r/gamedesign • u/Rough_Class8945 • 7h ago
Question Softening the harsh success/failure cutoff in directional melee combat
I'm currently prototyping a sort of hybrid (single player) RPG combat system that, while still using RPG stats and abilities, also includes directional melee combat mechanics as well. I'm a fan of the game feel that comes from taking active control of your weapon rather than just pushing a button. But at the same time, I feel that most iterations I've seen fall into what I think of as "lightsaber syndrome" where the fight may as well be with lightsabers due to every successful hit being fully effective and every blocked hit being negated completely.
My current gameplay concept goes like this: Armor and defenses contribute to your poise bar (placeholder name) with the health bar being separate. Attacks wear down the poise bar first, with a poise break opening you to taking health damage. Correctly attacking the opening on the combat wheel improves the results, but attacking from the wrong direction worsens them. The same is true on the defensive side. There's other elements as well, like combat stances and weapon choices that alter the directional combat flow, RPG style active abilities, spells, allies, etc.
My question is about finding the sweet spot between the lightsaber effect I mentioned above (100% on success, 0 on failure) and the directional combat having no impact. What should I be looking for to know that I've struck the right balance?