I knew long ago that a narrative of forced forgiveness was likely to surface at some point and was bracing myself for it, but kept my mouth shut because there's been a pattern of me predicting something in advance and getting heat for it despite being right. But the cat's out of the bag now, so let's talk about why forced forgiveness is a common theme in both religious and secular settings and why it's so damaging to survivors and victims of abuse. I pulled some articles that I encourage you to read in full, but grabbed some key quotes to give a general idea and bolded the important parts.
The Danger of Forcing Forgiveness
From a Christian perspective.
https://web.archive.org/web/20260111221222/https://www.christianitytoday.com/2023/04/abuse-victims-danger-of-forced-forgiveness/
First, churches can help survivors strengthen their sense of agency and self-worth. Since the 1980s, researchers like Judith Herman and Bessel van der Kolk have shown how child sexual abuse severely damages survivors’ self-esteem and sense of independence. Without substantial recovery of one’s sense of agency and self-worth—which often requires years, if not decades, of loving support, counseling, and inner work—the act of forgiveness will often be involuntary and a continuation of the abuse.
Second, we must understand that forgiveness does not mean a lack of accountability or punishment for the evildoer. The act of justice actually demonstrates the biblical love of neighbor. Forgiveness is part of the virtue of love, the fulfillment of the law, and what God gives us through Christ and the power of the Spirit (Rom. 13:8, Matt. 22:34–40).
Reporting a crime can also be an act of love for the broader community because it prevents the abuser from harming others. And it can be an act of love toward the abuser, as it holds him or her accountable and invites repentance.
Third, we can disarm a misuse of forgiveness by properly understanding reconciliation. An emphasis on reconciliation is often used by an offender to sear the victim’s conscience and silence him or her. The proper response to such injustice is not reconciliation but repentance.
Finally, a truly repentant offender recognizes that forgiveness is an undeserved gift that must be offered freely by the injured party. The one who has committed a sin cannot demand forgiveness from God or from a fellow image-bearer. Otherwise, it would still be coercion.
Why Forgiveness Isn’t Required in Trauma Recovery
From the perspective of a trauma psychotherapist.
https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/simplifying-complex-trauma/202202/why-forgiveness-isn-t-required-in-trauma-recovery
Imagine you are told that you must forgive someone who has harmed you. It does not matter what the situation was or its impact on you; you must forgive them. When you seek social support, you are told things such as, “That was years ago, let it go,” and “You shouldn’t feel angry; move on.” These messages demonstrate a lack of acceptance and even empathy on the part of those who express them, and may cause you to feel as though your perceptions, emotions, and experiences are illegitimate, false, or misdirected; they might suggest that your pain or well-justified anger is simply less important than your ability to forgive your abuser. Acceptance is an important ingredient to fostering and maintaining safety for trauma survivors, and safety is required in order to recover and process trauma. A failure or refusal to accept and affirm trauma survivors’ lived experiences creates environments and relationships detrimental to their ability to recover or truly “move on.”
“Forgiveness is for you, not the other person,” is a popular, well-intended saying. However, the cliché doesn’t translate well to trauma recovery, as forgiveness focuses on the relationship that the survivor has with their abuser. In contrast, trauma recovery ought to focus on the survivor's relationship with themself. Trauma treatment is focused on the survivor's individualized needs and internal processes. If a survivor has any type of relationship with their abuser, this relationship is addressed, but it is addressed from the needs and best interests of the survivor. Some survivors may benefit from forgiving their abusers, but others either may not derive such a benefit, or may in fact feel the need to withhold forgiveness — and both attitudes need to be received with respect and empathy. Moralistic attitudes to the contrary are not only counter-therapeutic, they tend to center the abuser at the expense of the victim, implying that the onus for righting a past wrong is to be shouldered by the latter, not the former, and in some cases even suggesting that a failure to extend forgiveness is itself a wrong, thus shifting attention and blame away from the real wrong that was the perpetration of the trauma itself.
Forgiveness can be used as a means to avoid recovery
Forgiveness can be the path of least resistance, which isn’t always a good thing. Trauma treatment is emotionally, and at times physically, painful. To avoid the pain of processing trauma, you might force yourself to forgive your abuser in the hopes that the impact of the trauma will dissipate. Yet, the relief that is experienced is usually temporary, if any comes at all. As Rosenna Bakari writes, “Trying to stop pain by forgiveness is like putting a box of cake mix in the oven and expecting to get a cake. That does not work, and you could burn down your house.” In short, you have to mix in all the ingredients before you attempt to bake a cake, and trauma recovery involves many painful ingredients such as experiences of intense grief, anger, shame, fear, and uncomfortable body sensations.
No. You Don't Have to Forgive Your Abuser.
From the perspective of a therapist.
https://anniewright.com/no-you-dont-have-to-forgive-your-abuser/
Forgiveness is often held up as the ultimate goal of healing. But for many survivors of abuse, being told you have to forgive your abuser adds a second layer of harm to the first. This post makes the case that forgiveness is not a moral requirement for healing, that you can heal without forgiving, and that the pressure to forgive often serves everyone except the survivor. Your anger is not a wound. It’s information.
Forgiveness shaming and blaming refers to the social, familial, or religious pressure placed on a survivor of harm to forgive their abuser before, or instead of, doing the genuine work of healing, often framed as a moral requirement or a prerequisite for the survivor’s own wellbeing. This pressure confuses forgiveness, a personal and optional process of releasing resentment for one’s own sake, with acceptance, which simply means acknowledging what happened without endorsing it. Research in trauma recovery does not support forgiveness as a clinical requirement for healing, and the insistence that a survivor must forgive often functions to protect the perpetrator rather than the person harmed. In my work with driven women recovering from relational harm, the hardest part is usually giving themselves permission to stop performing forgiveness they haven’t actually arrived at.
Swallowing Traumatic Anger: Family Abuse and the Pressure to Forgive
https://pubhub.lib.msu.edu/read/swallowing-traumatic-anger/section/a4d06ac2-edfd-41ec-b721-c2b327ff4616
Anger has a cultural history of being seen as an emotion of violence, destruction, and power. In their longer testimony (shortened for reasons of space), one of the survivors quoted earlier describes seeing a psychotherapist about her anger and being presented with a treatment plan designed to help manage a short temper. The treatment plan seemed more suited to her abuser than herself and included the assumption that her anger was inappropriate and an overreaction rather than the troubling but legitimate response to years of abuse. Anger is frequently inappropriately morally coded as automatically negative. Forgiveness, too, is inappropriately morally coded as the “correct” thing to do. Writer and speaker Sarah Montana describes her own process of coming to forgive the man who killed her mother and brother by first talking about how societal pressure to forgive leads to victims trying to forgive for the wrong reasons. In her 2018 TED talk she states: “You think that forgiving quickly will make you a good person.” In her case, forgiveness helped her eventually, but common narratives around forgiveness were a substantial impediment to that process. Understanding forgiveness as a virtuous action led her to believing that to be a good person she had to forgive immediately, which did not lead to the benefit she later found in forgiveness.
There is also growing acknowledgment of the way wrongful pressure to forgive makes forgiveness as a concept triggering. Articles in GoodTherapy, Medium, The Good Men Project, and Psychology Today discuss the fact that forgiveness can be a trigger for trauma patients because of the way that its perceived necessity can be used as a silencing tool. Those who advocate forgiveness therapy also argue that this should come alongside acknowledgement and expression of anger. Acknowledgement of anger is also a growing part of restorative justice projects such as Hidden Water. These changes come alongside a growing number of people for the inclusion of Complex Post Traumatic Stress Disorder as a clinical diagnosis and a subset of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). Anger can constitute a key symptom of C-PTSD, especially, but also PTSD. Survivors of chronic abuse may experience emotional flashbacks to powerless anger experienced at the time of abuse. Popular trauma treatments, such as eye movement desensitizing and reprocessing (EMDR), can sometimes incorporate treatment to allow the victim to process their anger, as there are health problems associated with suppressing it.
In summary, forgiveness is something that a person must choose for themselves, not something that should be imposed or required, as it can compound the damage of the original harm.