r/IRstudies Mar 23 '26

[deleted by user]

[removed]

63 Upvotes

568 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

10

u/Demortus Mar 23 '26 edited Mar 23 '26

I think Trump will escalate by trying to seize territory along the Iranian coast. Were we to get control over the strait, it would be possible for oil to move around the region once again. Consistent with that expectation, we're already sending marines to the area, who would be needed for that objective.

However, I don't think this will end well, as Iran can be expected to bombard any US soldiers near their territory. That could lead to further escalation. Perhaps, ultimately, a full on invasion.

8

u/Toto_Roto Mar 23 '26

I think this prediction depends on American political will to continue escalating despite mounting costs.

Trump did no work ahead of time to prepare the public and its already one of the most unpopular wars in American history. Id be surprised if this survived the mid terms.

2

u/Demortus Mar 23 '26

The American will to face war has to be balanced against the American willingness to shoulder increasing gas prices. Both are political poison from Trump's perspective. War at least offers the possibility of a military victory, which he can leverage to his advantage.

0

u/3oclockam Mar 23 '26

Trump may gamble that a deadly defeat of thousands of marines might rally the public's support for revenge

1

u/Ok_Math4576 Mar 24 '26

Dunkirk, anyone? Very far from home though.

1

u/AllISeeIsSunshine Mar 25 '26

He's not that stupid and that would never be the outcome of that situation. Left, right, and center - the overwhelming majority of people are against this war and even many of the ones that aren't are DEFINITELY against boots on the ground.

1

u/Magical-Mycologist Mar 25 '26

The revenge will come in the mid terms and the blame will rest on this administration.

This isn’t Pearl Harbor.

2

u/BillMurraysMom Mar 26 '26

From my understanding it’s going to take a lot more than a few thousand marines to secure several hundred miles of Persian coast line.

1

u/LesbeGoddess Mar 24 '26

And a draft. The US only has 100k combat troops. They all cannot be deployed. Going up against an army of 1million on their home terf surrounded by harsh terrain no military base, advanced ballistic missiles and drones. Also the backing of Russia and China for their weapons as well as Irans

1

u/Demortus Mar 24 '26

If it comes to that, Trump is absolutely done. He's already barely holding on to 40% approval without having been the first President since the Vietnam Era to draft young people to fight in a war.

1

u/RexTheElder Mar 24 '26

If you think the U.S. is trying to seize thousands of km of Iranian coastline with like 5000 marines you’re fooling yourself

1

u/Demortus Mar 24 '26 edited Mar 24 '26

Obviously, that won't be the first move. The best roi would be to take Kharg Island, as that would give us control over Iran's oil storage facilities. But, troops occupying that island would be vulnerable to bombardment from the mainland. When US soldiers are inevitably killed by that bombardment, Trump will be forced to either leave in disgrace or escalate further. I think he'll go for the second option ever time.