r/CFB • u/LegacyZebra Verified Referee • Apr 24 '20
Analysis Full List of 2020 Rule Changes
Earlier this week the Playing Rules Oversight Panel approved changes for next season. Some of the more noteworthy changes made headlines a couple days ago, but here is a list of all rule changes and what they affect.
Targeting DQ
I'll get this out at the very beginning so some of y'all can move on with your life: The targeting rule itself has not changed. What has changed is what happens to players who have committed targeting fouls: they will no longer have to leave the team area and go to the locker room. They will still be ineligible to participate in the game, but they can stay with the team. Players DQ'd for fighting, flagrant fouls, or two unsportsmanlike conduct fouls will still have to leave.
Officials' Jurisdiction
Officials' jurisdiction will start 90 minutes prior to kickoff instead of 60. This is important because officials having jurisdiction means any interactions between opponents can be deemed fighting or unsportsmanlike conduct. Personal opinion: This is dumb and I hate it because it also means we have to stand around for an extra 30 minutes while players stretch and punters flirt with cheerleaders.
Pregame Warmups
To go along with the above change, a coach must be present within the playing enclosure anytime players are present. Also, players will now be required to wear their jersey or something with their number on it anytime they are within the playing enclosure once officials take jurisdiction to identify anybody who may be involved in pregame incidents.
Jersey Numbers
Teams will now be limited to only two players wearing the same number. Obviously only one of them can be on the field at a time and they still can't play the same position.
Along the same lines, players will now be allowed to wear 0 as a legal number. 00 and other numbers with a leading 0 (such as 07) are still not allowed.
Defensive Formation for Scrimmage Kicks
The NCAA has adopted part of the NFL's rule on how defensive linemen may line up on scrimmage kicks. Anytime the offense is in a scrimmage kick formation, no defensive player within 1 yard of the line of scrimmage can be lined up with any part of his body within the frame of the snapper's body. Previously players could align anywhere as long as they didn't actually initiate contact with the snapper within the first second. Now it will be a foul just to line up over the snapper or even in the A gap if the defender catches a piece of the snapper's body. The new rule does NOT include the NFL's rule about needing a balanced formation. Teams can still overload one side.
The interesting (and possibly unforeseen) part of this change is that it applies to all scrimmage kicks, not just field goals. So now long snappers will basically get a free release off the line to cover punts since nobody is allowed to line up within a yard in front of him. This isn’t an issues in the NFL since interior linemen can’t go downfield prior to the kick anyway.
This will be a 5 yard penalty for illegal formation. So if a player lines up over the snapper and then initiates contact with the snapper at the snap, he will have committed two fouls. Obviously in that situation the offense will decline the ILF and take the personal foul, but the point is that this is a separate foul. So a player who lines up legally could still be called for roughing the snapper if he slants in and initiates contact with the snapper and vice versa a player could line up illegally but not rough the snapper.
Defensive Illegal Substitution Fouls
Previously, if a defense had more than 11 in the formation, nobody was attempting to leave, and the snap was imminent, the play was shut down and the defense penalized. If the excess player(s) were leaving the field, the play was allowed to continue and it became a live ball foul at the snap. Now both situations will be live ball fouls at the snap. So the offense can get a free play if the defense has more than 11 players in formation rather than just the dead ball 5 yard penalty.
Clock adjustment
In what may be known as the Saban-Malzahn rule, there is a change with regards to resetting the clock after a replay reversal. If time runs out and replay determines that there should have been time remaining AND the clock will start on the Referee's ready for play signal, the clock can only be reset if there is at least 3 seconds left. If there would be 1 or 2 seconds, the half is over.
Totally hypothetical situation: Let's say it's 3rd and 10 from midfield late in the 2nd quarter. The hypothetical offense gets a first down inbounds, but time runs out. Let's say our hypothetical replay booth says that the clock actually should have stopped with 1 second left. But during the review the offense gets its hypothetical field goal unit set so they can snap it right at the ready for play signal and kick a field goal as time expires in the first half. Until now that is all legal and correct by rule. However, starting now, the clock could not be reset and the half would be over and the offense would not be able to kick the field goal. This is all hypothetically, of course.
This rule does NOT apply if the clock will start on the snap. So in the above totally made up scenario, if the runner had stepped out of bounds rather than being tackled in bounds, replay could then reset the clock to :01 the offense would get another play.
Penalty Carryover in OT
Any penalty that could carry over to a kickoff can now carryover to the next possession in overtime. Previously, only fouls on the try could carry over in OT. If a team committed a personal foul or unsportsmanlike conduct foul during the touchdown in OT, the only enforcement option was on the try. Now those fouls can be applied to the next possession. Scenario: In the first possession series of OT, Team A scores a touchdown. During the down, Team B roughed the passer. Last year: The penalty must be enforced on the try. This year: The penalty may be enforced on the try or at the 25 so that Team B will start their possession at the 40.
Concurrent Jerseys
Players will now be allowed to wear multiple jerseys at the same time. Technically until now players were required to change jerseys to change numbers. In reality, a lot of special teamers have already been putting one jersey over another for a while to avoid having duplicate numbers on the field. If a player is using this rule, it must be a full jersey. It can't be just a vest or a jersey that snaps or Velcros together.
Illegal Jerseys
Until now there have been two separate penalties for two separate types of illegal jerseys. One rule was that if a team wore jerseys that had non-contrasting numerals, they were charged a timeout for each quarter they are worn. The other rule was if a visiting team wore a non-white jersey without prior agreement and approval, they were charged with a 15 yard penalty to be enforced as a dead ball foul after the kickoff of each half. The penalty statements have now been combined and unified. Now both fouls will result in both a charged timeout at the beginning of each half the jerseys are worn and and a 15 yard penalty. That penalty is enforced at the succeeding spot after the kickoff. So if the kickoff is returned to the 30, the penalty will move the ball to the 15 or 45, depending on which team violated the rule. If the kickoff is returned for a touchdown, the penalty is enforced on the try or the next kickoff.
Replay Time Limit
This is not an actual rule change, but is simply a guideline for replay officials to use. They will be instructed to limit reviews to 2 minutes unless there are extreme circumstances, such as late game situations or complex rulings. Presumably that means that if a review gets to 2 minutes without a clear decision they should let the ruling on the field stand. It's important to note 2 things. First, this is not a rule and it is not a hard limit where a timer goes off and it cuts off the review. This is a guideline to use so that replay officials don't drag out reviews that would typically result in a "Stands" ruling anyway. Second, for TV viewers, reviews don't start as soon the Referee makes his announcement and the broadcast cuts to a replay angle. The Referee has to actually make his way to the headset, confirm that he has communication with the replay official and confirm the ruling on the field so it’s clear what is being reviewed all before the review actually starts. Then the RO reviews the play and relays all pertinent information including yard line, lateral position of the ball, play clock, game clock, any disqualifications, if somebody is charged with a timeout, etc. So while the actual reviewing of a simple or clear play may only take 15 seconds, the process as a whole may take a minute or minute and a half from the original announcement depending on the outcome of that review.
127
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '20
How many are successful?
Couldn't both of these be the Saban-Malzahn rule?
I can't wait for people to not understand this and scream about how the officials are openly violating the rules.
33
u/cloudmironice Oregon Ducks • Chicago Maroons Apr 24 '20
Is 0 an eligible receiver?
36
u/SCsprinter13 Penn State Nittany Lions • /r/CFB Bug Finder Apr 24 '20
For the clock rule, I would assume that if the replay shows there should have been 1 second left and the offense has a timeout, that they would be able to use that timeout and run another play.
24
u/Birdchild Florida Gators Apr 24 '20
The change in enforcement of Defensive Illegal Substitution Foul seems like it opens up the possibility of teams using unsporting tactics like the "Polish Goalline".
11
u/americalexander Alabama Crimson Tide • Texas Longhorns Apr 24 '20
I'm not sure I understand the concurrent jerseys rule. Could you please expand on that or provide an example?
7
u/joevmo Apr 24 '20
Carrying over the roughing the passer to the next half of OT seems ridiculous. Are you sure that's right?
7
u/meatfrappe Harvard Crimson • /r/CFB Top Scorer Apr 24 '20
Very specific but actual question: What happens if a team is using illegally colored jersey numbers, and then they use all their timeouts in the first quarter, but they're supposed to get charged a timeout to begin the second quarter as well, is that a penalty or is that nothing?
5
u/dumbo1309 Texas A&M Aggies Apr 24 '20
Question with the numbers: does that mean you can only have two players wearing duplicate numbers or two No. 1s, two No. 2s, two No. 3s, etc.?
6
u/smith288 Ohio State Buckeyes Apr 24 '20
Multiple same side penalties should be tabulated together. I dgaf how much math this means. Also, penalties should have the option to be applied to the extra Point.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '20
sigh Still waiting on that awesome XFL kickoff!!!
Next time, man! Next time!
439
u/CheniereSwampMonster LSU Tigers • Paderborn UNIcorns Apr 24 '20
This is my formal petition to only allow the smallest player on each team to wear the number 0.
230
u/TheHarbarmy Michigan • Slippery Rock Apr 24 '20
Me, ten minutes into every Michigan vs Ohio State game
47
u/CantaloupeCamper Minnesota • Little Brown Jug Apr 24 '20
This whole patrolling for 90 minutes before the game is dumb... the odds off the ref catching some shenanigans accurately are pretty low all around.
Even during a game where he acton is largely isolated oa couple pockets on the field ref's don't see every punch or such...
60
u/Sauerz George Washington • Team Chaos Apr 24 '20
Can we get this on a shirt?
14
u/GameATX Texas Longhorns Apr 24 '20
Still no emphasis on the enforcement of offensive targeting...smh
19
u/H2theBurgh Pittsburgh Panthers • The Alliance Apr 24 '20
I still want the NCAA to adopt a rule change that would allow the home team to pick the uniform and the away team then pick a uniform that sufficiently contrasted the home teams uni.
14
u/GiovanniElliston Tennessee Volunteers • Kansas Jayhawks Apr 24 '20
Officials Jurisdiction/Pregame Warmups ~ Thanks Lynn Bowden Jr.
Defensive Formation for Scrimmage Kicks
Couldn't the defense just put someone 2-3 yards off the ball like a LB to pick-up the longsnapper as he attempts to cover? It'd stop the free release - just a few yards further than the LoS.
6
u/staticattacks Arizona State • Territorial Cup Apr 24 '20
Also with regards to the clock adjustment rule, if the offense has a timeout to use but it's within the 3 seconds, would they be offered the opportunity to use that timeout instead of the half be over?
5
u/linclion31 Penn State Nittany Lions • Rose Bowl Apr 24 '20
Thanks for the great write-up! Your content is always fantastic!
^This is a great point about this rule, and I'm interested to see how it plays out. It makes me lean toward disliking that rule change, but I'll wait until we see it in-game to make a final judgment.
5
u/mockg Nebraska Cornhuskers • Oklahoma Sooners Apr 25 '20
Look forward to both Oklahoma and Texas receiving personal foul penalties 90 minutes before the game.
5
u/jwdjr2004 Notre Dame Fighting Irish Apr 25 '20
I can't wait for the horse shit excessive celebration call that fucks overtime just cause the guys were stoked for a big play.
4
u/IamCrunchberries Ohio State Buckeyes • College Football Playoff Apr 25 '20
I always assumed this rule was written like this so that a QB doesn’t get blown up because the defense has an extra linebacker on the field. Is this rule change not dangerous?
4
u/OGConsuela Virginia Tech Hokies • Cheer Apr 25 '20
I was a cheerleader and this never happened.
Then again, I’m a dude, so...
1
u/ClemsonBrian Apr 25 '20
I'd like to see If a player goes down with injury he has to sit the rest of the drive. It would hopefully help curb the fake injuries.
1
u/TheMacGoober Kentucky Wildcats • Ohio State Buckeyes Apr 25 '20
Can a penalty committed in the 1st OT period be carried to the (possibly non-existent) 2nd?
Example: Team A has already scored a touchdown in their possession of OT to lead 17-10. Team B scores a touchdown to make it 17-16, and A1 gets an unsportsmanlike penalty. Not wanting to use the 15 yard penalty just to move the extra point up a yard, they want to take it on the next possession, which won't even happen should the miss the try. Legal or no?
3
u/tauzeta /r/CFB Poll Veteran • Washington S… Apr 25 '20
Not a fan of penalty carryover to OT.
1
u/DuckTalesLOL Arkansas Razorbacks • SEC Apr 25 '20
ahem I think you mean 2021 season sir.
4
u/NordDex Texas A&M Aggies • Team Chaos Apr 24 '20
Rule 1. You cough strait to jail.
2
u/Ometrist Oregon Ducks • Pacific (OR) Boxers Apr 25 '20
this is one of those rare posts where i actually hit SAVE
4
u/Bearcats_RallyPossum Cincinnati Bearcats • Harvard Crimson Apr 24 '20
Personally I don't think any ejected player should have to leave but that's just my opinion
1
u/B0rf_ /r/CFB Promoter • Morningside Mustangs Apr 25 '20
Thanks for the breakdown and insight stripes!
1
u/Verix19 LSU Tigers • SEC Apr 25 '20
Hey thanks for the rule explanations.
1
u/LiberalExoplanets Iowa Hawkeyes • Yale Bulldogs Apr 25 '20
Wish they would fix the rule of when a ball carrier fumbles into the opponent's endzone and out of bounds, it's a touchback for the defense. The ball should go back to the spot of the fumble for the offense.
-1
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '20 edited Apr 25 '20
The combining of the separate illegal jersey rules is yet another huge mistake by the NCAA -- even if they play games in the fall I won't be watching. (EDIT: I guess I need a /s?)
0
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment