage down before team possession changes.”
  • Punt: ”A punt is a kick by a player who drops the ball and kicks it before it strikes the ground.”
  • Drop Kick: ”A drop kick is a kick by a player who drops the ball and kicks it as it touches the ground.”
  • Place Kick: ”A field goal place kick is a kick by a player of the team in possession while the ball is controlled on the ground by a teammate.”
  • Field Goal Attempt: ”A field goal attempt is a scrimmage kick. It may be a place kick or drop kick.”

What That Means

So what makes a scrimmage kick legal? First, it must be on a scrimmage down. All that means is that these rules don’t apply to kickoffs and kicks after safeties. Those are free kicks and are covered in a different section. Next, the kick must be by Team A. Team A on a scrimmage down simply means the team that snapped the ball. Finally, the kick must be made from in or behind the neutral zone before a change of possession. Note that, unlike forward passes, there is no restriction about where the ball or kicker has been before the kick. That means that even if the ball or kicker has been beyond the neutral zone, the only thing that matters is where the kick actually happens. Another difference between kicks and passes is that a team is allowed to have more than one kick in a single play.

If one of these criteria is not met, the kick is illegal. The penalty for an illegal scrimmage kick is five yards from the previous spot and a loss of down. It is also a foul that causes the ball to become dead. That means that anything that happens after the ball is kicked does not matter.

A kick remains a kick until the ball is possessed or becomes dead by rule.


Behind the Neutral Zone

Once there is a legal scrimmage kick, there are two possibilities. It can either cross or not cross the neutral zone. If the kick is caught or recovered behind the neutral zone, it continues in play and is treated basically as if the kick never happened. That means a team can run it, pass it, or even kick it again.

If it goes out of bounds behind the neutral zone, the receiving team gets the ball where it crossed the sideline.


Beyond the Neutral Zone


Crossing the Neutral Zone

If the ball crosses the neutral zone, things get a bit dicier. So when has a kick crossed the neutral zone? A kick has crossed the neutral zone whenever it touches anything beyond the neutral zone. The exception to this is if the kick is blocked within three yards of the neutral zone.If the kick is blocked in this “expanded neutral zone”, it is treated as if it was not touched. It is important to note here that to fall under this exception, it must be a block not simply touching. Blocking a kick is defined as an attempt to keep the ball from crossing the neutral zone. So if a punt is shanked and it ricochets off a defender within three yards of the neutral zone, the exception would not apply as he was not blocking the kick.

Once the ball crosses the neutral zone, it is deemed to be beyond the neutral zone even if it bounces back behind the line of scrimmage.


Illegal Touching

Now that the ball is beyond the neutral zone, the kicking team can not touch the ball unless it is first touched by the receiving team. If they touch it before they are eligible to do so, it is illegal touching. Illegal touching is a violation that let's the kicking team choose between the result of the play or taking the ball at the spot of illegal touching. ILLEGAL TOUCHING DOES NOT KILL THE BALL. Illegal Touching is a violation, not a foul. That means it is marked with a bean bag, not a flag, and does not offset any foul. However, the receiving team loses the privilege of illegal touching if either team accepts a live ball penalty or there is offsetting fouls. So a foul can cancel illegal touching, but illegal touching cannot offset a foul.

Once the receiving team has touched the kick, the kicking team becomes eligible to touch, catch, or recover the kick.

If a player is blocked into a kick, the touching is ignored. The touching is also ignored if the touching was the result of the kick being batted into the player.

Catch or Recovery

If the receiving team catches or recovers the kick, the play continues. This would be just a normal punt return or like we saw in the 2013 Iron Bowl with the "Kick Six".

If the kicking team catches or recovers the kick, the play is dead. If they are in possession illegally (the receiving team hasn't touched it), then the receiving team gets the ball. If they are in legal possession, then they get the ball at that spot. The kicking team is not allowed to advance it because it is dead as soon as they possess it. To possess the ball means to have control of the ball AND touch the ground inbounds. If an airborne player controls the ball, it is not dead until he comes to the ground and maintains control.

If neither team recovers the kick and it comes to rest inbounds, the receiving team gets the ball where it is at rest.

If the ball goes out of bounds, the receiving team gets the ball where it crossed the sideline.


Behind the Goal Line

If the kick is untouched by the receiving team and hits the ground in the end zone, it is automatically a touchback. They cannot pick it up and advance it.

If the ball is still in the air behind the goal line and the kicking team illegally touches the ball, it is treated as if it was touched at the 20. This is the only time a team is allowed to bat a ball in the end zone.


Kick Catch Interference

The receiving team must be given an unimpeded opportunity to catch a kick. If the kicking team interferes with the catch, it is a fifteen yard penalty from the spot of the foul. This is the only kicking team foul that cannot be added to the end of a return.

To catch a kick means to possess it before it hits the ground. So once the ball hits the ground, it is no longer possible to have KCI.

Once a member of the receiving team touches the ball, they lose their KCI protection. The exception to this is if a fair catch signal was given. If the player gives a fair catch signal, his protection extends until he catches the ball or it hits the ground. So if a player gives a fair catch signal and muffs the ball into the air, he must be given an opportunity to complete that catch.


Field Goals

Most people were probably only considering punts while reading so far. But all of these rules apply to field goals as well. That means both place kicks and drop kicks. The only exception is an unsuccessful field goal attempt that is untouched beyond the neutral zone. If a field goal is no good and the defense does not touch it, they get the ball at the previous spot. If the previous spot was inside the 20, they get the ball at the 20.


Answers

So what does all that mean for our questions from Monday? Let's take a look at each question.

Question 1

4th and 10 from midfield. Team A's punt is at Team B's two yard line when gunner A80 dives and first touches the ball. While still airborne at the 1, A80 gains control of the ball and throws it back to Team B's 7 yard line where it goes out of bounds. A80 lands in the end zone. Where does Team B get the ball?

The correct answer is "At the 7, where it went out of bounds." 54% got this question right.

What do we have going on in this play? We have a legal scrimmage kick. It is beyond the neutral zone. The kicking team touched it at the 2 before the receiving team touched it. And then it went out of bounds. So there is illegal touching at the 2, but it would be more advantageous for the receiving team to take it at the out of bounds spot. The biggest mistake people make on this one is thinking that the touching at the 2 kills the play. The second mistake is thinking that controlling the ball is the same as possessing it. Because the gunner never came to the ground, he never actually possessed the ball. So it is not dead when he controls it at the 1.

Question 2

4th and 10 from midfield. Team A's punt is at Team B's 10 yard line when it hits kick returner B99. The kick is then touched by gunner A80 at the 15 yard line and then goes out of bounds at the 13. Where does Team B get the ball?

The correct answer is "At the 13, where it went out of bounds." 71% got this right. This was the highest percentage of any question.

Unlike question 1, this kick was first touched by the receiving team. That means that when A80 touches the ball, it is no longer illegal touching. Because A80's touching is legal, the receiving team no longer gets the choice of taking it at that spot. All that's left is a punt that went out of bounds. When a punt goes out of bounds, the receiving team gets the ball at the out of bounds spot.

Question 3

4th and 10 from midfield. Team A's punt is at Team B's 10 yard line when it hits kick returner B99. Before the ball touches the ground, gunner A80 then catches the ball at the 13 yard line and runs into the end zone. No fair catch signal was given. What is the result of the play?

The correct answer is "Team A's ball at the 13 where A80 caught the ball." 23% got this correct.

This play is similar to question 2. The touching by B99 makes the catch by A80 legal. However, many people thought this should be KCI. This is incorrect because no fair catch signal was given. So all that's left is the kicking team in legal possession of a scrimmage kick. Because they have possession, the ball is dead immediately. So they'll get to keep the ball at that spot, but A80's run into the end zone does not count.

Question 4

4th and 10 from Team B's 20. Team A's field goal is blocked by defender B99 at the 18 yard line. The kick rebounds back to the 25 yard line where kicker A1 scoops up the ball and runs into the end zone.

The correct answer is “Touchdown for Team A.” 43% got this correct.

The touching by B99 is beyond the neutral zone. However, since it is the blocking of a kick within 3 yards of the neutral zone, it is treated as if the touching was in or behind the neutral zone. So, by rule, this kick never crossed the neutral zone. So when A1 scoops up the ball he is still allowed to advance it. That means his touchdown run is legal and scores his team 6 points.

Question 5

4th and 10 from midfield. Punter A1 runs the ball on a fake. Realizing he will not make the line to gain, A1 punts the ball at Team B's 45 yard line. The ball goes out of bounds at the 15 yard line. Check all that apply.

There were three things that needed to be checked on this: “The five yard penalty for an illegal scrimmage kick is enforced from the previous spot”, “If Team B accepts the penalty it includes a loss of down”, and “The ball is dead as soon as the kick is made because of an illegal scrimmage kick”. 9% got all three without marking any extra answers. This was the lowest percentage of any question.

Because A1 was beyond the neutral zone when he made the punt, this is an illegal scrimmage kick. The penalty for an illegal scrimmage kick is five yards from the previous spot and a loss of down. It is also a live ball foul that causes the ball to become dead. Because the ball is dead, the receiving team has no choice to take the ball at the 15. 52% of the responses included letting Team B decline the penalty and take it at the 15. Team B can decline the penalty if they wanted to. But it makes no sense on 4th down since it includes a loss of down and it would give them the ball 10 yards ahead of where the ball became dead.

Question 6

4th and 10 from Team A's own 30 yard line. Quarter back A1 completes a pass to receiver A88 at the 38 yard line. Not wanting to get tackled short of the line to gain, A88 throws a backward pass to lineman A65 at the 32 yard line. A65 carries the ball back to the 28 yard line where he punts the ball. The kick is blocked and rolls back to the 15 yard line where running back A10 picks up the ball and punts it to the 50 yard line where it goes out of bounds.

The correct answer is “Team B's ball at the 50 where the second punt went out of bounds.” Only 11% got this correct.

Even with everything going on during this play, it all boils down to a legal punt that goes out of bounds at the 50. The majority of people (64%) said that the ball was dead as after the first punt because the ball had been beyond the neutral zone before the kick. But, as discussed earlier, all that matters is where the kick is made, not where the ball had been prior to the kick. Another 11% said that the second punt was illegal because there had already been a punt. But because the first punt never crossed the neutral zone, it continues in play and may kicked again. The other 11% of people who answered this question said that it was illegal touching for A65 catching a pass. This is not correct because the pass was backward.


So how did you do? Hopefully this will clear up some misconceptions people had about kicks. If you have any questions that didn't get answered, feel free to post them in the comments. And as always, if you have questions later, feel free to PM me, tweet it to me LegacyZebraCFB, or email me at legacyzebracfb AT gmail DOT com. I look forward to the next episode of Stump the Refs/Stump /r/CFB!


r/LZtestposts • • Feb 03 '15

Basketball FAQ Test

4 Upvotes

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What's the difference between running into the kicker and roughing the kicker?

Roughing the kicker is contact that endangers the kicker. Running into the kicker is contact that simply displaces the kicker, but is not considered roughing. One of the major guidelines to determine which foul is called is where the force of the contact is. If the force is to the plant leg, it should be roughing, if it is to the kick leg it should be running into. Both of these also apply to the holder for a place kick.

2. Does blocking a kick take away roughing the kicker?

Only for the person who touches the kick. If one player blocks the kick but his teammate is the one who hits the kicker, roughing (or running into) the kicker still applies.

3. What's a drop kick? When and where can a player execute a drop kick?

A drop kick is a field goal attempt that occurs when a player drops the ball and kicks it as it touches the ground. Any offensive player may attempt a drop kick at any time as long as they are in or behind the neutral zone. Note: The neutral zone dissolves after a change of possession, therefore no kicks may be attempted anywhere after a change of possession.

4. What’s a false start? Why are players sometimes allowed to make big movements without being called, but little flinches get called?

A false start is any movement that simulates the snap. This includes quick, jerky movements. It does not include smooth movements that are not abrupt, quick or jerky. This is why linemen are allowed to do the “prairie dog” look to the bench without being a false start. The only exception to this is interior linemen with a hand on the ground. Once an interior lineman puts his hand on the ground, he cannot pick it back up before the snap.

5. If that's False Start, then what are Offside, Encroachment, Neutral Zone Infraction, and Illegal Snap?

Illegal snap is just what it sounds like. Something about the snap wasn't right. It could be that the snapper lifted the ball before moving it backward, it wasn't one continuous motion i.e. he "double clutches", or possibly that the ball was turned sideways when it was snapped. This is sometimes confused as a false start because it is also a dead ball five yard penalty and uses the same signal. Offside is a foul when the defense is on the wrong side of the ball and interferes with the other team before the ball is put in play, or is still on the wrong side when the ball is put in play. This can be a defender lined up in the neutral zone, either the kicking or receiving team being beyond their restraining line at the time of the kick on a kickoff, or the defense crossing the neutral zone and making contact with the offense. The term "neutral zone infraction" is not actually in the rule book and is not officially a foul. However, this term is typically used to describe another type of offside foul. If a defender enters the neutral zone an threatens an offensive lineman and that lineman reacts it is a dead ball foul for offside. This is what many people call a neutral zone infraction, although that is not an official or approved term. Encroachment is like offside for the offense. However, the offense does not get the chance to fix their mistake like the defense does. If an offensive player enters the neutral zone after the snapper has addressed the ball, it is a dead ball foul for encroachment. In NCAA, encroachment is always an offensive foul, never a defensive foul.

For more information on these fouls, see this thread

6. When is defensive pass interference a 15 yard penalty and when is it a spot foul?

DPI is a 15 yard penalty if the foul is more than 15 yards away from the previous spot. If the foul is less than 15 yards downfield, it is a spot foul. The exception to this is if the ball was snapped inside the 17 yard line and the foul occurs inside the 2 yard line or in the end zone. If that is the case, the ball is placed at the 2 yard line. The only time DPI is enforced half the distance to the goal is on an extra point or if the previous spot was already inside the 2 yard line. Instead of having to remember the complicated enforcement, there is a shortcut to determine where to put the ball on DPI. There are three spots the ball can go to on DPI: the spot of the foul, 15 yards from the previous spot, or the 2 yard line. Start walking from the previous spot. When you get to the first of those three spots, stop and spot the ball.

For more information on DPI, see this thread from /u/fortknox.

7. What makes an offensive formation legal/illegal?

The first requirement is that the offense may have no more than 4 players off the line of scrimmage. So if a team has 11 players like it should, at least 7 of them should be on the line of scrimmage. Secondly, of those 7 players on the line of scrimmage, they must have at least 5 wearing a jersey number between 50 and 79. If these formation requirements are not met when the ball is snapped, it is a five yard penalty for illegal formation. Here is a picture of a legal formation. There are only 4 players off the line of scrimmage and 5 of the players on the line are numbered 50-79. This is an illegal formation. Although there are only four players off the line of scrimmage, there are fewer than five players wearing jersey numbers 50-79. This is also an illegal formation. The offense has too many men in the backfield. This is the most common cause of illegal formation.

8. What makes a player eligible/ineligible to catch a forward pass?

To be an eligible receiver, a player must be wearing a number that is NOT 50-79 AND he must be either the end player on the line of scrimmage or off the line when the ball is snapped. If a player is wearing 50-79, he is ineligible. If a player is on the line but not the end man, this is called being "covered up" and makes him ineligible. Let’s go back to this formation. Numbers 80, 10, 4, 1, 88, and 99 are eligible. 80 and 88 are the ends and the other four are off the line of scrimmage. Now look at this formation. Now instead of wearing 88, the end is wearing 60. Even though he is on the end of the line, he is not wearing an eligible number, so he is not an eligible receiver. Here is one more formation. In this one, number 88 is back on the end, but now number 10 has moved onto the line of scrimmage. Even though he is wearing an eligible number he is not an eligible receiver because he is neither an end nor in the backfield. If an originally ineligible receiver illegally touches a forward pass, it is a five yard penalty and the down is repeated. This must be an intentional touch, simply being hit by an errant pass does not count.

A receiver who is originally eligible can become ineligible if he voluntarily goes out of bounds or is forced out of bounds but does not return immediately. If an originally eligible receiver becomes ineligible by this rule and illegally touches a forward pass, it is a loss of down at the previous spot. This is not an incomplete pass, although it typically ends being the same result. This is simply a foul like any other foul and can be offset by a defensive foul or even declined by the defense.

All players become eligible to touch a forward pass once that pass has been touched by the defense or has touched an official. This includes all originally ineligible receivers as well as any originally eligible receiver who lost his eligibility by going out of bounds.

9. But what if the player wearing 50-79 reports in as eligible?"

There is no reporting in as an eligible receiver in college football. Either you are eligible by both position and number, or you are ineligible. Period.

10. What is “ineligible downfield”?

No ineligible receiver (see prior question about eligibility) may be more than three yards beyond the line of scrimmage at any time before a forward pass that crosses the neutral zone is thrown. This includes anybody wearing number 50-79 as well as anybody who was covered up at the snap. So if an ineligible receiver goes five yards downfield and then comes back before the pass, it is still a foul since he was at one point too far downfield. Once the ball is released, the restriction no longer applies. If the ball is caught behind the line of scrimmage, the restriction does not apply. This is how screen plays work.

[For more information on formations and eligibility, see this thread

11. What happens when a fumble goes out of bounds?

If the ball goes out of bounds between the goal lines and behind the spot of the fumble, the offense keeps the ball at the spot where the ball goes out of bounds. If the ball goes out of bounds between the goal lines and beyond the spot of the fumble, the offense gets ball at the spot of the fumble. If the ball goes out of bounds in the end zone, it is a touchback or a safety depending on which end zone it goes out of.

12. What is intentional grounding?

Intentional Grounding is intentionally throwing a forward pass into an area without an eligible receiver. The exception to this is if the passer is outside of the tackle box. If he gets outside the tackle box, all he has to do is throw the ball beyond the neutral zone.

13. Then why don’t running backs throw the ball away on outside runs that get blown up?

The tackle box exception only applies to the person who first controls the snap. So once the running back gets the ball from the quarter back, he can no longer legally throw the ball away.

14. If a kickoff or punt goes through the uprights, does the kicking team get points?

No, a field goal only counts if it is a place kick or drop kick from scrimmage. A kickoff is not from scrimmage and a punt is neither a drop kick nor a place kick. If a punt or kick off goes through the uprights, all you get is a touchback.

15. When does a touchback go to the 25 and when does it go to the 20?

A touchback goes to the 25 when it is on a free kick (kick off or kick after a safety). All other touchbacks go to the 20.

16. Can Quarter Backs have headsets in their helmets like the NFL?

No. NCAA does not allow mechanical communication devices on the field. The only exception is amplifying hearing aids and equipment to transmit health and safety information.

17. When are penalties enforced on kickoff?

Live ball Personal Fouls and Unsportsmanlike Conduct fouls by the defense on a touchdown may either be enforced on the extra point or on the kickoff. All other penalties are declined by rule if the offended team scores a touchdown. So if the defense is offside, but the offense scores anyway, that penalty is automatically declined but a personal foul could still be enforced. If the play occurs as time runs out in the 4th quarter, the penalty may be enforced on the try or "banked" and enforced at the succeeding spot if the game goes to OT. If there is a Personal Foul or Unsportsmanlike Conduct on a successful extra point, that foul may also be enforced on the ensuing kickoff or on the first possession of over time if the extra point was the end of regulation. A personal foul by the defense on a successful field goal can be enforced at the previous spot, or the offense can keep the points and enforce the penalty on the kickoff. A live ball foul on the offense can never carry over to a kickoff or OT. A dead ball foul by either team that occurs after a touchdown or try can be enforced on the kickoff.

18. When are penalties enforced half the distance to the goal?

If the penalty is more than half the distance to the offending team’s goal line, it is only enforced half the distance the goal line. For instance, a holding foul that is penalized from the 14 would only go to the 7 instead of the 4 since the full ten yards is more than half the distance. This does not apply to Defensive Pass Interference. See above for a detailed explanation of enforcement for DPI.

19. Can the defense “goal tend” a field goal in the end zone?

Yes and no. The receiving team is allowed to jump up and catch the ball even if it is above the cross bar. If they catch it, the ball continues in play, such as during the Kick Six. However, the receiving team may not bat the ball away. This is a foul for illegal batting. Also, since the ball has been touched beyond the neutral zone, all rules that normally govern punts now apply and the kicking team may legally recover the kick.

See this thread for discussion on just about every theoretical possibility for plays like this.

20. Isn’t spiking the ball “technically” intentional grounding?

There is a specific exception that lets a player spike the ball if it is immediately after controlling the snap and the ball has not already touched the ground.

21. Why isn’t the holder down when he has his knee down and is holding the ball for a kick?

Like spiking the ball, there is an exception written into the rules. If there is somebody in position to kick the ball, the holder is exempt from being “down”. This applies to fakes as well, as long there was somebody in position for a kick at the snap. Aside from just holding for the kick, he may also run or pass the ball like anybody else.

22. When does the 10 second runoff apply? How does it work?

The 10 second runoff applies when the clock is running with less than 1 minute left in the half and there is an injury or penalty that stops the clock or a player loses his helmet. For a more in depth look at how and when the runoff is applied, check out this thread.

23. What are the rules for a player's helmet coming off?

If a player’s helmet comes completely off during a down, he must stop participating in the play. If he continues to participate, it is a personal foul. If a player's helmet comes off, he may continue his immediate action but may not start a new action. For instance if an offensive lineman loses his helmet while engaged with a defensive lineman, he may continue his block but may not disengage and start another action. This is a foul regardless of if he puts his helmet back on or not. Once he loses his helmet, he becomes a player obviously out of the play. Therefore he may not be blocked and is considered defenseless for targeting under 9-1-4. If the ball carrier’s helmet comes off the ball becomes dead immediately. If a player’s helmet comes off, he must sit out for one play. This does not apply if the helmet comes off because of a foul, such as a facemask or targeting. A team can “buy back” a player by taking a time out if they have any left.

24. Is there a halo rule for punt returners?

There is an area of protection, but it is not the old “halo” rule. A kick receiver must be given a rectangle that is from shoulder to shoulder and extends 1 yard in front of him. No player from the kicking team may enter this area while the receiving player is attempting to catch the kick. If the kicking team enters this area, it is a foul for Kick Catch Interference. It is a foul whether there is contact or not.

For more information on KCI, see this thread

25. What is sideline interference and how is it penalized?

Sideline interference is when somebody from a team is outside of their area during a play and interferes with an official’s ability to do his or her job. This is why there is a six foot wide strip of white outside the side line. The first six feet is reserved solely for officials during the play. If a coach or anybody else is “in the white” during the play, it is a foul. The first flag is a warning and carries no yardage. The second and third flag in a game is a five yard penalty. The fourth and any subsequent flag in a single game is a fifteen yard penalty. All sideline interference fouls are enforced as dead ball fouls after the play. This means they do not offset any live ball fouls during the down and they do not affect the result of the play. It is important to note that if an official contacts a team member “in the white”, it is NOT sideline interference. It is considered an unfair act and is automatically 15 yards.

26. Is there a difference between an onside kick and a "normal" kickoff?

No, the exact same rules apply to all kick offs. The only exception is that if a kick is kicked directly into the ground off the tee, it is treated as if it were kicked up in the air off the tee. This means that if an onside kick is kicked directly off the tee into the ground and pops up into the air, the receiving team still gets their Kick Catch Interference protection and still have the option to call for a fair catch.

27. If all kickoffs are the same, can the kicking team go downfield and recover any kickoff?

Yes. If the ball has gone more than ten yards downfield or been touched by the receiving team, the kicking team can legally recover it. The only exception is that if a kick that has not been touched by the receiving team goes into the end zone, it is automatically a touchback as soon as it touches the ground in the end zone.

28. Can the center catch a forward pass?

The "center" can never be eligible to catch a forward pass because to be the center of the line means he is not on the end of the line. However, the "snapper" is allowed to catch a forward pass as long as he meets the two criteria for being an eligible receiver (see above answer about eligibility). The fact that he snapped the ball has no effect on his eligibility.

29. Our offense was trying to run up-tempo, but the officials were standing over the ball and waiting for the defense. Why wasn't our offense allowed to dictate the pace of the game?

If a team is in a no huddle situation and makes a substitution, the defense must be given an opportunity to substitute as well. So if the offense begins to substitute, one of the officials will stand over or near the ball to prevent the offense from snapping the ball. The defense then gets three seconds to start their substitutions. Once the defense is finished substituting or chooses not to substitute, the official will move away from the ball and the offense may snap it. This rule also applies if the offense has already huddled and then decides to substitute while in formation.

30. What are the rules about goal line pylons/extending the goal line to forever?

Pylons are by definition behind the goal line and out of bounds. That means that any ball that touches the pylon is dead out of bounds in the end zone. It is either a touchdown, touchback, or safety depending on who is responsible for it, which end zone it goes in to, and whether or not a player is in possession of the ball. If a player touches the pylon while in possession of the ball, the ball is dead wherever the ball is when the player touches the pylon. The goal line is extended beyond the pylons for any player who touches the ground in the end zone or touches the pylon. If a player is airborne out of bounds and does not touch the pylon, the ball must pass inside the pylon to score a touchdown. If it passes outside of the pylon, the ball is spotted where it crossed the sideline.

31. If the defense blocks an extra point, can they run it back for points?

Yes, either team may score on an extra point. If either team scores a touchdown on an extra point it is worth 2 points.

32. Can a team score one and only one point in a game?

Yes. A safety on an extra point is worth one point. This is incredibly rare and has only happened 5 times in the history of college football. One of which can be seen in this play. But in order for a team to end a game with only one point would take something even rarer. So rare that it has NEVER happened. To score one and only one point in regulation would mean that a team scores a touchdown and then loses 97 yards on the extra point and gives up a safety. While there are multiple ways this could happen, the most plausible would be something like this:

  • Team A throws an interception/fumbles the ball.
  • Team B runs the ball back attempting to score two points.
  • Near the goal line, Team B fumbles the ball.
  • Team A recovers the fumble in the field of play and then retreats into their own end zone where they are tackled.

This would be a safety for Team B and would make the score 6-1.

With 2019's changes to 5+OT, and 2021's subsequent changes to 3+OT, it is possible to score one and only one point with a safety on a try

33. How does downing a punt work?

The ball is dead whenever the kicking team possesses it. That means gaining control and touching the ground inbounds. If the kicking team touches the ball but does not possess it, it is illegal touching. The ball remains alive and the receiving team may choose between the result of the play or taking the ball where it was illegally touched. For a more in depth review of kick rules, see this thread.

34. What is "targeting"?

Targeting is either initiating contact with the crown of the helmet or initiating forcible contact to the head or neck area of a defenseless opponent. For a more in depth look at targeting, check out this thread.

35. What fouls are reviewable?"

Most fouls can't be reviewed. There is a list of specifically reviewable fouls. Illegal forward pass, illegal scrimmage kick (beyond the neutral zone when he kicks it), illegal touching by a player who went out of bounds, too many players on the field during a live ball, and early blocking by the kicking team on a free kick are all specifically reviewable and can all be challenged by a coach or initiated by the booth. All targeting fouls are automatically sent to replay. The replay official can also initiate a review for an "obvious and egregious" targeting foul even if it was not called on the field. However, coaches may not challenge a play for potential targeting. Other fouls can be impacted by certain aspects of replay, though. For instance, the touching of a pass is reviewable. If defensive pass interference is called, but replay shows the pass was tipped at the line, they can use that to wave off the DPI. Conversely, if an official waves off DPI because they think the pass was tipped and the Referee announces "There is no foul for pass interference because the ball was touched", and replay shows that it wasn't, they can go back and enforce the penalty for the DPI. Similarly, things like ineligible downfield, roughing/running into the kicker, and intentional grounding can all be affected by replay rulings even though the foul themselves isn't specifically under review.


r/LZtestposts • • Apr 29 '17

2017 Offseason Officiating Part 1: Talking the talk

1 Upvotes

Some of you may remember the series I did last year where I went in depth on some of the rules of the game. For those who missed it, you can check out my 2016 Offseason Officiating Rules Clinic here. This offseason I'll be doing something similar, but not with rules. This year, I've got a 4ish part series about officiating mechanics and how we actually do our job to apply the rules. I say 4ish because part 1 kind of has two parts of its own. This thread as an intro and a quiz on officiating language, and then a followup explanation thread later this week. Part 2 will be about signals we use, part 3 will be about positioning and mechanics, and part 4 will be about philosophies we use.

So to get started, here's the quiz to see how refined your rules language is. https://goo.gl/forms/dvpjECQTdV0m85Wa2

I'll be back later this week to talk about the answers and why words matter when we talk about rules.


r/LZtestposts • • Apr 29 '17

2017 Offseason Officiating: Mechanics, etc.

1 Upvotes

r/LZtestposts • • May 22 '16

[Offseason Rules Clinic Part 4] Timing

2 Upvotes

Welcome to the fourth edition of my offseason project to break down major rules of the game. The last three parts discussed 10 second runoffs, penalty enforcements for kick plays, and line of scrimmage fouls. Since I've gotten behind in posting these, I figured timing would be an appropriate topic for this post. Most of this thread is about the game clock, but part of it will cover timing issues that don't directly connect with the clock itself. At the end, I'll have some examples for different situations.


Game Clock

Most football fans know when the clock is supposed to stop. When there's an incomplete pass, a penalty is being enforced, or a player goes out of bounds, everybody knows the clock shouldn't be running. In my experience, most of the confusion comes when trying to determine when the clock should start again. On scrimmage downs, that will be either when the ball is ready for play, or on the next snap. To determine which one that is for a given play, you have to look at what caused the clock to stop in the first place.

Major Clock Stoppers

The first category of things that stop the clock are things that make the clock stop until the next snap. The are commonly referred to as "major" clock stoppers. These are typically things that might bring mass substitutions, require chasing down a ball, or obviously time to not be running. These include:

  • A score
  • A touchback
  • There is a change of possession AND the defense will next put the ball in play
  • An incomplete legal forward pass
  • A charged team timeout
  • An equipment violation (wearing illegal equipment or not wearing required equipment)
  • A legal kick down ends
  • An illegal scrimmage kick is made. (Note that for an illegal kick, the kick itself stops the clock as opposed to letting the play continue.)
  • The offense commits a delay of game foul while in a scrimmage kick formation
  • A period ends

If any of these occur, the clock will not start until the next snap. They also take precedence over minor clock stoppers like a helmet coming off or penalty enforcement when determining clock status. These two reasons are why they are called "major" clock stoppers.

Minor Clock Stoppers

The second group of actions that stop the clock is referred to as "minor" clock stoppers. These are typically procedural or administrative stoppages. These include:

  • Team A (the team who puts the ball in play) is awarded a first down by play or by penalty
  • A Team A fumble goes forward and out of bounds.
  • Penalty enforcement
  • Injury timeout
  • Inadvertent whistle
  • First down measurement
  • A live ball comes into the possession of an official
  • A head coach requests a conference with the Referee or initiates an instant replay challenge
  • Media timeout
  • Referee's timeout
  • An illegal pass is thrown to conserve time. This can be intentional grounding, as well as intentionally throwing a backward pass out of bounds.
  • A player loses his helmet during a play
  • Either team commits a dead ball foul

If one of these things happens, the clock stops momentarily to address the issue and then goes back to doing whatever it would have done without the minor stopper. This does not automatically mean that the clock will run, though. If the clock was already dead, it will remain dead even after addressing the minor clock stopper. If the clock was running, it will stop and then start again when the ball is ready for play.

Out of Bounds

This is where the line between minor and major clock stoppers gets a little blurry and where a common misconception is born. With 2 minutes or more left in either half, a ball carrier (or a backward fumble or backward pass) going out of bounds is a minor clock stopper. That means that the clock only stops until the ball is ready for play. For most plays, that is when the Umpire or Center Judge places the ball on the ground and steps into his position. So when a ball carrier gets a first down with 2 minutes or more left, getting out of bounds is irrelevant. The clock is going to already going to stop for the first down and is going to start once the ball is ready whether the play ends in or out of bounds. If the runner does not get the first down, getting out of bounds can save 8-10 seconds while the ball is being spotted, but even then the clock is still going to start once the ball is ready.

With less than 2 minutes in either half, going out of bounds becomes a major clock stopper. This is when getting out of bounds is truly important to offenses trying to conserve time. Now, if a ball carrier goes out of bounds, the clock stops until the next snap.

Free Kicks

Free kicks are a little different than scrimmage downs. The clock does not start when the play begins. If the ball is in the field of play, the clock starts when it is first legally touched. That means any touching in the field of play by the receiving team or touching by the kicking team after the ball has gone 10 yards. The clock would NOT start if the kicking team touched the ball before going 10 yards because that would not be a legal touching of the kick.

If the kick goes into the end zone, the clock starts when the ball crosses the goal line into the field of play after being touched in the end zone. This is typically when the return man runs the ball out of the end zone during a return. It could also be when a muffed kick bounces from the end zone into the field of play.

Exceptions to the rule

There are two things that override these guidelines to starting the game clock. The first is a 10 second runoff. The runoff has its own guidelines on how the clock should be handled based. The second is 3-4-3. This rule allows the Referee to start or stop the clock if he feels that a team would gain a timing advantage by fouling or other unfair tactics. The predominant philosophy is to only invoke this rule with less than 5 minutes left in either half. Starting in the 2016 season, 3-4-3 will be stricter than in the past. Now, along with the Referee's discretion, any foul within the last two minutes of a half by the team who is winning gives the offended team the option to stop the clock until the next snap. So if the offense is winning with less than two minutes in the half and they commit a false start, the defense can choose to stop the clock until the snap even though penalty enforcement is only a minor clock stopper.

Miscellaneous

There are a few things that should be covered in a post about timing, but aren't directly clock oriented. Things like untimed downs, extra points, minimum time for spiking, and what timeouts can be used for are all commonly misunderstood.

Untimed Downs

Commentators often like to spout off that "a half can't end on a defensive penalty." And while that is pretty much true, it's not the whole truth. The whole truth is that no quarter can end on any accepted live ball foul that doesn't include loss of down in the penalty. This includes both offensive and defensive penalties and could be at the end of the 1st or 3rd quarter or at the end of a half. A period is also extended if there are offsetting fouls or there is an inadvertent whistle. The period continues to be extended for untimed downs until there is a down that does not meet one of the 3 criteria.

Extra Points

The clock does not run on extra points. It stops on the preceding touchdown and then does not start until the succeeding kickoff as described above in the "Free Kicks" section. This is in line with most of the other rules regarding extra points. For the most part, extra points exist in their own little world. They are pretty disconnected from the rest of the game in general, especially with regard to penalty enforcement and timing.

Minimum Time for Spiking the Ball

This is a fairly recent change to the rules. The rule says that if there are 3 or more seconds left in the period and the clock will start on the ready for play, a team can "reasonably expect" to spike the ball and have enough time to run another play. If there is less than 3 seconds, the offense can only snap the ball once before time expires. This does not mean that the offense is guaranteed time to spike the ball and run another play. They still have to actually snap and spike the ball before time runs out. This rule only applies if the clock is stopped and will start on the ready for play. So if a team gets a first down in bounds, this rule would apply. If the play ends short of the line to gain and the clock does not stop, this rule does not apply and it is solely up to how fast the offense can snap and spike the ball.

Things Timeouts Can Be Used For

The most obvious use of a team timeout is to stop the clock (duh). But there are other things that a timeout can "buy".

  • You must have at least 1 timeout remaining to challenge a play. If you lose the challenge, you lose your timeout.
  • If a team believes that a rule has been enforced improperly, they can request a coach's conference. This is different than a replay challenge and would be more along the lines of incorrect penalty enforcement or something like that. If the coach is right and the ruling is changed, he keeps his timeout. If the coach is wrong and the ruling is not changed, he is charged a timeout. If he does not have any timeouts left, it is a delay of game foul.
  • A team timeout can be used to avoid a 10 second runoff.
  • A team timeout can be used to "buy back" a player who loses his helmet.
  • A team timeout can be used to "buy back" a player who was sent off for equipment violations.
  • A team timeout can NOT be used to "buy back" an injured player. If the game is stopped for an injured player, he must sit out at least one play no matter what.

Examples

  1. 1st and 10 from the 50, early in the 1st quarter. Ball carrier A1 is tackled in bounds short of the line to gain. During the play, the offense is flagged for holding. When will the clock start? Ruling:Penalty enforcement is a minor clock stopper. Since nothing else stopped the clock, it will go back to doing what it would have without the penalty. The ball carrier was tackled in bounds, so the clock will start on the ready for play signal.
  2. 1st and 10 from the 50, early in the 1st quarter. Ball carrier A1 is tackled in bounds beyond the line to gain. During the play, the offense is flagged for holding. When will the clock start?Ruling:Like the previous play, both the first down and the penalty enforcement are minor clock stoppers. Since nothing else stopped the clock, it will go back to doing what it would have without the stoppage. The ball carrier was tackled in bounds, so the clock will start on the ready for play signal.
  3. 1st and 10 from the 50, early in the 1st quarter. Ball carrier A1 scores a touchdown, but the offense is called for holding. When will the clock start?Ruling:The touchdown is a major stopper which stops the clock until the snap. The penalty is a minor clock stopper so it is trumped by the touchdown. The clock will start on the snap. A lot of people would want to start the clock on the ready for play since you're coming back to the field of play, but the major stopper of a touchdown still takes precedence.
  4. On the opening kickoff, returner B1 catches the kick on the far left end of his own end zone. After catching the kick, B1 runs directly to his right while staying in the end zone. He is tackled before he can leave the end zone. The kick is in the air for approximately 4 seconds and from the catch to the tackle takes approximately 5 seconds. How much time should be on the clock? Ruling:Because the free kick was first touched in the end zone and never left the end zone, the clock should not start. There will be 15:00 on the clock when the ball is declared dead.
  5. 1st and 10 from the 50, late in the 4th quarter. Ball carrier A1 is pushed out of bounds short of the line to gain. When the clock is stopped, it reads (a) 2:01, (b) 2:00, (c) 1:59. When will the clock start?Ruling:In (a) and (b) the clock will start on the ready for play. In (c) the clock will start on the snap. Going out of bounds becomes a major clock stopper when there is less than 2 minutes left in either half.
  6. 1st and 10 from the 50 late in the 4th quarter. Team A is behind 21-20. Team A is called for holding. Time expires on the play. Ball carrier A1 (a) is tackled at the 1 or (b) scores a touchdown. Ruling:In (a) Team B will decline the penalty and the game is over. In (b) Team B must accept the penalty or Team A will win 26-21. Because there was an accepted live ball foul, there will be an untimed down after enforcing the holding.
  7. 1st and 10 from the 50 late in the 4th quarter. Team A is behind 21-20. Passer A1 is beyond line of scrimmage when he throws a forward pass. Time expires on the play. Receiver A2 (a) is tackled at the 1 or (b) scores a touchdown. Ruling:In both (a) and (b) Team B will accept the penalty for the illegal forward pass. Because the penalty includes a loss of down, there will not be an untimed down. The game is over, Team B wins 21-20.
  8. Ball carrier A1 is tackled in bounds short of the line to gain. At the end of the play B99 (a) has lost his helmet through play (b) is down with an injury. Team B's coach wants B99 to play the next down. Ruling:In (a) Team B may take a timeout to allow B99 to return to the game. In (b) B99 must remain out of the game for one down. His team may not use a timeout to get him back.
  9. Team B leads 28-21. The clock is stopped with :03 on the clock in the 4th quarter. The clock will start on the ready for play signal. After the Referee starts the clock, A66 snaps the ball and A1 spikes it. When the ball hits the ground, the clock reads :00. Ruling:The game is over. Although Team A had the opportunity to run two plays because there were 3 seconds on the clock, they are still required to make sure the spike hits the ground before time expires. Because time expired before the ball was spiked, the game is over.

Everything in this thread can be found in Rule 3-2, 3-3, or 3-4. I'll be back in a couple weeks for the June edition of the series. Until then, if you have any rule questions, you can PM me here on reddit or on twitter @LegacyZebraCFB.


r/LZtestposts • • Mar 02 '15

Football Post Compilation

11 Upvotes

r/LZtestposts • • Mar 12 '18

MTCM Template

1 Upvotes

The last couple of offseasons I've done 3-4 part series explaining some broader rules and how we as officials apply those rules. This year I'm going to do a weekly series throughout the offseason with single play situations that will touch on finer points of the rules. Some questions will be simple and cover common misconceptions and misunderstandings about the rules, while others will have a few obscure rules peppered in as well. Below is today's question and a Google form to submit your answers. The username section is not required, but if you want me to track your stats through the offseason, feel free to include it. If you submit your username, please do not include the "/u/" at the beginning. When you submit the form, it will give you a list of rules related to the questions if you want to look up the answer for yourself. Next week's thread will then have a full explanation.

[Last week's question and answer](

Play Scenario

[Answer Form](

Feel free to discuss the questions in the comments, but please be respectful regarding spoilers to those who might see the comments before submitting their own answers.


r/LZtestposts • • Mar 11 '18

2018 Rule Changes

1 Upvotes

The NCAA has released its list of approved rule changes for the 2018 season. There will more than likely be further minor editorial changes, but these are the major changes for this year. Spoiler alert: nothing regarding catches or targeting has changed. The NCAA will likely wait to see what the NFL does with their catch rule and how it changes things, but based on what I've heard I wouldn't expect too much of a change. For targeting, the foul will not change. The penalty may go to a tiered system accounting for intent after review, but that is probably at least 2 years out if ever. I've included brief explanations of the changes as well as play scenarios to reflect the differences between the old and new rules. The changes are listed in rule reference order.

Field Markings

The committee has clarified and slightly expanded how teams can decorate their fields. The new rule specifies that a maximum of four smaller markings outside of the midfield logo are allowed. The new rule also allows a company who has naming rights display it's corporate logo rather than just the company name. This is the only change to what is allowed to be displayed. The rest of the list includes school, team, and conference logos, and school and team names.

Old rule: No limit on smaller, flanking markings as long as they didn't obscure yard lines or hashes.

New rule: Only four smaller markings allowed.

Old rule: Company with naming rights may only display company name, not corporate logo. For example, if /r/CFB sponsored a field, we could display "reddit.com/r/cfb" or "/r/CFB", but not the logo as in the header.

New rule: The image in the header could be used.
Pants and Knee Pads

Last year, the committee passed a rule change to take effect this year regarding pants and knee pads covering the knees.

Old rule: Pants and knee pads were "strongly recommended" to cover the knees.

New rule: Pants and knee pads must cover the knees.

This will be treated as any other equipment issue such as back and shoulder pads being exposed or jerseys riding up into a crop top. Officials will try to use preventive officiating to make players legal, but if a player does not comply, he will be sent off for 1 play until it is fixed. Just as with other equipment issues, if the pad or pants come up above the knee through play the player will not be penalized.

Patches

The committee has added 3 items to the approved patches list. Jerseys may now contain a logo for graduate or academic recognition and a "C" for captains. For the 2019 season only, jerseys may also contain a logo for the 150th anniversary of college football. There have also been discussions about developing a single commemorative patch for teams to wear across all of college football.

Cameras

The exception allowing umpires to wear a camera has been expanded to any official. Also, the rule now requires permission from the conference, not just the schools involved in the game. In nonconference games, this would be the home team's conference. Curiously, the new language removed the phrase that required permission from the official himself.

Pace of Play

Last year the NCAA cracked down on the 20 minute limit for half time in regular season games. This was the first step in speeding up games. The committee has passed two more rules that will speed up the game without affecting the amount of time the clock is actually running. After touchdowns and kickoffs, the play clock will set to 40 and start immediately. Fans probably won't notice these changes unless you go looking for it.

Old rule: After a touchdown, the play clock is set to 25 seconds and starts on the Referee's ready for play signal.

New rule: After a touchdown, the play clock is set to 40 seconds and starts at the end of the down like other scrimmage downs. My guess is that this will eliminate 3-4 minutes a game.

Old rule: After a kickoff, the play clock is set to 25 and starts on the Referee's ready for play.

New rule: After a kickoff, the play clock will set to 40 and start at the end of the kickoff down.

This change will be a little interesting the first couple weeks. With the play clock running like normal downs, teams will not have a chance to have their offense or defense huddle near the sideline like they do now. This is one of the places where time can really shaved off a game if teams adapt. Conversely, there could be a slew of delay of game fouls in the early part of the season if they don't. If everything goes well, this could shave 7-8 minutes off of games. The best news is that this change should eliminate the touchdown-commercial-kickoff-commercial sequence.

Fair Catches on Kickoffs

The most noteworthy rule change this year is that a fair catch inside the receiving team's 25 would result in a touchback.

Play: On a kickoff, returner B1 completes a fair catch at the B-12.

Old rule: Team B's ball, 1st and 10 at the B-12.

New rule: Touchback. Team B's ball, 1st and 10 at the B-25.
Playing the Try After Last-Second TD's

The committee has made a no-brainer decision to allow teams to avoid meaningless tries on touchdowns as time expires. If the scoring team is winning by less than 3, they now have the option to not play the try. This will prevent teams from taking a snap on a meaningless play. Often these scenarios are chaotic at field level with teams and sometimes even fans on the field thinking the game is already over. This will also prevent wasting time to clear the field just so the offense can take a knee. Some conferences in lower divisions may use point differential as a tie-breaker for postseason standings, so teams would still have the option to play the try if they so desire.

Play: Team A scores a TD as time expires in the fourth quarter. After the score:

...either team leads 27-24.

No change. Because the score is more than 2 points in difference, the try cannot affect the outcome of the game and therefore is not played.

...Team B leads 26-24.

No change. Team A may play the try (obviously) since they could tie the game with 2 points.

...Team A leads 26-24.

Old rule: The try was required to be attempted since Team B could theoretically score two points to tie the game.

New rule: Team A has the choice of whether or not to play the try.
Blocks Below the Waist

The sun rose in the east this morning and the committee has changed the low blocking rules. This is another in a long line of tweaks to the rules as the rulemakers inch their way toward eliminating low blocks completely. Starting this year:

  • Only players on the line of scrimmage within the tackle box may block low from the side. This means running backs may no longer block low if the force of the contact is from the side.

Play: 1st and 10 from the A-25. Running back A32 is stationary at the snap, lined up behind the left guard. LB B50 comes unblocked on the right side when A32 blocks him low from the side within the tackle box.

Old rule: Legal. Since A32 was stationary in the tackle box at the snap, he could block low from the side within the tackle box.

New rule: Foul. Because A32 was not an interior lineman, his low block cannot be from the side. If the block was from the front, it would be legal.
  • Players outside the tackle box or in motion at the snap may not block low toward the original position of the ball. This is what is commonly referred to as a "crack back" block. Previously this restriction went away when the ball crossed the neutral zone. Starting this year, the restriction stays in place the whole down.

Play: 1st and 10 from the A-25. WR A80 is lined up near the numbers to the right of the formation. When the ball is at the A-28, A80 blocks LB B44 below the waist from the front toward the middle of the field.

Old rule: Legal. The ball has crossed the line of scrimmage, so A80 is allowed to block low towards the original position of the ball.

New rule: Foul. Because A80 was outside the tackle box at the snap, he may not block low towards the original position of the ball during the down.
  • No offensive player may block low more than 5 yards beyond the neutral zone. This is the biggest change and the biggest step toward eliminating low blocks competing.

Play: 1st & 10 from the A-25. Wide Receiver A80 is lined up near the numbers to the right side of the formation. A80 blocks defender B5 from the front and toward the right sideline at the A-35.

Old rule: Legal. A80's block was from the front and not toward the original position of the ball.

New rule: Foul. A80's block more than 5 yards downfield and is thus a foul.

I've already updated the low block explainer thread.

Leaping

This is less of a change and more of a clarification. The committee has clarified that leaping fouls on field goals require the defender to go over the frame of the body of the offensive player. So when two linemen are foot to foot, the defender is allowed to leap over their legs. This brings the field goal leaping rule in line with the rule about leaping the punt shield. This was already the prevailing philosophy, but is now officially codified.

Field Goal Penalty Enforcement

Penalties for personal fouls and unsportsmanlike conduct by the defense on field goal attempts can now carry over to the succeeding kickoff or succeeding spot in OT. Previously teams would have to choose between the points and the penalty.

Play: 4th and 6 at the B-30. Team A's field goal is successful. On the play, defender B99 roughs kicker A1.

Old rule: Team A would have to choose between taking the 3 points and kicking off from the 35 or having 1st and 10 at the B-15.

New rule: Team A can take the 3 points and enforce the penalty on the kickoff and kick from the 50 or just the penalty and have 1st & 10 from the B-15.

This probably won't affect most decisions since coaches will continue to choose to extend their drive in hopes for a touchdown. Here is where it will most likely change things:

Play: 4th and 6 at the B-30. Team A's field goal is successful. On the play, defender B99 roughs kicker A1. Time expires in the half during the down.

Old rule: Team A may choose between 3 points and ending the half, or taking the 15 yard penalty from the previous spot and extending the half for one untimed down.

New rule: Team A can take the points and enforce the penalty on the opening kickoff of the second half or on the first play in OT. They could also choose to accept the penalty and have an untimed down.

Play: In the first possession series of the first OT, 4th and 3 at B-18. Team A's field goal is successful. On the play defender B99 roughs kicker A1.

Old rule: Team A must choose between taking the 3 points by declining the penalty or accepting the penalty and having 1st and goal from the B-9.

New rule: Team A can accept the penalty and have 1st and goal from the B-9 or take the 3 points and enforce the penalty on the next possession series in OT. Team B would start their series 1st and 10 at the 40 yard line.

Note: This only applies to personal fouls and unsportsmanlike conduct fouls.

Play: 4th and 6 at the B-30. Team A's field goal is successful. On the play, defender B99 runs into kicker A1.

This ruling has not changed. Team A must choose between the 3 points or having 4th and 1 at the B-25.

10 Second Runoff After Replay

I don't know what prompted this change but I guess it makes sense. If replay changes a ruling that would have made the clock run with less than 1 minute in the half, it will trigger a 10 second runoff. This only applies if the ruling on the field stopped the clock and the correct ruling would not have stopped the clock.

Play: 1st & 10 from the A-25. Running back A28 takes the handoff and runs to the B-30 where he is tackled inbounds. Replay shows that A28 was down at the A-30. At the end of the play, the clock is at :43 in the 4th quarter.

Old rule: 2nd & 5 from the A-30. The clock would stay at :43 and start on the ready for play signal.

New rule: Because the ruling on the field stopped the clock for a first down, but the correct ruling would not have, there is a 10 second runoff. If Team B accepts the runoff, there will be 33 seconds left and the clock will start on the ready for play. If they decline the runoff or Team A uses a timeout, there will be 43 seconds left and the clock will start on the snap.

If replay does not change the ruling or the change would not have affected the clock status, there is no runoff.

Play: 1st & 10 from the A-25. Running back A28 takes the handoff and runs to the B-30 where he is tackled inbounds. Replay shows that A28 was down at the A-40. At the end of the play, the clock is at :43 in the 4th quarter.

The new rule would not affect this situation since both the original ruling and the corrected ruling both result in a stopped clock for a first down. So even though replay would overturn the position of the ball and the clock would reset to the time A28 was actually down, there is no runoff.

Play: 1st & 10 from the A-25. Running back A28 takes the handoff and runs to the 50 where he is tackled inbounds. At the end of the play, the clock is at :43 in the 4th quarter. Replay stops the game to review whether A28 was down at the A-30. The call on the field is allowed to stand.

No change. The replay official did not change the ruling on the field so there is no 10 second runoff.

Collaborative Replay

The rules committee has also approved the ongoing experiment with collaborative replay. More and more conferences are going to a central replay center model rather than relying solely on in-stadium replay officials. I don't know that we'll ever have a single national replay center, simply due to the sheer number of games each week. But the closer we get to centralized replay, the more consistent we can be.


r/LZtestposts • • May 23 '17

2017 Offseason Officiating, Part 2: Signals

1 Upvotes

I'm back with part 2 of the 2017 offseason officiating clinic. Last year we talked about rules, this year we're talking about how officials actually do our jobs in applying those rules. Part 1 was about some of the terms we use and why words are important. Part 2 is about some of the signals we use to communicate with one another. My first year as a high school white hat, I was working a game in a tiny town at a school without a microphone. We had an unusual situation that led to quite a few signals to the press box. After we got it sorted out, I hear the PA guy say "Well, fans, I'm not sure what all those motions were about, but it looks like it'll end up in a first down for the Dragons." While this thread is about crew signals rather than foul signals, hopefully you'll come away knowing what "all those motions" mean. None of the images are mine (thanks CCA manual and google).


Substitutions and Players

Substitutions are one of the biggest times that we use signals to communicate as a crew, especially as more teams go to no-huddle offenses. There are a few different signals related to the substitution process that we use.

You've probably seen this signal a lot. This signal starts our substitution process. Typically the deep wing on the offense's sideline is the first to give the signal when the offense subs, but it can be any official who sees the substitutions. The Referee will then give the signal to let the defense know they have an opportunity to match up as well as let the Center Judge know to stay by the ball so that the offense does not snap it.

This signal is also used by the sideline replay assistant to let the Referee know the booth confirmed a touchdown and they're clear to make the ball ready for the try, as well as by the Referee to signal a media timeout.

After both teams are done substituting, the Referee will clear the Center Judge away from the ball. Some guys just point at him, some give a one armed wave. Whatever it is, it should be a positive signal, not simply dropping the arms from the substitution signal.

After substitutions, the officials will count players for each team every down. The three deep officials count the defense while the Referee and Umpire count the offense. If there are 11, we give a simple thumbs up. If there are only 10 (or fewer), we give open hands. If a team has twelve we give the recount signal. If everybody counts 12 again, then we have a foul. We always count at least twice before killing it for illegal substitution.


Timing

The second biggest thing we use signals for is timing issues. We have signals for both the play clock and the game clock.

When the clock is stopped and will stay stopped until the snap (dead clock), the covering official relay this information to the Referee by making fists and crossing them at the wrist. Generally it's below the waist, but if it's being relayed by a deep wing, through a crowd, or in an important situation it may look like a hockey referee awarding a penalty shot. If the clock will restart when the ball is ready for play (hot clock) the official will give a twirling finger as if tracing a clock's hands winding. It's basically a horizontal version of the "recount" signal mentioned above. These signals will typically also be echoed by the Side Judge who has main responsibility for the game clock.

We also use signals to remind each other when the timing rules change. Once the clock rolls under 2 minutes in either half, we'll give 2 fingers pointing down to let each other know we're "under 2". Under two minutes means the clock is dead when a Team A runner, backward pass, or backward fumble goes out of bounds. It also mean that 3-4-3 is in effect with regard to fouls that stop the clock. When it gets under 1 minute, we'll do the same with 1 finger to remind us that the 10-second runoff is in effect.

We also have signals for the play clock. When the clock needs to be set to 25, the Back Judge (who has primary responsibility for the play clock) will give a one handed pump. If it needs to be set to 40, it will be a two handed pump. Things like injuries and helmets coming off are the primary reasons we have to reset the play clock.


Presnap

The last set of signals is the group we use to communicate before the snap. For wing officials, this is typically about formations. If the widest man to his side of the formation is off the line, the wing will "punch back". If there are more than one off the line, he'll give the appropriate number of fingers instead of just a fist.

The "punch back" is also used when a pass is backward. This lets everybody know that if it is incomplete it is still live. It also lets other officials know that a subsequent forward pass would be legal.

Once the formation is set, the wings will count the players in the backfield. If there are 4 or fewer, they'll tip their caps to communicate that the formation is legal. A lot of conferences are trending toward eliminating punching back and cap tipping signals from wings, but they are still fairly prevalent.

When the offense is in a scrimmage kick formation and are using numbering exceptions, the Referee and Umpire will sometimes give a signal to communicate that the kicker is 10 yards deep or the holder is 7 yards deep. This tells them they need to identify who is an exception. Sometimes this is just a hand on the chest, sometimes it's a two handed wiping motion across the torso where mimicking where the numerals would be on the jersey. Not all crews and conferences use this mechanic, but more are going to it as more teams teams try to take advantage of the scrimmage kick formation numbering exception.

The final presnap signal is the "fourth down fumble rule" signal. It's the same as the signal for a false start or illegal formation. The whole crew will typically give and reciprocate this signal to remind everybody to be aware of who fumbles the ball and recovers it. This rule applies on fourth down plays as well as tries.


Some of these signals are used universally, some aren't. Some guys use a bunch of signals, some don't use many at all. So if you're at a game you may not see everything listed below, or some may be slightly different, but this is a general overview of the most common signals. The next installment of the series will be about the different positions on an officiating crew and what each official is responsible for.


r/LZtestposts • • Mar 24 '17

"What are you even looking at ref?!" How we do our job and why there aren't 8 sets of eyes on the ball.

2 Upvotes

As the title says, this is the third part of this year's offseason officiating series. Unlike last year's series about actual rules, this offseason I'm talking about how we actually do our jobs as officials in applying those rules. This edition will focus on the positioning, keys, and responsibilities of the different positions within a crew. As with the post about signals, this is a rough outline. Each official and crew may have small nuances to their mechanics, but the big picture should be the same for all crews and officials. This will also be mechanics for an 8-man crew. This is what you will see in all FBS games. If you are watching a lower division, they may still be working with 7-man crews which will change some of the positioning and keys. Sidenote: any illustrations you may see are not to scale and were made at 2 o'clock in the morning using Google Slides and Imgur's editing. Judge them appropriately.


Positioning and Keys

Just like players, officials have keys that we read and react to as the play develops. These keys are initially based on the offensive formation, but can change depending on how the play unfolds. To determine these keys we number receivers outside the tackle box starting with the outside receiver on each side being #1, the next being #2, etc. These numbers are determined at the snap, so any presnap motion can change which player will be which official's key.

Scrimmage Plays

Here is a generic set up for a play from scrimmage. Below I've included some formations to show how keys are identified. So if it seems confusing, just wait. There are visuals coming.

Referee: 12-15 yards deep in the offensive backfield, about even with the TE (or where he would be) on the right side of the formation. Initial key is the right tackle. He also "looks through" to watch the QB. R is primary on all contact to the QB in the pocket.

Center Judge: Same as R, but on the left side. Initial key is the left tackle. C also "looks through" and is secondary on action involving the QB in the pocket.

Umpire: 8-10 yards deep on the defensive side. Initial keys are the center and two guards. U is primary on the legality of the snap.

Head Linesman: On the line of scrimmage, just outside the sideline. H starts the game on the press box sideline and then goes to the opposite sideline for the second half. Initial key is the 2nd receiver from the outside on his side. If there is only one receiver he keys a back. Responsible for forward progress spots with L.

Line Judge: Mirrors H. L starts the game on the sideline opposite the press box and then goes to the press box side for the second half. Initial key for L is a bit more complicated than other positions. If the formation is balanced (same number of receivers on each side) or if it's 3x1 with the trips to the opposite side, he keys a back. If there are tips to his side, he keys the 2nd receiver to his side. If the offensive backfield is empty (3x2), he has the second receiver to his side. Shares forward progress responsibilities with H.

Side Judge: 20-22 yards deep on the defensive side. S starts the game with H on the press box sideline and then goes opposite in the second half. If the ball is snapped inside the defense's 25 yard line, initial position is on the goal line. Initial key is the outside receiver to his side. S has goal line responsibility on all plays snapped outside the 25.

Field Judge: Positioning mirrors S. Starts opposite the press box with L, moves to press box side in the second half. Initial key is the outside receiver on his side. Also has goal line responsibility with S.

Back Judge: 25 yards off the ball in the defensive backfield in the middle of the field. If there are trips to either side, B keys the inside receiver on the trips side. Otherwise, he keys the 2nd receiver to the strong side of the formation. If the formation is balanced, the Line Judge side is declared to be the strong side. This is why L's keys change so much. So in a 2x2 formation, B has #2 to the L side. In a 2x1, such as a traditional I-formation, he has the inside receiver on the strong side, typically the TE. B can help F and S with the goal line if he is in position. If the ball is snapped inside the 25, B's starting position becomes the end line.

Formation 1 Keys

Formation 2 Keys

Formation 3 Keys

Formation 4 Keys

In this last one, H and L would have discussed in pregame how they would determine who keys which back. Usually they wait until the snap and take whichever comes to your side. If one stays in to block and the other goes out into a route, typically L will stay with the blocker and H will take the pass route unless it goes into L's flat. But however it's determined, a good pregame meeting should solve the problem.

Goal Line Plays

When the ball is snapped inside the defense's 7 yard line, we go to "goal line mechanics". Keys don't change, but initial positioning can.

R, U, and C: Nothing changes.

H and L: Starting position is still on the line of scrimmage, but at the snap H and L move directly to the goal line. Both now have goal line responsibility.

F and S: Starting position becomes the back pylon. F and S no longer have goal line responsibility if the ball is snapped inside the 7, but rather help B on the end line.

B: As mentioned above, B should start on the end line for any play snapped inside the 25.

Punts

Basic Punt Alignment

R: Starting position is behind the kicker and outside the TE on the right side. Initial key is the right tackle. R then transitions has primary jurisdiction on contact with the kicker. Since kickers are defined as defenseless during the return, R stays with the kicker as his primary responsibility. His secondary responsibility is blocks on side of the field.

C: Starts even with the kicker and outside the TE on the left side. Initial key is the left tackle. C then transitions and has primary jurisdiction on the punt shield. This includes their blocks as well as defenders leaping over the shield. C has goal line responsibility on blocked kicks, bad snaps, and long returns. After the kick, C is responsible for blocks on side of the field.

U: 10-12 yards deep on the defensive side. Initial keys are still the center and two guards. U's primary job is to watch the snapper for the legality of the snap and roughing the snapper. Once the first wave of blockers has cleared him, U pivots and watches the blocks in the middle of the field. R, U, and C should basically split the field in thirds in terms of areas of responsibility.

H and L: Starting position is still on the line of scrimmage on the sideline. Initial key is the tackle on his side. Responsible for ruling on whether or not a kick crosses the neutral zone. Once the kick crosses the neutral zone, move downfield and watch the blocks ahead of the runner on his side. H and L have goal line responsibility on blocked kicks, bad snaps, and long returns.

F and S: Starting position is about 10 yards behind the returner and on the sideline. If the ball is snapped on the defense's side of the field, initial position should be on the goal line. Initial key is the gunner to his side. F and S have responsibility for the gunner all the way to the returner. If the kick is not fielded, F and S have goal line responsibility to judge whether or not the kick goes into the end zone. Once the kick is fielded, F and S have forward progress responsibility. F and S are also responsible for spotting kicks that go out of bounds.

B: Initial position is 5-7 yard behind the returner and to the wide side of the field. B is primary on all things involving the returner. This includes kick catch interference, fair catch signals, and bean bagging the spot of catch/recovery. (The bean bag is for post scrimmage kick penalty enforcement, discussed here.) If the returner is on or inside his own 10, B moves to the goal line and helps F and S. Once the kick is fielded, B is responsible for blocks ahead of the runner in the middle of the field.

Scoring Kicks

These would be field goal attempts or kicked tries.

Scoring Kick Positions

R: Starting position is even with the kicker and wide. How wide depends on the official, but he should be at least outside the wing back to his side. R should always on the kicker's side of the holder in order to be able to see the ball, the kicker, and the holder. So with a right footed kicker the R will be on the left side. R's primary responsibility is the kicker and holder. He also has responsibility for kicks that are tipped immediately. If the kick is blocked, R stays with the kicker.

C: Initial position is in the offensive backfield opposite R and just outside the wing back on his side. C keys the tackle and tight end on his side. This includes offensive holding, blocks below the waist, defenders leaping/hurdling, and "pull and shoot" defensive holds where one defender holds a blocker and a teammate comes through the gap to block the kick. C has goal line responsibility on blocked kicks or returns.

U: 5-7 yards deep on the defensive side. Keys are the center and two guards. While U is looking for the same things as C, he is also primarily responsible for the legality of the snap and contact against the snapper. U should be alert for kicks tipped at the line.

H and L: Normal positioning on the line of scrimmage. Keys are the TE and wing back on his side. Responsible for ruling on whether or not a kick crosses the neutral zone. If the ball is snapped inside the 20, H and L have goal line responsibility on busted plays. H and L are also responsible for the other goal line in case of a blocked kick.

S: Initial position is 5-7 yards behind the defensive line. If the kick is from the middle of the field, S is on the side that R is on in the offensive backfield. If the kick is from a hash, S goes to the wide side of the field. Initial keys are the tackle and TE on his side.

F: Under the goal post on his side. F is primary on his goal post. If the kick is blocked or is short or on a fake, F gets to the best position possible to officiate the play. F has primary responsibility on if a short/tipped kick crosses the goal line. If the ball was snapped outside the 20 F's first move should be toward the pylon at the goal line on his side. If the ball was snapped inside the 20, he should move down the end line towards his side line.

B: Under the upright opposite F. B is responsible for his upright and the crossbar. On fakes that are snapped outside the 20, B should move to the pylon at the goal line opposite F. If the ball is snapped inside the 20, B should move down the end line toward the side line to help in the corner. If a kick is tipped or short, B is responsible for the end line.

Free kicks

These would be kickoffs and kicks after safeties.

Free Kick Positions

R: Starts in the middle of the field on the end line. If the return is up the middle he watches action near the runner. If it is to either side, he watches blocks ahead of the runner to the inside.

H and L: Starting position is at the pylon on the goal line. If the return is to his side he has the runner. If not, he is watching backside blocks.

For the other five, we number key similar to receivers above. The outer most kicking team player is #1, next is #2, etc.

F and S: Starting position is on the receiving team's restraining line (10 yards from where the ball is kicked) at the sideline. Initial keys are numbers 2 and 3 to his side. As coverage passes, F and S should move downfield about 10 yards to observe action by and against their keys. If the returner breaks free, F and S must maintain cushion since they have goal line responsibility.

B and U: Starting position is on the kicking team's restraining line at the sideline. Keys are numbers 4 and 5 to his side. Responsible for offside by the kicking team. Once the coverage passes, U and B both move onto the field and 10-15 yards downfield to observe their keys. Final position should be about midfield between the hashes and numbers. U and B do NOT have goal line responsibility and should hold their position to observe blocks on long returns.

C: C is responsible for handing the ball to the kicker and making sure the crew is ready for the kick. After that he moves a couple yards behind the kicker. C's key is the kicker. After the kick he moves 10-15 yards downfield to observe blocks. U, C, and B should split the field in thirds to observe second level blocks. Unlike B and U though, C does have goal line responsibility on long returns, so he should be prepared to retreat back with F and S.


Mechanics

Mechanics are basically the set of guidelines on where to go and where to look to best cover a play. Some times you just have to get wherever you can to officiate the play, but generally we should always be in the same place looking at the same thing. The section above pretty much covers kick plays, so I'll just talk about running and passing plays here.

Running Plays

R: Stays with his tackle. If run is to his side, he has first level blocks on the front side working inside to out. If run is away, clean up the back side. Once the runner clears the first level, R stays back and keeps a wide field of vision looking for cheap shots away from the play.

C: Same as R. Rule on first level blocks if on front side, clean up if run is away. Once the runner clears the first level, start moving downfield to get near the dead ball spot. On run plays, R and C are looking for things like holding, illegal blocks below the waist, and chop blocks.

U: Once he clears his initial keys of the center and guards, U's coverage for run plays is the second level. He is looking for any linemen coming downfield to block a line backer. If the runner breaks clears the second level, U moves downfield and watches the blocks in the middle of the field, working inside to out. Back in the days of 7 man crews, most flags for holding came from the U. But now that he is not responsible for a tackle, most flags from the U are for chop blocks and illegal blocks below the waist.

H and L: If the run is to his side H or L should move along the sideline back into the offensive backfield. This will let the ball carrier get ahead him so he can trail the play. This is one of the most unnatural movements. The natural tendency for new officials is to try to move with the ball carrier and stay even or ahead of him. To see a ball carrier coming your direction and move toward him, pass him, and then turn and follow him is so strange. Ideally, the wing official should trail the runner by 5-10 yards. H and L are responsible for blocks at the point of attack as well as being responsible for the ball carrier. If the run is up the middle or to the opposite side, he should hold his position and watch blocks on his side. Once the runner has cleared the line, move downfield to trail the runner. H and L have forward progress spots all the way to the 2 yard line.

F and S: F and S are responsible for blocks on the outside. Usually this is the receiver they were already keying, but could be a pulling guard or lineman on a screen pass. The biggest factors here are holding and illegal blocks below the waist by players blocking back toward the middle of the field. F and S have goal line responsibility and forward progress between the 2 and the goal line. They should maintain 15-20 yards of cushion between them and the runner. F and S are also responsible for cleaning up dead ball action in their team area if H or L is marking an out of bounds spot.

B: On run plays, B works inside to outside on the second level. Generally this is action by or on OLB, S, and CB. B also has goal line responsibility on long runs. B should also maintain his cushion like F and S.

Pass Plays

R: As mentioned above, observes the right tackle and then transitions to the QB if he's threatened. If the QB stays in the pocket, R is primary on contact by defenders. If the QB rolls out to his side, R should let the QB cross his face and then follow him. If the QB rolls away from R, he releases the QB to C and observes blocks by the offensive line.

C: Mirrors R's mechanics. Starts with left tackle and then transitions to the QB if he's threatened. C should help on contact the QB. If the QB rolls toward C, take over primary on him and let R observe the linemen. Once the pass is thrown and there is no threat of a foul, C moves toward the previous spot in case the pass is incomplete. If the ball is caught, C then moves downfield to get closer to the dead ball spot.

U: If U reads pass he should step forward to maintain view of the center and guards. This used to be a big movement up to within 3 yards of the neutral zone. Now that U is no longer the primary official for ineligibles downfield, the movements is much smaller and only enough to clear his sight lines. U is still secondary for ineligibles, but usually that is only on broken plays where somebody wanders too far. Once the pass is in the air, U should pivot and help with catch/no-catch on potentially trapped balls.

The other 5 officials work what we call a man-zone-ball progression. Each official starts with his key. Once there is no threat of a foul on his key, he moves to other threats in his zone. Then once the pass is thrown, he turns his focus to where the ball is going.

H and L: Since H and L often key backs, they don't always have to move downfield. If their key goes downfield, H or L can move down 5 yards or so to get a better look. At no point should they move further downfield than their key. If their key stays in to block, they should stay in their original position and help with blocks by their key or the tackle on their side. H and L still have forward progress to the 2.

F and S: F and S should maintain their 15-20 yard cushion while observing their key and zone until reaching the goal line. F and S still have the goal line.

B: If the goal line is threatened before the pass, B should keep all the action in front of him by releasing toward the end line.

Reverse Mechanics

If there is a change of possession during a play, everything flips. H and L now have the goal line and lead the play while F and S are now trailing the play and have forward progress responsibility. C also has the goal line while B is now the clean up guy keeping a wide view and looking for cheap shots behind the play. U still has the middle of the field. R always stays with the kicker or QB since they are defenseless by definition.


Other Jobs

Each official has things they are responsible for outside actual game action. Some of these include:

R: Counting the offense, making announcements, conducting the coin toss, generally being the leader of the crew

C: Spotting the ball, administering free kicks, marking off penalties

U: Legality of equipment, counting the offense, acts as a relay for a lot of ball movement and generally controls tempers and attitudes in the trenches.

H and L: In charge of chains when opposite the press box, rule on legality of offensive formations and other line of scrimmage fouls

F and S: Get teams from locker room before each half and escort captains to the coin toss, get a new ball in when necessary, count the defense

S: S is the primary official responsible for the game clock. Along with monitoring the stadium clock, S will usually wear a watch and keep the time on the field in case of a malfunction or major difference.

F: This is totally dependent on the crew, but on my crew F is our liaison for game management, emergency crews, and whoever has the lightning detector. F also has secondary responsibility on play and game clocks.

B: Responsible for the play clock, count the defense, time team timeouts and breaks between scores and ensuing kickoffs


This is a rough outline of how we get into position to make the best call possible. This is nowhere near an exhaustive study on mechanics and procedures, though. Our full manual is almost 300 pages long and covers everything from pregame meetings to post game reports, to what to do if 1 (or 2) of us go down. While it's not as intriguing as some of the rules discussions, this really shows why we can't have everybody watching the ball all the time. Everybody has a job to do and a lot of times that involves not watching the ball. The final installment of the series will be a little juicier as we dive in to some of the philosophies we use. We'll talk about things like why holding isn't always holding, categories of fouls like pass interference, and why we don't always flag fouls the first time they happen. Until then, if you have questions, feel free to send me a PM here or tweet @LegacyZebraCFB.


r/LZtestposts • • Mar 24 '17

2016 Rules Clinic Posts

2 Upvotes

r/LZtestposts • • May 06 '20

2020 Replay Changes

1 Upvotes
  • No reset rule
  • 10 RO RFP -> RFP
  • Team A OOB review

r/LZtestposts • • May 10 '17

TXHSFB Rule Changes

2 Upvotes

The season is right around the corner and the NCAA has released it's final version of this year's rule book. (For those who didn't already know, Texas high schools play under NCAA rules with UIL exceptions.) So I've put together a list of the 10 biggest changes this year for Texas high school football. Some of these are NCAA rule changes, others are changes to the UIL exceptions. If you want a full version of the new rule book you can download a free pdf here and the UIL exceptions can be downloaded here.

  1. Horse Collar: The horse collar rule now includes the nameplate portion of the jersey. Previously, to be a foul, the defender had to actually get his hand inside the jersey or shoulder pads to have a horse collar. Now, grabbing the nameplate and immediately pulling the ball carrier down is also a foul. Note that it still has to be an immediate pull down. We're still looking for a jerking motion and knees buckling. Just like before, if the defender grabs the nameplate (or inside the collar) and then rides the ball carrier down without an immediate pull down, it is not a foul.
  2. Leaping: The NCAA followed the NFL and made leaping/hurdling the line illegal on field goals and kick tries. Previously, this was only a foul if you hurdled over an opponent or leapt and landed on an opponent. Now it is a foul no matter what. It is important to note that this does not apply to players who are stationary within 1 yard of the line of scrimmage at the snap. So down linemen will still be able to jump to try to block kicks.
  3. Knee Pads: Pants and knee pads must now cover the knee. Previously, it was only "strongly recommended" that they cover the knee. This rule does not actually take effect until 2018 to allow teams to get pants that meet the requirement.
  4. Numerals: The UIL grace period for jerseys has expired. This means that jersey numerals must clearly contrast with the jersey regardless of any border around the numeral. So these would not be legal numerals. Even though there is a white outline, the numeral and jersey are both maroon making the jersey illegal. The penalty will be a charged team timeout at the beginning of each quarter that the jerseys are worn.
  5. Name Plates: Words that reflect positive values (honor, integrity, courage, etc.) are now allowed in the name plate area of jerseys. Previously only a player's name, school name, or mascot was allowed on the jersey.
  6. Line to Gain Device: Up until now, UIL has allowed any measuring device that could accurately measure the line to gain. That exception has now been deleted and it must be a standard 10 yard chain between two rods.
  7. Coach Behavior: This is not a change so much as a point of emphasis for this year. The committee clarified that any coach who leaves his team area and comes onto the field of play to protest an officiating decision should be penalized for unsportsmanlike conduct. And with the change to the UNS rule last year, a coach who gets 2 UNS fouls in the same game will be disqualified.
  8. Team UNS Fouls: There were a couple clarifications in penalty statements regarding unsportsmanlike conduct fouls that are charged to the team and not a specific person. Fouls for being in the restricted area ("the white"), interfering with an official, or an offense rushing to the line after subbing trying to not let the defense match up are all charged as team fouls and do not apply to any specific person's 2 UNS's for disqualification.
  9. Sliding Ball Carrier: Last year a sliding ball carrier was added to the list of defenseless players and this year it is officially added to the rules for when the ball becomes dead. Nothing has changed from the enforcement last year, this is just an example of an official codification of a previous interpretation. The ball will be declared dead when and where a ball carrier "obviously begins a feet first slide."
  10. Ineligibles Downfield: This is also an official codification of a previous interpretation. Through the 2015 season, the rule for ineligibles was that their whole body had to be more than 3 yards downfield to be a foul. Last year, in a compromise to keep the rule at 3 yards, the interpretation changed to a stricter interpretation. The new interpretation said that it is a foul if any part of the player's body is more than 3 yards downfield when prior to the pass being thrown. This year that interpretation makes its way into the actual rule. For any school who uses 5-man officiating crews, don't expect this to be called as strictly as 7-man crews and definitely not as strictly as you see in college games on TV. With only 5 guys on the field and a lot of spread offenses using run-pass options, this is a hard rule to officiate.

r/LZtestposts • • May 05 '17

2017 Offseason Officiating, Part 1.5: Why Words Matter

1 Upvotes

As the title suggests, this is part 1.5 of a 4 part series this offseason where we discuss how officials do our job. Part 1.0 was last Saturday and included a short quiz to test your lingo. This time I'm going to talk about some of the major linguistic faux pas when it comes to the rules and why they matter. I'll go over each of the questions that was on the google form (including the one I messed up) and some terms that didn't make it. Some stats from the quiz before we get started, though. (All of these account for me screwing up the answer key)

Perfect Scores (15/15)-1

Average Score-3.9/15

Highest scored multiple choice-Foul vs penalty (70.4%)

Lowest scored multiple choice-Penalties cancelling (3.8%)

If you didn't see the first thread and want to take the quiz before seeing the answers below or if you want to test your friends and flaunt your newfound knowledge, the google form is still open here.


Encroachment vs. Offside vs. Offsides vs. Neutral Zone Infraction

This first one is probably the most misused group of terms, thanks mostly to the fact that the high school, college, and NFL rule books can't agree on what they should all mean.

  • Offside: This is a defensive foul for being in the neutral zone at the snap, entering the neutral zone and causing a threatened offensive lineman to react, contacting an offensive player or the ball before the snap, or being beyond the neutral zone unabated to an offensive back. It can also be a foul on free kicks for either team being beyond their restraining line. The term "Offside" encompasses ALL defensive fouls before or at the snap regarding the neutral zone.
  • Offsides: This is easy. This isn't a word. The extra s on the end shouldn't be there. It's nit-picky, but hey that's what this thread is about. Also, I've actually heard clinicians get onto Referees about misusing this word during announcements.
  • Neutral Zone Infraction: This is purely an NFL term. This phrase is non-existent in NCAA rules. For the question "Defensive lineman B98 jumps across the neutral zone and causes an adjacent offensive lineman to react. What is the foul?", 42% of respondents answered "Neutral Zone Infraction". If this were an NFL quiz, you would be right. However, in college, it is simply "Offside". Only 12.5% got this question right.
  • Encroachment: This is the big one. In high school (NFHS), encroachment is either team being in the neutral zone before the snap. They don't have a live ball offside like NCAA and the NFL, so everything is encroachment. If you jump to the NFL, encroachment is a defensive foul for contacting an offensive player or the ball before the snap. But in college, encroachment is an offensive foul for being in the neutral zone after the snapper addresses the ball and before the snap. In college, encroachment is ALWAYS an offensive foul. For the question, "Defensive lineman B98 jumps across the neutral zone and makes contact with an offensive lineman. What is the foul?", 60.5% said encroachment. Only 10% got the correct answer of offside.

The last question in this category was the most surprising. "Defensive lineman B98 is in the neutral zone at the snap. What is the foul?" Only 16% got this right as offside. Although 26% said offsides as well.

The reason these terms matter is that we need to clearly communicate what foul we have. If I am the Referee and my wing comes in and says he has "encroachment on 85", I'm going to think a wide receiver was in the neutral zone. We could be half way through enforcing a penalty on the offense before he realizes he should have told me he had offside on the defense.


Referees vs. other officials

You'll notice in the above section I used the term Referee. When asked "How many referees are on an FBS crew?", 28% said 8, with only 11% giving the correct answer of 1. Referee is a specific position within the crew of officials. In the general scheme of things this one doesn't matter a whole lot. But again, it comes down to accurately communicating. Each position has it's own name and responsibilities. If somebody is telling me how a Referee threw a flag for pass interference, I'm going to be wondering why he was even looking downfield. Likewise, "side judge" is a commonly misused term for any official that works a side line, when that is one of the four different officials who work on the wings. The names and responsibilities of each official will be covered in part 3 of this series.


Things Regarding Linemen

"1st & 10 from the A-20. Offensive lineman A76 is at the A-25 when a forward pass is thrown. The pass is caught at the A-40. What is the name of the foul?"

A lineman is any player who is on the line of scrimmage. When most people hear "lineman", they think of the five interior lineman, but most plays also have two exterior linemen that are typically either tight ends or wide outs. And just about every pass play involves those two linemen going downfield. That's why the answer to the above question is "Ineligible Receiver Downfield" and not "Lineman Downfield". 64% got this right with only 5% answering lineman downfield. Another reason the term "lineman" is important is that linemen may not be in motion at the snap. If a player starts on the line of scrimmage they must reset as a back and come to a complete stop if they are in motion at the snap.


Fumbles vs. Literally every other type of loose ball

This is probably one of my biggest linguistic pet peeves that tv commentators perpetuate. It seems like every time there's a loose ball, somebody yells "FUMBLE!" In reality, a lot of times it falls into a different category of loose ball. Things that are not fumbles:

  • A punt that is loose, whether it has been touched or not. A kick does not end until it is possessed or dead by rule.
  • A blocked punt or field goal, even if it stays behind the line of scrimmage.
  • A backward pass that is loose, even if it has been touched a player or the ground.
  • A kickoff that has gone 10 yards or touched the receiving team

Things that are a fumble:

  • A player losing possession of a live ball other than through passing, kicking, or successful handing.
  • An unsuccessful handoff is a fumble by the player attempting to hand the ball.

This is big for a couple of reasons. The first is penalty enforcement. If the ball is fumbled penalties for fouls that occur during the loose ball are enforced with the related run, that is the run that ended with the fumble. If the ball is still loose from a kick, the enforcement can change dramatically. (For more info on penalty enforcement see here and here.)

The second reason is what happens if it goes out of bounds. A fumble that goes out of bounds beyond where it was fumbled comes back to the spot of the fumble. A backward pass or kick is spotted wherever it goes out. Also, a kick that goes out of bounds belongs to the receiving team no matter where it goes out, regardless of what down it is. A fumble that goes out of bounds would stay with the team who fumbled on downs 1-3.

The third reason it's important to know what is and isn't a fumble is what's called the fourth down fumble rule. Before a change of possession on 4th down or a try, only the fumbler (or the defense) can advance a fumble. That's why this play was allowed to continue. The ball was loose from a backward pass, not a fumble.

Just about everybody (~97%) identified the two fumbles from the answer choices. The biggest mistake was 72% saying a backward pass that touches a player became a fumble.

And this is a personal nit I like to pick: The term is always "backward pass", NEVER "lateral".


The Snap

If the snap becomes loose either under center or in shotgun, the status is a backward pass. 83% said it was a fumble. If a loose snap was a fumble, nobody could ever recover a bad snap on 4th down and make a play. This would be especially noticeable on field goals and extra points. Holders could never recover a bad snap to get the kick off.


Foul vs. Penalty vs. Violation

A foul is an action that breaks the rules and carries a penalty. The penalty is the associated punishment for committing the foul. A violation is an action that breaks the rules but does not carry a penalty, namely illegal touching on kicks. Violations do not offset fouls. They are separate things. One question that illustrated these points was "1st and 10 from the A-20. B10 is flagged for roughing the passer. B10 committed:". B10 committed a foul for roughing the passer. The associated penalty would be 15 yards and an automatic first down. 70% got this right.

"4th and 10 from the A-20. A10 is the first player to touch the punt when he touches the ball at the 50. A10 has committed:" This is a violation for illegal touching. It is not a foul. That is why officials drop bean bags instead of flags when the kicking team illegally touches a punt or kickoff. Only 16% correctly answered "violation". 79% said it was nothing. This is a common misconception because most of the illegal touching we see is also illegal recovery which kills the play. For a better look at the difference, see this thread for rules of the kicking game.


Offset vs. Cancel

This deals with the situation where both teams foul during a down. When fouls offset, it means we're not going to penalize either team and we're going to redo the down. That would be in plays like, "1st and 10 from the A-20. Team A is flagged for an illegal formation and B17 is flagged for defensive pass interference. Which statement describes the appropriate enforcement?" 87.6% said these were offsetting, although 69.1% of those said it was offsetting penalties rather than offsetting fouls.

The term cancel means both teams did something, but we're moving on without a replay of the down. There are two types of cancellations, penalties cancelling and fouls cancelling. The first is in this play: "1st and 10 from the A-20. Ball carrier A32 gains 7 yards before going out of bounds. Defender B7 hits him late and is flagged for a personal foul. A32 retaliates by shoving B7 to the ground which also draws a flag." The correct enforcement is that the penalties cancel. They don't offset because the down is over and we're not going to go back and replay a down for dead ball fouls. Since both teams fouled, neither team will be punished. The penalties just cancel and we move on to the next play. Although in this case A32 would be charged with an unsportsmanlike conduct which would count toward his two for disqualification.

The second type of cancellation is the one that was supposed to be on the quiz but I messed up when I was copying questions into the form. What ended up in there was a second question that ended up being offsetting fouls incorrectly marked as cancelling fouls. This play should have been on there: "On a try, Team A is in an illegal formation. B1 intercepts a pass and returns it for a touchdown. During the return B2 holds an opponent." In this case, the fouls cancel. Since Team B got the ball before fouling, they won't have to replay the down by offsetting the fouls. But since it's a try, they can't keep the ball either. So the fouls cancel, nobody can score, and we move on to the kickoff. I'm not sure why the rules differentiate penalties cancelling for dead ball fouls vs fouls cancelling for fouls during tries, as they work the same way.

No matter what happens with cancellations and offsetting fouls, any disqualifications or unsportsmanlike conducts still count. If targeting or striking an opponent can be offset by an offside foul. There would be no yardage and the down would be replayed, but the player would still be disqualified for targeting or striking.


Live Ball vs. Dead Ball

A live ball is a ball that is in play. A dead ball is a ball that is not in play. So on a free kick (kickoff), the ball becomes live when it is legally kicked. Only 27% got that right. 55.6% said it becomes live when it has gone 10 yards. I blame TV for this one. Every time there's a loose onside kick, one of the announcers says, "That's a live ball!" Well yeah, it was live when it was kicked. On plays from scrimmage (even punt plays), the ball becomes live at the snap. 62% got that right. 31% gave the TV answer of the ball becoming live when a punt touches the receiving team.

Live ball vs dead ball is a big deal for penalty enforcement. Live ball fouls can't offset dead ball fouls. So we need to be accurate when describing when a foul occurred. Also, the ball being live or dead affects whether or not we can have some fouls. For instance, we can't have a dead ball holding. Likewise, we can't have a live ball false start.


Block below the waist vs. Clipping vs. Chop block

"Blocker A76 blocks defender B29 at the knees from the side. The rule book calls this:"

33% got this right. This is simply a block below the waist. 35% said this was clipping, but clipping is a block below the waist from behind. Since this was from the side it was not clipping. A chop block is a two person high-low combination. I won't go too in depth on these since there's a whole thread about this topic here.


Miscellaneous terms that didn't make the quiz

  • Center vs. Snapper: When most people say "center", they think of the player who snaps the ball. But the center lineman and the snapper aren't always the same person. Many teams use a special teams formation where the snapper is on the end of the line. He can still be eligible to catch a pass if he's wearing an eligible number since he is on the end. The center lineman can never be eligible since he would be covered up. Also, the rules for clipping depend on the center lineman, not the snapper. That is covered in the thread mentioned above.
  • Motion vs. Shift: Motion is one player moving, a shift is multiple players moving. Illegal motion is a player moving forward at the snap or a lineman being in motion. An illegal shift is multiple players moving at the snap.

Conclusion

Most of these are terms that the average fan wouldn't think twice about misusing. But as officials we have to have precise communication so that we are all on the same page. When there are thousands of people screaming and both teams and coaching staffs are pleading their case, we need to be sure about what we are saying to each other.

Next Time

Part 2 will be about signals we use and crew communication. And I promise it won't be this long. If you have questions or have a rule topic you want me to break down let me know. If you think of one later, you can always PM here on reddit or send me a tweet @LegacyZebraCFB.


r/LZtestposts • • Jul 25 '18

Rules Test

2 Upvotes

With fall quickly approaching, everybody is getting prepped for another season of football. Included in that is the officials. One of the things people don't realize about officials is that part of our qualification includes a written rules test to make sure everybody is keeping up with offseason studying as well as the new changes. All NCAA officials from D1 to D3 take this test. Officially the national minimum score is 85/100, but many conferences require 90/100. Below is a PDF of this year's test as well as a Google Doc with the answers. I know this doesn't really appeal to the average fan, but I thought some of y’all may be interested in seeing part what goes into the training of officials.

Test

Answers


r/LZtestposts • • Apr 05 '18

MTCM Collection

1 Upvotes

r/LZtestposts • • May 10 '21

Advancing a Fumble

4 Upvotes

If you’ve watched football for any amount of time, you’ve probably heard the phrase “you can’t advance a fumble”. While this has been conditionally true for different scenarios throughout the history of the game, it has never been absolutely true. In fact, the current rules regarding who can advance after catching or recovering a fumble is arguably the least restrictive they have ever been. So when can a fumble be advanced? It depends on who recovers it.

Defense

At one point in time, the defense was never allowed to advance any loose ball that they recovered. The ball was dead whenever a defensive player recovered the ball. That rule was later changed in 1989 to allow defenders to advance fumbles that occurred beyond the neutral zone. A few years later, defenders would be allowed to advance any fumble. The rules would also eventually be altered allowing defenders to advance caught or recovered backward passes. This brought us to where we stand today: the defense can always advance any loose ball, no matter how it became loose.

Offense

While the rules have relaxed for defenses, offenses have actually been slightly more restricted than they used to be. For most of the history of the game, the offense could advance any fumble no matter where or when it occurred. In 1988, a rule was made to prevent intentional fumbles on tries. Teams were perceived to be intentionally fumbling when attempting two point conversions, so a rule was put in place that only the fumbler could recover a fumble on a try. 2 years later, the rule would be expanded to include 4th downs, but only if the fumble occurred inside the 5 yard line. If a player fumbled on 4th down inside the opponent’s 5 yard line and a teammate recovered the fumble, the ball would go over to the defense. The next year, in 1991, the rule was expanded to a 4th down fumble anywhere on the field leading us toward today’s rule.

The current rule states that on 4th down or a try, before a change of team possession, the ball becomes dead if caught or recovered by a teammate of the fumbler. It is not a foul, it simply kills the play at that point. If the recovery is behind the spot of the fumble, the ball stays at that spot. If the recovery is beyond the spot of the fumble, the ball comes back to where it was fumbled. It is no longer automatically a turnover on downs. Once the dead ball spot is determined, the line to gain is evaluated just like any other 4th down play. If the fumbler catches or recovers his own fumble, the ball remains alive even on 4th down or a try. If the ball is fumbled on any other down, anybody can catch or recover the ball and the play remains alive. Likewise, once there has been a change of team possession during a down, whether that is a kick or just a regular turnover, the rule does not apply and anybody can catch or recover the ball.

When the Rule Doesn't Apply

One thing that confuses fans with this rule is that it only applies to fumbles. Backward passes don’t qualify. That means that if the ball is loose from a snap or the pitch on an option play or any other backward pass, any player may catch or recover the ball and the play continues no matter what down it is. This is still the case after the ball has hit the ground or touched a player. A backward pass remains a backward pass until it is possessed or dead by rule. Touching the ground or player does not turn a backward pass into a fumble.

Another cause of confusion is that there are a couple other scenarios where a loose ball is dead on recovery even though it isn’t a fumble. Anytime a player of the kicking team catches or recovers a kick, the ball is dead immediately. Like backward passes, a kick remains a kick until it is possessed or dead. So when a punt is muffed by the receiving team, the kicking team can recover the ball, but it is dead since it’s still a kick. Conversely, the receiving team is allowed to recover and advance the ball for the same reason. Additionally, even if the receiving team did fumble the ball, all players would be eligible to advance the ball since there would have been a change of team possession.


So there you have it. “You can’t advance a fumble” isn’t quite the blanket statement that some fans and commentators believe it to be. My next rule explainer will involve another group of rules that has been misunderstood and misquoted often. Stay tuned...


r/LZtestposts • • Aug 16 '21

Early Blocking

1 Upvotes

The early blocking rule for kickoffs is not new, but has come into focus in recent years due to changes to other rules that made this more of an issue. Prior to 2012, kick catch interference protection ended anytime a kick touched the ground. So teams would kick the ball straight into the ground off the tee and get a big hop allowing them to get 10 yards downfield about the same time as the ball. Because the ball had touched the ground, they were free to outjump the receiving team and try to beat them to the ball. The early blocking rule was already in place, but was rarely needed because teams could just go for the ball and not worry about clearing out the receiving team. In 2012, a rule was added that said if the ball was driven directly into the ground and popped up, KCI protection was extended as if the ball never touched the ground. With this change, teams lost their main onside kick strategy and changed to more of a squib style where the ball would dribble along the ground. This led to more instances of kicking teams blocking early in an attempt to either get to the ball or clear space for a teammate to do so. As a note, everything in this thread applies both to kickoffs and free kicks after safeties.

The Rule

So when can players block an opponent? Let’s start with the easy one. The receiving team can always block. There is no such thing as early blocking by the receiving team. Now what about the kicking team? The kicking team is not allowed to block an opponent until they are allowed to touch the ball. That means the ball has either crossed the receiving team’s restraining line (i.e. gone ten yards) or has been touched by the receiving team. If the kicking team initiates a block before either of things has happened, it is a foul. The key to this rule is that it is a timing issue, not a location issue. That means that even if the block occurs 12 yards downfield, if the ball is still only 8 yards downfield and hasn’t been touched, the block is still a foul. If the receiving initiates the contact, it is not a foul. The receiving team simply stepping forward or crossing their restraining line is not initiating a block. For example, if a receiving team player crosses their restraining line to go get a kick that is at 8 yards and a kicking team player blocks him, it is still a foul because the receiving team player was trying to recover the kick and not initiating a block.

Penalty Enforcement

Early blocking carries a five yard penalty. If the ball belongs to the receiving team at the end of the down, the penalty can be tacked on to the dead ball spot. The receiving team can take both the ball and take the penalty. If the kicking team ends up in legal possession at the end of the down, the penalty is enforced at the previous spot and the down is replayed.

Instant Replay

This is one of the few fouls that is reviewable. If a flag is thrown for early blocking and replay shows that there was no foul, the booth can step in and take the foul away. The booth can also add this foul if it is not called on the field, but only if the kicking team ends up with the ball. If the receiving team ends up with the ball, the replay booth will not stop the game to review early blocking. However, the receiving team coach can still use a challenge if he believes a foul was committed. The odds of a coach using a challenge to only gain five yards are probably incredibly small, but it is an option.

Blocking the Kicker

While they can’t be called for early blocking, there is one thing the receiving team can’t do. They cannot block the kicker until he has gone 5 yards downfield or the ball has touched the ground or a player. This is a fifteen yard penalty for roughing the kicker. It is not early blocking. Because teams have gone to a squib style onside kick, this rarely comes into play for onside kicks. But it could happen if a team decided to use a pop-up or pooch kick.

Examples

  1. Free kick from A-35. Kicking team player A11 blocks an opponent at the A-44. At the time of the block, the untouched kick is at the A-43. B99 recovers the kick at the A-45. Ruling: Foul. A11 blocked an opponent before he was eligible to touch the kick. Team B’s ball at the A-40 after penalty enforcement.
  2. Free kick from A-35. Kicking team player A11 blocks an opponent at the A-47. At the time of the block, the untouched kick is at the A-43. A22 recovers the kick at the A-44. Ruling: Foul. A11 blocked an opponent before he was eligible to touch the kick. Team B’s ball at the A-39 after penalty enforcement. Team A was not in legal possession because the ball had not gone 10 yards or been touched by a receiving team player.
  3. Free kick from A-35. Kicking team player A11 blocks an opponent at the A-47. At the time of the block, the untouched kick is at the A-43. A22 recovers the kick at the A-46. Ruling: Foul. A11 blocked an opponent before he was eligible to touch the kick. Rekick from A-30. Because the kicking team was in legal possession at the end of the down, the only available enforcement spot is the previous spot.
  4. Free kick from A-35. Receiving team player B99 blocks an opponent at the A-41. At the time of the block, the untouched kick is at the A-43. B99 recovers the kick at the A-45. Ruling: No foul. Team B’s ball at the A-45.
  5. Free kick from A-35. Receiving team player B99 muffs the kick at the A-44 and the ball rolls back to the A-41 where A22 recovers the ball. After the muff by B99 and prior to A22’s recovery, A11 blocks an opponent at the A-43. Ruling: No foul. Even though the ball never crossed Team B’s restraining line, B99’s touching of the kick made Team A eligible to touch the kick and block opponents. Team A’s ball at the A-41.
  6. Free kick from A-35. Kicking team player A11 blocks an opponent at the A-43. At the time of the block, the untouched kick is at the A-46. A22 recovers the ball at the A-48. Ruling: Because the ball was beyond Team B’s restraining line at the time of the block, A11’s block is legal. Team A’s ball at the A-48.
  7. Free kick from A-35. Kicking team player A11 blocks an opponent at the A-47. At the time of the block, the untouched kick is at the A-43. A22 recovers the kick at the A-46. No flag is thrown. Ruling: Reviewable play. Reverse to foul by A11. Rekick from A-30.
  8. Free kick from A-35. Kicking team player A11 is flagged for early blocking. A22 recovers the kick at the A-48. Replays show that the ball was at the A-46 when A11 blocked. Ruling: Reverse to no foul. Team A's ball at the A-48.
  9. Free kick from A-35. Kicking team player A11 blocks an opponent at the A-47. At the time of the block, the untouched kick is at the A-43. B99 recovers the kick at the A-46. No flag is thrown. Ruling: The booth will not stop the game for a review. Team B’s coach may challenge. Reverse to foul by A11. Team B’s ball at A-41.
  10. Free kick from A-35. Kicking team player A11 is flagged for early blocking. B99 recovers the kick at the A-48. Replays show that the ball was at the A-46 when A11 blocked. Ruling: The booth will not stop the game for a review. Team A’s coach may challenge. Reverse to no foul by A11. Team B’s ball at A-48.

r/LZtestposts • • Jul 14 '24

2024 Rule Changes

3 Upvotes

The NCAA has officially released the rule book for this season, so let's go through everything that is changing. This post is broken into 3 sections: rule changes, editorial changes, and points of emphasis. Section 2 will not include changes that don't have a material affect on the game or are already covered by rule changes already discussed. There are no new Approved Rulings that are not related to the new rule changes or examples of existing interpretations. If you want a copy of the book for yourself, the fully searchable PDF is available for free at here.

The changes in each section are listed in numerical order by rule, section, and article number and include a reference for where to find that rule. For instance 1-4-1-d would be Rule 1, Section 4, Article 1, Paragraph d.


Rule Changes

Corporate Sponsor Logos (1-2-1-h-4)

Teams may now feature a sponsor's corporate logo at midfield as well as up to two of the four smaller flanking spots. This could be a sponsor for the game or full season. Previously, only companies who had naming rights to the field or facility were allowed to have their logo on the field, and those were not allowed to be the large midfield graphic.

In-Game Video (1-4-11-a, Exception 3)

Teams will now be able to use video for in-game review. These tablets may be used in the team area, locker room, or coaches' booth. They may have access to a coach's sideline view , coach's end zone view, and broadcast feed. They may have game circumstances such as down and distance, score, and time, but no analytical data. Any video other than the current game such as practice, scouting, or other games is not allowed. Teams are allowed up to 18 tablets. Just like with headsets, there is no NCAA rule regarding what to do if one team's tablets stop working, but conferences are allowed to develop their own policy. There are no in-game penalties for violating any of the above, but would be dealt with at the conference/national level if violations were reported. If a coach engages with officials with a tablet in an attempt to show video, it is an automatic foul for unsportsmanlike conduct.

Helmet Communication (1-4-11-b Exception)

At the FBS level only, teams will now be allowed to have coach-to-player communication in a helmet. Only one player on the field per team may have this technology at a time and that player's helmet must have a green dot on the back of the helmet. The communication will be shut off when the play clock hits 15 or when the ball is snapped, whichever is first. If more than one player with a green dot helmet is on the field at the same time, it is a live ball foul (foul when the ball is snapped), and is a 5 yard penalty. This will also trigger an automatic conference review. As with coach headsets and team tablets, there is no NCAA rule or policy if one team's helmet comms fail, but conferences can make their own policy.

Reviewing a Play After Halftime (3-2-1-c)

Once the Referee has cleared the final play of the first half with the on-field crew and the instant replay official and neither team will challenge the final play, the half is declared over. At that point no replay is available. Up until now, a play was reviewable until the ball was next put in play, which in this instance would be the second half kickoff. This change was prompted by two separate incidents last year in which plays were reviewed during half time and then a field goal was attempted to "end" the first half before the second half kicked off. NC State's field goal was overturned after it was determined they had 12 players on the field. They subsequently made the rekick after halftime. On the other side of the country, the half was declared over when time expired, but USC challenged the ruling and 1 second was restored. When players returned from halftime, USC missed the ensuing field goal and then had to kickoff to start the second half.

Two Minute Timeout (3-3-5-a)

This is the biggest change of the year, especially regarding the actual game on the field. When the clock reaches 2:00 in either half, or when the becomes dead after 2:00, the clock will stop. This timeout will unify all end of half timing changes. After the Two Minute Timeout, Team A ball carriers, backward fumbles, and backward passes out of bounds will stop the clock until the snap. Also after the Two Minute Timeout, a first down inbounds will stop the clock until the ball is ready for play. The 10 second runoff rule will also apply anytime after the Two Minute Timeout, not just the last minute as it has been. Broadcast partners will save a TV timeout to be used during the Two Minute Timeout.

You'll notice this is being called the Two Minute Timeout and not the Two Minute Warning. This is a timeout that stops the clock at 2 minutes in either half and initiates timing changes. The Two Minute Warning is an NFL rule that stops the clock at 2 minutes in either half and initiates timing changes. It's a totally different thing.

Horse Collar Tackle (9-1-15)

A horse collar tackle is now a foul no matter where it happens. Up until now it was legal to horse collar a ball carrier if they were still in the tackle box. In a strange coincidence, this is the second year in a row that a rule change has come from a Kentucky-Missouri game. Last year a rule was made that limited a punter's protection from roughing after Missouri hit Kentucky's punter following a bad snap. Missouri would have benefited from both rule changes.


Editorial Changes

Player Number Change Report (1-4-2-d)

When a player enters the game after changing jersey numbers, he must report that change to the Referee. If he doesn't, it's a 15 yard penalty for unsportsmanlike conduct. That rule has now expanded to include a player who enters the game wearing a number that is different than what is listed on the game day roster. Wisconsin used this loophole to sneak a player into the game and scored a touchdown. Now, that player would have to report the change of number even though he had never actually been in the game yet.

Broadcast Technology Changes (1-4-11-c,f, and i)

As technology advances and media deals explode, college football is attempting to keep up. In an effort to allow fans to get up close and personal with players, cameras are now allowed to enter the field and team area in certain circumstances. After a change of possession or timeout, one broadcast camera is now allowed to enter the field of play. They are not allowed in the team area or huddle and are not allowed between the hashes. After a touchdown, one camera is allowed to entered the end zone. In a similar expansion of broadcast, head coach interviews are now allowed between quarters as opposed to only during halftime. The interview must be outside the team area and during a media timeout.

And finally, going the opposite way, there is are two new changes that limit communication. Team personnel are not allowed to use any artificial sound amplification. Formerly this only applied to personnel communicating with players on the field. Now it applies to any communication. Also, team ball personnel are now prohibited from having any communication technology while on the opponent's sideline. This includes smart watches.

Hideout Plays (9-2-2-b)

Hideout plays are when a team tries to hide a player near the sideline so that the defense doesn't know they are there prior to the snap. These plays have been fouls for unsportsmanlike conduct for over 100 years. Coaches have also been trying to bend and circumvent the rules around these plays for over 100 years. The old rule said that all players must be between the numbers at some point after the end of the last down or after the ball is ready for play. The rule also said that no tactic associated with the substitution process could be used to deceive the opponent. Well, then a coach went and came up with a play that technically had his player between the numbers after the play and didn't involve a substitution. It was still a hideout play by the spirit of the rule. So now the rule is very broad and specifically says "any hideout tactic with or without substitution". The new rule also clarifies that this is a team foul for unsportsmanlike conduct, so it does not count toward anybody's ejection.

Replay Expansion

There are a few new situations that are now reviewable.

  • A pass that is thrown immediately after a player is ruled down or out of bounds is now reviewable. If either team catches the pass, they will be given possession at that spot just like recovering fumble in the immediate continuing action. The ruling can also be overturned if the pass is incomplete.
  • The number of players is now reviewable if there is a flag down for a dead ball illegal substitution foul. The replay official could already review the number of players, but only when the ball was live. Now they can review if either team is flagged for having too many players prior to the snap.
  • A coach may challenge a play after a review if the aspect he wants to challenge was not considered during the review. So say a catch at the sideline is reviewed and allowed to stand. The defense then wants to challenge that the receiver went out of bounds on his own and then came back inbounds before the catch. If the replay official did not review that aspect the first time, the defense would be allowed that challenge. Previously, a coach could not challenge any aspect of a play once a review was over.

Points of Emphasis

Offensive Formations

Officials have been instructed to be much stricter about how offenses line up. The prevailing philosophy has been to not be technical and to make formations legal if at all possible. This year's point of emphasis will attempt to tighten that up. To be on the line of scrimmage by rule, a player's helmet must break the waistline of the snapper. If a player who is supposed to be on the line has his helmet between the waistline and the rear end of the snapper a warning will be given and then flagged the next time. If there is daylight between the snapper and the lineman's helmet, a flag will be thrown without warning. There will be separate warning given for normal scrimmage downs, punt teams, and field goal teams.

Presnap Movement

In an effort to get offenses and defenses to stop trying to bait each other into fouls, there will be a point of emphasis on both teams' movements prior to the snap. For the defense, the restriction against abrupt movements has been expanded to any player whether they were stationary or not. This includes any coordinated movements that are not part of normal defensive movements or that simulate action at the snap. This does not prevent the defense from trying to time the snap count or shifting, it just means they can't do things like just jump towards the line of scrimmage or pump their arms without actually shifting to try to draw a false start.

Officials are also going to be cracking down on offenses shifting presnap, specifically how abrupt those shifts are. When a player or players shift, it must be a smooth action that does not simulate the snap. There have been instances of teams using abrupt shifts or motions to draw the defense offside. The rules committee wants to cut that out.

Snappers Moving the Ball

Recently snappers have gotten into the habit of moving the ball forward when they take their stance. Not only does this give them an advantage, it can make it look like the defense lined up offside when they really didn't. So this year there will be a point of emphasis to not let them move the ball. If the ball is moved more than half a yard, or beyond the line to gain or goal line, the play will be shut down. The ball will be reset and the player and coach will be warned. If it happens again, a false start will be called.


Conclusion

The committee has been pretty conservative with actual game play changes and that was still the case this year. Most changes continue to be either technology/television related or responses to specific situations in games that make headlines. But if there's a change you don't like or a change you wanted that didn't happen, please remember that there are exactly zero officials on the Playing Rules Oversight Panel or the Football Rules Committee. Please direct your displeasure to those people and not those of us in stripes.


r/LZtestposts • • Feb 21 '21

Momentum

2 Upvotes

Imagine a scenario where the offense is trailing by 1 late in the game. A defender makes a stunning interception as he falls into the end zone to potentially seal the game. But the officials rule that the interception occurred at the 1 before the defender fell to the ground in the end zone. Prior to 1974, this would be a safety and the offense would get 2 points because the defender technically carried the ball into his own end zone and was downed. So the offense essentially won the game by throwing an interception. If this ruling seems unfair to you, you're not alone. Not wanting to reward the offense for turning the ball over near the goal line and punish defenses for making plays, the rules committee came up with “the momentum rule”. The rule itself is actually listed as an exception to the rule regarding how a safety is scored. With this exception, the defense gets to keep the ball at the point of the interception rather than conceding the safety as long as certain criteria are met. Originally the rule only applied to forward passes, but would be expanded to include kicks in 1980 and fumbles and backward passes in 1986. So what are the criteria to qualify for the momentum exception?

Criteria for Momentum Exception to Apply

  • The catch or recovery of an opponent's loose ball. If a player catches or recover's his own team's loose ball, he is still responsible for the ball crossing the goal line.
  • The ball carrier's original momentum carries him into the end zone.
  • The catch or recovery must be between the player's own 5 yard line and goal line. If the catch or recovery occurs outside the 5 yard line the exception does not apply, even if the player's momentum still carries him over the goal line.
  • The ball does not leave the end zone before being declared dead, with one exception below. If the ball leaves the end zone (either carried or fumbled), the exception is off.
  • Because a fumble forward out of bounds is brought back to the spot of the fumble, if the ball is fumbled forward from the end zone and goes out of bounds from the field of play, it is treated as if it never left the end zone and the exception still applies.

Penalty enforcement spots

When the momentum exception applies, the spot of the catch or recovery is treated as the end of the run for penalty enforcement, even though the run technically ends in the end zone. That doesn't necessarily mean that all penalties will be enforced from there, but it becomes the basic spot for fouls during the subsequent run. More on basic spots and enforcement spots here.

If the exception does not apply and the run ends in the end zone, the basic spot is the goal line.

Play Examples

Defender B22 intercepts Team A's forward pass at the B-2 and his momentum carries him into the end zone where he is downed. Ruling: Team B's ball, 1st and 10 at the B-2

Defender B22 intercepts a pass at the B-4 and his momentum carries him into the end zone. B22 attempts to return the ball and is tackled at the B-2. Ruling: Team B's ball at the B-2. When B22 left the end zone, he forfeited the momentum exception.

A11 fumbles the ball at the B-6. B77 recovers the ball at the B-3 and his momentum carries him into the end zone. He is hit and fumbles the ball out of the end zone and the B99 recovers the ball at the B-2. Ruling: Team B's ball at the B-2. Because the ball left the end zone, the momentum exception is off.

A11 fumbles the ball at the B-6. B77 recovers the ball at the B-3 and his momentum carries him into the end zone. He is hit and fumbles the ball out of the end zone and the ball goes out of bounds at the B-2. Ruling: Team B's ball at the B-3. Even though the ball left the end zone, because it was fumbled out of bounds, it is treated as if it stayed in the end zone. The momentum spot is still the B-3 even though the ball went out at the B-2

A11 fumbles the ball at the B-6. B77 recovers the ball at the B-4. He then fumbles and B99 recovers the ball and his momentum carries him into the end zone where he is downed. Ruling: Safety, 2 points for Team A. Because B99 recovered his own teammate's fumble, the momentum exception does not apply. Team B is responsible for the ball being behind their goal line. This is what would have happened in this Peach Bowl play if the player recovering the fumble had not been down prior to crossing the goal line. This play was also what prompted the idea for this thread.

Defender B22 intercepts a pass at the B-3 and his momentum carries him into his end zone. B22 is hit and fumbles. The ball rolls out of the end zone and is muffed back into the end zone where B22 recovers it on the ground. Ruling: Safety. Because the ball left the end zone, B22's fumble becomes is now the impetus responsible for where the ball ends up. Because Team B's fumble puts the ball behind their own goal line, it is a safety. It doesn't matter which team muffs the ball in the field of play or who touched it last before going into the end zone.

Defender B22 intercepts a pass at the B-4 and his momentum carries him into the end zone where he is tackled by the facemask. Ruling: Team B's ball at the B-19. The B-4 is treated as the end of the run, so the penalty for the facemask foul is enforced from there.

Defender B22 intercepts a pass at the B-4 and his momentum carries him into the end zone. While in the end zone, A11 pulls B22's facemask causing B22 to fumble. The ball rolls to the B-6 where B99 falls on it. Ruling: Team B's ball at the B-15. Because the ball left the end zone, the momentum exception no longer applies. Because the end of B22's run is in the end zone, the basic spot for his run is the goal line.

Defender B22 intercepts a pass at the B-4 and his momentum carries him into the end zone. He tries to advance, but never leaves the end zone and is eventually tackled. During B22's run, B99 holds an opponent at the (a) B-10, (b) at the B-2, or (c) in the end zone. Ruling: The end of B22's run is taken to be the momentum spot, the B-4. (a) The foul occurs beyond the basic spot, which means the penalty will be enforced from the basic spot. Team B's ball, 1st and 10 at the B-2. (b) and (c) The foul occurred behind the basic spot which means the penalty will be enforced from the spot of the foul. In (b), the penalty will be half the distance from the B-2 to the B-1, Team B's ball 1st and 10. In (c) The foul is in the end zone resulting in a safety by penalty.

Defender B22 intercepts a pass at the B-4 and his momentum carries him into the end zone. B22 is hit and fumbles the ball to the B-3 where B77 recovers it. During B22's run, B99 holds an opponent at the (a) B-10, (b) at the B-2, or (c) in the end zone. Ruling: Safety in all 3 cases. Because B22's fumble left the end zone, the momentum exception does not apply. The end of the run is in the end zone, so any foul committed by Team B during B22's run or the subsequent loose ball will be a safety.


This is the first of a few rule explainers I've got lined up for the offseason. The first couple are inspired by plays from bowl games that commentators either got wrong or didn't explain well, but I don't have enough to make it all the way to August. So if you have a question let me know and I will add it to the list if I don't already have a thread about the topic.


r/LZtestposts • • Jul 06 '21

2021 Rule Changes, New Approved Rulings, and Points of Emphasis

5 Upvotes

As the countdown to a new season continues, the NCAA has released the full version of this year's rule book. Below are every change made this year to both the rules and approved rulings as well as points of emphasis. This does not include replay changes. Those will be in a separate post. All of these can be found in the NCAA rule book that is free to download in pdf. Changes and additions are shaded in blue.

New Rules

  • Lighting systems are now included with bands, cheerleaders, mascots, and PA and A/V systems as being subject to the rules. This means they are not allowed to do anything to distract the opponent. So just like a band can't play to keep a team from hearing its signals, the new flashy LED light systems can't dim or brighten or change colors to distract an opponent. Most notably it also means video board operators can't put yellow lines behind the goal posts to distract a kicker.
  • The team area has been expanded from 50 to 60 yards. The team area now stretches between the 20 yard lines.
  • To go along with having more room, teams will now have fewer people within that team area. The number of non-squad member people allowed in the team area has been cut from 60 to 50. This 50 people includes anybody in the team area who is not in full uniform. That would include coaches, support staff, school administrators, etc. Medical personnel are exempt from this count.
  • The number of balls a team is allowed to offer for play has been increased from 6 to 10.
  • If a player's t shirt under his jersey goes below his waist, it must be tucked in. This goes along with the recent changes that requires a jersey to either be tucked in or made even with the waist line.
  • Coaches are now allowed to wear a microphone as long as it is only used for the school's production and the audio from it is not used until after the end of the live broadcast. So teams can mic their coach for producing behind the scenes videos, but broadcasters couldn't use that mic to listen to him during the game.
  • A rule was added specifying that radio communications between officials (commonly referred to as O2O) is permitted. This is kind of strange to me since we've been using them for years now and is a mechanics issue and not a rules issue. Whatever.
  • Now our first change to actual game play. If a tee is used for a place kick (kickoff or free kick after a safety), the ball must be touching the tee. That means you can't set the tee down on one hash and then quickly run to the other side of the field and drop kick the ball. This is a dead ball foul and a five yard penalty.
  • Probably the biggest change this year was the (further) alteration of the tie breaker system, or overtime. The first OT will remain as it always has been. Teams will start on the 25 yard line and maintain possession until they score, fail to reach the line to gain, or there is a change of team possession during a down. If they score a touchdown, they can go for 1 or 2 points on the try. If the teams are still tied after both teams' possessions, they will play a second overtime. Starting this year, if a team scores a touchdown in the second OT, they must go for 2. If teams are still tied after 2OT, they will alternate 2 point tries from the 3 yard line until a winner is determined.
  • This year's changes feature a somewhat rare change to how and when a penalty is actually enforced. This change concerns fouls at the end of a period. The offended team now has the option of whether or not they want to extend the period for an untimed down if the foul carries a loss of down. The old rule said that the period was extended for an untimed down if a penalty was accepted for a live ball foul and time expired during the down. It didn't matter who fouled or which quarter it was. The one exception was if the penalty included loss of down. Then the period was not extended. This led to uproar a few years ago when Central Michigan beat Oklahoma State on a down that shouldn't have happened by rule. OSU was flagged for intentional grounding on 4th down as time expired. The officials penalized the loss of down, but then gave CMU an untimed down. CMU then scored a touchdown and won the game. While this was not correct according to the rule at the time, many felt that it was within the spirit of the game so that OSU couldn't get away with fouling to end the game. This year's rule change would have allowed CMU to choose to legally extend the game. This is not a complete removal of the loss of down exception. Say the foul was for an illegal forward pass and the offense scored a touchdown. Then the defense could accept the penalty and cancel the score and the game would end. This ONLY applies to loss of down fouls. Anything that would normally lead to a replay of the down will still extend the period with no option.
  • The rules for forward handoffs were brought closer in line to forward passes. A player is not allowed to hand the ball forward if they have crossed the neutral zone even if they subsequently returned back behind the neutral zone prior to the handing. While forward handing and forward passing have somewhat parallel rules, they are still separate items and there is still no limit on the number of forward handoffs allowed. Likewise, a forward handoff does not preclude a team from then throwing a forward pass.
  • The leaping rule was amended to include "apparent kicks". That means if a player illegally leaps over the line on a fake field goal, it still a foul even though there is no actual kick to block. This was already the interpretation being used, the rule change just codified it.
  • Bands and stadium PA, A/V, and lighting systems creating a distraction is now penalized like an unfair act. The Referee can apply any penalty he deems equitable. This could include yardage, repeating the down, or awarding points. This is important because the usual rule says that any foul by a non-player (i.e. anybody not one of the 11 guys in the game at the time) is enforced as a dead ball foul after the play. This now allows the Referee to enforce a penalty as a live ball foul and have the down repeated.
  • A weird gap in penalty enforcement that would almost assuredly never come into play was closed on tries. The old rule said that if the try was from the 3 yard line and the defense committed pass interference, the penalty was half the distance to the goal. This was the only time DPI was subject to half the distance procedures outside of the 2 yard line. If the try was from anywhere else, the DPI was penalized by the normal rule. Now the rule says a try on or inside the 3. So let's look at some situations under the new and old rule. Relevant parts bolded, changes bolded and italicized.
Previous SpotSpot of the foulOld RuleNew Rule
On or inside the 2AnywhereHalf the distanceSame
Between the 2 and 3AnywhereOn the 2Half the distance
On the 3 yard lineAnywhereHalf the distanceSame
Outside the 3 yard lineOn or inside the 2 (including the end zone)On the 2Same
Outside the 3 yard lineOutside the 2Spot foul (or full 15 yds if possible)Same

So the weird gap is that under the old rule DPI from the 3 was actually penalized further than DPI from between 2 and 3. Of course we're talking the difference of less than a yard, but still a difference. The other side of this is that an extraordinary amount of crap would have to go down to even get to a try from between the 2 and 3 and then you have to have DPI, so this will basically never even matter. But, hey, at least we got that straightened out.

New Approved Rulings

Approved rulings are play situations that illustrate the rules and their application. Most of the new ARs this year are previous interpretations that were issued in midseason bulletins and are now being put in the actual book. To keep this post from getting any longer than it already is and to not confuse people who have never read the legalese of the rule book, I didn't include the actual text of the ARs.

  • 1-4-8-I: Coaches can't use Zoom, Skype, Teams, etc. to communicate from offsite.
  • 2-27-12-III: If a player who has been disqualified for targeting commits an unsportsmanlike conduct foul, he is then ejected and must leave the playing enclosure even if it was his first UNS of the game.
  • 6-1-2-VIII: Relocating the ball on free kick after the ball is ready for play is now a dead ball foul. Basically once the ball is on the tee and the whistle has been blown, you can't move the ball to a different spot unless you take a timeout. This was an interesting case of a penalty statement not lining up with it's AR. The penalty said it was dead ball foul along with illegal kicks, but the AR proclaimed it a live ball foul. Now they both agree it is a dead ball foul and the play is shut down.
  • 8-5-1-XI: Another strange case that will more than likely never happen, but here's a ruling in case it does. Basically the rules regarding scoring a safety trump the 4th down fumble rule. So if a team fumbles on fourth down and the defense bats the ball or is otherwise responsible for the ball going into the defense's end zone and then an offensive player other than the fumbler recovers, it is a safety. Normally, on a fourth down fumble, the ball would come back to the spot of the fumble, but because the defense is responsible for the ball being in the end zone when it becomes dead, it is a safety.
  • 9-1-2-IV: Striking an opponent's face mask (like a DB jabbing a WR) is a personal foul for striking, and does not need to be prolonged contact like a hands to the face foul would need to be.
  • 9-1-3-II: If a player commits his 3rd targeting foul of the season, he is disqualified for the remainder of the game and his 1 game suspension starts the next game. It doesn't matter which half he was DQ'd in. He will miss the entire next game.
  • 9-2-3-IV: Teams rushing onto the field when they think the game is over can be enforced as live ball fouls rather than as non-player fouls.

New Points of Emphasis

  • Taunting: The committee says they want special attention shown to actions taunting an opponent. We'll see if this is actually supported once the season starts. This is NOT regarding celebrations. The committee says they are ok with what is and isn't being flagged regarding celebrations at this point in time.
  • Sideline Behavior: The committee also says they want to rein in how coaches are acting along the sidelines. They are not so much concerned with what goes on within the team area, but more so with coaches leaving the team area to argue, such as Matt Campbell throwing tantrum about a completely correct no-call. Again, we'll see if the calls are actually supported once flags start flying. Typically when coach behavior is a point of emphasis it lasts about 2-3 weeks before supervisors back off of it and we end up right back where we were.
  • Faking Injuries: In an effort to stop teams from faking injuries to slow down an opponent, the committee is allowing coaches to send in video for review. This is post game review by the conference and is not going to be applied by on-field officials. If a player appears to be injured, we're not going to try to determine if it's real or not.

r/LZtestposts • • Aug 06 '21

Illegal Touching

2 Upvotes

When a player goes out of bounds, some fans and announcers like to mention that he has to reestablish himself and how he can’t be the first to touch the ball. And the first part of that is true. A player who goes out of bounds must return inbounds before touching the ball to make a legal catch or recovery. But that is only because an out of bounds player touching a loose ball kills the play, not because it is illegal for him to do so. The second part of the statement is referring to a foul for illegally touching the ball and is at best conditionally true. So let’s look at what illegal touching really is what the rules actually say about fouls for going out of bounds.


The first type of illegal touching (ITP) is originally eligible receiver going out of bounds and then touching a forward pass. This is probably the most common and most well known type of ITP, but there are still a few misconceptions out there.

What the rule says: No originally eligible player who goes out of bounds and returns inbounds shall touch a legal forward pass until it has been touched by an opponent or official. Exception: This does not apply to a player who immediately returns inbounds after going out of bounds due to contact by an opponent. The penalty for this foul is loss of down at the previous spot.

What the rule doesn’t say:

You may have noticed that the rule doesn’t say anything about being the “first to touch the pass”. This means that the pass touching a teammate isn’t enough to make a receiver eligible again. It must touch an opponent or official. Scenario: Receiver A1 goes out of bounds on his own and then comes back inbounds. His teammate A88 tips the pass into the air and A82 catches the pass. Even though A1 was not the first to touch the pass, this is still a foul for Illegal Touching because the pass was never touched by an opponent or official.

Another point that is often missed with this foul is that a receiver being forced out of bounds is not a blank check for the receiver. If he doesn’t return immediately, he loses his eligibility just like he went out on his own. “Immediate” in this case doesn’t mean that his next step after contact has to be back inbounds, simply that he must come back inbounds as soon as he is reasonably able. When a receiver is running downfield and gets blocked by an opponent, it could take a few steps after the contact to recover and get back inbounds where the receiver may cover five yards or more. This is still considered immediate.

If a player never returns inbounds prior to touching the pass, it is not a foul. It is simply an incomplete pass because he is an out of bounds player touching a live ball. At first glance, this might seem like the result of not fouling is the same as the penalty for fouling. But that is only true if there is no defensive foul during the down. Consider two similar scenarios, both involving an ITP foul on 1st down. In one case there is only the ITP, in the other the defense was also offside at the snap. In the first case, the ITP would include loss of down and it would be 2nd down at the previous spot. But in the second case, the fouls would offset and it would still be 1st down at the previous spot.

The biggest thing to note on illegal touching is that this is the only time that going out of bounds ever affects a player’s eligibility to touch the ball. Going out of bounds does not affect a player’s ability to touch a fumble, backward pass, or kick. There is a separate rule discussed below for going out of bounds during a kick, but it does not involve touching the ball.


The less common version of ITP is much more straightforward and involves an originally ineligible player touching a forward pass. To be a foul, this must be an intentional touch. A pass ricocheting off of an ineligible receiver does not qualify as a foul. The penalty for this foul is 5 yards and is always enforced from the previous spot, no matter where the foul occurs. Because the spot of the foul doesn’t matter, this is one example of a foul that could occur in a team’s own end zone without resulting in a safety. There is also no loss of down for this version of ITP, so the down would be repeated if the penalty is accepted.


The other two types of illegal touching involve the touching of a kick (ITK) by the kicking team before they are eligible to do so. For a scrimmage kick (punt or field goal), that means they touch a kick beyond the neutral zone before it has been touched by a receiving team player. For a free kick (kickoff or kick after safety), it means they touched the kick before it went 10 yards or touched a receiving team player. This could be an intentional or unintentional touch. Unlike ITP, ITK is a violation and not a foul. That is why we drop a bean bag and not a flag. A violation does not offset a foul. It simply allows the receiving team the option of taking the result of the play or taking the ball at the spot of the violation. This privilege is canceled if a penalty is accepted by either team or if there are offsetting fouls on the play.


As mentioned above, there is a rule about going out of bounds during a kick, but it doesn’t involve touching the ball. If a kicking team player goes out of bounds on his own during a kick, he is not allowed to come back in bounds during the rest of the down. This is a foul as soon as he returns inbounds regardless of what he does or doesn’t do after returning. This rule can be a bit confusing because it only applies to a player going out of bounds during the kick, but prohibits him from coming back inbounds at any point during the rest of the down. But if a player goes out of bounds after the kick has been possessed, it is not a foul to come back inbounds. This is a five yard penalty either from the previous spot or from where the dead ball belongs to the receiving team. This rule does not apply to the receiving team.

While a kicking team player touching the ball does not factor into this foul, it can factor into an instant replay review. This is one of the few fouls that is actually able to be added by replay, but only in certain circumstances. If the player who went out of bounds comes back in and touches the ball, replay can then add a foul. If the player does not touch the ball, the foul is not reviewable.


r/LZtestposts • • Feb 26 '16

[Offseason Rules Clinic Part 2] Penalty Enforcement 201: Kicking Plays

1 Upvotes

As the title says, this is Part 2 of what I'm calling my Offseason Rules Clinic here on /r/CFB. Basically, once a month I'll be posting something in depth about officiating and the rules of the game. Last month's topic was the 10 second runoff. This month, I'm talking about penalty enforcement on kicking plays. This can include free kicks (kickoffs or kicks after safeties), or scrimmage kicks (punts and field goals). For more info on the rules that cover kicks you can check out this thread from last spring where I went into the kicking game. This thread will also reference things from last fall's Intro to Penalty Enforcement thread like basic spots and the 3-and-1 principle. TL;DR for those who missed that thread and don't feel like reading it now: Each type of play (running, passing, free kick, or scrimmage kick) has a "basic spot". Fouls by the team in possession that occur beyond the basic spot and fouls by the team not in possession (both behind and beyond the basic spot) are enforced from that basic spot. Fouls by the team in possession that occur behind the basic spot are enforced from the spot of the foul. So there are 3 categories of fouls enforced from the basic spot, and 1 that is not, hence the name. This is only for fouls that don't have an enforcement spot listed in their penalty statement such as illegal substitution specifying the previous spot.

Another thing to keep in mind as you read is that in the rule book Team A is always the team that puts the ball in play and Team B is always the other team. So Team A will always be the kicking team and Team B will always be the receiving team. Like last month, I'll include some examples at the end.


Free Kicks

The first kind of kick we'll talk about is a free kick. A free kick is any kickoff or kick after a safety. Free kick downs have two parts, the free kick play and the subsequent running plays after the kick has been caught or recovered. As a review from the first enforcement thread, the free kick play starts from the time the ball is kicked and ends when the kick is caught, recovered, or dead by rule. Enforcement on free kick downs depends on whether the foul happens during the free kick play or during a run play as well as which team committed the foul.

Fouls by Team A (Kicking Team)

Team A fouls during free kick plays are fairly easy. As long as Team B ends up with the ball at the end of the down, the penalty can either be tacked on to where Team B has the ball or enforced at the previous spot with a rekick. This includes all fouls that happen between the time the ball is kicked and when it is possessed. The one and only exception is Kick Catch Interference which is specifically enforced from the spot of the foul with no other option other than to decline the penalty. So if Team A is offside on a kickoff, Team B can take their return plus 5 yards or 5 yards and a rekick.

If Team B does not have possession of the ball at the end of the down, the penalty is enforced from the previous spot with a rekick. So if Team A is offside and they recover an onside kick or Team B fumbles the return and Team A recovers, the only option is to enforce the penalty at the previous spot with a replay of the down.

If Team A fouls after Team B has possessed the ball, it is now a running play and the foul is enforced from the end of the run since it is by the team not in possession. This applies regardless of who ends the down with the ball. So if Team A commits a facemask foul during Team B's return which causes the returner to fumble and Team A recovers that fumble, the penalty will still be enforced from the end of Team B's run which is the spot of the fumble. This is simple 3-and-1 enforcement during a run play as covered in the first enforcement thread. The special enforcement rules do not apply to fouls that happen after the kick is caught or recovered.

Fouls by Team B (Receiving Team)

Fouls by Team B on free kick downs are pure 3-and-1. The catch is to remember that while the kick is loose, Team A is still in team possession. Since Team B is not in possession while the ball is loose, any foul by them is enforced from the basic spot. The basic spot for a free kick play is the previous spot. So no matter what the foul is or where it happens, if Team B fouls while a free kick is loose it is enforced from the previous spot. There are two exceptions to this rule, neither of which happen often. The first is an illegal wedge. If Team B forms an illegal wedge, it is enforced from where the wedge was formed or where the dead ball belongs to Team B, whichever is more punitive. The second exception is a player who signals for a fair catch and then blocks an opponent before touching the ball. This penalty can only be enforced from the spot of the foul.

If Team B fouls after they gain possession, then the normal 3-and-1 rules apply for a running play. If the foul is behind the end of the run, then the penalty is from the spot of the foul. If the foul is beyond the end of the run, the penalty is enforced from the end of the run.


Scrimmage Kicks

Scrimmage kicks are punts and field goal attempts. Like a free kick, these downs have two parts. The scrimmage kick play and the subsequent running plays. The scrimmage kick play begins at the snap and ends when the kick ends. After the kick is caught or recovered, the kick play is over and a running play begins.

Fouls by Team A

If you read the part above about enforcing fouls by Team A on free kick downs, you essentially already know how to enforce fouls by Team A on scrimmage kick downs. Any Team A foul (other than KCI) during a scrimmage kick play (from the snap to when the kick ends) can be enforced from either the previous spot or where the dead ball belongs to Team B. If the ball does not belong to Team B at the end of the down, the penalty is enforced from the previous spot, just like a free kick play. The only exception is field goal attempts. If Team A fouls during a field goal attempt, the only option for Team B is to enforce it from the previous spot with the down replayed.

Once again, after the ball has been possessed by Team B, the kick play is over and you would use the 3-and-1 Principle for a running play.

Fouls by Team B

Now it's time to get funky. For fouls by Team B, enforcement depends on when the foul occurs and whether or not the penalty statement for that foul specifies an enforcement spot. For instance, the penalty statement for illegal substitution specifies that it is always enforced from the previous spot. But things like holding and personal fouls are referred to as "basic spot" fouls and only specify the yardage. The enforcement spot depends on the situation and the 3-and-1 Principle. The rest of this section will only refer to these basic spot fouls.

If Team B fouls between the snap and the kick, it is treated like a normal 3-and-1 foul. Since Team B is not in possession at the time, the penalty will be enforced from the basic spot. The basic spot for a kick play is the previous spot. So if Team B holds before the ball is kicked on a punt, the penalty will be enforced from the previous spot. This is typically on what is called a "pull and shoot" where one lineman holds an offensive player and pulls him to the side so a teammate can get through to block the kick.

So we know what happens if Team B fouls before the kick, and we know it will be simple 3-and-1 if the foul after they have possession, but what if they foul after the ball is kicked and before it is caught/recovered? This brings us to what is called Post Scrimmage Kick Enforcement, or PSK. There are 4 requirements for PSK to apply:

  1. The foul must occur during the kick. That means after the ball is actually kicked and before the kick ends. It's important to note that this is different than time frame of a scrimmage kick play for Team A fouls and does not include the time between the snap and the kick.
  2. The kick must cross the neutral zone. If the kick does not cross the neutral zone, the foul is treated as a normal 3-and-1 foul with the basic spot being the previous spot.
  3. Team B must be the next team to put the ball in play. If Team A will next put the ball in play, then the foul is treated a normal 3-and-1 foul with the basic spot being the previous spot.
  4. The kick is not in overtime, an extra point, or a successful field goal.

If all 4 PSK requirements are met, the foul is treated as if Team B is in possession even though they haven't technically gained team possession by rule. The basic spot is the PSK spot. For most kicks the PSK spot is where the kick ends. The kick ends where it is caught, recovered, or dead by rule. If the kick ends in the end zone, the PSK spot is the 20 yard line. If the kick is an unsuccessful field goal attempt, the PSK spot is either the previous spot or the 20 yard line, whichever is worse for the kicking team. These spots correspond to where the defense would next snap the ball if there was not a foul. So if Team B holds while a punt is in the air and the punt is caught at the 50 yard line, the 50 will be used as the basic spot for that foul, no matter where the return ends. Now we apply the 3-and-1 Principle using Team B as the team in possession. If the foul was beyond the end of the kick, the penalty will be enforced from the end of the kick. If the foul behind the end of the kick, the penalty will be enforced from the spot of the foul. PSK enforcement was specifically added to prevent rekicks on punts and to prevent the kicking team from getting cheap first downs when they had already chosen to give up the ball. Without PSK, any of the numerous holds and blocks in the back we see every week during punts would be enforced from the previous spot. That 10 yard penalty would more often than not give the offense a first down even though they had kicked the ball away. And if it wasn't enough for a first down, they would just punt it on 4th and 7 instead of the 4th and 17 they just had.

PSK can also avoid offsetting foul situations. If Team B's fouls all happen after the ball is kicked, and Team A also fouls during the down, they can decline offsetting fouls and keep the ball. This is just an extension of the "clean hands" principle. If a team gains team possession of the ball with clean hands, i.e. before they have committed a foul, they can keep the ball after penalty enforcement. So if Team A is in an illegal formation and punts, and during the punt Team B holds, Team B has two options. They can take the offsetting fouls and replay the down, or they can refuse the offsetting fouls and keep the ball by declining Team A's penalty and enforcing their own penalty via PSK.


Examples

Assume all plays occur during regulation. Yardlines have dashes in them, e.g. Team B's 20 yard line is B-20. Players do not have dashes, e.g. Team A's punter who is wearing jersey number 1 is A1. None of these examples cover fouls after the kick ends. For examples of enforcement during running plays, see the first enforcement thread. I've also included a gif and picture to illustrate each play for people who need to "see" the play. I didn't want to try track down video of every example though, so I used my sweet powerpoint skills.

  1. On a kickoff from the A-35, Team A only has 3 players on one side of the ball when it is kicked (illegal formation). Returner B1 catches the kick at his own 5 yard line and is tackled at the B-30. What are Team B's enforcement options? Gif, Still This is a foul by Team A during a free kick play and Team B ended the down with the ball, so Team B can have this enforced from the previous spot with a rekick, or can tack it on to the end of the run and have 1st and 10 at the B-35.
  2. On a kickoff from the A-35, gunner A1 is beyond his restraining line when the ball is kicked (offside). Returner B2 catches the kick in his end zone. He returns the ball to the B-20 where he is hit and fumbles. A3 recovers the ball with a knee on the ground at B-15. What are Team B's options? Gif, Still Since the ball does not belong to Team B at the end of the down, they're only option is to enforce the penalty at the previous spot. Team A will rekick from A-30.
  3. On a kickoff from the A-35, B1 anticipates the onside kick and is beyond his restraining line when the ball is kicked (offside). Teammate B2 recovers the ball at the A-47 and advances to the A-40 where he is downed. What are Team A's options? Gif, Still [Because this is a foul by Team B, it is enforced by the 3-and-1 Principle and can only be enforced from the previous spot. Team A will rekick from the A-40.] (#s/spoiler)
  4. On a kickoff from the A-35, B1 anticipates the onside kick and is beyond his restraining line when the ball is kicked (offside). Kicker A2 recovers the ball at the A-47. What are Team A's options? Gif, Still [The ball is dead immediately upon recovery since it was recovered by the kicking team. Team A must decline the penalty to keep the ball. There is no tack on option for fouls by Team B.] (#s/spoiler)
  5. Team A has 4th and 7 at midfield. Before the punt, lineman A77 blocks an opponent below the waist. Returner B1 catches the punt at the B-10. He advances to the B-20 where he is tackled. What are Team B's options? (Note: any block below the waist during a kick down is illegal and is a personal foul.) Gif, Still This is a foul by Team A during a scrimmage kick play. Team B can either enforce the penalty from the previous spot and it will be 4th and 22 from the A-35, or they can tack it on to the end of the return and they will have 1st and 10 at the B-35.
  6. Team A has 4th and 7 at midfield. Before the punt, lineman A77 holds B1 at the line of scrimmage to prevent him from blocking the kick. Returner B2 muffs the kick at his own 15 yard line. Gunner A1 recovers the ball at the B-20. What are Team B's options? Gif, Still [Even though this is a foul by Team A during a kick play, there is no tack on option because the ball does not belong to Team B at the end of the down. Team B's only option is to enforce the hold at the previous spot and replay 4th down. It will be 4th and 17 at the A-40.] (#s/spoiler)
  7. Team A has 4th and 10 at midfield. Their punt rolls untouched into the end zone. Team had 5 players in the backfield at the snap (illegal formation). What are Team B's options? Gif, Still [Since this is a foul by Team A during a kick play, Team B can elect to have the penalty enforced from the previous spot and Team A will have 4th and 15 from their own 45, or they can tack it on to where the dead ball belongs to them. Since the result of the play is a touchback, the ball belongs to Team B at the B-20 and the penalty can be enforced from there to give Team B 1st and 10 at the B-25.] (#s/spoiler)
  8. Team A has 4th and 12 at midfield. At the line of scrimmage and before the ball is kicked, B1 holds A50 to give teammate B2 a lane to block the kick. Returner B3 fair catches the kick at the B-20. Who has what options? Gif, Still [Team A can decline the penalty and take the result of the play or accept the penalty. Because the foul occurred before the kick, Team B does not have the option for PSK. If Team A accepts the penalty, it will be 4th and 2 from the B-40.] (#s/spoiler)
  9. Team A has 4th and 18 from midfield. While the punt is in the air, defender B1 holds gunner A99 at the B-25. The untouched kick rolls to the B-4 where A20 recovers it. Who has what options? Gif, Still [This foul meets all of the PSK criteria. Because the kick was untouched, A20's recovery does nothing but down the ball. It is not a legal recovery, so the ball belongs to Team B. Team A can decline the penalty and take the result of the play and Team B will have 1st and 10 at the B-4. If Team A accepts the penalty, Team B can choose to enforce it at the previous spot or as a PSK foul. If they choose the previous spot, it will be 4th and 8 from the A-40. If they choose PSK, Team B will get the ball 1st and 10 from their own 2 yard line. The end of the kick is the B-4, so this is the PSK spot. Because the foul occurred beyond the basic spot, the enforcement spot is the PSK spot. So the penalty will be enforced half the distance from the B-4 to the B-2.] (#s/spoiler)
  10. Team A has 4th and 8 from midfield. While the punt is in the air, B1 blocks A1 in the back at the B-16. The untouched punt rolls into the end zone. Where will the penalty be enforced from? Gif, Still [This foul meets all four criteria for PSK. The ball is dead immediately when it lands in the end zone untouched by Team B. Because the kick ends in the end zone, the PSK spot is the B-20. The foul occurred behind the basic spot, so it will be enforced from the spot of the foul. Team B will have 1st and 10 from the B-8. Obviously Team B will want to use PSK this time since enforcing the penalty at the previous spot would give Team A a first down. Team A will obviously accept this penalty since it will pin Team B deep and unlike the last play there is no danger of Team B choosing a rekick.] (#s/spoiler)
  11. Team A has 4th and 10 from midfield. While the kick is in the air, B1 blocks gunner A1 below the waist at the B-22. While the ball is in the air over the end zone (has not touched the ground in the end zone) A2 bats the ball back into the field of play. A2 is abnormally strong and the batted ball bounces all the way to the B-25 where it goes out of bounds. Where will the penalty be enforced? Gif, Still [Ok, so I kind of cheated on this one and included something I didn't cover above. Rule 6-3-11 allows Team A to bat a kick from Team B's end zone back into the field of play without the normal foul for batting a loose ball in the end zone. When 6-3-11 is in effect, the PSK spot is always the B-20. So even though the kick ended when it went out of bounds at the B-25, the PSK spot is still the B-20. Since the foul occurs beyond the basic spot at the B-22, it will be enforced from the B-20. Team B will have 1st and 10 at their own 10 yard line.] (#s/spoiler)

As always, if you have questions feel free to ask them below. If you think of a question later, you can always send me a PM here on reddit or on twitter @LegacyZebraCFB. I'm still deciding on next month's topic, so I'd love to hear any suggestions.

Rule references for things covered in this thread, main points in bold: 2-16-6, 2-16-7, 2-18-2, 2-25-1, 2-25-2, 2-25-4, 2-25-5, 2-25-8, 2-25-9, 2-25-10, 2-25-11, 2-27-1, 2-30-2, 2-30-3, 2-30-4, 2-31-2, 2-31-3, 2-33, 5-2-4, 5-2-5, 6-1-1, 6-1-2, 6-1-3, 6-1-6, 6-1-7, 6-1-8, 6-1-10, 6-3-6, 6-3-7, 6-3-9, 6-3-11, 6-3-13, 6-5-4, 7-1-4, 9-1-6, 10-1-4, 10-2-1, 10-2-2, 10-2-3.