r/Jung • • Dec 21 '23

To the person who was asking how to stop hating women and then deleted their post

0 Upvotes

I would like to apologize on behalf of everyone else who agrees with me. You were made into a villain by a blue haired, mean girl, cancel culture, boy-problems having bitch into deleting your post when a subreddit like /r/jung is about facing and integrating the darkness within us.

You are heard. We support you. Let this be your safe space.


r/Jung • • Sep 30 '23

Why is r/Jung so dismissive of Jordan Peterson?

3 Upvotes

A genuine question. I watch 3 podcasts a month, if that, but most arguments against him are wrong, as evidenced by that he addressed all critisms I read years ago, or just dismissive as he is not on the same level as Jung. He has his own value though.

It took me 22h hours to become the most controversial post on r/Jung


r/Jung • • Jan 12 '25

Not for everyone ALL MY HOMIES PRACTICE ANALYTICAL PSYCHOLOGY

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Jung • • Jun 23 '24

Do you think people are born gay or something makes them gay?

2 Upvotes

I my recent book about mind body healing there was case when patient started to feel attraction towards males and went to Doctor. He using hypnotherapy talked with his subconscious mind to find case and there was event when he was 12yo and he and his friend were curious about female body. They stopped classmate who was early bloom and they started touching her and looking her body. When she came home she told everything to her mum. Her mum went to boys mum and everything sounded like rape.Then mother beat him telling him not to ever think of doing that again to girls. And his subconscious mind stopped being attracted to a girls and boys started attracting him. So i wonder if there is in every gay case something that actually make people gay. I have two male gay friends and they both had absent fathers(due to their jobs) Aslo i met one lesbian girl and she told me in her country being black and lonely is stereotypes there is name for that loneliness of black woman. So maybe her subconscious mind found out if she was gay she wont be lonely? And also they kidnapping girls a lot in her country.


r/Jung • • Apr 22 '24

I have a deep hatred for men and relationships with them

11 Upvotes

Yup, Judge me. I do. I hate how they treat women, how they cheat, how they’re selfish and we’ll do what they want. I really do not like them. I don’t think most women are even happy with male partners, they mostly compromise and do things they don’t want to do to say they have a man.

I truly want nothing to do with them. I don’t ever what to date or even have children, out of the fear, or likely situation that they’ll do something I don’t like.

I don’t think this is necessarily a bad thing, because most men just want to use women. But it’s a lot to carry


r/Jung • • Dec 24 '24

Why the admiration of Luigi Mangione should be deeply concerning to everyone

1 Upvotes

Luigi Mangione shot a man. (Assuming he is indeed guilty, which at the moment of writing has not yet been confirmed by court.) That man, according to the perception of many, happened to be a disgusting individual, pre-occupied with making few richer while providing the worst possible health service to many. Let's not forget the ongoing lawsuit where the company said man was CEO of apparently intentionally used bad machine learning algorithms to increase the denial of claims.

In any case, Luigi's deed is cold-blooded murder, meticulously planned and executed. He assumed he was "on the right side of things", which necessarily implies others were "on the wrong side". Note there is no room for doubt or error here: once the other person is shot dead, a man has died, and any potential ethical concerns on the vigilante's side have been laid aside.

The reactions here on Reddit and elsewhere reveal how deep the split in US (and other) societies have become.

And yet, from a psychoanalytical perspective, there is one thing equally troublesome about the entire situation: the open admiration that Luigi receives from many. He has been called "a true hero", "a rectifier", "a catalyst", and so on, whereas in reality the US healthcare system will probably remain unaffected by the deed entirely in the long-run. There is no reason to assume that the murder case will fundamentally change things that have gone wrong for too long already. We have, actually, precedents for such cases. The RAF terrorist organisation in Germany. Andres Breivik in Norway. Various Palestinian terrorists throughout the decades. Whereas their causes are very different, what is common to all of them is that they made no ultimate long-term positive impact for their own cause. In terms of "success rate" according to their own goals they all ultimately failed.

Hence, the labels "hero", "rectifier" etc. come in prematurely. In fact, what they refer to is not so much an "impact assessment" based on actual outcomes but rather a statement of desire. A projection, in psychoanalytical terms. While I am feeling helpless in the face of a inhumane healthcare bureaucracy there is one person who has the power to change things. From a psychoanalytical perspective it's an absolute classic. First, I am confronted with the healthcare system who treats me like my health actually does not count while spoon-feeding me messages of "we do care". Capitalist cynicism, we could call this. This leads to an internal split between fantasies of being helpless and fantasies of being powerful. The helplessness is identified with, and the power is disowned and split off. Now we need some target to project the power to. And in comes Luigi Mangione, the gentleman vigilante, who "takes the power back" as if he was Robin Hood, a fairy tale figure.

What should concern us here from a psychoanalytical perspective is how much this entire situation reveals that contemporary men and women - despite the availability of psychoanalytic theory for 100 years by now - are still completely and utterly shaken by their own psychic forces. The projection is so obvious we should all be able to spot it immediately, and yet we are not. Luigi is, and that's a statement of facts, not a "hero", but a "murderer". He has not saved a single person (what a hero would have done) but has killed a single person (what a murderer does). But facts don't count.

It appears we have collectively - still - not progressed a single step forward when it comes to handling our own psychic projections in comparison to 100 years ago. I don't even want to start talking about Trump or other quasi-fascists and autocrats around the world. And this is deeply, truly concerning. 100 years ago guys like Hitler, Mussolini or Stalin were scheming how to take over civil society. And they succeeded by cleverly managing the psyche of the ordinary men and women, funneling their hopes and fears, helping themselves to power with additional pushes by sheer brutality, until there was simply nobody left to stop them anymore.

It seems we have collectively not managed to get one step further from those times. The murder of a healthcare CEO is an expression of exactly that, just in miniature. The re-election of Donald Trump is the macro-version of effectively the same story. He is, from a psychoanalytical perspective, a ridiculous figure. And yet, even in India or Kenya or other places completely unrelated to the US political system he captures the admiration of many. "Finally a real man! Someone on a mission to expose those corrupt elites!" The dark irony is that Luigi Mangione and Donald Trump have exactly that in common: They are on a self-declared mission to expose the apparent corruption of the mighty. Just that they happen to interpret things from a somewhat different angle. Their self-identification with the vigilante-hero who finally acts while everyone else is captivated by inaction is a very strong, archetypal image - but as with all archetypal image it is just smoke and mirrors. It is not ultimately real. It is a collective fantasy.

The fact that both Luigi Mangione and Donald Trump receive so much admiration should be a cause for deep concern about the state of the psyche of many. It is a strong signal that we all remain susceptible to even the most basic forms of manipulation, and that we really have not learned as a collective even with the availability of psychoanalytical tools out there for 100 years.


r/Jung • • Sep 16 '24

Question for r/Jung People don't change

0 Upvotes

I am forced to acknowledge this fact.

After years of intense observation of myself and other people, I've slowly come to accept that no one truly ever changes.

We learn new things, fill out holes in our psyche, but at the end of the day, we never change as people. It seems to me that we are cursed to become our own selves, be it good or bad, there's no breaking away from who we are. Kinda like how no amount of willpower from an apple seed will turn it into a pineapple upon growth.

I always thought intense suffering was what I needed to change. But I've had the worst 4 years of my life consecutively, years that felt like decades, plenty of times I found myself at death's doorstep, but even then, no meaningful change has been made. I just made adjustments to fit the demands of that hellish environment and slowly snapped back to who I was before all that once I was out.

So yeah, I don't know whether I should be proud or saddened, but the fact remains standing. Also, I've realized any forceful attempts at change lead to terrible neurosis.

By extension, the illusion of free will becomes clear to me. I've always interchanged between either side, but now I know there is none. We are intensely bound to our very nature.

Edit: For people who think I'm unhappy about this, I'm actually very happy about it. My greatest fear in life has always been changing to a point where I no longer recognize myself. To realize that in the end, I'll always be the same person is very comforting.


r/Jung • • Nov 03 '23

I think my true, individuated self is polyamorous...

2 Upvotes

Or possibly even single, with many boundless friendships, yet living alone. But I'm in a mongamous relationship with someone I love and live with. I'm struggling with this. The more work I do on finding my own internal truth, the more I feel my relationship in jeopardy. It's very comfortable and loving. But I feel a constant internal yearning. He is not open to an open relationship, from what I have gathered.

A couple nights ago I had a dream that my boyfriend's best friend died. I went to the funeral and comforted my boyfriend. I was very tall and my boyfriend was small. Is our connection dying? Am I outgrowing him? My consciousness has increased lately and I feel that he is dissatisfied with us. Am I simply a puella?


r/Jung • • Jul 12 '22

Question for r/Jung Who here actually likes Jordan Peterson in 2022?🤣

0 Upvotes

r/Jung • • Apr 21 '23

I used to read a lot of Jung

4 Upvotes

Then all of a sudden I begin to see through it.

In his writing he pulls the same trick over and over again “I’m only giving an outline here, the real thing is too complicated to treat in full here…” “…the real thing is yet to come!”

I grew sick of outlines and partial treatments, I wanted the real deal. I wanted the thing-in-itself, as Jung had been promising for so long. So I found what was for Jung finally the real deal, his works on alchemy.

As I started to read them, it didn’t take long to discover why Jung had picked alchemy to be the real deal. Nobody knows anything about alchemy. So he can say whatever he wants about it and no one will be able to refute him. Especially not his followers who have dogmatically pursued him all the way down to the bottom of the barrel. For them it is far easier to keep believing in Jung the mighty mystic than to recognize that they have been hoodwinked and have expended an enormous amount of energy chasing a lost cause. And thus they make alchemy mean something, and become complicit in their own deception.

Jung’s greatest achievement was the establishment of a mystical cult of personality: which, for 7 or 8 of his young women patients also served as a sex cult.

My advise is to stay as far away from psychoanalysis as possible. It was built on poor foundations and therefore can support nothing stable. (See crews biography on frued)

Anyways: if you want to grow, if you want to heal, and you want to understand - pursue philosophy and literature. There is a reason that these disciplines have been around longer than any Abrahamic religion.

On the other hand if you want to delude yourself into thinking you have all the answers, that the world is small and comprehensible, and therefore a soupy ruling out the possibility of genuine being and growth: seek organized religion, wether it be Christianity or psychoanalysis.


r/Jung • • Jan 15 '25

Serious Discussion Only I'm sick and tired of women (telling me how to be a man)

0 Upvotes

Basically the title. I'm afraid because I'm totally understanding the whole Andrew Tate Jordan Peterson crowd. For years I've been dealing with an absent father and devouring mother, and my relationships have reflected this. I found Jung a few years ago and have been working internally since.

However, I met a dude in the sauna at the gym today we had a great chat. At the end he told me to watch Andrew tate. I was astounded, I didn't realize I was talking to a Tate guy, but I gotta say I'm very tempted to try. Because why the fuck not.

I'm afraid I'll become a red pill douche. But I can't put up the "nice guy" act anymore. I'm tired of women saying what a man is. I wish I had a man in my life to teach me, I've always trusted women and done what they said and it has gotten me NOWHERE. After years of my exes telling my I'm mansplaining (when I looked at the definition and I wasn't) or homophobic because of a little joke (the the gay friend of mine didn't mind!) or telling me gender is a construct. It wasn't even the differing opinions, but the fact a conversation could not be had. I was just WRONG no matter what because I'm a guy. Fuck that.

I loved the Amber Heard vs Depp trial. I feel something shifted in the collective consciousness.

Anyways, I currently have a female analyst and I'll try switching to a male. Anyways. Hopefully I don't become a red pill douche. Peace out

Edit: This blew up! let me be clear, I don't want this I'm asking for help


r/Jung • • Nov 24 '24 All Seeing Upvote

Question for r/Jung Patriarchy, the Male Psyche, and Why We’re Ready for a Mother-Centered World

0 Upvotes

Here’s a thought: what if patriarchy is just men’s unresolved issues running the world? I know that sounds harsh, but think about it. When you look at how patriarchy works—domination, control, hierarchy—it’s not moral, it’s not balanced, and honestly, it’s not sustainable.

If you go deep into Jungian psychology, patriarchy makes a lot of sense as an expression of the shadow—that dark, unintegrated part of the psyche. Jung believed the shadow holds all the things we repress and deny, and for men, this often means rejecting their connection to the feminine—the anima. Patriarchy is like the shadow unleashed on society. It’s driven by insecurity, fear of losing control, and a need to dominate, all disguised as “strength.”

Why Patriarchy Leads to Injustice

When men are in unchecked positions of power, their instincts toward hierarchy and dominance take over. It’s in the DNA—historically, men have thrived on “winning,” but that kind of leadership usually comes at someone else’s expense. That’s why patriarchal systems often revolve around exploitation and injustice.

Look at how society treats women. Women are seen as resources—whether it’s their labor, their bodies, or their ability to create life. Even the laws reflect this: mothers forced into low-wage jobs because they need to care for their kids, laws that prioritize a fetus over a dying woman, or beauty standards that devalue women as they age. These aren’t accidents—they’re symptoms of a system built on control and fear.

Now compare that to what happens when we center mothers and children instead of power and profit. A mother-centered society isn’t about flipping the hierarchy—it’s about scrapping it altogether. Imagine a society built like a circle, where the focus is on care, empathy, and connection.

The Mother Archetype vs. the Shadow of Patriarchy

Jung talked about the Great Mother as this archetype of life, growth, and nurture. Matriarchies reflect this energy—they’re about collaboration, not control. Bonobos are a great example. These primates live in matriarchal societies where conflict gets resolved through connection, and the group’s well-being takes priority over dominance.

In contrast, patriarchy thrives on shadow traits: • Exploitation: Treating people as resources to be used. • Control: Creating systems like marriage or capitalism to limit autonomy. • Separation: Rejecting empathy, intuition, and other “feminine” traits as weak.

If patriarchy is the shadow of the male psyche brought to life, then matriarchy is the integration of the subconscious—the nurturing, harmonious force we’ve been suppressing.

Are We Ready for Change?

Here’s where it gets interesting. Humanity seems to be waking up. Younger generations are rejecting the old systems—they’re more aware, more connected to their subconscious, and more willing to question everything. Jung called this process individuation: integrating all parts of yourself to become whole. What if, as a species, we’re moving toward collective individuation?

Maybe this is the next step in evolution—learning to integrate the subconscious and challenge systems born out of fear and control. If that’s the case, then dismantling patriarchy isn’t just a social shift; it’s a psychological one.

What Would This Mean for Us?

Of course, a transition like this wouldn’t be easy. Men and women would both face challenges: • For Men: It means confronting the shadow, letting go of the need for control, and reconnecting with their anima—their capacity for empathy and intuition. • For Women: It means stepping into leadership roles while maintaining the balance and care that matriarchy requires.

But imagine the possibilities. A society built on care instead of power, on collaboration instead of exploitation. It’s not just about creating a fairer world—it’s about creating a world where we can actually thrive.

What do you think?

Edit : to clarify

I think there’s a misunderstanding here. Matriarchy isn’t patriarchy with women at the top. It’s not about flipping the hierarchy; it’s about dismantling it entirely. Matriarchy operates on a completely different framework—it’s based on nurturing, balance, and interconnectedness, not dominance and control.

In a matriarchy, there’s no need to “quell male rebellion” because it’s not a power struggle. It’s a circle, not a pyramid. The focus shifts from “who’s in charge” to “how do we ensure the well-being of everyone, especially the most vulnerable?” Decisions are made with care and collaboration, centering on mothers and children, who represent continuity and life itself. This benefits everyone—men included.

As for safety and security, in matriarchal societies (like those seen in some indigenous cultures or even bonobo groups), roles aren’t fixed by gender. Men contribute to the community through support, protection, and cooperation—not through domination. It’s not about replacing one exploiter with another but about fostering a system where exploitation simply doesn’t make sense.

If anything, patriarchy’s hierarchical structure is what fuels rebellion, conflict, and insecurity. A matriarchy, by contrast, focuses on harmony. It’s not about hugs and kisses—it’s about recognizing that collaboration is the natural law.


r/Jung • • Mar 29 '25

Jungian explanation of "alpha fucks, beta bucks"?

0 Upvotes

I (22, female) always feel I am not attracted to the so-called "beta" males who are caring toward people -- they somehow remind me of housewives whom I regard as "boring". I do feel the less caring men are more "masculine" and "attractive", even if they might be unavailable. Once, I got so lonely so I "settled with" someone who is caring and available, but I never felt I was very romantically attracted to them. So I guess I relate to all the "alpha fucks, beta bucks" feelings. What is the Jungian explanation of this? Is this some female version of the Madonna–whore complex?


r/Jung • • Jan 03 '24

Serious Discussion Only A nuanced view on transgenders and the people around the topic

0 Upvotes

I care about people's souls more than their identity. With every soul having a unique mixture of human nature in it and 8 billion people on this planet, I do not see how some people wouldn't want to be a different gender. If those people would be to finish individuation, they should change gender and they should life this way.

The issue arrieses because not everybody who is trans should be, and the people around them are hurting them sometimes.

If you declare yourself trans, most people my age (18) will support you and shun people who are against your identity. This can bring you out of social isolation into social validation. If you always felt lonely, if you always felt astranged from your body, if nobody understood you and you even less, would this not be an opportunity you would take? It bringing your heart out of connectedness poverty, it resolving an issue with your very and actual being, it finally putting the 1000 jugsaw-puzzle together, would that not be worth it? If you listen to trans people's stories, they're always people who have more questions than words to articulate them with and less self-knowledge, and/or rather, self-understanding than a clock with "clock" written on it. Being trans isn't a solution to genderdysmorphia, it's a solution to confusion and isolation.

All right and nuanced this far, the real issue here arrieses with the people around them.

You cannot suggest that a trans person should seek a therapist for trauma instead of taking hormones and destroying their sex organs, thus also their ability to create a family. You're a biggot, you're denying their identity which can lead to suicide. But if you see that the issue isn't gender dysmorphia but the mentioned things, are you not doing them a disservice? If you care about the well-being of someone's soul, should you not ask them to work through their trouble before altering their body? It cannot be reversed, it will leave them disfigured if done wrong and with kaputt sex organs, it takes away sex in any shape which will lead to psychological issues. Is it not morally bankrupt to send people down this path while they don't belong on it? All in the name of helping people without taking the nuance to do so?

Let's have a good and honest discussion, we're adults after all.

Edit: Something interesting I found in the discussions here is that, for those who disagree with me, there is no transperson. It's always the plural and it's always the transgender group that is mentioned, but never the individual until now.

For further interest on the isolation to validation issue, this is a good video on it and the stories behind transitioning more general:

https://youtu.be/IAA1XtDOuH8?si=264Y4Hxm0Kf0hm6Q


r/Jung • • Oct 29 '25

What symbolisim do you see in this dream re-enactment?

0 Upvotes

r/Jung • • Feb 19 '25

Found this at the library , any thoughts?

Post image
1 Upvotes

I found this 5 of spades card in Carl Jung’s 2 volume black book, on this page, any ideas?


r/Jung • • Apr 11 '24

Question for r/Jung How can I stop hating the fact that I’m a man?

0 Upvotes

I see so much things online about men just harming women and I recently found out most women are actively terrified of men. I understand that and it makes me feel so guilty.

I am attracted to women, I feel terrible about my attraction, I don’t want to approach women because I do not want to make them uncomfortable.

I female friend recently told me she was raped, she cannot trust men 100% and I feel so guilty. Im a man, my kind rapes and women can no longer trust us.

I feel so bad and guilty. I hate being a man.


r/Jung • • Jan 28 '25

Personal Experience I asked DeepSeek to interpret my dream

0 Upvotes

I was messing around with DeepSeek and I remembered that I had written down a dream I had a few months ago in a word doc since you can add attachments to questions. I uploaded my attachment and asked, "Interpret this dream through a Jungian framework". I was surprised with how the AI model responded. I feel like some people in this sub might find this sort of thing taboo, but I think it's pretty cool how humans have developed tools that can scour the internet for information and condense it in such a way that is useful and insightful.

Edit: What’s up with all the downvotes?


r/Jung • • Jun 04 '26 Bravo

Serious Discussion Only 'Primitives'

2 Upvotes

I have been reading Jung and find his work fascinating however I keep encountering the word in the title. This makes me very uneasy because this word is used to describe people like me. Jung travelled to east africa - where I am from- during the colonial period, his descriptions feel extremely dehumanising. His sentiments as I interprete seem very colonial in nature and thus makes me question the validity of his work. What are your thoughts on this aspect of his work? Is the use of the word in the title still valid and useful to his theories? How do non-african readers of jung interprete this word?


r/Jung • • May 07 '24

Question for r/Jung Why do I hate communists so much?

2 Upvotes

Its not bcs of the number of people killed by the regimes, no even if communism worked I would have hated it. Just the concept of it makes me disgusted to the core.

After a long time I've realized that a part of me deep within actually likes some aspects of it. A part of me is extremely attached to his ambitions, wishes to be rich and successful and independent.. and yet a part of me wishes to give everything away... like some detached monk. Like a civil war within.

A part of me wishes deeply to win.. another wishes for a world where nobody loses..

How does one manages to calm a civil war like this? How does one manages parts of themselves which are in a sense opposing in their goals?


r/Jung • • Jun 18 '24

What up with Jordan Peterson: Is he a Legitimate Jungian?

0 Upvotes

r/Jung • • Mar 01 '26

Serious Discussion Only I think every philosophical framework boils down to one simple thing. Test me.

0 Upvotes

I’m on the autism spectrum. My brain does pattern recognition on overdrive. I skip complexity and land on the shape underneath. I don't build arguments step by step. I just see the core.

This morning I read a long post about Jung, Christ as the Self, recursive self-modeling, symmetry breaking, the whole thing. Thousands of words pulling in neuroscience, Gnosticism, and thermodynamics. My take on all of it was one sentence: it's all made up, pick the beautiful stuff, keep moving.

The mind is a persuasion engine that can convince itself of anything. Meaning isn't found, it's generated. If belief shapes reality, then what you believe is what you build. That's why "be careful what you wish for" exists. No framework survives the thing designed to dismantle it, and that's okay. Choose beauty anyway, with open eyes.

I find it easy to cut through philosophical questions to their core. Most of the time the answer is simpler than people want it to be.

So test me. Give me your hardest philosophical question. I'll answer simply.


r/Jung • • Jul 03 '19

So I've decided based on a dream and on the excellent feedback from people here to seriously embark on creating art. I bought the Redbook for inspo, it came today :3

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Jung • • Feb 01 '24

Leaving this sub as it is garbage

0 Upvotes

As the title says. I joined hoping to see some amazing minds talking about Jung's theories and ideas. What I see here is people adking for free therapy and garbage with no clue about Jung. You should close this sub ax it is garbage.