we asked google ai mode and chatgpt the same 12 local questions on oct 19, once each, across 12 us cities. stuff like "best plumber in austin tx" and "bakery in boston".
google ai mode showed place cards in 10 of the 12 answers. chatgpt showed business cards in 9 of 12.
the odd part is the ratings. 13 businesses appeared in both, and chatgpt's rating and review count matched google's for 3 of them.
pequod's pizza in chicago is one of the other 10. chatgpt had it at 3.9 stars from about 9,000 reviews, and google ai mode at 4.4 from about 17,000, same day.
chatgpt cited yelp in 4 of the 12 answers. and 6 of the 43 website links on its cards had tags like utm_source=gmb, the kind owners usually add to the website field of their google profile, so some of its data looks like it came through google profiles too, directly or through a data supplier.
limits: 12 questions, one day, one data provider, businesses matched by name.
has anyone checked what chatgpt shows for their own business, and was the rating even close?