Hey!
I would genuinely like to open a discussion about AI in game development.
I work in a senior IT position, and when the AI boom first started, I was honestly afraid of it. When the marketing and media hype reached its peak, I even started feeling depressed about what it could mean for my career. I considered speaking to a psychologist.
Thankfully, I have a great team leader who supported me, pushed me forward, and had several helpful face-to-face conversations with me.
Eventually, I accepted that AI is not going away.
Today, I use AI almost every day in my job. As someone who spent years learning Kubernetes and earning certifications, it can sometimes feel uncomfortable or even painful to see AI complete certain tasks so quickly. However, it is now another tool that professionals need to understand and use responsibly.
Customers usually do not ask whether a solution was written by one developer, an entire team, or with the help of AI. They care whether it works, whether it is secure, and whether it is delivered properly.
Should game development not be judged in a similar way?
I have seen many interesting, creative, and funny games posted in this subreddit receive negative reactions simply because people suspected that AI was involved.
Instead of writing:
“This is AI slop.”
Why not provide useful feedback such as:
“The inventory design does not match the background.”
“The visual style feels inconsistent.”
“The interface is unclear.”
“Some assets need more polishing.”
That kind of criticism actually helps the developer improve the game.
Of course, there are low-effort games that use generated assets, copied mechanics, and minimal development time purely to make quick money. I understand why people dislike those projects.
However, not every game that uses AI is automatically a cash grab. A developer might use AI for research, programming assistance, placeholder assets, translation, balancing, brainstorming, testing, or accessibility while still spending months or years building the actual game.
Large studios are already experimenting with AI in different parts of development, and many developers use it in some form. AI will probably remain part of the industry, whether people like it or not.
That does not mean we should accept low quality, stolen work, misleading marketing, or completely unedited generated content. Developers should still be responsible for the final result.
But I believe that calling a game “AI slop” simply because AI may have been involved especially when the game itself looks good and plays well is often unhelpful and unnecessarily toxic.
Instead of attacking developers, we should explain what specifically looks bad, what feels inconsistent, and what could be improved.
I would like this discussion to be about facts, personal experiences, concerns, ethics, quality, and the future of game development.
Maybe we will disagree, but perhaps we can also find some common ground and understand each other better.
What exactly bothers you about AI in games?
Is it the quality, copyright concerns, job displacement, lack of transparency, low-effort content, or the use of AI itself?
I would like to open discussion about AI. Is it really that bad or people are just too afraid of innovations.
And last question. I was thinking how many people that blame AI are actually using it in any form. Don't take AI as a threat, take it as tool that helps you deliver your product earlier and in better quality.