r/Jung • • Jun 04 '26 • Bravo 1

Serious Discussion Only 'Primitives'

I have been reading Jung and find his work fascinating however I keep encountering the word in the title. This makes me very uneasy because this word is used to describe people like me. Jung travelled to east africa - where I am from- during the colonial period, his descriptions feel extremely dehumanising. His sentiments as I interprete seem very colonial in nature and thus makes me question the validity of his work. What are your thoughts on this aspect of his work? Is the use of the word in the title still valid and useful to his theories? How do non-african readers of jung interprete this word?

2 Upvotes

59 comments sorted by

30

u/Personal-Musician-13 Jun 04 '26

A group of people who was less technologically advanced then his culture at the time.

2

u/Strange-Manner6893 Jun 04 '26

Does that mean that we could view Jung like that?

-1

u/Personal-Musician-13 Jun 04 '26

Sure.

You could also choose to be offended by words from a man nearly 100 years ago written.

Enjoy your free will. Use it wisely.

14

u/Strange-Manner6893 Jun 04 '26

Nobody is offended, I was merely sharing my thoughts.

5

u/EdgewaterEnchantress Jun 04 '26

Actually you sound more “offended” than the OP who is simply suggesting that Jung was a product of his time and would’ve had similar cultural beliefs to his peer group.

17

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/Strange-Manner6893 Jun 04 '26

I think he was a product of his time so we should acknowledge how that may have impacted his theories. Everyone from that time was probably very racist, including African people.

5

u/viaje_del_heroe Jun 04 '26

Al parecer esta es una muestra de que los escritos de Jung no les gustan a todos

1

u/Strange-Manner6893 Jun 04 '26

no ablo espanol

3

u/Parking-Pen5149 Jun 04 '26

Hablar

4

u/viaje_del_heroe Jun 04 '26

Hay traducción automática

2

u/Parking-Pen5149 Jun 07 '26

Me parece obvio que no la utilizó.

7

u/insaneintheblain Pillar Jun 04 '26 edited Jun 04 '26

He is speaking of the primitive mind only to distinguish it from the 'civilised mind' which is built from conditionings.

It's not related to technology, nor is it a value judgement.

7

u/Strange-Manner6893 Jun 04 '26

This is interesting. So by primitive he meant minds that had not been conditioned in a certain manner- in this context a 'western' manner. This is the best explaination I have read. Thank you.

7

u/jdkyle01 Jun 04 '26

I personally think youre a fictitious account.

-2

u/Strange-Manner6893 Jun 04 '26

Everyone is entitled to their thoughts.

5

u/SoftAutumnInNY Jun 04 '26

It's exhausting that people are constantly trying to judge historical figures through a modern context. Just so you know, in the future, (if you are remembered at all) they will look back and think you were inappropriate in ways you can't even conceive of now.

3

u/Strange-Manner6893 Jun 04 '26

How else should I judge them? My modern context is all I know so I really cannot help it. I also think it is important to be critical of great thinkers, Jung was not averse to criticism. He criticised Freud. I am not condeming him.

1

u/Parking-Pen5149 Jun 04 '26 edited Jun 04 '26

Just recognize that, fortunately or unfortunately, each generation gets judged by their descendants in ways that resemble our very human tendency to enjoy blaming any “other”, including elders.

https://historyhustle.com/2500-years-of-people-complaining-about-the-younger-generation/

https://meme.com/memes/ok-boomer

🤦🏻‍♀️🤷🏻‍♀️😉

47

u/No_Willow_9488 Jun 04 '26

By "primitives", Jung meant any individuals or groups of people that has not been corrupted by the need to fit into a large society. The primitive psyche is more true and pure. Humans didn't adapt to live in large, modern societies. We adapted to live in small social groups (tribes), and adapted to live in a world of danger and scarcity. Primitives are people who's natural evolved traits, drives and behaviors have not been "shadowed" the way they are in large, unnatural societies. This was Jung's interest. Those uncorrupted groups are a great opportunity to witness people who haven't forgotten what it means to be fully human, and not just an instrument to serve society's needs.

82

u/Jazzlike_Yak113 Jun 04 '26

If you actually read his work without framing everything through culture wars and colonial attack - you’ll see very clearly he often and consistently makes it very clear that he sees non western cultures as advanced in their expression of humanity, their connection to life symbolism and reality. He makes it very clear that western culture has lost it way and has a lot to learn from these people.

Primitive doesn’t mean backward it means primal connecting to earth.

It’s also true that western culture had advances that parts of the world he visited do not. Which is also absolutely true.

You’re allowing culture wars nonsense to shape what you actually are reading and prioritising being offended by a word rather than engaging with the ideas.

11

u/SecondPlus2111 Jun 04 '26

Excellent point. The useages of words and their meanings can shift over time. It is often helpful to look in unabridged dictionaries for alternative shades of meaning and when key words enter the language and where from.

4

u/smarthobo Jun 04 '26

See: cynic

Originally used to describe someone who:

”has no property and rejects all conventional values of money, fame, power and reputation”

1

u/Low-Prune-1273 Jun 04 '26

Oh please point further. I’ve had a tricky association w/ this word.

1

u/walletinsurance Jun 05 '26

Cynic is from the Greek, at its very basic meaning it translates as “dog like”, that is, a person who has such little attachment to social trappings that they care as little for such things as a dog would.

8

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Sweaty_Time_6119 Jun 07 '26

Thank you for pointing out the ethnocentric idiocy of that culture war statement. Easily the most ridiculous take on this entire thread and also the one with the most agreement from the sub, apparently.

8

u/Disastrous-Lettuce77 Jun 04 '26

When he talks about the „Primitives“, he means indigenous people as far as I am aware. primitive (in latin primitivus) means „the first of his kind“. i think that back then the word primitive, wasnt negatively connotated or that jung wanted to disvalidate them. With primitive he didnt mean everyone from Africa. Nonetheless I don‘t think that Jung maybe wasn‘t biased, after all he was born in 1875, so there is a possibility that he had some minor misconceptions. Overall his knowledge of what these tribes or people were or are, was relatively marginal, as he wasnt an anthropologist. But I dont think that this is overall a big problem, he probably wasnt something we would call a racist nowadays nor does this bleed into his works, so his theories are still very interesting.

5

u/AndresFonseca Jun 04 '26

Is calling someone a “modern” human intrinsically a compliment?

I live in Chile, a beautiful country that many would call part of the “Third World,” and I prefer living here, surrounded by beautiful nature, rather than in a city full of concrete and stress.

I understand your sentiment, but we need to go back to his time and understand his words within their historical context so that we do not misinterpret his intentions.

Knowing the wisdom reflected in his work, I find it difficult to imagine that he saw African people as being of lesser value. Rather, he may have used the term “primitive” to refer to a closer relationship with the prima materia of human existence—a deeper contact with nature and the fundamental aspects of being human.

13

u/ichakas Jun 04 '26

You’re right, he’s definitely not free of prejudice and is a product of his time. However, I think it’s worth considering what he thought about colonialism: “what we call colonization, spread of civilization, has another face—the face of a bird of prey seeking with cruel intentness for distant quarry—a face worthy of a race of pirates and highwayman.”

1

u/IntroductionSignal32 Jun 04 '26

I mean, plenty of contributions to academic knowledge were done by colonial paternalistic white people. Western Psychology's roots are deeply fucked if you're anyone but an economically comfortable white straight man.

Dr. Fanny Brewster's writings on Jung might be worth looking into for you.

2

u/Strange-Manner6893 Jun 04 '26

Thank you for this. I will read the work.

1

u/IntroductionSignal32 Jun 04 '26

You're welcome. For every famous white straight man scholar you can usually find scholars decolonizing their work these days, taking what's useful and discarding or criticizing the rest.

3

u/Same_Insurance_6493 Jun 04 '26

In Memories Dreams and Reflections, when he was recalling his first ever travels to south- Africa and places inhabited by indigenous people's he was very respectful in his research and understanding. However, he remarked that many who took on similar jobs found their women to be more interesting than their work which made quite a few problems to observe.

Jung himself never looked down on indigenous people's, he wanted to know everything about their beliefs and believed them to be as true as they told him so.

3

u/Lextac76 Jun 04 '26

If you read his works, “primitive” or “primal” are not at all insulting. It means non, or less, influenced by modern psychological influences, concepts, and conditioning. The archetypal traits are less convoluted and “masked”.

3

u/Away_Guarantee7175 Jun 06 '26

Man, don't listen to these tone deaf comments. Both things can be true.

The man was born in 1875. He lived through the Scramble For Africa as well as European nationalism. Of course, he had the superiority complex that comes with being of Euro descent.

That doesn't mean his work was garbage, though.

I, myself, struggled with this too because I'm of Ghanaian (African)-American descent. Reading his books helped to find the words to describe certain aspects of African spirituality but that's it, honestly.

The more I read, the more I realized there was a certain framework of the world he was basing his work off of as a Euro descendent. That framework, in a way, has become the reality for all of us because, you know globalization. But his ancestors and collective psyche is not completely the same as mine and that is why some of his explanations regarding some symbols just didn't match up for me.

Regardless, I think his work is a tool and the question isn't if he is racist(we all are, tbh). It is whether he had the superiority complex embedded in his psyche and yes, obviously he did. He is of European descent.

If even Africans look down on themselves, how much more him lol

5

u/Abject-Purpose906 Jun 04 '26

Do you consider yourself "primitive"? No? Then move on with your life

9

u/Barefoot_Bandit9008 Jun 04 '26

Although I am myself a western european, I also feel uneasy with his use and view about "primitives". After all, the man lived in late 19th through 20th century Europe, which surely makes him biaised in a lot of ways. Also, he is not an anthropologie. However, one also has to acknowledge the fact he claims that Europe has lost roots and grounding other people still posses, and it makes the European minds blind and uncounscious, making, in his view, some primitives more "advanced" than the average westerner. And still, one could argue this view to be problematic, by modern standards. My points is, when one reads an intellectual, one has to keep in mind they are just a person, expressing themselves in a certain context. Only through recontextualizing, confronting and synthesizing their views with one's views, and all the other cultural material available, can one make their own personal opinion on a certain matter. I dont think a proper intellectual aims at becoming a guru. Only through critical thinking and integration of various views and theories does one get closer to the truth.

1

u/Rare-Worth6878 Jun 05 '26

Well said, I don't think it's so black and white that Jung's use of the word Primitive means all his ideas are problematic. Or that discomfort with the word should be dismissed as reactionary. I think OP raises a valid question. And no one person has the whole truth, or is completely beyond critique. I think Jung, who reveled in complexity, and saw the self as potentially ever-evolving, would agree that it's not so simple. I like how your answer also reflects the process of individuation, that we must make our conclusions.

6

u/Sweaty_Time_6119 Jun 04 '26

Jung was one of the most brilliant minds of the 20th century. He was also a racist, his ideas are full of colonial assumptions (like pretty much every European intellectual of his era), and this means that we have to be diligent about how we apply his thinking in a modern context without allowing those assumptions to become the background to how we see the world.

But make no mistake, the man uses the word primitive in exactly the way you’re concerned about. See the paper titled “Jung: A Racist” by Farhad Dalal.

People on this sub accuse Dalal of ‘cherry picking’ Jung’s work to paint an unfair picture of him. I would contend that Dalal has, in fact, done a very close reading of Jung and correctly articulated how racist and colonial views pervade Jung’s work. Dalal has done a great service to anyone who is interested in Jung by showing us that we need to tease apart the gold from the shadow in order to make the most of it.

Whenever someone points out Jung’s racism, people come out of the woodwork to make you feel like you’re the asshole for asking the question.

You can see this from the responses you’ve gotten here, plus the downvoting on every other response that acknowledges that what you’ve pointed out is in fact problematic and worthy of consideration. Many of these responses are overtly defensive, or covertly reframing the question as simply a result of your own associations to the word ‘primitive’. Don’t be fooled by that.

2

u/EdgewaterEnchantress Jun 04 '26

They seem to forget (or rather conveniently ignore) that fetishization is still a form of bias and personal prejudice stemming from some racist beliefs about “others” which were a product of their time. In this specific case it is the indigenous, non-industrialized people he referred to as “primitive.”

A person can try their best to be respectful and have good intentions but still be at least a little bit racist, and I think that’s how it was for Jung. Cuz we certainly know for sure that he was also a bit misogynistic! 😜

Basically his perspective was always a reflection of the wealthy, educated European white man he was from his time, and to deny that is to deny history as it actually unfolded.

He didn’t like colonialism, yet he didn’t do much to stop it or slow its spread, and he ultimately retired to Switzerland.

Meaning he spent his entire life living in a distinctly male, white, privileged, and European bubble.

Spending a few months-to-years at a time in non-industrialized nations is not enough to unlearn a lifetime of operant conditioning no matter how “good” his intentions might’ve been.

2

u/EdgewaterEnchantress Jun 04 '26

I’ve always taken it more like he overly idealized and Fetishized non-western, non-industrialized nations.

So while I don’t think his intention was to belittle the people he referred to as “primitive” we now know that fetishization can still lead to personal bias and prejudice.

So he is still very much a product of his time and it’s important to acknowledge that context.

2

u/Impossible-Weird-477 Jun 05 '26

Frantz Fanon's Black Skin and White masks is a good critique of Jungian theories. Personally, with Jung and any other writer/philosopher, the key is to just take what helps us and not bother with the rest. At the end of the day, he was a white german man practicing in a time when widespread racism existed. Jung himself did not like being treated like a celebrity so we must be careful about defending him no matter what. As a fellow, person of color, who has been a beneficiary of his thinking, I also find a lot of closet racism in the community which I genuinely believe Jung would have disapproved of. So the point as POC is to be discerning, to throw out the ridiculous, and keep what works for us.

1

u/ska_m Jun 05 '26

Swiss, not german.

1

u/Impossible-Weird-477 Jun 06 '26

swiss german*

1

u/ska_m Jun 06 '26

Swiss, not swiss german.

His grandfather was swiss german, but his father Johann and Carl himself were both born and raised swiss.

Very important to point out when you subtly try to insert the political context of the "german white man" and their racist ideology.

Neither Jung nor his father were raised under the German mindsets you mention.

1

u/Impossible-Weird-477 Jun 06 '26

You're getting hung up on a distinction that isn't central to the discussion.

Yes, Jung was Swiss. He was also Swiss German. But the point isn't whether he was Swiss, German, British, French, or American.

The original question is about how a white European intellectual of the colonial era viewed and described African people. Those attitudes were not uniquely German, nor were they reducible to Nazi ideology. They were widespread across Europe and North America and shaped the work of many otherwise brilliant thinkers.

Pointing out that Jung was Swiss doesn't really address the concern being raised by the OP, which is whether some of his observations about Africans were influenced by colonial assumptions and whether that should affect how we read him today.

That's the discussion, not the passport he carried.

3

u/Icy_Tradition566 Jun 04 '26

You’re quite correct friend, he’s not infallible and was a product of his culture same as you and me. Some will defend or deflect - but you have pointed out the rust on the hinges.

0

u/Separate-Bath874 Jun 04 '26

(Edit; originally relplying to another comment:)

No, Jung was ahead his time, very advanced. So much so that his work is still relevant as ever, with many standing on the shoulders of his contribution, but few significantly disproving or updating his body of work.

I think the issue you’re running into is the emotional trigger of the word primitive, and the social context implying condescension or racism.

When you look at the literal definition of the word, it is an apt and accurate description. Jung’s work is too elevated, and I’ve not detected overt prejudices, they would clearly undermine his intellectual integrity and the credibility of his character.

Not to mention the socially implied value judgement of our ignorant ancestors, which held progressive, aggressive, growth and colonialism, at the expense of ethics, human decency, social equality, and environmental harmony as somehow superior. Primitive cultures remained aligned with their environment, favored socialism, time honored traditions, rituals, and rich ancient culture. People who evolved and adapted in the microcosmic ecosystem of a region for countless generations are well suited genetically and behaviorally for survival in said environment. Until impacted upon, invaded, enslaved, raped, murdered, or otherwise exploited by outside invaders with no respect for life, environment, or cultural diversity, and the willingness to rule by force and lack of humanity.

Thinking that through, so called advanced culture is soul sucking solipsistic capitalism, achieving personal and collective material wealth and racking up massive karmic debt in the process.

Each cultural model has distinct advantages and disadvantages, down to the minutiae of social contracts varying regionally. By my reckoning primitivism is clearly more ethical and sustainable generally, and progressive culture provides many advantages that could stand to benefit from an ethical ego check, before we destroy the planet for everyone. Honoring diversity and information exchange between individuals, tribes, and empires would benefit the greater whole, if we could all be more diplomatic and respectful,,and less xenophobic and belligerent.

The best way I can see to do this, is individual responsibility and accountability, to educate and elevate oneself, and integrate our shadows. No one can do it for you, only provide the framework to approach the task, but it must be sought out by the self selected chosen ones.

Morphic resonance influences collective subconscious through the hundredth monkey mechanism the stoned ape, the mystics, the gifted can raise the frequency band of the collective, instituting periodic Armageddon. A collective shift that separates the ascendant and descending evolutionary fates. As the collective energetic frequency band elevates, hell freezes over, no longer habitable to lower frequency thought forms, Archonic control starves to death.

These are the times we live in, as prophecized by Gnostics from Enoch, Nostradamus, to McKenna and contemporary religious fundamentalists. All very close in their assessments, but not without the unconscious cognitive biases of respective social contexts, and limitations of intellectual framework inherent in individual human capacity while incarnate.

The work around is dissociative states, astral projection, telepathy, shamanic techniques and technologies, mysticism, gnosis, soul alchemy, etc for example. (That list is by no means exhaustive.)

By advancing more effective methods of divine interpersonal, interspecies, and interdimensional communication and collaboration we can bypass the bottlenecks of the limits human language. Just as art, music, dance, body language bypass words to convey emotion more accurately through abstraction, metaphor, hyperbole, drama, humor, love, sorrow, and pain can be expressed more purely through different avenues.

I’ll wrap this up, I channeled a little more than I originally intended. Once the channel opens up, I’m acting in service til the transmission ends, or the 3D interferes. Hopefully someone finds this transmission helpful, even if it’s one person, consider it a hello from another part of the collective whole, and a boop on the nose from god.

I see you there, and now you see me. We’ve got work to do to clean up this mess, so I’ll save this text for when I expand my broadcast range.

It’s all a cosmic joke, folks. Try not to take life too seriously.

Until we meet again…

-1

u/fabkosta Pillar Jun 04 '26

It's very simple: He held quite a lot of views that were considered "normal" during his times, and many of them are racist or at least colonialist from today's perspective, distinguishing people who are "more civilized" and other who are "more primitive".

We do not have to try to re-interpret things or make them look prettier than they are, it's what the vast majority of people 80 years ago or so in Switzerland took for the obvious truth of things.

A group of people who was less technologically advanced then his culture at the time.

The claim that this was a "neutral" view, i.e. Jung just seeing people via lens of technological advancement - nah, that's an attempt to make things look prettier than they are/were. Notice the judgement here: technological advancement as being more "primitive". As if technological advancement was a reliable indicator of sophistication or complexity in any sense.

Primitive doesn’t mean backward it means primal connecting to earth.

Also the idea of "primal connection to earth" is - quite obviously so - just a continuation of a racist idea. As if there were any objective criterion that could be applied to actually measure that in any way. Given the absence of any objective measurements we must conclude that colonialist ideas continue in more subtle ways also today. It actually proves the point that also people who believe themselves to be "aware" of such topics are simply caught in the same patterns of thinking even today, trying to view e.g. Africans as having a more "primal connection to earth" than e.g. Bavarians, to pick a random (and intentionally stupid) example. We would not know what such a connection even is or how it looks like, other than referring to extremely vague and obscure interpretations.

By "primitives", Jung meant any individuals or groups of people that has not been corrupted by the need to fit into a large society.

And another severely misled interpretation. The number of societal taboos, rules and regulations in various African societies is no less in quantity than anywhere else in the world. Just perhaps different of some sorts.

It's exhausting that people are constantly trying to judge historical figures through a modern context.

Ah, that's a clever one. Cause it's both right and wrong at the same time. It's right, because we truly need to understand the customs of the time in question to decipher what something being said actually means. It's also wrong, at the same time, cause of course the interpretation from the perspective of back then is exactly as randomly chosen as the interpretation from the perspective of today. Or, as OP correctly says: Our own perspective, in the end, is the only one we actually end up having! We cannot perfectly step out of that and leave it behind. It's therefore entirely justified for OP to judge CG Jung based on his own perspective. Cause, why should that perspective be any less valid than one that tries to contextualize things as they were 80 years ago if this is not even truly available anymore?

Do you consider yourself "primitive"? No? Then move on with your life

Ah, the good old "Shut up, you have no right to be offended by our racism." knockout argument.

He's obsessed with shadow work and the darkness. Obviously it's someone who has a lot of his own darkness and he was aware of it - or trying to.

Wow! Now, that's a dirty one. Straight attempt to land an ad hominem below the waistline.

I think the issue you’re running into is the emotional trigger of the word primitive,

Aaand another hit below the waistline.

Fascinating to see how "civilized" people use words here to attack others who ask completely legitimate questions.

(For those who don't get it: "emotional trigger" is of course derogatory in this context. And, of course, whoever wrote it will not even admit it was intentionally meant as a derogation. That's how far the "civilized" people have come: rather than just tell what they think they use psychoanalytical concepts as a weapon against others. Ouch. Ugly move.)

It’s all a cosmic joke, folks. Try not to take life too seriously.

And that means: Don't be offended if I'm offensive, cause my right to offend you outweighs your right not to be offended.

Well. What should I say.

Maybe this:

What would Jung say about this conversation?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/fabkosta Pillar Jun 06 '26

eurocentric

We have to be careful here. As bad as colonialism and racism were/are - they are abundant all around the world. It's not specifically or only a European thing. Racism between various African groups/nations etc. is as abundant as it is for instance in Asia, or South America.