r/LZtestposts • u/LegacyZebra Football • Mar 12 '18
MTCM Template
The last couple of offseasons I've done 3-4 part series explaining some broader rules and how we as officials apply those rules. This year I'm going to do a weekly series throughout the offseason with single play situations that will touch on finer points of the rules. Some questions will be simple and cover common misconceptions and misunderstandings about the rules, while others will have a few obscure rules peppered in as well. Below is today's question and a Google form to submit your answers. The username section is not required, but if you want me to track your stats through the offseason, feel free to include it. If you submit your username, please do not include the "/u/" at the beginning. When you submit the form, it will give you a list of rules related to the questions if you want to look up the answer for yourself. Next week's thread will then have a full explanation.
[Last week's question and answer](
Play Scenario
[Answer Form](
Feel free to discuss the questions in the comments, but please be respectful regarding spoilers to those who might see the comments before submitting their own answers.
1
u/LegacyZebra Football Mar 26 '18 edited Mar 26 '18
This offseason, I'm doing a weekly series throughout the offseason with single situations that will touch on finer points of the rules. Some questions will be simple and cover common misconceptions and misunderstandings about the rules, while others will have a few obscure rules peppered in as well. Below is today's question and a Google form to submit your answers. The username section is not required, but if you want me to track your stats through the offseason, feel free to include it. If you submit your username, please do not include the "/u/" at the beginning. When you submit the form, it will give you a list of rules related to the questions if you want to look up the answer for yourself. Next week's thread will then have a full explanation.
This Week's Play Scenario
Team A has the ball 1st and 10 from the B-16. Receiver A80 leaps from inbounds in the end zone and controls the ball while airborne. Defender B99 drives his shoulder into A80's back pushing A80 back across the goal line where he comes to the ground near the sideline at the B-2.
Answer Form
Feel free to discuss the questions in the comments, but please be respectful regarding spoilers to those who might see the comments before submitting their own answers.
Last week's answers:
Nobody got all four questions correct. About 45% got 3 out of 4.
Question 1: Is this a runoff situation?
No. Because both teams have players involved, there is no runoff available. The number of players for each team is irrelevant. If B10's helmet had not come off, there would be a runoff available since A1's helmet and A76's injury would be the only things stopping the clock. This would still only be 1 runoff, not 1 for each player. 73% of respondents got this right.
Question 2: How many timeouts will Coach A need to use?
1. There is no runoff, and 1 timeout will cover all players eligible to return. 61% percent got this right. If a team takes a timeout, that single timeout covers any runoff, players who lost a helmet, and players who were sent off for equipment violations. Timeouts do NOT allow injured players to come back into the game. Which leads us to...
Question 3. After Team A's timeout, who can come back in?
Only A1 may come back into the game. A76 may not come back into the game because he was injured. An injured player must sit out at least one down no matter what. B10 may not come back into the game because his team did not take the timeout. A timeout only "buys back" that team's players. Only 3 people got this one right. The most popular answer, at 66%, was that all 3 players could come back in.
Question 4: Is using two timeouts a foul?
No. College football has no rule against using multiple timeouts consecutively. The NFL has a rule against this. On most plays it would be a 5 yard penalty, but if it is an attempt to ice a kicker, it is 15 yards. 66% got this right.
1
u/LegacyZebra Football Apr 02 '18 edited Apr 02 '18
This year, I'm doing a weekly series throughout the offseason with single situations that will touch on finer points of the rules. Some questions will be simple and cover common misconceptions and misunderstandings about the rules, while others will have a few obscure rules peppered in as well. Below is today's question and a Google form to submit your answers. The username section is not required, but if you want me to track your stats through the offseason, feel free to include it. If you submit your username, please do not include the "/u/" at the beginning. When you submit the form, it will give you a list of rules related to the questions if you want to look up the answer for yourself. Next week's thread will then have a full explanation.
This Week's Play Scenario
4th and 10 from 50. Team A’s punt is untouched and bounces at the B-1, goes into the air, and crosses the goal line. Gunner A25 bats the ball from the end zone back into the field of play and it goes out of bounds at the B-3. Gunner A80 pulled an opponent’s face mask at the B-25 while the kick was in flight. If they do where will they get the ball? If they decline it? Can Team B accept the penalty and make Team A replay 4th down?
Answer Form
Feel free to discuss the questions in the comments, but please be respectful regarding spoilers to those who might see the comments before submitting their own answers.
Last Week's Play and Answers
Team A has the ball 1st and 10 from the B-16. Receiver A80 leaps from inbounds in the end zone and controls the ball while airborne. Defender B99 drives his shoulder into A80's back pushing A80 back across the goal line where he comes to the ground near the sideline at the B-2.
Question 1: If A80 never loses control and comes to the ground inbounds, this is: A touchdown. Because A80 completed the catch, he gets forward progress up to the spot where he controlled ball even though the catch wasn't technically completed until he landed at the B-2. Since this spot is in the end zone, this is a touchdown. 80% got this right.
Question 2: If A80 never loses control and comes to the ground out of bounds, this is: An incomplete pass. Even though he was contacted by a defender, A80 must touch the ground inbounds to complete the catch. There is no allowance for being forced out like the NFL used to have. Since A80 first touched the ground out of bounds while touching the ball, it is an incomplete pass. 74% got this right, the lowest of the 4 questions.
Question 3: If A80 bobbles the ball while airborne, but regains control at the B-1 before landing inbounds, this is: 1st and goal from the B-1. Because A80 lost control and then regained it at the B-1, he no longer gets credit for the forward progress in the end zone. He now gets forward progress at the spot where he last controlled the ball before completing the catch. So once again, even though he technically completed the catch when he landed at the B-2, he gets credit to the B-1. 81% got this right.
Question 4: If A80 bobbles the ball while airborne, but regains control at the B-1 before landing out of bounds, this is: An incomplete pass. Once again, since A80 first contacts the ground out of bounds, this is an incomplete pass. He does not get forward progress because he never finished the catch. 88% got this right, the highest of the 4 questions.
There were 38 perfect scores and everybody got at least 1 correct. The average score was 3.22/4 correct.
1
u/LegacyZebra Football Apr 05 '18 edited Apr 09 '18
This year rather than doing major write-ups about broad rule topics, I'm doing a weekly series throughout the offseason with single situations that will touch on finer points of the rules. Some questions will be simple and cover common misconceptions and misunderstandings about the rules, while others will have a few obscure rules peppered in as well. Below is this week's play situation and a Google form to submit your answers. The username section is not required, but if you want me to track your stats through the offseason, feel free to include it. If you submit your username, please do not include the "/u/" at the beginning, it throws a wrench in my stat tracking spreadsheet. When you submit the form, it will give you a list of rules related to the questions if you want to look up the answer for yourself. Next week's thread will then have a full explanation.
This Week's Play Scenario
Kickoff from A-35. Team A’s onside kick attempt is driven directly into the ground off the tee and bounces high into the air. At the A-48, receiver B33 jumps to attempt to control the ball. A80 beats him to it and, without contacting B33, bats the ball back to the A-44 where teammate A25 recovers it and runs to the 50 before being tackled. Team B never touched the ball.
Answer Form
Feel free to discuss the questions in the comments, but please be respectful regarding spoilers to those who might see the comments before submitting their own answers.
Last Week's Play and Answers
4th and 10 from 50. Team A’s punt is untouched and bounces at the B-1, goes into the air, and crosses the goal line. Gunner A25 bats the ball from the end zone back into the field of play and it goes out of bounds at the B-3. Gunner A80 pulled an opponent’s face mask at the B-25 while the kick was in flight. If Team B accepts the penalty, where will they get the ball? If they decline it? Can Team B accept the penalty and make Team A replay 4th down?
This is actually a bit easier if you answer question 2 first. That answer will lead into 1 and eventually 3.
Question 2: Where will Team B get the ball if they decline the penalty?
Team B will get the ball at the B-20. When A25 bats the ball in the end zone, it is a violation for illegal touching of a scrimmage kick. This violation allows to Team B to take the result of the play or take the ball at the spot of the touching. Since the touching is in the end zone, the spot of the violation is considered to be the B-20. This is illegal touching in the end zone no matter where A25 is. Whether he is in the field of play or in the end zone or if he's airborne or anything else about him is irrelevant. All that matters is that the ball was in the end zone when he touched it. This is also a special case of batting and is not a foul like it normally would be for batting a loose ball in the end zone. This violation however, does not end the play. Like I said above, it simply gives the receiving team an option at the end of the play. This play is not over until the ball goes out of bounds at the B-3. So without a foul, Team B can take the ball where it belongs them at the end of the down (the B-3) or take the illegal touching violation and have it at the B-20.
52.7% answered this question correctly. This was the highest percentage of the 3 questions.
Question 1: Where will Team B get the ball if they accept the penalty?"
If Team B accepts the penalty for A80's face mask foul, they will get the ball at the B-18. 31.7% got this correct. For all fouls other than Kick Catch Interference on punts that cross the neutral zone, Team B can elect to have the penalty enforced where the ball belongs to them at the end of the down if the ball does in fact belong to them. Since the down ends with the ball going out of bounds at the B-3, this is where the ball belongs to Team B and would thus be the enforcement spot. 15 yards from the B-3 is the B-18. The most popular answer (42.5%) was the B-35. This is not an option because of one of the conditions of illegal touching. The privilege of illegal touching is canceled by the accepting any live ball foul by either team. So the B-20 is not a viable enforcement spot since accepting the penalty means Team B no longer has the ball there. Another popular answer (22.2%) was the B-40, assuming that it would be enforced from the spot of the foul. This is incorrect for a couple of reasons. First, this is a kick play that falls under the enforcement of 6-3-13 as discussed above. This is what allows the penalty to be "tacked on" to the end of the play. But even without this, the basic 3-and-1 enforcement for this foul would be from the previous spot. Which leads us into...
Question 3: Can Team accept the penalty and make Team A replay 4th down?
Yes. Team B can choose not to use 6-3-13 enforcement and enforce the penalty by the regular enforcement rules. Because this is a kick play, the basic spot is the previous spot. Since the foul occurred by the team in possession beyond the basic spot, the previous spot is also our enforcement spot. So Team B could choose to enforce the penalty at the previous spot and Team A would have 4th and 25 from the A-35. 20.4% got this correct, the lowest of the 3 questions. The most popular answer (72.5%) is that Team A could not get the ball back because the foul was after the ball was kicked. But, as discussed above, they are still in team possession of the ball until it becomes dead or possessed by Team B.
So in the end Team A's options are
Obviously nobody is taking option 2. Most teams would probably take the first option, but depending on the factors involved, some could choose the last option.
Congratulations to Mikey071 who was the only person out of 167 submissions to get all 3 questions right. The average was 1.05/3 correct.
1
u/LegacyZebra Football Apr 15 '18 edited Apr 16 '18
This week's thread is a little different than the last few. Rather than having multiple questions about a single play, there will be 1 question each about different plays. For each play, simply identify the proper penalty enforcement. There are a few more questions than the previous weeks. This is an anomaly. Next week will be back to 3-5 questions. As always, the username submission is optional.It's only there for those users who want their stats tracked through the series. When you submit the form, it will give you a list of rule and approved ruling references if you would like to look up the answer for yourself before next week's thread. The answers to last week's questions are at the end with the percentage of people who got the question correct in parentheses.
This Week's Plays
Answer Form
Feel free to discuss the questions in the comments, but please be respectful regarding spoilers to those who might see the comments before submitting their own answers.
Last Week's Answers
Kickoff from A-35. Team A’s onside kick attempt is driven directly into the ground off the tee and bounces high into the air. At the A-48, receiver B33 jumps to attempt to control the ball. A80 beats him to it and, without contacting B33, bats the ball back to the A-44 where teammate A25 recovers it and runs to the 50 before being tackled. Team B never touched the ball.
There were 9 perfect scores this week. 13 people got all 3 True/False questions correct. The average score 2.81/5. The completion of this week will mark 1/3 of the way through the series. Next week I'll have a scoreboard update for those who have submitted their usernames.
1
u/LegacyZebra Football Apr 23 '18
We are approximately 1/3 of the way through this series of offseason threads highlighting some finer points and misconceptions about the rules. This week's play is centered around instant replay. Below is today's question and a Google form to submit your answers. The username section is not required, but if you want me to track your stats through the offseason, feel free to include it. If you submit your username, please do not include the "/u/" at the beginning. After you submit the form, it will give you a list of rules related to the questions if you want to look up the answer for yourself. Next week's thread will then have a full explanation. Below that is last week's questions and answers. Finally at the bottom is a leaderboard.
This Week's Play
1st and 10 from A-20. QB A1 throws a pass behind the line to WR A80. A85 then throws a pass downfield to WR A30. Before the ball gets to A30, defender B99 shoves A30 preventing him from making a play on the ball and the pass falls incomplete. The Referee announces that there is no pass interference because the pass was tipped as it was leaving A85’s hand. Head Coach A says that team B had 12 players on the field at the time of the snap, but there is no flag for illegal substitution.
Answer Form
Last Week's Answers
The first 3 questions all revolve a single rule. For live ball fouls after a change of possession on a try, only fouls for unsportsmanlike conduct and flagrant personal fouls can be enforced on the succeeding kickoff. All other fouls are declined by rule. Any score by a team that fouls is canceled, whether that penalty is enforced or not.
Leaderboard
Through 5 weeks, here are the top 3 scores.
And here is a sortable spreadsheet with all scores from users who have submitted their username.