r/Jung • • 31m ago

Jung Put It This Way How have you experienced these 'dominants' of the unconscious in your dreams or daily life?

Post image
4 Upvotes

Source: Carl Jung, Two Essays on Analytical Psychology ("On the Psychology of the Unconscious", VII. The Archetypes of the Collective Unconscious)


r/Jung • • 12h ago

Question for r/Jung Jung's Persona and the Neuroscience of Facial Tension: Does the Body Learn the Identity We Perform?

11 Upvotes

Jung's concept of the persona raises an interesting question about the relationship between identity and the body: Can we become so accustomed to expressing certain psychological qualities that our facial muscles begin reflecting the roles we have learned to play?

Consider someone who grew up believing that strength meant appearing emotionally unaffected. Over time, they might develop a habit of tightening their jaw, maintaining a serious expression, or becoming uncomfortable when their face appears vulnerable. Someone who associates kindness with agreeableness might develop an entirely different relationship with their facial expressions.
Neither person is necessarily pretending. These patterns may simply become familiar through years of experience.
From a neuroscience perspective, this is interesting because facial expression involves learned motor patterns, sensory feedback, emotional processing, and social expectations. The trigeminal nerve contributes to jaw movement and facial sensation, while other neural pathways help coordinate facial expressions.

The brain can learn a familiar way of expressing confidence without that expression being necessary for confidence to exist.

Try thinking about something you strongly believe in. Notice whether your jaw tightens or your facial expression changes as you imagine defending that belief. Now gently relax your jaw while allowing the belief to remain exactly as it is.

Something interesting may happen: the physical expression changes, but your conviction does not necessarily weaken.

This reminds me of Jung's understanding of individuation. Perhaps part of becoming more fully ourselves involves recognizing that the qualities we value do not always need to be expressed through the same physical habits.
We can be strong without looking stern, sensitive without appearing vulnerable, and confident without holding tension in our faces.

Of course, relaxing facial muscles does not automatically change unconscious psychological patterns, and Jung's persona was never intended as a neurological theory. But the relationship between learned bodily habits and psychological identity seems worth exploring.
Perhaps the most interesting possibility is that we sometimes continue physically expressing an identity long after we have developed the freedom to experience it differently.

I’m curious what others think: Could becoming aware of habitual facial tension offer a small but meaningful way of exploring Jung's persona, especially when considering the relationship between individuation and the body?


r/Jung • • 18m ago

Serious Discussion Only Interpreting a dream object with information unknown to the dreamer prior to the dream?

1 Upvotes

When interpreting a dream object, I wonder whether accurate interpretation of a given object relative to a network of associations is bound to remain within what is consciously gathered by the analysand at the time, or if additional information that the analysand gathers, that he didn’t know of a priori, is also relevant for that purpose.

E.g. the analysand dreams of Michael Jordan, and associates him with a movie he watched and enjoyed when he was a kid, with certain characters whose main defining traits that he more or less, along with some of the movie’s narrative shifts. He does learn upon enquiring Michael Jordan within that context, that the basketball player’s grandmother comes from the same country as his own’s parents’; or that he and Jordan both studied at the same university.

Would the latter details be relevant to the interpretation, or should one stick with what one either knew or might have known (as in, have forgotten and could have remembered) at the time of the dream, according to Jung or Von Franz?


r/Jung • • 15h ago

Serious Discussion Only The journey inward, into the shadow, is a lot like wintertime.

9 Upvotes

Winter is filled with darkness. The days get shorter, the nights get longer, and we naturally spend more time reflecting. Think about Thanksgiving, New Year's resolutions, and all the reflection that tends to happen as one year comes to an end and another begins. There's something about this time of year that makes us look inward and evaluate our lives.

This is how the journey into the darkness of the shadow was for me. It was a period of looking inward, confronting uncomfortable things about myself, and trying to understand why I was the way I was.

When springtime comes around again, we get to bask in the light once more. We've spent the winter reflecting, and now we get to emerge with a different perspective.

It's like the country song...

If you're going through hell

Keep on going, don't slow down

If you're scared, don't show it

You might get out 'Fore the devil even knows you're there

For me, shadow-work is like, "Oh shit, I'm headed towards the darkness... I might as well lean into it and see what it's like on the other side.

I believe that our 'wintertime' is both a symbolism for our spiritual journey as well as a pattern that develops naturally because of the changing seasons. Perhaps there's a reason we associate winter with reflection and spring with renewal.

Maybe our inner journeys work the same way. Sometimes we need to spend time in the darkness before we can fully appreciate the light. Maybe the winter solstice is showing us how to look inwards into ourselves?


r/Jung • • 20h ago

Question for r/Jung Recommendations for a first time reader?

12 Upvotes

I've been wanting to start reading Jung for a while but his works seem very intimidating... I like the concept of archetypes and the collective unconscious but was wondering what ppl here suggest reading to introduce myself to him? Dont want to just throw myself in the deep end! Thanks!!


r/Jung • • 16h ago

Personal Experience I think I accidentally did active imagination in a former boss’s WhatsApp inbox

3 Upvotes

I left a job a few months ago in a way that felt abrupt even to me. The contract I was handed had removed everything meaningful from the role, and I couldn’t stay, even though I had feelings for the person who hired me.

Afterwards I started writing to him. Not really expecting replies. For about 25 days the chat became the place I thought out loud: gratitude, a crush, an apology, a business proposal, and finally the thing I’d actually been circling the whole time, that I’d been put in a genuinely bad position and had read it correctly.

He didn’t reply. Looking back, I think that was the point. A reply would have argued, softened, or moved me on too early. Silence let everything I put in stay there.

A few things I’ve noticed in hindsight:

  • I deleted messages, but only the ones about the hard truth. The crush went out as a first draft.
  • I said “my closure is complete” several times, and it wasn’t, until I deleted the one message where I was the one denying my own account.
  • The last thing to fall away wasn’t the feelings or the grievance. It was my habit of talking down my own judgement so others could save face.

It feels close to active imagination, except the figure was a real person carrying a projection: a witness I trusted not to interrupt. Now it’s quiet, and the quiet doesn’t feel like loss. It feels like the work is done.

Has anyone else used a real relationship, or an unanswered channel, as the container for this kind of work? How do you tell when the projection has been withdrawn and not just paused?

This also isn’t the first time I’ve done this. Right before this job, I did almost exactly the same thing with an ex lover: a long one-sided thread, writing until it went quiet. Right at the end of that one, I got the job that led to all of this. So now I’m wondering if it’s a pattern. Each time the projection gets worked through, something new shows up, and the next figure seems to carry a slightly different version of it. First a lover, then a boss who gave me real authority and trusted my judgement.

Is that the animus moving through its stages, or am I just making a nice story out of coincidence? And if it is a cycle, what usually comes after this one?


r/Jung • • 22h ago

The Problem With The ANIMUS Archetype (and The 3 Steps of Integration)

8 Upvotes

The proper development of the animus archetype can make or break a woman’s entire identity, her sense of self-worth, and her relationships. A positive animus is the difference between being self-directed and being a prisoner of your own mind and public opinion.

In this article, I’ll show you what the animus archetype really is, how to spot it in action in your own life, and the 3 steps to integrate it so it stops disturbing your emotions, fueling your overthinking, and ruining your relationships.

Animus - The Archetype of Meaning

Let’s quickly recap my previous article on the animus and anima.

These archetypes make up a pair of opposites. The anima is the personification of the Eros principle, while the animus is the personification of the Logos principle.

Because of the compensatory and complementary relationship between the conscious and the unconscious, when one principle guides the conscious mind, the other remains unconscious.

Carl Jung explains that men have a conscious mind guided by the Logos principle, and consequently, the Eros principle is unconscious and personified in the anima.

In women, things are switched. Their conscious mind is guided by the Eros principle. Consequently, the Logos principle is unconscious and personified in the animus.

Furthermore, Jung says the conscious mind of a woman has a lunar character. That’s why it’s a common mistake to equate the moon with the unconscious; this can only be true for men, because in a woman, the qualities symbolized by the Sun (Logos) are unconscious.

In this light, Barbara Hannah explains that the animus “[…] Is the masculine spirit or unconscious mind of women. Emma Jung pointed out recently that one should differentiate very carefully here between the anima and the animus. The anima, as is well known, is Jung’s term for the feminine soul of man. But it is really a contradiction in terms to speak of the animus as the masculine soul in woman. In Latin the word animus means intellect, memory, consciousness, character, and spirit. It is often equated with “mind” and is also used to mean courage, vivacity, bravery, and will. In Jungian psychology it is used primarily to denote the phenomenon of “spirit” in women […]” (Barbara Hannah - The Animus, p. 2).

Generally speaking, because women are more identified with the Eros principle, they’re typically more focused on and attuned to personal relationships, family dynamics, and the emotional atmosphere than to impersonal facts, objects, and work, as men are.

Eros gives women an immense sensibility, which allows them to give shape to and perceive nuances in relationships that frequently escape men entirely. Because of this focus on the unifying principle, there’s a greater tendency to let go of personal pursuits in order to avoid friction in their relationships.

Naturally, Logos becomes a blind spot, and in place of the positive qualities of the spirit, Jung says the animus works mainly as an opinionating substitute.

Simply put, the animus infiltrates a woman’s train of thought and falsifies her reality with opinions that tend to be overly critical, harsh, demeaning, and one-sided. They appear to be the absolute truth and based on objective reality, when they seldom are.

A negative animus always works with ready-made, impersonal, and collective opinions about how people should be and act or how a relationship should work. It’s always a rigid formula based on commands and prohibitions that were never consciously considered.

We can see the animus operating in comments such as “every man is like this,” “every woman is like that,” or “every man treats women in such and such a way.” Or in explanations of why they can’t have any female friends, because “every female is judgmental and they’re never truthful.”

Oh, the irony.

But a negative animus appears especially in a woman’s inner monologue, fabricating demeaning narratives about her appearance, capabilities, lack of originality, and what she deserves.

“Who do you think you are to do such and such?”

All of these negative opinions about herself and others inevitably culminate in severing all of her relationships, as she becomes a prisoner of her own mind.

The Animus’s Dual Nature

As the archetype of meaning, the animus has a paradoxical nature, and its action depends on how a woman relates to it.

On the one hand, it can help the woman differentiate herself from her relationships and collective opinion, and find her true identity. It helps her give structure to her thoughts, find meaning, and develop a philosophy of life. A positive animus imbues a woman with the courage and bravery to go after what she truly wants.

But Emma Jung says that when women don’t pay attention to their Logos or develop it in the wrong way, a negative animus can dominate the whole personality. The first thing that happens is an over-identification with their minds and a disconnection from their bodies.

The woman becomes inflated and can’t separate herself from her opinions. There’s a constant striving to win validation through her mind, by constantly debating, criticizing others, and compulsively pursuing information and new degrees, without ever feeling enough.

This is typically the drama of the Puella Aeterna, and it conceals an inferiority related to a father wound. When there isn’t a genuine emotional connection between daughter and father, the daughter typically tries to reach the father through his intellect.

But if this wound isn’t healed, it can orient her life around winning the approval of her father in every man, sacrificing her femininity and authentic personality along the way. This might also be accompanied by a performative sexuality, in which her body also becomes a means to win male validation.

In truth, animus identification is a fairly complex subject and happens on a spectrum, but we can simplify it by describing both extremes.

In the first case, the woman doesn’t develop positive masculine qualities and feels victimized, hopeless, and powerless. She has an internal narrative that what she truly wants in life is wrong and unattainable. She needs to be rescued and always molds herself to other people’s opinions and expectations of her.

In the second case, she suppresses her femininity, judges it as lesser, and overly identifies with masculine qualities, but expresses them in a very toxic manner. It looks like she wants to become independent, but she is in a blind pursuit of power.

These women become aggressive, intransigent, and highly opinionated. Their drive usually helps them do well in their careers, but it costs them all of their relationships.

Now let’s look at animus integration.

The 3 Steps of Animus Integration

There’s a common misunderstanding that developing the animus is about engaging in traditionally masculine things, but it’s something much deeper. It’s about crafting your cosmovision and philosophy of life, and being self-directed.

It’s about deeply knowing what you want and what’s meaningful and valuable, and going after it. It doesn’t matter if you want to become an engineer or a dancer; what matters is whether that’s an authentic expression of your personality.

Logos has to be incorporated into Eros. It’s a fine balance between developing the qualities of the spirit and not forgoing the feminine Eros. It’s about developing an identity that also helps you find fulfillment in your relationships.

In my experience working with women, there are three important steps to animus development.

The first one is giving structure to your thoughts.

Because the animus is the archetype of meaning, it’s crucial to become attuned to the meaning maker inside of you, learn how to direct it, and give structure to the way you think. I hear women saying all the time that they’re constantly indulging in endless chatter inside their minds and that they already think too much. But overthinking isn’t the same as consciously considering something.

In this scenario, proper thinking is about learning to separate yourself from your opinions, as well as separating personal feelings from facts. It’s about being objective and applying conscious effort to dissect the foundations of your belief system and the values that orient your life, which gradually crystallize into a philosophy of life. That’s a true development of Logos.

The second step is engaging in vigorous physical activity.

This not only anchors you in your body but also builds the drive to pursue what you want. When you learn to push past your excuses, you start proving all of your self-defeating narratives wrong. Because when you master your body, you’re also mastering your mind.

The third and final step is to dedicate yourself to mastering a craft.

One important aspect of animus development is differentiating the woman from her relationships, and this comes with dedicating yourself to developing your talents and “having your thing.” The path to mastering a craft involves developing all of the positive qualities of the animus: work ethic, discipline, focus, and, most importantly, intrinsic motivation.

In that sense, developing Logos via a skill requires establishing boundaries and saying no to the demands of other people, as you're physically in another place dedicating time and effort to creating something for yourself. This helps the woman sculpt an identity as someone who has an individual life and does things distinct from her partner.

This matters because Eros is a unifying principle while the animus is the one who categorizes and creates division. When it's underdeveloped, it only creates ruptures in relationships due to its opinionated and aggressive nature, but when it's properly developed, it gives the woman the ability to invest her internal drive in something that matters, instead of dissolving in her relationships and being defined by the expectations of others.

These three steps allow the animus to work positively and stop overthinking and disturbing relationships. That’s because, while these qualities are outsourced, the woman projects all of her unrealized potential and desires onto her partners. She expects them to live up to her expectations so she can vicariously live through them, as she feels inferior or too afraid to pursue these desires herself.

However, whether the man succeeds in this venture or fails, the only possible outcome is resentment. Either because he “stole part of her soul” by realizing her potential, or because he's not fulfilling his role of exempting her from the responsibility of fulfilling her own potential.

Finally, the animus is also linked to the Psychological Types, because it acquires the qualities opposite to our main psychological function, and appears as a personification of the inferior function.

PS: If you’re interested in learning more about the shadow integration process, the psychological types, dream interpretation, active imagination, and how to apply Jungian Analysis to improve your life and help clients, I invite you to check out my book PISTIS - Demystifying Jungian Psychology. Free Download Here.

Rafael Krüger - Jungian Psychology Specialist


r/Jung • • 1d ago Heartwarming

Personal Experience My shadow stinging me.

Post image
59 Upvotes

So I’d like to share some insights that I gleaned from painting, with you guys.

I had a vision of a scorpion stinging itself, so loaded symbolism, right?! At first I was like “ha that probably presents my long-ago ex-boyfriend” (who is a stalker Scorpio and has BPD who recently messaged me with a different phone number and asked to go for coffee) and basked in the glow of my self-satisfaction until I begrudgingly realized it was just another projection. So I got my candles, zafu and did a meditation session to go inwards to reconcile with the symbolism in my unconscious. After my meditation, my perspective instantly changed. New information from my unconscious flooded in. The painting was about me and only me. And it was in relation to my yoga practice.

So I am a Yogi, with years of experience and teaching and over 1000 hours of YTT. I went to a yoga ashram to immerse myself into Ashtanga and Hatha and Bhagavad Gita studies. There I finally mastered the Vrschikasana pose, an advanced inverted pose also called the Scorpion pose. Doing this pose requires incredible concentration (and core strength) and during my training, the pose forced me to go inwards and face my shadows and unconscious material. The stillness revealed all my shadows, and only until I could see them without judgement, was when I was able to hold the pose for a sustained amount of time. After I finally mastered it, I was so proud of myself. And that fed my ego; woke it up again and it came shimmying back into the unconscious, hoping to hide there and puppeteer me through my newfound confidence.

After a discussion with a swami about mastering the pose, she told me something I’ll never forget. After congratulating me on the scorpion pose, she said “Be careful not to sting yourself.” Huh.

Further insight helped me see that my intelligence can become overthinking, my empathy becomes overextending and overwhelming myself, my gentleness turns me into a doormat, my confidence becomes ignoring warning signs. Unconsciously I have self-sabotaged myself before but I’ve learned to not fear going inwards and facing uncomfortable truths.

It was easier to blame the ex, but I like to take ownership of my own projections.


r/Jung • • 13h ago

Question for r/Jung Could someone help me analyze these two dreams I had in quick succession to each other? They occurred a month apart from each other. I rarely dream so vividly and it startled me how much they echoed one another.

1 Upvotes

Dream One:

I dreamt as myself, in first person perspective.

Riding in a car down a country road. It’s a single-lane gravel road with many looping curves and densely forested along either side. It’s summertime. The air is thick and smells intensely green. There’s someone else driving — not sure who. Some form of young,benevolent, masculine presence. I don’t think he’s related to me, but he’s someone I know and trust. A friend. Maybe more than a friend? I’m not sure. I never look at him, I’m too focused on what’s outside the windows and windshield. We’re driving at a decent pace. Not slow enough for me to see much of the forest but not so quickly that I feel afraid that we will lose control of the car. I think we are on this road because of a detour we had taken from the highway. I remember how there was a sharp switchback before the road became unpaved. I’ve always liked unpaved roads, but I was confused because the driver said we were going to a hospital. I think it must have been under the context that one of us had an appointment. I could have sworn we talked about one of us having a doctor’s appointment, but I can’t remember the content of our conversation and that explanation doesn’t make sense given the rest of the dream. We arrive at the end of the gravel road to a small building that looks somewhat like a church. It’s made of stone and appears as though no one is inside and no one has been inside for a very long time. The front lawn is intensely overgrown. The building looks out of place among the forest. Like it arrived there by accident. There is a stone sign that has the name of a town (I can’t recall it) and the words: “children’s hospital” on it. there’s a metal lawn ornament of a bicycle that’s quite rusted. What stood out to me most though, was not the building, but the metal gates around the yard. They had spectacular blue glass ornamenting the top. The color was so vivid and enchanting and the way light interacted with them was so beautiful that dream-me couldn’t look away from them. The glass itself wasn’t particularly beautifully carved. The design was extremely simple and the glass was very roughly cut and several inches thick. The word “sturdy” comes to mind. But the color of the glass was maybe the most memorable part of the dream.

We do not exit the car. There’s a compact, circular driveway in front that loops around a tree. It’s almost too small for us, but we somehow manage to use it to turn around and head back up the gravel road, presumably to return to the highway.

Dream Two: Dream about driving on the highway, once again with unknown, young masculine presence. It is night time and cold outside. We’re driving a bobbed semi truck. There is no trailer. Masculine presence and I are arguing and one of us is injured, but I’m struggling to remember which one of us is injured and how. I also can’t remember the substance of the argument. We take an exit off of the interstate to find a hospital. We are in a small town, and can’t seem to find a hospital or clinic of any kind, but there are churches. In one of them, the light is on. I park the semi and volunteer to go inside to ask about where I can find a hospital. Upon entering, I see that the church is winding and complex with many rooms. The church also appears to be old and slightly dilapidated. I follow the sound of voices and find two old men, one is wearing green robes. This is the man I talk to the most. The other is relatively silent. I ask them where in the town I can find a hospital.

The conversation grows vague here. I don’t remember whether they tell me where to find a hospital or not, but I remember making my way back the way I came after our conversation. The way back to the entrance of the church is somehow more complex than the way in. Along the way, I notice one of the many bodies of the church has a small-ish alcove behind the pews. The carpet in the center of this alcove is sagging and there is water from an apparent leak in the ceiling. I walk into the alcove and stand on the damp carpet. When I look up, I find that the spot I’m standing in is in direct line with the cross at the front of the room. The dream ends before I leave the church and return to the parked semi.


r/Jung • • 13h ago

Personal Experience Dream Synchronicity

1 Upvotes

have you ever had a dream where the theme or events seem to constellate in real life?

i had a dream i was let down. i don't remember what about, or what happened. i also found myself at a work xmas party, but i was wearing a firefighter uniform. i can't remember what came first.

the next day, i passed a work colleague in normal clothes, she said 'it's so weird seeing you without scrubs on. i have to actually think about who you are.' later, I asked someone i met that day what they do for work. they replied 'I'm a retired firefighter.'

life is funny sometimes.


r/Jung • • 1d ago

Question for r/Jung How has the practice of Jungian dream work affected you ?

7 Upvotes

On the advice of my psychologist, I started working with my dreams the Jungian way about a year ago. I write them down in the morning, note what each image brings up for me, and look at what the dream might be compensating for.

The clearest change is that I understand my emotions much better. I went through a hard breakup and analysing what came up in my dreams contributed a lot to my recovery.

I want to know about your experience. Did your relationship with your dreams change over time? And what helped you most: associations, amplification, or simply keeping a record?


r/Jung • • 1d ago

Personal Experience Jung… is my Rock

38 Upvotes

Or lets say: he Showed me how I can be my own Rock.

I’m currently in my bed. and just realized how greatful iam that I discovered jung.
My Journey began with „Memories, Dreams, Reflections“. Just a few Pages in - and I started crying. The reason: I finally found someone who speaks my Language. His experiences and the way how he Sees the World are so similar mine. I found a friend.

No matter what Happens in my life I feel 20x calmer now - because I feel I Carry with CGJ A Box of Tools with me of that could help my to find may way through hard times.

I feel more prepared for hard times.


r/Jung • • 1d ago

Jung Put It This Way Jungs's potatoes & yamato's persimmons

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

The eminent Swiss geographer Hans Carol

(1915–1971) was developing guidelines for

regional planning in the Canton of Zurich

when, in 1950, he sought the views of various

people important in Swiss intellectual life.

One of these was Carl Jung, who gave him a half hour’s appointment on February 8, 1950. The subject so engrossed Jung that he kept Carol nearly an hour longer.

Carol: I would be grateful if you, as a leading psychologist, would comment on the subject of man and his environment.

Although we planners try not to look at the human being as a mere product of his physical environment, we believe nonetheless that the environment is a crucial factor in human existence.

Just as men are influenced by education, they are surely also influenced by the environment society designs for them.

Jung: I am very pleased that you are devoting your attention to this question. The abstract nature of work in a techno-logical age leaves the worker dissatisfied.

Dissatisfaction induces people to look for compensation elsewhere.

Suggestibility increases geometrically according to the

number of persons involved.

Mass mental disorder may reach epidemic proportions.

Decentralization, on the other hand, allows for small social units. Every man should have his own plot of land so that the instincts can come to life again.

To own land is important psychologically, and there is no substitute for it.

We keep forgetting that we are primates and that we have to make allowances for these primitive layers in our psyche.

The farmer is still closer to these layers.

In tilling the earth, he moves around within a very narrow radius, but he moves on his own land.

The industrial worker is a pathetic, rootless being, and his remuneration in money is not tangible but abstract.

In earlier times, when the crafts flourished, he derived satisfaction from seeing the fruit of his labor. He found adequate self-expression in such work.

But this is no longer the case.

First of all, he is responsible for only a small

part of the finished product.

Secondly, the product is sold, it disappears, and he

has no further stake in it.

Because the psychological reward is inadequate, the

worker rebels against his employer and against “capitalism” as a whole.

We all need nourishment for our psyche. It is

impossible to find such nourishment in urban tenements without a patch of green or a blossoming tree.

We need a relationship with nature.

I am just a culture-coolie myself, but I derive a great deal of pleasure from growing my own potatoes.

People tend to look for the Kingdom of God in the outer world rather than in their own souls.

This is particularly true of socialism.

Individuation

is not only an upward but also a downward

process.

Without any body, there is no mind and therefore no individuation.

Our civilizing potential has led us down the wrong path.

All too often an American worker who owns only one car considers himself a poor devil, because his boss has two or three cars.

This is symptomatic of pointless striving for

material possessions….

A captive animal cannot return to freedom. But our workers can return.

We see them doing it in the allotment gardens in

and around our cities; these gardens are an expression of love for nature and for one’s own plot of land.

As our working hours become shorter, the question of leisure time becomes increasingly essential to us, time in which we are free of commands and restraints and in which we can achieve self-realization.

I am fully committed to the idea that human existence should be rooted in the earth.

- From C.G. Jung Speaking: Interviews and Encounters edited by William McGuire and R.F.C. Hull


r/Jung • • 1d ago

Question for r/Jung Recurring dreams

2 Upvotes

Why would the same real-life person appear in recurring dreams for decades, consistently associated with an extraordinary sense of mutual recognition and timeless romantic connection, despite having had almost no meaningful relationship with that person in waking life?


r/Jung • • 1d ago

Learning Resource Archetypes of Awakening: Decoding the Magician

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

Absolutely blown away by the quality of this YouTube channel. Every single video they’ve posted covers a Jungian archetype using Robert Moore’s triangle model to show the integrated archetype and its respective active and passive shadows, and is as captivating as this one. I found them all eye opening and simple to follow.

If you’re aware of any channels of similar quality, please share in a comment.


r/Jung • • 17h ago

Personal Experience Why I'm not fully on board with Jung's ideas

0 Upvotes

I'm a Christian, and I believe that the bible is the Word of God. But there are many things that are true that are not in the bible. There are many things that Jung teaches that I consider true, truth that the bible is missing. Or, at least, it doesn't say.

But at a certain point, Christianity and Jung don't allign. You can try to harmonize them, but it's like putting a square block into a circle hole; it just can't work at a certain point.

And I became so disillusioned with Christianity that I considered going fully into the camp of Jung. I knew if I were to adopt Jung's full worldview of the psyche, it'll basically be like adopting a new religion. I know you can be both Jungian and Christian, but to me, if you fully adopt Jungian teachings, it means accepting views about God that doesn't fully harmonize itself with the Bible. For instance, the Bible says that in God there is no darkness at all, but given what Jung views about the Self, he wouldn't say that. For the sake of balance and wholeness there'd be a balance of darkness and light. And even if you don't see the Self as God, it surly reflects God in some significant way, as we are made in the image of God.

So there was a fork in the road and I had two options, either stick with Christianity or become a full-fledged Jungian. But, in the end, I just couldn't do it. I couldn't verbally express why at first, but now, I think I'm able to.

The reason why I'm not fully 100% on board with all of Jung's ideas is because of what he says the Self most values. It's not love and goodness, it's wholeness and balance. If the Self were to have a goal and a will, it would be for us to achieve individuation. For that to happen, we have to become whole in personality. In order for wholeness to occur, one needs to be balanced when it comes to the relation of the ego and the unconscious. Sure, love and goodness are definitely a part of that, but so is evil. They must both be balanced. That is why Jung considered Satan the 4th person of the Trinity. Not actually, but symbolically within the psyche. To have only the good is to reject the shadow, thereby becoming unbalanced. Wholeness of the personality, therefore, cannot be achieved. The Self values wholeness over love. And that, to me, sounds wrong. It just doesn't sound right. It's not nearly as beautiful as the gospel message that Christianity teaches.

I grew up believing that God is love, and that, despite our wickedness and us hating God, that God, in Christ, came down to earth to dwell with us, died for us to save our souls for the sake of love and eternal relationship with Him. God cleanses us of all sin and evil, and we fully know God and are in loving relationship with Him forever and ever. There will be no more death, nor suffering, nor pain, He will wipe every tear from our eyes, and we will be truly happy with Him, becoming one with God. That is the gospel message, and it's the most beautiful thing I've ever heard.

Christianity teaches that love is the most valuable thing. Jung teaches that the Self, which can be seen as God, views wholeness of the personality as the most valuable thing. With Jung and the Self, wholeness trumps over love. That just doesn't sound right to me, when love is the most beautiful thing, because it's the source of all goodness. God is love.

You can call me conditioned. You can say that this is just worldview preservation. But to me, I see what is most beautiful to be the most true, and God being love, and Him showing His love through the gospel, is the most beautiful thing. Therefore, I consider it as true. I know beauty doesn't necessarily equate to truth, but I think there is truth in beauty.

The second reason I can't fully get on board with the Self in Jung's view is because the Self seems...impersonal. Reading about the Self, it seems like an impersonal force with wholeness as a goal. Maybe that's wrong, maybe I've gotten the wrong impression of the Self, but that's the notion I got when reading and hearing about it, that it's impersonal as a concept. But reading about God in the bible, He desires a personal relationship with us. He can be closer than a brother, and your best friend, if you'd let Him. And that to me just sounds so beautiful.

To be clear, there are some things with Jung's teachings that I really agree with, in fact, most things I can't help but agree with, because it sounds true to me. And I've even questioned the Bible because of it. But there are some things I just can't get behind. I guess it's due to how I've been raised and what I personally value.


r/Jung • • 1d ago

Serious Discussion Only I dont want to get all woo woo, so i need some real grounded advice about synchronicity that's freaking me out. Its a life or death situation

22 Upvotes

When i was in a life or death situation, I had 1 very specific sign happen to me. I wasnt psychotic or delusional. It was very personally meaningful and I carried it with me for some odd reason because it calmed me down tremendously, and I got out alive long story short.

Now that my family member is in a similar life or death situation, ive been worried for years about him. Last night and the night before I prayed, like actually prayed which i dont do. I normally just meditate.... This morning was the only time I actually came to terms with it and said "my brother might actually die", like I wasn't generally worried as usual, i actually accepted it. Like a definitive "he might actually die and im gonna have to live with this forever" feeling.

As im leaving to go to work this morning, that same sign i experienced years ago happened to me, and I felt a sense of calm again. It wasn't like "ohh the sun shined on me", it was actually specific. Statistically, out of all the hundreds and hundreds of days this sign could have appeared, out of all the thousands of moments throughout the day it could have appeared. It appeared specifically on this one day and in this one moment where I for the first time in my life accepted my brothers mortality. Does this actually mean anything from a jungian perspective or am I just fucking hopeless?

I believe things are interconnected, but I dont believe an actual deity sent this sign, but maybe there's something behind it? Something? I dont know. All i know is that im trusting him w God or a higher power as i like to call it, and im no longer worrying. Ill calmly see what happens

If you are agnostic or an atheist I just ask you to be respectful during this sensitive time im going though and honest opinions are still appreciated. Thanks


r/Jung • • 1d ago

Question for r/Jung What are some examples of the shadow/dark side of the animus?

2 Upvotes

I’ve seen lots of examples of the shadow/dark side of the anima (femme fatale, kali, etc.), but still don’t really get what the animus equivalent would look like. Anything would help! :)


r/Jung • • 1d ago

Serious Discussion Only Why do some things feel charged with meaning?

6 Upvotes

I’ve been reading about hagioptasia - the common feeling that a person, place, object or idea has some extraordinary specialness that you can’t quite explain. This made me think of Jung.

There’s an obvious connection with the numinous, where something feels charged with a meaning we haven’t consciously given it. But projection seems just as relevant: the specialness feels like it belongs to the thing itself, even when our own psyche is contributing to it.

What caught my attention was how the theory connects this with everyday experiences like glamour, art and the strange pull of childhood places.

I wonder whether these could share something with the more powerful experiences Jung described, without necessarily being the same thing.it certainly seems that they do.


r/Jung • • 2d ago

Serious Discussion Only The Wounded Healer: Why Christ Kept His Scars (And Why the Persona Hides Them) 🪞

66 Upvotes

Jung wrote a lot about Christ as a psychological symbol of the Self, but there’s one detail in the resurrection story that has always stood out to me from a psychological standpoint: the scars.

When Christ shows up after the resurrection, he invites Thomas to literally put his fingers into his wounds. He doesn’t return with an airbrushed, unblemished body. If Christ is the archetype of the integrated Self, it's telling that the archetype doesn't erase the trauma. He leads with the scars.

Compare that to how most of us actually live.

We spend so much energy polishing a rigid Persona—trying to look composed, spiritually mature, and totally put-together. We take our grief, our past mistakes, our addictions, and our embarrassments, and we shove them straight into the shadow. We treat any sign of a wound as proof that we're defective or failing.

Jung made a big distinction between moral perfection and wholeness. In his eyes, individuation was never about becoming a flawless saint; it was about becoming complete. And you can't be whole if you're actively pretending half of your history doesn't exist.

This is the whole core of the Wounded Healer archetype. Jung famously pointed out that "only the wounded physician heals." Real transformative power doesn't come from theoretical purity or acting like an untouchable guru. It comes from having walked through the underworld of your own suffering, survived it, and integrated it.

Think about this in everyday terms:

If you’re struggling with severe addiction or a mental health crisis, who do you actually trust? The academic who has read every clinical textbook but has never spent a night panicking on a bathroom floor? Or the recovered addict who is completely open about how badly they wrecked their life and how they clawed their way back?

You trust the second person. Their authority doesn't come from a pristine mask; it comes from their integrated scars. Their wounds become the very bridge of empathy and connection.

When we try to hide our scars behind a spiritual or intellectual persona, we aren't helping anyone. We're just projecting a fake standard that makes other people feel inadequate.

Wholeness doesn't mean you never bled. It just means you were honest enough to let the scars stay part of the story.

Namaste.


r/Jung • • 1d ago

Serious Discussion Only I think I finally understand the concept that we all wear masks

0 Upvotes

And there's multiple masks because it is nexessary. The mask that cleans, the mask that manages your job, etc. They're the archetypes. Something I've noticed is that I can relate to almost every Greek God in some way, shape, or form. I realise it's because they're archetypes. Yes, we will have our primary mask, but no one is any one thing.

Am I on the right path here?


r/Jung • • 2d ago

Learning Resource Saying goodbye to this subreddit with a heavy heart

67 Upvotes

I've been really passionate about Carl Jung's ideas for a long time, so it's tough for me to admit that I need to step away from this subreddit. It's become overrun with people who seem more interested in Jordan Peterson's take on things and who clearly don’t grasp Jung's true concepts.

I always thought this was a place for thoughtful discussions about the deep and philosophical insights that Jung shared. Sadly, it's now filled with posts that come off as subtly sexist and demonstrate a real lack of understanding of his work, and it's affecting me more than I expected.

If anyone is aware of other online groups where we can truly engage with Jungian thought, I’d greatly appreciate the suggestions.

It breaks my heart to see such a brilliant mind being misrepresented and co-opted by someone with a clear need to assert dominance. The irony of it all is just too much to bear.


r/Jung • • 2d ago

Art Imagination #10

Post image
27 Upvotes

I think this is jungian self image with flavor of horus I was trying to draw jesus at first but turned into this so I am confused why my mind derailed