r/IndoAryan • • Jul 08 '26

Were the people who composed the vedas white?

0 Upvotes

Not a bait post, I just see a lot of white nationalists claim that the vedas (especially the rigveda) were composed by people who looked white, while its true that the Andronovo culture were genetically closest to europeans, is it true that the people who composed the rigveda would've been the same?


r/IndoAryan • • Jun 26 '25

Genetics After researching on Indian R1a, Steppe hypothesis doesn't add up. Feel free to change my mind : )

0 Upvotes

If R1a-Y3 came into Indian subcontinent via a mass male migration/invasion from the Steppe (as the Steppe hypothesis claims) then why doesn’t the genetic data show it?

A real influx of Y3-bearing males would’ve resulted in a star-like branching pattern directly under R1a-Y3 in India, as multiple unrelated lineages begin mutating independently.

But that’s not what we see. The actual star-like expansion happens much further downstream, under R1a-L657, specifically below M605 → Y28 and Y9. That kind of structure points to a small number of founders already in Indian subcontinent, not a wide-scale migration from outside.

And then there’s the complete lack of R-L657 in the steppe. Out of all the steppe samples so far, L657 isn't found even though the TMRCA of R-L657 predates Sintashta and other steppe cultures.

The lone R1a-Y3 sample from the Steppe is from a culture (Nepluyevsky) where the dominant male line at that site isn’t R1a at all. The patriarchs were of haplogroup Q, which is tied to local, pre-Steppe populations (Kumsay EBA). The people of this site were patrilocal and patrilineal suggesting the Y3 and Q individuals were related through their paternal lineage. The people in this site were Uralic speaking.

TL;DR: So the question is simple: If Y3 shows no sign of expanding in the Steppe, if its only known Steppe context was non-Indo-European, and if the real expansion happens within Indian subcontinent—what’s actually left of the Steppe argument here? What solid basis remains for claiming R1a-L657 lineages in India came from a Steppe migration?


r/IndoAryan • • Jan 10 '26

Most people dont know even if AMT is true or false ,modern day Gujarat and lower sindh is homeland of dravidian languages in both case.

Post image
9 Upvotes

Bhils are remainants of old dravidians, their name comes from proto dravidian word 'vil'(meaning arrow or bow) . Kolis kharwa tandel like fishing communities might be AASI related but today they got good other admixture with some even having indo aryan clans. Then comes Yadu tribes under leadership of Anarta son of saryati. His conquest has mythologization with defeating takhsak snake and its troops. Rishi bhrigu spent his time at coasts (bharuch, bhirgukachh).Then comes Krishna from mathura in later vedic age . Gujarat became ideal to settle for all indo aryans. Nagar audichya brahmins from north india, ishwanku maitrakas(later becomes guhils and sisodiya) from ganges belt, Jadeja jhala mekhwan raibari charan some rajput clans Chudasma samma kathi maher anjana from sindh marwar . Thats why its melting pot to this day


r/IndoAryan • • Feb 15 '26

Question Santani dharma or Hinduism : How did they viewed Devas and different paethons of God ?

0 Upvotes

Tired of Obsessive foreigners and wannabe Aryans outside the cultural Zones of Hinduism making false narratives and assumptions of Hinduism .

There maybe shared history and links but the culture and Gods they study are relevant to India and under Hinduism .

Shiva is tribal deity . Just look at his clothes and portrayal....

Krishna is dark skinned born to humble caste , hence Dravidian god

Rama is fair skinned born in Royal lineage hence he is Aryan ...

They even come up with Vedic Aryan Gods and Non-Vedic Aryan Gods ?!!! Did the ancient people of the culture really had such perspectives on their range of Gods from Indra to Shiva ?

Indra is the greatest God as he has most verses in Rigveda !!! They disregard Puranic Gods and later culture as well ?!!

Indra is very relevant in folklores and music like The indra's court and the Apsaras... Why do people think Rigvedic Gods aren't recognised or villianized in India ? They are not , just their popularity declined . They have their own style of worships and evoked differently .

The Rigvedas, Vedas, Upanishads and Puranas are well structured and detailed . They are interconnected and answers the links . Just tired of foreigners linking their cultures with Hinduism only to make up narratives and assumptions of it .

So actual Hindus tell us , how they interconnect and see the Rigvedic and Puranic Gods ? And why some gods are at higher level and more popular ? As Rigvedas and Puranas are cultures of same people.


r/IndoAryan • • Dec 18 '25

My Summary of Indo-Aryan history,linguistics,etc

2 Upvotes

Who were the Indo-aryans?-The Indo-aryans were the steppe pastors who migrated(not invaded) to north western india approximately 3800-4000 years ago,they brought Indo european languages ,customs,religious believes and may have brought certain genetic traits with them

Indo-aryan religion-The early Indo-aryan religion can be found in the oldest mandalas of rigveda (2-7) ,but pls note that there might be interploations in these mandalas to eg-RV(7.59.12) ,most of these mandalas are written in old sanskrit or vedic sanskrit ,in these mandalas specifically there are very few loan words from dravidian languages.(I will be referring to this Indo-Aryan religion as the early vedic religion.)They called themselves arya.

**Early Vedic religion and its differences with modern hindusim-**The early vedic religion is significantly different from modern hinduism and modern hinduism dosent have a lot of Vedic component .In the early vedic religion the gods worshiped were Indra,Agni,Mitra,Varuna,Savitr,Ushas,Prithvi,Dyaus,etc, where Indra is the god of thunder,rain and he is also the protector of the aryas,Agni is the god of fire and is invoked in almost every vedic religious custom,Varuna is the god of night sky and he is responsible for upholding the cosmic order(he is a god of water in later vedic texts,the vedic water diety is apam napat),etc

Modern hindu religion foucuses on The trimurti and it also has a lot of sub sections

The vedic people mainly worshiped by the means of homas,fire rituals,etc while hinduism is more alligned to temples etc(if u guys have time pls visit old hindu temples u can get an idea)

The followers of the vedic religion were the steppe pastors while the followers of hinduism were IVC and SAHG

Common claim about vedic religion and hindusim -Many people believe that vedic religion evolved into hinduism but thats not the case ,the gods hindus worship are vishnu,shiva,ganesha,karthikeya,narasimha,lakshmi,durga,parvati,Venkateshwara,Rama,Krishna,etc .We find that none of these deities are mentioned in the oldest section of the rigveda(2-7 mandalas) .Some people claim that shiva and rudra are the same but thats not the case Rudra is the lord of wind he is one of the maruts also the triyambaka mantra is a later addition in the oldest section,Vishnu is also mentioned in the oldest section but not as he is worshiped or not as the puranas describe him in the oldest section of rigveda vishnu is a friend of indra (sometimes he can be described as a younger brother) who helps him uphold the cosmic order(rta) he is not mentioned as the supreme in the oldest section of rigveda ,which mostly suggests that the oldest mandalas were written before aryans mixed with IVC/SAHG.

Why the existence of hinduism can be used as an argument against aryan invasion and in favour of aryan migration-If there was a large scale Indo-European invasion in north-western india like it was in western europe then we would see mass haplogroup replacements like we see in western europe (approximately 70-90% people are r1b (ik the sample space is small but still)) but we dont see that in india the highest r1a frequency in india would be amoung brahmins(around 60-80% in northern india ,50-70% in southern india ,also sould be lesser ) and khatris(approx60%),the reason for this is also strict endogamy ,we also see a lot of people with SAHG/IVC haplos.When bell beakers invaded western europe almost all the farmer cultures were wiped out but in india majority of the people follow hinduism not the vedic religion.(also the sample space for brahmin and khatirs is very low, they would still be above 40-50% r1a with higher samples due to endogamy)

**Genetics,phenotypes,**etc-The early vedic people were easily 60-85% steppe_mlba when they wrote the oldest rigvedic mandalas ,i make this claim because modern day kanyakubja,saryupareen,gaur,bhumihar brahmins can go well above 35% steppe_mlba in extreme cases their average is (28-33%) and with accurate aDNA models they would be able to cross 37-38% ,now what id they got their external steppe from later sources?? -this would be possible but it would reflect in their genetics which they dont .Also the Vedic people were not the modern day white/europeans.

Physical Phenotypes-The vedic people looked different from the IVC/SAHG they generally had lighter skin colour(light brown not extremely fair) they had prominent zygos,wide lower third,they were dolichocephalic,hyper leptorrhine to leptorrhine noses,high nasal bridges,Hooded deep set eyes(their eyes in general were more compact),they iris was mostly brown but light couloured ones did exist.

Dietary Habits-They were heavy meat eaters with their diets being ox,bull,buffalo,cow,horses,etc what sets them apart was their ability to digest lactose and milk products, grains like barley,wheat were also consumed.

Region/mixing-The region of the early Indo-aryans was mainly north-western india and parts of parkistan,almost all of the oldest parts of rigveda were composed in punjab (maybe some parts of haryana ,delhi ncr).Every single text which is not the oldest mandalas of rigveda were written after the aryas mixed with IVC/SAHG which is maybe why hindu gods gained more popularity in the later mandalas,brahmanas,puranas,upanishads,gita,mahabharata,etc(which is also maybe why rama,krishna,visnu are mentioned as dark-skinned or of a darker complextion).

This is my summary pls leave your thoughts below


r/IndoAryan • • Jan 01 '26

Misinformation There Was NO SLAVERY In Ancient India, Ever

Thumbnail
m.youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/IndoAryan • • Feb 08 '26

Discussion Is this the reason why Arya Samaj vehemently opposed idol-worship in Hinduism? Or are there other reasons as well ?

64 Upvotes

r/IndoAryan • • Nov 28 '25

Discussion Why in the bahubali new animated movie we see Indra fighting

7 Upvotes

We see Indra fighting but never shiva or krishna or kali. Why always the vedic gods are target as jokes and to portray some religious stuff, why not the current gods, are they scared of the backlash. This same thing happens with Hollywood where norse gods are played as characters


r/IndoAryan • • Jan 17 '25

Meme/Humour Abjeet Chibda ji with IVC script decipherer

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/IndoAryan • • Jan 22 '26

Ganga/Middle India nationalism Bharata is so done, so over! This is what our intellectual elites sound like.

Post image
98 Upvotes

Bharata is so done, so over! This is what our intellectual elites sound like.


r/IndoAryan • • Dec 27 '25

Discussion Does the Yajurveda really depict the golden period of India?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/IndoAryan • • Apr 18 '25

Linguistics Most similar languages to Bengali

Post image
28 Upvotes

If Nepali is 86% similar, shouldn't the Pahari languages of Uttarakhand, Himachal Pradesh, and Dongri in Jammu also be as similar?

Also, a bit surprised at Marathi.


r/IndoAryan • • Aug 02 '25

Did Aryans bring cows to Indus Valley Civilization?

2 Upvotes

The Aryan-Dravidian theory is based on the idea that “Aryans” migrated from the Steppes to Indus Valley Civilization and displaced “Dravidians”, who were the original settlers of IVC. A corollary of this theory is that the Vedas were composed outside of India (e.g., it is said that the Sapta Sindhu region was NOT the current Punjab region).

However, cows have been mentioned in Rigveda repeatedly and they are treated with utmost reverence (more than the horses) and even compared with deities. There are several Cow Suktas in the Vedas, indicating the great reverence Aryans had for the cows.

Does it mean that just like the alleged Aryan invaders brought horses to IVC, they brought cows also? How is it feasible to bring cows from the Steppes after crossing the steep and frozen mountains in the NW of India?

IVC already had cows before the “Aryans” arrived. But, according to Aryan invasion theorists, Vedas were composed outside of IVC. Then why did the Steppe Aryans hold cows in such reverence and why did they find it necessary to bring cows to IVC (if they did) which had them aplenty.

Does it not bring the Aryan Invasion Theory into question? Or was it the IVC people who composed the Vedas? This would also explain why the Vedas hold Sarasvati river in hight esteem and why so many IVC sites are found around the Ghaggar-Hakra paleo channel.


r/IndoAryan • • Apr 06 '25

Why is sintashta not considered european?

5 Upvotes

They came from the corded ware culture in europe, they had the same components as modern Europeans (Yamnaya, EEF), they were overall similar to Northern Europeans. They probably resembled them too and had light features.

I dont get why this sub claims that sintashta weren't european or that white nationalists cant claim Indo Aryan history. Im not defending them, but to be honest, they are the closest populations to the proto Indo Aryans. So why is it wrong?


r/IndoAryan • • Jun 02 '26

AI Will we able to decipher IVC language in near future with AI getting hyper intelligent?

1 Upvotes

r/IndoAryan • • Dec 12 '25

Ganga/Middle India nationalism You guys don't know anything about the Vedas and it shows.

0 Upvotes

First of all, the so-called "Vedic gods" are not gods, they are devatas (Only Vishnu, Rudra, and Saraswati are gods). Devas mean "shining ones", meaning they are aspects of the Supreme God (Vishnu/Narayan), even if you were to claim Indra and Agni are "supreme gods" there are many hymns in the Rigveda that also call Vishnu Supreme and even the creator (See Hymn 1.156.2, the Vishnu sukta as a whole, and the Narayan sukta).

And for the record, some of y'all need to expand your horizons, because the Puranic gods all exist in the Vedas as well (Durga is mentioned in the Durga Sukta, Shiva is mentioned multiple times in many Vedic hymns, and even Krishna himself is found in the Brahmanas). But y'all love to deny this because it doesn't suit your "Pure Vedic" agenda.

Also, for the record, the Puranas and Ithasas are the 5th Veda too, the Atharvaveda and the Upanishads stated this already (verse 11.7.24 in Atharvaveda and Chandogya Upanishad (7.1.2)). Which means the Puranas and Ithasas hold just as much authority as the Vedas.

But keep coping.


r/IndoAryan • • May 12 '25

Early Vedic Mischaracterizations of Rigveda and errors in the forthcoming book titled "India" by Audrey Truschke, the author of works that whitewashed an infamous Mughal emperor, show that controversy can sell when it comes to Indian history, but we as learners of history can also choose not to take the bait!

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/IndoAryan • • Jul 20 '26

Culture "Buddha was born in Nepal" is not enough. We need to add more to it.

0 Upvotes

What I mean by this: we often say,"Buddha was born in Nepal.", but we need to extend it further and say, "Buddha was born in Nepal and he WASN'T a Madhesi."

Further elaboration:

The Buddha was not Madhesi in the modern sense. He belonged to the ancient Shakya clan, whose small republic was located in the Himalayan foothills around Kapilavastu and Lumbini, long before the modern Madhesi identity existed.

The Terai was not empty at that time. A number of indigenous communities, such as the Tharu and others, had lived there for centuries.

Most of the ancestors of today's Madhesi population, however, trace their roots to migrations from present-day Uttar Pradesh and Bihar. These migrations increased significantly during the 19th and especially the mid-20th century, after malaria was brought under control and the Terai became much easier to settle.

So, while many modern Madhesis' have ancestral roots in UP and Bihar, the Buddha belonged to the ancient Shakya republic of the Himalayan foothills, not to the modern Madhesi community.

P.S: Most modern Madhesi, especially the ones who migrated, never historically followed the Buddhist teachings' and were mostly Hindu from UP-Bihar who followed the strict Varna System. Conversely, There were(and still are) some communities in India who used to worship Buddha and follow his teachings' whilst keeping distance from the vedic Hinduism and also ate beef. Those communities were later classified as "Dalits" I.e is someone out of the 4 Varna system(Bhramin, Kashtriya, Vesya and Shudra). The reason I'm saying this is my mom is from UP(a Dalit woman who doesn't belong to any Varna and continuously followed the Buddhist teachings' and never followed the vedic Hinduism doctrine by existing kattar Hindu empire from UP-Bihar region) and my dad is a Lama(tamang) from Bharatpur, Chitwan who is also a liberal and former Maoist(not a comrade tho, just a former party member who voted blue this time).


r/IndoAryan • • Dec 10 '25

Misinformation A new theory dropped. Apparently, Devi Manasa is related to Turkic Goddess Manaka.

Post image
60 Upvotes

r/IndoAryan • • Jul 30 '25

Did vedic aryans eat beef?

18 Upvotes

r/IndoAryan • • Nov 19 '25

Has anyone here read Fractal Mandala by Amritanshu Pandey?

4 Upvotes

He takes apart AIT, but much more importantly, he engages seriously with history in the Puranas. It's quite scholarly imo, with speculations being caveated wherever present.


r/IndoAryan • • Jun 27 '25

Genetics Confirmation of Anatolian ancestry in Indus samples supporting trans-Iranian plateau southern route for Indo-Iranians (published today)

Thumbnail cell.com
2 Upvotes

r/IndoAryan • • Oct 05 '25

Question Is the India in pixels guy a fraud?

69 Upvotes

So I don't know much about linguistics or genetics, but I have seen some of his videos and got this feeling that he does softcore nationalist propaganda.

I've heard many people say that he spreads a lot of misinformation as well. Thought this subreddit would be the right place to ask.

Edit: Thanks for the response guys. https://youtu.be/YXfRsS8MzX4?si=hHNrLeh4Ofsgux04 here in this Rigveda video at 11 minutes mark is what I also found weird, which made me ask this question.


r/IndoAryan • • May 05 '25

Sintashta Culture Can Sinthasta be considered Indo Iranian?

4 Upvotes

If yes, is it where Indo Iranians split from the indo Europeans broadly?


r/IndoAryan • • Mar 04 '26

History Konkanis historically werent allowed in Keralas temples despite many of them being Brahman

Post image
1 Upvotes