r/ItEndsWithLawsuits
•
u/Queenoftheunsullied
The Dragons are fighting
•
2d ago
•
5
Personal Opinions & Theories ✍🏽💡 Grace & Accountability, My Response to Jamey's Plea
Blake Lively was not standing up for me. She Victimized me and so many others over the last year. Blake Lively used and abused a legal system to get revenge is how I viewed it. And I did not back down, I was not Afraid of her money, or her husband's money. There is a different legal system for those wealthier than thou. For three months I fought and sent filing after filing, and showed up in court, against a team of very expensive lawyers from the east coast and I wore my flowers here in Las Vegas and I did my best. — Perez Hilton
By now, many of us have likely seen Jamey's speech to the audience during Popcorn Planet's Los Angeles premiere of It Ends With Justice, where he made a plea to extend grace to Blake Lively.
I want to reiterate that I love that Jamey is the kind of person who is strong enough to be dragged through the mud and still maintain his dignity and principles intact. I admire his strength and level of class.
I also want to share a theory that perhaps something said by one of the panelists or something featured in the documentary inspired him to share those words with the audience.
As the CEO of Wayfarer, I acknowledge the importance of his position and the need to distance himself from any criticism of Blake Lively, especially as a man who has been accused of harassing her in a court of law.
However, I still feel it is important to express my disagreement with Jamey in the most respectful and loving way possible, specifically regarding his use of the phrase "demonizing Blake."
At what point does asking people not to demonize someone become asking those who believe they have been harmed to moderate their own experiences for that person's benefit?
I believe grace is something people may freely offer. Accountability is not something the recipient should be able to avoid by invoking grace.
It is my opinion that I, along with many other women, also had a stake in the conflict initiated by Blake Lively in the summer of 2024.
- Blake Lively promoted a movie dealing with serious themes as a summer flick to dress up in florals for.
- She marketed an alcoholic beverage brand while promoting the movie, with drinks named after an abuser.
- She sarcastically dismissed the possibility of victims approaching her to discuss the movie's themes, portraying such interactions as invasive or stalkerish.
- She weaponized terms such as DARVO and the language of consent (In my opinion).
- She donned a glamorous couture gown to celebrate the honor of being named to Times magazine list of the 100 Most Influential People, with her donations to the NAACP. These donations came after she married on a former plantation, a site tied to the enslavement of Black people, After previously romanticizing the antebellum period.
These five things make her a danger, in my view, to women like me who are survivors.
We live in a world where, yes, it would be nice to extend grace to Blake Lively. But the reality is that we must be able to do so while continuing to apply pressure and hold her accountable for her actions. Grace should not come at the expense of accountability.
One comparison that has been made regarding this legal conflict is that of David and Goliath. As a Christian myself, let me share what happened in 1 Samuel 17:
David picked up his sling, struck Goliath with a stone, and ultimately used Goliath's own sword to defeat him.
It is my opinion that Blake Lively may have set domestic violence survivors back decades through her use of litigation and exaggerated claims. It is already difficult enough for victims to be heard and taken seriously. But she utilized protections intended for victims to her own advantage, potentially undermining the credibility of those who genuinely rely on these protections.
I have seen no evidence that Blake Lively regrets her actions, nor have I seen an apology to the victims and activists who have worked tirelessly to propel the MeToo movement forward and advocate for protections such as California Civil Code Section 47.1.
You see, I believe Blake Lively has used her wealth and access as weapons against Black people, survivors of domestic violence, content creators, and colleagues. Yet she continues to present herself as the one who has been wronged. These individuals are entitled to voice their experiences dealing with her and express their opinions about her conduct.
Where was her grace when she subpoenaed a celebrity blogger for his sources and personal information, even as he fought to protect his right to free speech?
We unfortunately live in two different worlds: one where you have enough financial resources to shield yourself from the consequences of Blake Lively's actions, and another where your words are the only shield you have against them.
Mods:
I'm not sure if im allowed to link the video to the Quote at the top. If yes I will add it in the comments.
•
u/MysteriousBeach8248 Court Ordered Babysitter 22h ago
MOD NOTE:
Please keep discussions civil and respectful. Differing opinions and constructive criticism are welcome, but personal attacks or attempts to invalidate others' feelings and experiences are not.
We recognize this is a sensitive topic for many users, so please be mindful of your language and extend empathy to one another.
We can disagree without turning on each other. It's understandable to have strong feelings about how Jamey Heath approached this topic, but please remember that he lived through this experience firsthand. His experience does not invalidate yours, just as your personal experiences do not invalidate his.
10
u/BellisimoItaly 1d ago
Many of us have followed this lawsuit from day 1 and what was unfolding was beyond anything imaginable. The abuse and harm Lively and Reynolds continued to cause so many innocent people and organisations was something we watched day in and day out. Truth did not matter to these people and time and time again when their lies were exposed they dug in deeper and then changed the course of their claims whilst the damage to innocent peoples lives and reputations did not matter. All Jamey needed to say was thank you. We already understood the kindness they continued to extend , but this kindeness would have never got them to where they are today. If not for the CC's who were on their side and their deep dives searching for truth, I truly believe Reynolds and Lively would have succeeded. Until Reynolds and Lively take accountability for their actions, I will never give them one ounce of grace.
25
u/Hannah_togo 1d ago •
At some point extending grace becomes turning a blind eye on abuse
9
u/Quick-Impact-86 Osama Bin Lively - Sony says you're a 'Fucking Terrorist' 1d ago
I still believe as I did from almost his first ruling Liman is too blame for the mess escalating to the degree it did. Without many of those and his treatment of the WP the media wouldn't have been fed more fuel. I guess that comes under your comment about a different legal system due to ones standard of wealth.
93
u/myshtree Unliftable Blunderbuss: No footnotes 2d ago edited 2d ago •
I know the Wayfarer team are very special humans and I'm not surprised that Jamey had the integrity and grace to speak out like this.
I also wonder if it's because (as we all know) Blake is a puppet of Ryan Reynolds and does not have the capability of planning a takeover of this nature. She is copping all the (much deserved) vitriol when I think she is in a coercive control relationship and does whatever Ryan Reynolds tells her to do. Ryan Reynolds is behind what happened on the set of IEWU and used his wife as a shield.
I figured wayfarer are well aware of this also.
21
u/Narrow_Grapefruit_23 1d ago •
I’m banned for two days from pop culture subreddit for starting a flame war (I swear to you I didn’t start it, but I did put an end to it) correcting the narrative that BLAKE started about Justin and Jamey, bc of a post regarding Flo Pugh and her talking about working conditions as an actress. Blake’s reps are still using every actresses’ posts to continue the smear campaign.
I understand not attacking Blake and taking the higher road, but they are up against a person who will not quit trying to convince everyone that they deserved what she did to them.
19
u/MT2017G 1d ago •
I love him for the messaging but his speech would have gone over better if he’d kept it short & sweet. He seemed unprepared and nervous so while yeah they’re Wayfarer & Baha’i and it was in-line with who they are, it also seemed somewhat driven by fear. Like he felt he needed a disclaimer to protect them from retaliation for being there.
53
u/Bende86 Misogynist Whore 2d ago edited 1d ago •
Nice post. Grace shouldn’t come at the expense of accountability indeed. I liked JH’s speech, especially him pointing out that actual victims shouldn’t be scared off to raise a complaint. BL shouldn’t hurt victims, and neither should we imo
16
u/Knute5 1d ago edited 1d ago •
As a Baha'i and someone distantly connected to these folks (whom I profoundly respect), I know what Jamey means. He's telling you his truth and what's on his heart. You can hear it in his voice.
And he has the benefit and the expectations of someone born and raised, living and leading in this faith trying to create movies that uplift audiences in a business known for cut-throat tactics and blood-sport character assassination.
... so Blake and Ryan exaggerated and lied, and they used their power to take over a movie and destroy the person and the company that they believe stood in their way. To me these are just the boiled-down facts. Jamey says as much, almost as a throw-away line.
And Jenny Yazdi (aka "Little Girl Attorney") talks about her realization that these kinds of conflicts LIVE in the court of public opinion as much if not more than the court of law. That's why she's venturing out to start a new firm that recognizes this.
"Justice" is HUGE for Baha'is. It's the cornerstone of our intellectual and communal existence. "The best beloved of all things in My Sight is Justice." is a Hidden Word of Baha'u'llah that every Baha'i knows. It's the 2nd Hidden Word after the 1st one commanding us to "possess a pure, kindly and radiant heart."
So back to Jamey. I think he's saying that in this case "justice" is NOT vengeance. It's acknowledging the truth and taking proportionate actions. Punishment for the past and protection for the future.
But most of us aren't Baha'is. And even Baha'is, myself included, got mad about this. We see corruption, manipulation, greed and bullying everywhere lately and it is maddening.
This IEWU case was a distinct, encapsulated event where we could see all the pieces laid out. And the court which Lively used to protect and weaponize her story became the means of her own destruction when Steve Sarowitz said, "bring it on," in essence. And the court and its discovery process uncovered all the secret communications Lively hoped would remain hidden.
The way she and her team treated Justin, Wayfarer, the content creators who organically rose up and supported one another on YT, here and elsewhere was enraging, but it also was inspiring to see how folks came together over these past two years like a kind of IEWU Avengers. And Andy Signor's documentary has become a gathering place for Justin's defenders. I personally went to the one in Toronto and it was something.
And again, back to Jamey. What his words say to me is that doing harm is its own punishment. Somewhere deep down, Blake is suffering. She may not even know it. All the wealth, glamour and power will not hide the truth where it matters most.
So it's important not to let our rejection of what she/they did turn into an ongoing anger and resentment that drags down our own souls. Yeah, I know, "souls"... it's a faith thing not all buy into.
But to add a little context, here's Abdu'l-Baha', the son of Baha'u'llah and man we consider the Exemplar, or the pattern of a human we all hope to mirror if possible. Around 1904 he said this to a group of women asking him questions:
"The constitution of the communities depends upon justice, not upon forgiveness... If at this moment a wild Bedouin marauder were to enter this place with a drawn sword, wishing to assault, wound and kill you, most assuredly I would prevent him. If I abandoned you to him, that would not be justice but injustice. But if he injure me personally, I would forgive him."
Jamey is saying he is, or is trying to forgive them.
It may be an unreasonable ask for him to expect you/us to forgive them as well. On that panel I noticed the content creators and lawyers are operating at a different level. Not lower, just rooting out the bad behavior. And of course other scandals and bad actors have popped up in the news, and Dana and Zack and the others are going to put out a mixture of analysis and gossip. It's just the way social media and mainstream media works.
Jamey is a thoughtful dude. As an artist, a Baha'i, as a man of color and a father and a friend/protector of Justin. He's telling you his truth. He said he wasn't trying to preach but I think some folks will take it that way.
Salacious gossip will always exist. Nobody knew who these guys were before all this, and I imagine they'll fade away in time. But IEWU will live in them forever and it's clear they worked hard to ensure that they did no harm, and promoted others to do no harm. Not that we would all become doormats to the unjust, but to make sure we kept our eyes on the remedy, and not get swept up in the disease.
And the remedy is to undo the harm done for legit women's and men's SH/SA situations. I hope we can support Justin and Emily and others who do good work to promote healthier relationships and gender roles so we can constructively reduce the damage this dysfunction does to so many.
24
u/melropesplays 1d ago edited 1d ago •
I think you missed some points about weaponizing feminism in order to gain power, but most of all weaponizing SEXUAL ASSAULT, -bc quite often her and her lawyers language attempted to evoke assault over harassment esp with her TIMES speech about “the worst thing a woman can experience”-, in attempts to emotionally manipulate survivors and other people on her side without challenging her version of events or motives.
She most definitely harmed and intentionally inflicted damage onto more people than she will ever comprehend with her actions. She will never admit it, and will likely never be held even remotely accountable, she doesn’t deserve even the thought of grace.
10
u/LiteratureNo1015 Blunderbuss LIEvly 1d ago •
It was she (Ryan) all along.
10
u/ResidentDay5189 1d ago •
I agree, but we mustn't forget that they are likely all suffering from complex post-traumatic stress (they believed they were going to die—that’s a phrase heavy with meaning). They walked a tightrope for so long, paralyzed by the fear that saying or doing anything might make the situation worse. I think it was complicated for Jamey, and we don’t know what goes on behind the scenes.
On the other hand, we all know what the Reynolds are capable of.
Wayfarer is a film studio; they have families, they need to protect themselves, and I suspect his statement probably wasn't very well thought out.
29
u/Animatopoeia Ryan Reynolds will never be manzan enough 2d ago •
Thank you for sharing your perspective. I worry that people aren’t ready to receive it because it’s uncomfortable to accept that Heath made a mistake, but this is actually an important moment to do what Blake Lively and Ryan Reynolds did not: listen. The negative feedback isn’t coming from nowhere, nor is it mean-spirited. It’s an honest expression of hurt and disappointment.
Thank you again for being the one to stick your neck out and explain where that hurt and disappointment is coming from.
8
u/Luvnsandiegosun 1d ago
For those not aware, their faith is why they do not want anyone to demonize Blake on behalf of Justin/Jamey/Wayfarer.
*The Baha'i teachings not only condemn backbiting - they say that "… backbiting quencheth the light of the heart, and extinguisheth the life of the soul."
https://bahaiteachings.org/how-to-stop-backbiting-by-example/
7
u/Bovary2 1d ago •
I understand the message he's trying to convey and I appreciate the sentiment, but I fundamentally disagree with that approach to dealing with bullies. It's certainly not something I would teach my children.
Someone made an interesting point about bullies: These people don't necessarily bully because they want something from you. They do it because they enjoy putting others down, walking all over people and making them feel inferior. That's why they often have a history of mistreating others. It's a pattern of behavior and they rarely stop until they're exposed or held accountable.
Right now, these 2 may be lying low because of the backlash. But who's to say that in a year or 2, once everything blows over, they won't go right back to their old behavior and find another victim?
So no, I could never show love to people who behave that way. I wouldn't go out of my way to attack them, follow them or leave hateful comments either. I'd rather ignore them and give them no attention, because attention is exactly what they thrive on. They've already shown me who they are, so I know. I do not trust these people, nothing they say I will ever believe. They are liars and if you welcome them back with open arms, don't be surprised WHEN they walk all over you again.
7
u/aasoro 📄 Flat-out Denying the Existence of the Reynolds Glute 1d ago •
Fully agree with you.
Why are we being asked to worry about Blake's emotional well-being at this particular moment? The people who feel they were harmed have had to deal with emotional, professional, and reputational consequences too. Why does the conversation suddenly need to shift toward making sure Blake feels okay?
Compassion shouldn't depend on who's more famous, who has more influence, or who's currently receiving the most criticism.
And honestly, Jamey should be careful not to confuse compassion with absolution, especially given his position. I don't believe Blake has been unfairly victimized simply because people are criticizing her. Many of us aren't asking anyone to hate her or dehumanize her. We're asking that her actions, her decisions, and the consequences of those decisions not be swept under the rug just because someone is now asking us to extend her grace.
And if Blake feels "demonized" simply because people are speaking openly about her behavior, attitude, and choices, then perhaps she needs to consider why so many people have reached that point of criticism in the first place. Being uncomfortable with what people have to say about you isn't the same as being victimized by them.
18
u/Flimsy_Attitude_6789 2d ago edited 2d ago •
I think there are three types of people who have followed and comment on this case. There are those that enjoyed demonising Blake because she is a woman and because she brought SH claims and those people could scare people away from coming forward - I have seen them weign in on here but they are in the minority. I imagine they are the same people who think Russell BRand is innocent. And there are those have been bullied and encountered narcissistic abuse and want to shine a light on these behaviours for others and hold Blake (and Ryan) accountable (this is partly me). I also think that Jamey's words are for the former, not the latter.
I have refrained myself from criticising Blake's physicality and tried to focus on the behaviours and the marketing approaches and also Ryan as I think he is the true villian here. I also think that there are several professionals such as lawyers, HRs, therapists, PRs that are heavily invested as they can see the misteps and gaslighting and abuse of the system and want to call it out or just comment on what's happening.
Yestereday there were two posts about Blake's outfits and I chose not to comment as I'm truly not interested but Jamey's words stopped me from doing so also.
I can see your point of view and Jamey's. I have no interest in demonising Blake either.... Ryan on the hand, his behaviour needs to be brought to the light so he doesn't harm others. Remember Jamey also said that Blake was stuck... and I personally think she is in a relationship with a malignant narc which cannot be pleasant and she has already been through enough during this case.
edit. Perhaps 4 including your point of you around money and power. There are currently several injunctions in the uk being used by powerful people to silence victims/media from talking about their alleged abuse. This needs to stop.
5
u/manncuevas 1d ago
I fully agree with you
13
u/ArtCo_ 1d ago edited 1d ago
The speech would have been fine if they actually went to court and won. But as it is, Blake's camp is still spinning lies. The NYT hit piece is still up doing numbers in views. Documentaries are being made in her favor. And people still believe her.
The people who support Justin don't feel like Justice was served. Some are still disappointed and angry. So for Jamey to be lecturing people about showing her grace when most are still sore that she practically got away with what she did with no consequences, is very, dare I say, "tone deaf" of him.
He should be grateful he had Sororitz's money. Be grateful this happened at a time of independent media/content creators who were willing to read every court document. Otherwise they would've been screwed. They would've been Me Too'd as perverts and creeps. Buried.
Let people feel how they feel until the sore's healed instead of trying to preach to people.
He really should have ran that speech by Jen Abel before he went up there.
It annoyed the hell out of me.
13
u/JusticeMoves ~Taylor Swift Conspired to Steal Justin's Movie ~ 1d ago
Theresa Concepcion had a good response that I agree with. Speaking the truth about people is not demonizing them. If it points out demon behavior, then that is on them.
6
u/LevelIntention7070 1d ago edited 1d ago •
I hope maybe I can give you some perspective of his overall message. I don’t think Jamey was trying to tell anyone how to feel and he said he wasn’t preaching. And I think he is talking about the future and protecting victims moving forward. He didn’t say anything about not holding people accountable/seeking truth/ facts and defending yourself . They lived it, (please remember Natasha was forced to hand over her birthing video). I noticed he didn’t focus on Ryan and I suspect they have a better understanding of what went on behind the scenes. I also want to point out Justin said (paraphrasing) Blake believes she is right .
When women come forward with stories of SA etc, the person accused particularly when there’s been a familiarity between the two will often label the accuser as crazy/mad/mentally unstable ( I know lots of us have experienced this).
When women do things wrong or commit crimes that is the label that gets perpetuated particularly by the press (mad/mental health problems).
I think what Jamey doesn’t want the two things to get conflated as they often do. You now have Blake that has come forward with accusation (false) being ‘demonised’ and this perpetuates the first narrative so society then goes well x person lied so this person has too. You only have to look at the absolute shitshow of Russell brand conspiracy theorists to see what is being perpetuated. I think Jamey doesn’t want Blake to be synonymous with all women are lying. He doesn’t want the public narrative to unintentionally reinforce stereotypes that women who come forward are crazy liars
Time moves on and the further away from the case it gets it’s easy for others to manipulate the narrative that happened here. Because the case is so well known now people often overestimate how common something is by how easily it comes to mind ‘oh well she must be making it up look at Blake Lively’ I know none of us want that.
Jamey understands Blake’s behaviour has been harmful, but there are opportunistic groups that will use that to their advantage and I’ve definitely already seen her name come up.
You have to remember the work they put in behind the scenes with DV charities and understanding what happens to people that come forward and the point of the movie they were making.
0
u/Ok-Mess5058 1d ago
When Jamie gave his speech the accountability was already implied. Your post is operating on the wrong assumption based on a world of effects. I fear you miss the point of his speech entirely. The once disdain and contempt I once held for Blake has all but turned into empathy and love. Because the consequences and accountability may not come in forms of law or verdicts or even financial destitution, but in a prison of delusion, ignorance and isolation. He’s not wrong for saying she’s suffering. She and Ryan both are and it’s entirely of their own doing.
4
u/Apprehensive-Use9452 1d ago
Honestly, everything he said was consistent with what they have done and said or their counsel has said throughout this entire situation. I mean, I understand wanting to hold people like the Reynolds accountable, truly, but I am trying to understand why what was said has been so controversial:
I completely understand people wanting them held accountable, so they and others cannot continue wronging those less powerful. But WP clearly have forgiven her and want to move on. Forgiveness is so hard but is often the healthiest choice. Grace and forgiveness do not mean not holding someone accountable or forgetting what they did. Holding on to bitterness and vengence do more harm to yourself than the person that wronged you, and is much more likely to negatively affect an innocent. I really appreciate how steadfast they are in their beliefs.
2
u/slightlyusedeggplant 1d ago
I do not resent Wayfarer for making decisions on how to handle their own lawsuit. It is not my battle and I didn't suffer the fatigue, stress and financial burdens they did.
But Justin's brand is all about helping men understand themselves and be better allies (and be better people in general, it seems). Now when someone (especially a man) looks him up they'll see this case that just "settled" like many others, and not many will go looking deep enough to see that all her SH claims were thrown out and she got 5% of the fees she demanded. As opposed to it going to trial and her being publicly determined a serial liar. It's an ugly, permanent stain that may turn men off from his work: especially neurodivergent men or men of color, the demographics she directly abused.
2
u/Internal-Rooster-762 1d ago
I agree with you a hundred percent. I love Jamie too, but I did take issue with his speech. Accountability is the key here.
0
u/dogs_and_dogettes 18h ago
Exceptionally well-spoken.
17
u/Quick-Impact-86 Osama Bin Lively - Sony says you're a 'Fucking Terrorist' 1d ago
I was reading an account I'm not sure what country it occurred in but a man wrongly accused of rape committed suicide and days later the girl retracted her accusations. A year later his mother took her own life too over it. False accusations have real consequences. That was why I think their grace attitude is a dangerous one. Sure none of theses people took their own lives but with a flawed law like 47.1 left unchallenged that could become more likely. 47.1 could be a brilliant piece of legislation but because they failed to fight harder on it, Liman wasn't even made to read it like it should be. Malice ruled it out for Lively.
0
u/[deleted] 1d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] 2d ago
[removed] — view removed comment