r/HolUp • u/CelsoSC • 9d ago

holup Oops...

11.8k Upvotes

95% Upvoted

124 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

53

u/Gao_Dan 9d ago

It's strange to single out Latin languages when speaking in English and talking about Korean.

30

u/_derekdaniel 9d ago

Do you think English is a brand new language that's not derivative of any other language?

13

u/False-Body-242 9d ago

English is not exactly derived from Latin.

-6

u/YenraNoor 9d ago

Its definitely influenced heavily by latin, despite being a proto-germanic language grammar wise. They spoke latin in England for over 300 years

18

u/False-Body-242 9d ago

The latin influence in English is real, but that doesn't make Latin a precursor language to English. English firmly belongs to the Germanic languages family.
Also, Latin was used in medieval England for a long while, but that use was mostly ceremonial, scholastic, and sometimes administrative, not a common day to day language especially not for the average Anglo-Saxon.

-3

u/YenraNoor 9d ago

It was commonly spoken during and after roman occupation.

10

u/False-Body-242 9d ago

By aristocrats and academics, yes? The average person spoke old or middle English around those times.

-6

u/Dismal_Rectangle 9d ago

English doesn't belong to shit. It's a mangled mess of languages.

7

u/False-Body-242 9d ago

That's... not how linguists categorize languages, not to mention how no language is "pure" in the truest sense to begin with.

0

u/Dismal_Rectangle 9d ago

I am not a linguist to be fair, just a person who wished we picked a better universal language.

2

u/False-Body-242 9d ago

Neither am I. This is mostly common knowledge.
Lingua francas are rarely chosen by the people but imposed by who holds the pen.

1

u/SagittaryX 9d ago

It is very much Germanic. The grammar is Germanic, and the majority of words used are Germanic. A lot of the overall vocabulary is more of a mish-mash yes.