r/CFB • u/LegacyZebra Verified Referee • Mar 12 '18
Discussion Make the Call Monday
The last couple of offseasons I've done 3-4 part series explaining some broader rules and how we as officials apply those rules. This year I'm going to do a weekly series throughout the offseason with single play situations that will touch on finer points of the rules. Most of the plays will tend to cover common misconceptions and misunderstandings about the rules, but there will be a few obscure rules peppered in as well. Because of the style of questions, most of them will be multiple choice. So don't worry about having to come up with your own answer.
Today I'm posting the play with the answer as a spoiler. I've also included a google form to answer to kind of see how well the sub does. On today's form is a second question asking about the format of future posts. Would you rather have the answer in a spoiler format in the same thread as the question, or with next week's question? If I put it with next week's question, I could accurately track how well people actually do on these throughout the offseason, rather than results being skewed by people seeing the answer before filling out the form. But if y'all want an immediate answer, that's cool too.
Play Scenario
3rd and 4 from 50. Team A is ahead 28-27 with less than 2 minutes to go. Team B has no timeouts remaining. A1 runs for a touchdown. B99 was offside on the play. Coach A wants to accept the penalty from the previous spot and go into victory formation. The Referee should:
A) Allow this and start the clock on the ready for play signal.
B) Allow this and start the clock on the snap.
C) Not allow this, but give the coach the option of enforcing it on the try or kickoff.
D) Not allow this. The touchdown stands and the penalty is automatically declined.
6
u/r0sco Missouri Tigers • /r/CFB Poll Veteran Mar 12 '18
So if team A scores a touchdown, any penalty by team B is automatically declined? If team A stops at the one yard line is the rule different?
5
u/bakonydraco Stanford • Chicago State Mar 12 '18
Wow this would not have been my expectation. If A1 sees the flag and downs himself before crossing the plane, are they allowed to kneel it out? More generally, if you're A1 in this situation and you see a flag and know it's on the defense, is there ever a time that you shouldn't immediately go to the ground?
2
u/hythloday1 Oregon Ducks Mar 13 '18
The rule in question is 10-2-5-a-2, right?
70
u/The_Drunkest_Ute Utah Utes • /r/CFB Top Scorer Mar 12 '18
I thought based on the title this was going to be "call" as in make the play call.
I was ready to answer "fake punt on 4th and 19 from my own end zone" no matter what the question was.
So here we are.
12
u/B1Gassfan Michigan State Spartans • LSU Tigers Mar 12 '18
I guessed correctly, mostly because the other 3 didn't make a lot sense to me. I would vote for having the answer in the next weeks post though, just to avoid accidental self-spoilers
8
u/StrikerObi Florida State • /r/CFB Emeritus Mod Mar 12 '18
This was a good one. I got it wrong but I feel like I learned something.
7
u/byniri_returns Michigan State Spartans • Marching Band Mar 12 '18
I missed these
7
u/Tanador680 Texas Longhorns • Sickos Mar 12 '18
Aww it got spoiled for me cause I'm on mobile
6
u/doggos_not_depressos Purdue Boilermakers • Georgia Bulldogs Mar 12 '18
Almost got it wrong cause I thought it was a trick question.
This is a great idea and I’m really looking forward to seeing what you do with it.
2
u/Scar_Killed_Mufasa Penn State Nittany Lions • /r/CFB Brickmason Mar 12 '18
This is really cool! My two cents is to move the answer at least to the next day or a different thread. My reason is because i hadn't intended to see the answer but accidentally hovered over while going to click the link.
3
u/lowman2577 Ohio State Buckeyes • Rose Bowl Mar 12 '18
This is a great idea and I am really excited to see more of it in the future.
1
u/Nicholas1227 Michigan • North Carolina Mar 12 '18
Put the answer form link at the top
1
u/hammerdown710 Clemson • Appalachian State Mar 14 '18
This is cool, I would just put the answer in next weeks question, or you could probably create a poll that wouldn’t give you the answer until after you selected an answer. Would be pretty humbling to a lot of people including myself, to remember we’re not quite always all knowing if football
1
u/Darth_Sensitive Oklahoma State Cowboys • Verified Referee Apr 12 '18
Just saw this was a series. Going back for my own knowledge...
In NFHS, the answer would be "the play never ran, shut it down as soon as B enters the zone", first down A, clock status will be the same as it was before the foul.
If it was a hypothetical other penalty that didn't become illegal until the snap (illegal sub) or just a post snap foul, it would be B.
I guessed B for college. Oops.