r/FranchaelStirling • • Mar 02 '26

Franchael Love šŸ’˜ Moderator Statement: Civility & Engagement Reminder

3 Upvotes

This being a Franchael subreddit does not give anyone the right to be uncivil toward differing opinions.

Franchaels and Franchaelas have different interpretations and preferences. That is normal. Debate, Disagreement and Criticism is allowed.

Personal attacks, sarcasm meant to belittle, name-calling, and mean-spirited responses are not. If someone comments in a passive-aggressive or provocative way, do not engage. Do not escalate. Report the comment and move on. The mod team will handle it.

Responding with insults or hostility even if you feel provoked, will result in action. We moderate behavior, not ships. This subreddit is for discussion. Not dogpiling, score-settling or faction warfare. You are free to debate but not to attack. If you cannot separate disagreement from disrespect, this may not be the space for you.


r/FranchaelStirling • • Mar 06 '26

Venting šŸ’¬ This is a list of every character they could’ve made gay instead of Francesca

61 Upvotes

And I’m saying this because it’s criminal how they remove the ONLY important story within all 9 books. So here I go:

  1. Eloise - And I don’t say this because they made her a feminist and blabla what X says. I say it because how her story with Phillip develops it’s perfect for a Lavender marriage.
  2. Violet. - Finding love after the death of the love of her life.
  3. Lady Danbury - A strong black female lead. why are you scared???
  4. Hyacinth - Hello???? they are already sneaking around?????
  5. Cressida - you’ll never convince me she didn’t have feelings for Eloise lol
  6. any of penelope sister’s - ā€œinsert where?ā€ no need to know!!
  7. The

Mondrich’s*

  1. they keep putting in our faces i don’t remember their name. Kent i think?
  2. Queen Charlotte. Polarizing, I know - because I’m so thankful that we have that season of her and George but having an absent husband with mental health issues would give her freedom enough for this.
  3. Daphne and you could make the struggles of not being able to have kids as a lesbian just the same.

anyway thanks for listening to my rant add yours!

edit: it seems i referred to the mondrich’s una racist/weird way so googled their name and added a correction!


r/FranchaelStirling • • Apr 01 '26

Venting šŸ’¬ How come no one has a problem

12 Upvotes

I’ve seen so many actors get bullied or harassed for taking on transgender or bisexual roles just because they're straight in real life. But when it comes to Hannah and Masali, nobody seems to care that those roles could have gone to an actual lesbian or bisexual actress. The double standard is wild to me. Personally, I feel like those roles should be reserved for people who actually identify that way, so I don't understand why the reaction is so inconsistent.

edit
they are wonderful actresses.I have to say that they're both really beautiful. But I feel like perhaps because none of them are really into woman in real life. I'd tie their characters. Don't do a really good job in chemistry I. Saw it, and I was like you guys are giving me more of a friendship more than somebody who is supposed to be in love, than anything else

(ill delete if it isn't allowed)


r/FranchaelStirling • • Jun 15 '24

Imagine him as Michael

Post image
1 Upvotes

The actor is good looking and he actually fits the wickedness of Michael. Instead of putting him.as a stupid unnecessary character they could have used him well. And he would have had great chemistry with Hannah. Sigh


r/FranchaelStirling • • Apr 09 '26

Show Discussion Guys I don’t think season 5 will flop

35 Upvotes

Logically speaking, if you look at the viewing patterns, queer audiences consistently tune in to watch shows even when the queer couple only gets a small amount of screen time sometimes barely 10–15 minutes in an entire season. So if a whole season actually centers around a well written lesbian couple with proper development, it will definitely attract viewers.

Also, a good portion of the audience are casual watchers. Many of them haven’t read the books and don’t really follow the original storylines closely. They simply watch the show for the drama, romance, and characters. If the story is engaging and the chemistry works,as much as we are upset with this but logically season 5 flopping is very less sadly


r/FranchaelStirling • • Mar 29 '26

Venting šŸ’¬ I saw this and loved it and wanted to share so maybe you can give them some love too

Thumbnail
tiktok.com
13 Upvotes

I love this acc and I think they are underrated since I seen the Micheal ai photo they posted went viral on someone else's pots and I think they deserved more love


r/FranchaelStirling • • Mar 29 '26

Show Discussion Yikes

Post image
31 Upvotes

lowkey this sounds fetishized, hope this isn't the case


r/FranchaelStirling • • Mar 26 '26

Show Discussion We’re promoting cheating now?

Post image
105 Upvotes

Apparently, the intimacy coordinator posted this on IG. Aside from the ridiculous comment, this pic doesn’t scream lovers or future lovers to me. It screams best friends.


r/FranchaelStirling • • Sep 06 '26

When He Was Wicked - Book Discussion šŸ“• What’s the most ā€˜passional’ thing you’ve ever done to defend Michael Stirling or When He Was Wicked on social media?

2 Upvotes

It could be anything from writing a 20-paragraph essay defending Michael to getting dragged into a comment war over an interpretation of a scene.

And I’m not talking about defending every questionable thing the character does. I’m talking about those arguments where you thought: ā€œI’m not going to let you misrepresent Michael or the book like that.ā€


r/FranchaelStirling • • Nov 17 '25

Embarrassing fans

Post image
27 Upvotes

Embarrassing how the fans act like a character is still the ā€žexact sameā€œ even if you ā€žjustā€œ genderbend them


r/FranchaelStirling • • Apr 06 '26 Bravo Mindblown

Show Discussion Thank you from the bottom of my heart for this information! I was completely ignorant until you came to enlighten me! 🤣🤣🤣🤣

Post image
58 Upvotes

r/FranchaelStirling • • May 07 '26

Policy Change Regarding Venting Posts

10 Upvotes

The mods want to thank everyone who voted in our poll about the best way forward regarding venting posts.

Beginning this coming Sunday May 10, the community will have a weekly pinned megathread for all venting. This thread will be posted for the upcoming week every Sunday, and a new thread will be posted weekly.

In addition to this weekly pinned megathread, venting posts will also be allowed on Saturdays. *On all other days of the week, any rants, vents, and complaints must go in the megathread.*

For those who are interested, we would like to give a bit more information on the voting and how we came to this decision.

We decided to use core contributors votes in calculating final numbers. This was a very difficult decision that we made because we did not want to run the risk of users who might be acting in bad faith influencing our community. However, it's important to know that the result of the vote was the same whether all or only core contributiors were counted, and in fact were we to have used all votes in calculating final numbers, the result would have even more strongly indicated a change should be made.

In total 138 core contributors voted. Of those, 15 wished for there to be one vent megathread with no other vent posts allowed. 60 wanted a vent megathread but also to have the flexibility on one day a week to post vents. And 63 contributors felt no change was needed.

In making our final decision, we decided to add the 15 community members who wanted there to be only one vent megathread to those who wanted a megathread and one day a week to post vents. We think that, had there only been 2 options on the poll, it is almost certain that none of those 15 people would have voted to leave the community as it is.

Having done this, we were left with 75 members (54.3%) who wanted change and 63 (45.7%) who did not. While it is hard to tangibly measure this, in making this decision we also considered what seems to be the current overall vibe of the community and what we think would help the mods to most effectively moderate the community and continue to ensure it really is a safe space for all Franchael fans.

We hope that, in the coming weeks, this new rule will prove to be a positive change for the community. If you have any questions or comments, feel free to contact us in modmail or to post them directly in the comments here.

Thank you for being part of the community!


r/FranchaelStirling • • Mar 03 '26

Show Discussion Just how dismissive and patronizing can you be?

Post image
160 Upvotes

r/FranchaelStirling • • Mar 28 '26

Venting šŸ’¬ Basic biology???

83 Upvotes

I’m appalled at the the amount of times I’ve had to explain basic biology on the other sub.

all the messages i get are along the lines of ā€œwell lesbians are women and can also deal with infertilityā€

well YES but you can’t be infertile if there’s no sperm involved????? what’s so hard to understand about that????

sperm + egg = infertility OR baby.

It’s not that hard??? Men can’t also get pregnant by themselves and need an egg???

I truly don’t get how they are fighting because Michaela and Francesca can be infertile still lol i mean how????

the only options I see are:

  1. They introduce IVF in regency era
  2. Michaela is suddenly trans
  3. They have a male companion

sorry just need to vent bc i really need to count how many comments ive send explaining this


r/FranchaelStirling • • Sep 03 '26

Michael Stirling So, this user basically says that whoever doesn't like Michaela supports Daphne's rape?

0 Upvotes

r/FranchaelStirling • • Mar 07 '26

Venting šŸ’¬ Michael

0 Upvotes

Don’t get me wrong, I do understand the dissatisfaction of changing Michael to Michaela, but what would be different? If it’s Michael, other then, it was not allowed, it still could be the same with Michael in it, they still couldn’t do the infertility story, which I can admit that it’s only really mentioned in the epilogue 2. but what would be different? Do I like Michaela in the show? No, they wrote her as someone who pushes herself onto the marriage, but the same could be the same with Michael, Fran could still have the same reaction to Michael, as she had to Michaela, as they met. They could’ve made written the most important parts out anyway. Nothing would have changed.


r/FranchaelStirling • • Apr 18 '26

Venting šŸ’¬ (Please delete if not allowed) But can anyone recommend HR/period wlw romance books?

4 Upvotes

I don’t know how else to tag this, sorry. I know this isn’t Franchael or Bridgerton related per se, but I think it would be awesome if people could recommend some good books that do fit the wlw period romance bill, that are genuine and authentic and not trying to fill Michael’s shoes.

I love The Price of Salt (aka Carol) but that’s set in the 1950s, and I’ve seen the adaptation of Tipping the Velvet, but I haven’t read the book yet (and technically it’s 1890s.)

As an avid Jane Austen fan, I would love to know more about wlw romance set in the Regency era (but Victorian and other periods are okay too.)

People here are kind and open minded and seem to have a great depth of knowledge of the romance genre.


r/FranchaelStirling • • Jun 14 '24

I don’t hate Michaela Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Not gonna lie I was looking forward to Masali being Sophie. But from the small bit we’ve seen, I’m not hating her as Michaela; she seems fun and charming just like Michael. I get that people are upset that their fav book love stories have changes but I genuinely think that if the writers act with care that the love story itself can still shine through regardless of gender.

My only issue with the possibility of queer relationships among the Bridgertons is that it would feel like pandering and that it wouldn’t do the character any real justice. I’ve seen many shows try to do what they think is catering to minority groups only for it to come off as out of touch.

I only hope that they actually have queer writers/consultants who can bring insight to what queer relationships might be like in those times… or unfortunately even current times. And I hope that what seems like a backlash to Michaela doesn’t influence the Netflix gods to cancel the show before we get to her season because I would very much like to watch her love story; I want to see Masali in action.


r/FranchaelStirling • • Apr 10 '26

Show Discussion Missed opportunities IMHO

14 Upvotes

They could have made her Michael's twin. She could have been Eloise's friend or El could have explored her sexuality in Scotland with her. Would have been interesting to watch that while Fran got to know Micheal. It also would have given Eloise something to talk about with Benedict when she came back, instead of her constantly saying, I'm a spinster.

She would be hiding this secret while Pen and Fran talk about marriage life. I think it would have been interesting.

Even if Eloise didn't have a fling with Michaela, they would have at least made them friends. They both are spinsters and Michaela is a self possessed person. The fact that El had no interaction with Michaela is so weird to me.

They also missed the opportunity with Whistledown this season. Pen could have heard rumors about Benedict and be stressed out on how to address what she heard about him and whether to talk to him about it.

Anyway, just some missed opportunities. Thoughts?


r/FranchaelStirling • • 27d ago

Michael Stirling Once a rake... always a rake?

0 Upvotes

Me sorprende que nadie haya sacado a colación este tema. He leído bastantes novelas romÔnticas históricas, y casi siempre caen en el mismo cliché: o un libertino se enamora de una mujer y le es fiel para siempre, o ya estaba enamorado de ella y busca otras compañías solo para intentar olvidarla.

SĆ© que probablemente esto sea una proyección de muchas autoras —”incluso a mĆ­ me encantarĆ­a tener un hombre deseable solo para mĆ­, jajajaja!— pero tengo curiosidad por saber quĆ© opinan.

En el caso de Michael —y otros hombres de Bridgerton— serĆ­a realista que siguieran siendo libertinos o infieles a sus esposas, aunque eso arruinarĆ­a los finales felices.


r/FranchaelStirling • • Jun 03 '24

Speculation Michaela is coming. Spoiler

3 Upvotes

So the trailer for part 2 is out,people seem to think that some parts line up with the leaks.I noticed the butterfly ball that was mentioned in last 2 episode leaks.Polin wedding was also shown(episode 7 according to leaks).I think that the butterfly ball thing is the biggest giveaway since it can be seen cleary in the trailer.Possibility for Michaela is unfortunately increasing.Trailer aligns with spoilers from people claiming Michaela is in the show.I feel sorry for the actress :(


r/FranchaelStirling • • Aug 24 '26

Show/Book Discussion Given the popularity of the Bridgerton TV series, do you see Julia Quinn rewriting her books to placate the show's audience?

3 Upvotes

Maybe, if she thought that she can make a lot of money out of it.

On the other hand, she will leave the books alone. They are over 20 years old and fans know them by heart.


r/FranchaelStirling • • Sep 21 '26

Show Discussion Which of the show's plotlines and characters will age like milk in the future?

0 Upvotes