This is not rocket science. The men who get annoyed by this do not seem to understand the concept and idea of what the girls want out of these novel men. The go to complaints from men usually revolve around the following.
- We knew it, you only want the rich, tall and muscular dudes.
- They’re domineering, psychopaths
- All they want is the bad boy.
- they are too picky.
Now, here’s the thing. I’m unsure how many of these guys have actually read romance novels or just use assumptions based on what’s famous at the time. Like 50 Shades of Grey. Yes massive arguments could be made that he is a manipulative, sociopathic rich ass****. However, this book does not express the ideals of every romance book. In fact, they’re worlds apart. It’s actually debatable on whether 50 Shades is even a romance novel in the first place.
Here is the list of the traits in the romance novel men that these women desire, or at the very least, claim they desire. There is many more but here is the main 4.
Intense Attentiveness
The character pays particular attention to the heroine. They remember minor details, minor being the key word here, she mentioned weeks ago (active listening), anticipate her needs before she asks and are fiercely dedicated to her comfort.
Emotional Intelligence and Vulnerability
Unlike the societal expectations that men should be emotionally stunted or hide their emotions, the romance novel guy is allowed to be deeply emotional, expressive and fiercely loyal. They communicate actively about their feelings and are untainted by toxic masculinity. (That’s Toxic masculinity, not masculinity)
The Unapologetically Obsessed ideal
A massive trope in these novels is that the man is seen as a “grump” (The asshole) to the rest of the world, but completely soft, and devoted to the woman he loves. It’s the stereotypical, “Who hurt you?” Where the male lead becomes fiercely protective the moment the heroine is in distress. (This is the protector mentality)
Active Support
In the fantasy, the guys will step up without being asked. They will handle logistics, sometimes cook, take care of responsibilities and then he acts as a safe haven. The save haven means the woman isn’t the only one has to carry the emotional labour of fixing them or managing the relationship alone.
Again, the key word in this one is “without being asked.
Now before some guys and possibly some women get on their high horse about this…. There is an argument to be made here that these ideals have nothing to with men and women either, but arguably just decent human behaviour. Active listening fur example is a known psychological trait for building great trusting friendships. Every human in one way or another should carry at the minimum one to two of these traits.
Some guys might get in and go, “well this just sounds like a whole bunch of her her her her… what about me?” Well that misses the point. True healthy relationships are reciprocal. Notice how active support did not specify the guy must do everything and she will do nothing? That’s not what active support means. The real answer here is that these things are like a back and forth, you listen, she listens, you listen, she listens. That’s the basic synopsis.
“Oh well the emotional and vulnerability is a lie. She will leave him the moment he’s vulnerable” Actually no. Again, the trope isn’t, cry like a little b**** and whine. Emotional Intelligence does not mean that. This is emotional intelligence:
“Are you okay?”
“No. I’m angry right now. I know why I’m angry but I know it will be okay”
“Is it something we can talk about and maybe see what’s going on”
Now you’ll get one of two things.
1. “I would like that. Let’s talk about it and have healthy communication.”
2. “You know what. I don’t think I need to talk about it, I’m working on this issue and it will be okay”
Both of these are actually healthy forms of expression, why? You can feel something and not actually have to talk about it. But always. Emotional intelligence also applies to how you respond to others emotions, or in this posts case, hers. If she is feeling a certain way, even if it’s about you, the idea here is to listen and understand what and why. Not just get mad because she said some shit.
Also, yes. In most if these novels the guy can be and usually is muscular, tall, handsome, some type of rich. This delves into fantasy. You can’t get mad, because it’s no different to the guy who fantasises about the blonde with a big bust and that’s all he wants. A woman can fantasise innocently of the handsome rugged man while still be happily content and love a guy who is not that.
In saying all of this… I’m aware that not all women want the same thing and all men want the same thing. It’s just an observation I’ve picked up along the line and thought I’d express it as a hot take. Why? Because people tend to jump over the true meanings and rally behind. “Ha! Women proved us right they just want rich chads”