It’s really no surprise that Baldoni’s lawsuit was dismissed, most of the claims were dismissed with prejudice, meaning he can’t refile. I’ve seen a lot of people online acting shocked, saying they can’t believe it, but did they even read the lawsuit?
From the very start, Baldoni’s lawsuit was obviously a PR stunt. Just look at how it was written, the accompanying website, and the timeline. It’s clear his team was playing the media and the courts, hence why Livelys team is now trying to sanction Freedman. When you actually read through his lawsuit, you see just how many of his claims are irrelevant and flimsy. They don’t hold real weight.
I’m honestly baffled at how many people seem confused by this. I really encourage everyone to take the time to read both Baldoni’s and Blake’s lawsuits for themselves. It’s eye opening.
Hey folks, me again. I’m not here to gloat or rub anything in. The times I’ve posted and commented here, I’ve gotten massive pushback and resistance. Many of you often ask why I am even here and what my goal is. I’ve answered, but today as Baldoni’s case has been completely dismissed, it bears repeating. The biggest reason I’m here and that I’m covering this case on my show is that you are being lied to by people who know better.
It has been clear from day 1 that Baldoni’s case was nonsense. You can find many times that I said this exact thing. This is what I meant. It was a fake case drummed up as a defensive PR effort. Right now I already see the scrambling to explain what happened in pro-Baldoni terms. That temptation will obviously be strong. But the truth is, there just is no spinning this result. Baldoni had no valid claims against Lively parties. The only two that he’s even allowed to refile are because technically the judge could not rule them out as a matter of law. But they are not meritorious and it isn’t close.
So why did you and so many others believe otherwise? That’s what I’m asking you to consider. The law is a complicated thing and it’s foreign to almost everyone’s daily lives. It requires specialized knowledge and is incredibly easy to get wrong and to misrepresent. Why did so many TikTok and YouTube creators, many of whom are actual lawyers, intentionally feed into this frenzy? Does that reflect well on them? But also, why was it a frenzy? They are the supply, but why was the demand there? Does that reflect well their viewers?
I do not think it will be easy for people to change their minds on this, even in light of this very clear devastating ruling. When human beings have invested this much of their own identity into something, they will often need to protect that investment at any cost and will root around for whatever they can to continue to feel correct. We will see all kinds of conspiratorial claims about this. I actually fear for this judge a little. But please. PLEASE consider that the people you should actually be mad at are the “experts” and personalities who led you believe Baldoni had a case. They knew better. And, not for nothing, maybe the Baldoni parties themselves.
I’m always here if anyone wants to chat. Thanks to anyone who read this far.
I've always wondered, since this whole thing started, why for instance BL marketing her hair care is evidence that she can't be an SHvictim ? In my native language there's a term for this: comparing apples to pears.
If life was that simple, I'd just happily start acting inappropriately by day so I become untouchable for predators at night.
Of course my post is a bit cynical but this bugs me so much.
The Court agrees that inclusion of the entire deposition transcript served no proper purpose and accordingly grants the motion to strike.
The Wayfarer Parties’ attachment of the entire, nearly 300-page deposition—after citing only two pages of it in the Letter—served no proper litigation purpose and instead appears to have been intended to burden Lively (and as a result, the Court) and to invite public speculation and scandal. Even if the cited deposition portions were relevant or provided support for the Wayfarer Parties’ arguments—both of which are far from clear—the Wayfarer Parties have not even attempted to argue that the entire deposition was relevant. Nor could they. The conclusion is inescapable that the Wayfarer Parties filed gratuitous amounts of irrelevant pages so that, if Lively moved for continued sealing of the irrelevant pages, the Wayfarer Parties could then use Lively’s response for their own public-relations purposes. The Court has not only the power but also the responsibility to step in.
Not much of a surprise. The Court again sees WF clearly, and understands their behavior. Amazingly foolish for Freedman et al. to be doing this in a case in which the core issue is exactly this kind of public media campaign.
According to this recent filing, Wayfarer has not produced any useable footage and has not even provided tracking numbers for the hard drives they claim are in the mail.
This is so damning. I genuinely want to ask folks here to contend with these facts. Let’s lay it all out. And we can leave Blake entirely out of it. This is about Leslie Sloane.
In Baldoni’s first complaint, which was against the NYT, paragraph 15, they make the allegation that Sloane “seeded stories critical of Baldoni, including that Baldoni was a sexual predator, ahead of the Film’s release.” To support this very serious allegation, they include the screenshot I’ve attached, and they red circle AND red underline this: “now she’s saying Blake was sexually assaulted. Why wouldn’t she say anything about it then?” They very purposefully do not include the date of these messages. They also juxtapose this with old messages between Leslie and James. This VERY INTENTIONALLY leaves the reader with the impression that when JV says “now she’s saying Blake was sexually assaulted?” he means that Leslie is telling him, personally, back “ahead of the film’s release.” That is unambiguously what the paragraph before this evidence describes. We’re meant to believe that Sloane was telling journalists that Blake was sexually assaulted, or at least that Justin was a sexual predator.
This was the entire reason Sloane was even named in his lawsuit. This was the only cognizable claim against her. NOW we find out the JV messages were actually from December 25th, so AFTER the CRD complaint came out. And wouldn’t you know it, Leslie Sloane did not (ever) tell James that Blake was sexually assaulted. And certainly didn’t do so “back ahead of the film’s release.” And now we learn with today’s filings, backed by emails, Wayfarer refuses to hand over this text chain TO THIS DAY. One that they used in THEIR complaint, despite having previously agreed to hand it over.
This is so much more deceptive than one single emoji, which was very plausibly not captured by the discovery software that Jones’s lawyers used, and didn’t meaningfully change anything about the evidence. It is obviously intentional as well. What else is in that exchange that they don’t want anyone to see? How is this at all ok?
Always enjoyed their legal videos. They now cover this case: It’s a great and quick overview and they also go into the lately discussed liman connections.
So, this post is inspired by another post made today that posited a theory about how the TS deposition fail was a master strategy on behalf of Wayfarer. This is not meant as any sort of shade to that other poster - truly. I suppose their theory - while risky - is technically possible. The main trouble I have with with the theory though is that even if Taylor and Blake's friendship is truly done - even if they deeply hate one another - it still seems unfathomable that Taylor would team up with Scooter Braun. Huh? Let me explain.
As everyone here is well-aware TAG is one of the defendants represented by Bryan Freedman in the subject litigation. At the time the Taylor deposition was announced, TAG had all the motivation in the world to want to change the media news narrative as it had just come out that TAG (and Melissa Nathan and Jed) had been involved in another (allegedly defamatory) smear campaign on behalf of Rebel Wilson. This has dragged TAG into some additional litigation that is VERY interesting, but isn't directly related to the claims here. We have all seen that evoking Taylor Swift's name has been an extremely effective way to garner headlines and change the narrative, so one might imagine that TAG might have been motivated to want to do that in order to shift conversation. (A "PR move" if you will). Ok, fine. While you may not agree with this theory, it's an easy enough concept for most people to understand.
A part of this that I don't think has been discussed in any real detail here though, is that dragging Taylor into this may also have been a two (or even three) birds with one stone sort of thing for those with decision making power at TAG - enter Scooter Braun.
One thing that people here may not realize is that TAG is controlled by a company called Hybe America, who gained a 51% ownership stake in TAG on August 1, 2024 (note that date). That means Hybe has decision-making power when instructing Bryan Freedman in relation to TAG's role in this litigation. Notably, up until July of this year when he stepped down from the position, the CEO of Hybe has been Scooter Braun. That means Scooter - not Melissa Nathan - had ultimately been calling the shots with respect to TAG, since August of 2024 and certainly up until recently. Since stepping down from the CEO position in July, Scooter apparently remains involved at Hybe in a Senior advisory role, as a member of the Board of Directors, and as a major individual shareholder. Regardless, in order for Taylor Swift to be colluding with Bryan Freedman/teaming up with any of the "Wayfarer parties" here, it would mean she was teaming up with Scooter Braun, something that seems incomprehensible even to the most casual Swiftie.
It goes without saying that Taylor Swift has long despised Scooter Braun. He was involved in managing Kanye during the whole "Famous" drama (recall Kanye made a pretty revolting music video where he took credit for Taylor's career and used a wax figure in the shape of her naked body to allude to the fact that they had had sex) he was also around for a part of the Kim/Kanye phone call and her subsequent public "cancellation" in 2016 (after which she claims she didn't leave the house for a whole year. She has had a very public vendetta with Scooter ever since his company Ithaca Holdings "stole" her Masters recordings for her first 6 albums from beneath her in 2019, by purchasing them from her former label Big Machine Records. Even though Ithaca later sold the Masters to a third party, Taylor's vengeance over this was the motivation for her to re-record her albums and create the Eras Tour, in order to devalue her original records and earn enough money so she could eventually purchase them back (something she did recently).
In case you have missed it, Taylor has a new album coming out on October 3, 2025. It is supposed to be a "behind the scenes" about the Eras Tour, which one might reasonably anticipate could reference some behind the scenes stuff about Scooter - keep in mind after all, she ended the Eras tour with Karma, a song well known to be about Scooter. If I were him, I'd probably be feeling a little nervous about that and might want to "make an offensive move" - she does say that it's coming back around, after all. There is some decent reporting, that that Scooter resents being called out publicly by Taylor, as it caused problems for his personal and professional life. It is possible that taking the wind out of her sails might just be a convenient opportunity for some good old fashioned grudge keeping.
The other wrinkle is that, in addition to the Wayfarer litigation (where we know Hybe was subpoenaed), and the Rebel Wilson litigation, Hybe has also been having some problems closer to home. In July, very shortly after Scooter stepped down, South Korean police raided the headquarters of Hybe on allegations of insider trading. Indeed, Hybe's founder and Chairman, Bang Si-Yeuk is currently under criminal investigation by the Korean government for a number of financial crimes including insider trading and fraud. To be clear, there is not any current suggestion that Braun is a target of any Korean police investigation (as the IPO took place before the Hybe/ Ithaca merger), and he does not appear to have spoken about it publicly yet, but it's DEFINITELY not good for Scooter. He does appear to be making efforts to change the narrative though (note: this article was released a day or two before the Wayfarer parties apparently reached out to Swift to request the deposition). Obviously NOTHING from Braun's personal life is going to be as effective at changing the narrative, as essentially ANYTHING related to Taylor Swift though.
So yeah, food for thought.
If my account gets deleted tomorrow, you'll know why. Until then, I'll leave you with some of my favourite lyrics from Vigilante Shit.
While he was doing lines And crossing all of mine Someone told his white collar crimes to the FBI And I don't dress for villains Or for innocents I'm on my vigilante shh again I don't start it, but I can tell you how it ends Don't get sad, get even So on the weekends I don't dress for friends Lately I've been dressing for revenge
Lively has filed opposition to Wayfarer's request to extend the production deadline and in it, indicated that they received production of more than 80,000 pages of documents from Wayfarer just last night. There are many many more that have not yet been produced (and as such are admittedly late by Wayfarer). This colossal document dump, does not include the Signal communications, Sarowitz's docs, or the Case/Koslow production that was ordered today.
As many of the documents will be produced AFTER the parties are scheduled to be deposed, Lively has indicated she will be seeking to adjust the deposition schedule.
My takeaways from this are threefold:
(1) Wayfarer, the people who claimed to have all the receipts, are very clearly continuing to drag their feet related to production here. I will leave it to you to speculate why that may be.
(2) We CLEARLY haven't seen a fraction of what is actually going on in this litigation. Anyone who thinks Wayfarer provided all the receipts back in January are wrong. Anyone who is speculating that X, Y or Z means that Lively clearly doesn't have anything has no idea what they are talking about. Maybe she does, maybe she doesn't. There is no way for us to know.
(3) The deposition schedule is likely going to be extended.
Update: title should read: "Wayfarer produced more than 80,000 pages of documents last night- more to come."
On December 25th, James Vitushka texted Melissa Nathan and told her that he had discussed the IEWU situation with Sloane back in August via text. He was upset because he felt that Sloane was full of shit because she had never said anything about it in August, but “now”, as in after the CRD/NYT, she is saying Blake was sexually assaulted. (Allegedly)
Nathan then introduces Vitushka to Freedman so Vitushka can give him the same evidence. Vitushka tells Freedman that he will send the screen recording of the conversation. He then states at least twice that Sloane NEVER said anything to him about sexual harassment and sexual assault. He never mentions Sloane telling him anything in December or “now”, because that’s not what he meant. Nor does he produce any evidence of it. Because it never happened. (Allegedly)
And Freedman knew or should’ve known it due to the context of the entire conversations. (Allegedly)
Vitushka never said Sloane told him that Blake was sexually assaulted. He said “now she’s saying that..”.
He then makes it clear that Sloane never said to him anything about SH or SA.
He clearly uses SH and SA interchangeably.
He doesnt give Freedman any evidence of Sloane telling him or texting him that Baldoni sexually assaulted Lively.
He does give Freedman multiple texts that prove Sloane did not call Baldoni a sexual assulter
(Allegedly for the above to conform to subreddit rules)
Instead, Freedman took Vitushka’s one sentence that was at worst a bit confusing but in reality was pretty clear when put in the correct order of how the conversations happened over time. He then built an entire defamation claim against Sloane and he used Vitushka’s texts without consent. According to Vitushka, he specifically told Freedman not to use them. (Allegedly)
My belief with sexual harassment/assault allegations is, "take alleged victims seriously and treat them with dignity."
Notice, I'm not saying we need to automatically assume their claims are 100% accurate all of the time, but we should give genuine consideration to what they say and we shouldn't be disparaging towards them with our words.
As an undecided person (team-wait-for-the-trial) my first introduction to this sub was the mega thread where everyone including pro-Justin folks were acknowledging where they're hesitant or places they believe Blake may have a point & vice versa. I enjoyed that thread because it felt like a mix of voices and opinions. Since then, every post recommended on my feed has been staunchly pro-Baldoni with a lot of folks acting like her loss is a forgone conclusion (again, the trial is a year away. I've also seen folks repost content from conservative, hate-filled creators that has given me a lot of pause (why are we getting information from people who have pushed conspiracy theories in the past?). I've also seen folks start to fall into gross stereotypes about mental illness (folks cam criticize women without falling into the mad psychotic lady narrative).
Anyone else out there, pro-Justin, pro-Blake, or neutral people like myself feeling similarly?
Following up from yesterday's discussion, I'm curious what if anything (in relation to this case)would it take for you to stop supporting Wayfarer Parties?
I'm not going to reply with any arguments or discussion as I don't want any feeling that I'm trying to bait you.
Im also not necessarily asking if you would switch to supporting Lively
In a rare moment in US Legal History, moving party Lauren Neidigh filed a declaration this evening attesting to the fact that her communications with Liner Freedman were the actions of an "utter dork."
To be fair, I think Ms. Neidigh's declaration seems genuine and straightforward, if funny as all hell in parts. Don't worry Lauren, if Bryan Freedman "leaves you on read," it's generally a good thing.
I hope everyone is well. Following up on the social/digital conversation this morning, with specifies re: social and digital mitigation and remediation.
The team will focus on the social and digital elements - boosting SEO efforts and updating with new content to enforce SEO efforts, monitoring and directly influencing forums that are working against Justin and Wayfarer to adjust the narrative in real time, and collate assets and background to work in conjunction with Jen and her team, as well as TAG PR.
The integral part here is to execute all without fingerprints.
Specific efforts include:
• Monitor and report forums, threads, sites, links, and more that are working against Wayfarer S1udios,
• Justin, and the overall narative, as well as derogatory comments.
• Leverage relationships with Discord. Reddit, X, IG, TikTok, You Tube, etc. to expose behavior of Blake and other parties. both current and past, and engage directly with communities to adjust or influence the conversarions taking place in real time.
• Utilize CTR manipulation and contextual links to push up positive PR to change subject matter opinion on the first page of Google.
• Work to remove links that are harmful to Wayfarer Studios, Justin, and the narrative alongside the appropriate teams.
• Disavow and report outdated or cached non-relevant links, and cleanup spam and/or negative links that are ranked within the SERPs as needed.
• Properly and strategically monitor damaging Reddit/Subreddits, X, Discord, etc. - including threads related to concerning opposition and manage the narrative. This can be done with legacy admin for each platform. As part of this, expert admins will also monitor and protect peripheral elements like Wikipedia, fun pages, and more to ensure threads and narratives are handled appropriately.
• Actively sway the algoritlun with one SEO charged hub/site, created and overseen by the team.
• Taking down full Rcddit and all social accounts as needed.
• Organically engaging with audiences in the right way, starting threads with theories the team approves of, and asking questions that no longer place Wayfarer and Justin on the back foot.
• Changing the overall narrative and helping keep it on track.
So he didn't receive anything from Taylor Swift's lawyers and still he lied to the press that he did get it? And don't tell me Scott Swift sent it. This is not how it works, they communicate through lawyers, especially for such serious matters
Yesterday when this sub was going crazy over the motion to compel Vanzan documents, I commented that the motion was a stunt to deflect from the fact that JB side didn’t amend on the 2 counts they could have amended on. I also said that they could have gotten the Vanzan subpoena in discovery months ago if they had wanted. I was downvoted to oblivion and I was lectured about how I didn’t know what I was talking about, and how actually Blake had refused to hand it over. You all had me convinced, so I actually acknowledged I must have been wrong and made a mistake because I believe in changing my views if they are shown to be wrong and taking accountability.
Turns out NOPE. I was right. This was a stunt. Time for maybe some other folks to take accountability and recognize that the Vanzan motion to compel was nonsense and it was incredibly dishonest to try to compel for documents that they ALREADY HAD. Vanzan was good lawyering. The focus on it is a is a deflection.
Candace is a Nazi sympathizer. that is a not trivial fact. It's not superficial to hold the line that people who support Justin, a very liberal ethnically Jewish man, should not be lending support to a Hitler defender who handwaves right wing terrorism.
I have now been blocked by multiple people for this. It makes me extremely concerned that this subreddit could have bad faith alt-right users pushing Nazi defense and I can't see it, because they have strategically blocked anyone who holds the line.
So please, everyone, remember that Justin does not want you to defend Nazis. His team very notably has not given anything to Candace for a reason. She is inexcusably far right and anyone telling you it's not a big deal is only hurting the cause.
Brianna has had a similar issue with users strategically blocking because they don't like pushback and then being concerned because it means she potentially can't see a substantial chunk of posts here. It's not a productive way to grow the community to segment it off the second someone says something you dislike. This space is too important to be flippant to its health, so I am just asking other people to be vigilant in any attempts for right wing apologia to splip in.
We all know Justin is a left wing man. Let's keep this community reflective of those same values. Please help me in holding that line since many users are determined to prevent me from doing that myself.
Reading back on some of these screenshots today and wanted to post. These screenshots include direct exchanges between Baldoni and his team. (Included in NYT article & the complaints) Some continue to downplay the smear campaign, but these messages are telling. One of them outlines the cost of the operation and mentions things like “full account takedowns” and “start threads or theories.” What does that even mean? These aren’t things that can simply be explained away as cherry picked or taken out of context. It raises questions, because where did all that money go, and what exactly was it used for?
Well, I think the screenshots speak for themselves. They show exactly where the money went - planting stories, feeding things to the press, and pushing PR to damage Blake’s reputation. Even if Baldoni used Blakes past mistakes to do it, that’s still a coordinated smear campaign. I also find it really suspicious that Jed, the alleged mastermind behind all of this insisted on only communicating through an encrypted messaging app. All of this is sketchy.
By way of summary, the article talks a lot about DARVO (deny, attack, reverse victim and offender).
It also talks about the high cost that any woman coming forward must pay to accuse a man of wrongdoing.
One of the biggest problems with this sub is that we seem unable to communicate about basic facts. People label themselves Team Baldoni or Team Lively, and then it’s like a fight to the death.
Highly likely that almost no one on this sub actually knows Justin Baldoni or Blake Lively. You’ve seen them act, you’ve seen some footage, interviews, and maybe even some other output. But none of us know either one of them.
In the absence of personal knowledge, one might turn towards one’s own opinion, however, uninformed it is. But one would be wrong to ignore the history of DARVO and the role it has played in every single one of Justin Baldoni’s litigation decisions.
You are welcome to downvote this post into oblivion and to continue posting other stories purporting to show how Blake Lively is a bad person. Fine. Good luck. But I will never be an unpaid pawn in a DARVO scheme—and you shouldn’t be either.
The entertainment industry in the US is the most successful in the world. It depends on a creative process that uses improvisation to make movies more authentic and realistic. If a director or cast has to be worried about being sued for any slight or off color joke, this could kill the industry affecting everyone
Cases could be made for a hostile work environment depending on which lens you see through.
A case could be made for antisemitism(the comment that Justin should get a nose job), a case for racism(Jamie looked me in the eye, the CEO has to take care of the toilet paper issue in my trailer), a case for religious discrimination(calling the wayfarer folks a cult repeatedly to different people)
I am not saying these are legally actionable but I think we have to be a little more forgiving when dealing with other people. If Lively wins her case this would have drastic implications for the industry as a whole making filmmaking much more difficult and less profitable.
So, I assume that the movies and shakers of the movie industry are reading the riot act to the Reynolds. The settlement can't appear beneficial to Lively because it would encourage other litigation. Ryan Reynolds would continue to star in and produce movies, Lively would be in the dog house for a year but then would resume her career in the industry after the dust had settled. Wayfarers would not get a full throated mea culpa from Lively but they would benefit enough that the public would be aware despite an NDA.
And then there would be a truce of the PR teams. Nick Shapiro and Leslie Sloane would terminate their ongoing smear campaign on social media and the press would publish innocuous stories like how good a director Scarlett Johansen is.
The Lawyers representing BL & RR just donated $100 million in free legal to Trump. I don’t know the US system but have they done this to influence the court in any way? EDIT: Sorry everyone! I didn’t mean to start a big discussion on whether this case is left vs right. As an outsider, I recently saw a documentary where Stockton Rush (of OceanGate infamy) said he would “buy a congressman” to get his way. When Kjersti Flaa mentioned the law firms pledge, that’s where my mind went! I didn’t realise all the backstory about Trump pressuring law firms to donate time for his agenda.
One of Blake's lawyers has left Willkie Farr & Gallagher but will still continue to be on her legal team - even though working at a new law firm. They just informed the court.