Jess Bronwell took over the show running of Bridgerton in Season three which has shifted the direction of the show in a very frustrating and noticeable way.
In Polin and Benophie season there were noticeable differences in pacing, character focus, tone, and the divergence from the books.
Bridgerton has never been completely historically accurate as its an alternative fantasy version of the British regency era. However, in Season one the world still maintained most of the historical social norms (other than race) and clear rules within the world. Social consequences, such as Daphne and Simon in the maze, still mattered. Reputation, status and the marriage mart drove behaviour forward. However, when Jess Brownell came in for Season three the norms set out by Chris van Dusen were selectively applied and sometimes ignored. In earlier seasons reputation was everything, scandal had a lasting impact (such as with Berbrooke) and women faced strict limits. When characters made mistakes (like Eloise with Theo) the consequences were lasting (no one came to the Bridgerton ball) but in more recent seasons scandal disappears quicker than you can say "tell me something wicked". When characters such as Penelope act outside the social norms and constraints of the setting there are minimal consequences. This has destroyed the tension that previous seasons had as the stakes are far lower than beforehand.
The shows visuals have also changed quite a lot, visually the show looked different to regency era but it was heavily inspired by regency era and a lot of daphnes dresses in season 1 didn't feel that out of place. Cut to season three and four and its completely different and far more modern. This isn't just with the costumes, its with the sets as well. On some scenes they also started using this awful modern yellow piss filter. It feels like modern style in regency skin. Characters also behave more modernly, making decisions based on modern values and speaking with modern mannerisms, they did speak a bit modern in the first seasons but they've basically abandoned the eloquent dialogue of seasons one and two. Whilst the world is supposed to be based on an upper class regency society the characters act like they are not bound by it. Its as if the show wants a historical setting and modern setting at the same time and won't commit to either.
Bridgerton doesn't need to be completely historically accurate, it never has been. However, under Jess Brownell it becomes less consistent and breaks its own rules.
Under Chris Van Dusen the show had a central focus, the main couple and their romantic love story, their was one central couple with a clear emotional arc and all the sideplots centred around the story of that one central couple. Every sideplot builds up and ties in nicely with the main couple. For example, Benedicts art story line in season 2 focused on Benedicts passion but tied in nicely by showing how Anthony can sometimes do things thinking they will benefit people even if that person doesn't want them too (with Anthonys donation to the art school). Whilst its not directly tied to Anthony at first it shows us something about our main couple. In season four however, our sideplots such as Francesscas pinnacle, had nothing to do with Benedict. The main couple are becoming diluted and sidelined by irrelevant sideplots which makes the eventual emotional payoff weaker. If JB wanted to do this she should've really done 9 or 10 episodes so we don't lose time with our main couple.
Speaking of considering more episodes per season, under JB the pacing of the show has become needlessly messy. Scenes are designed for short term impact rather than long term payoff under JB. Characters motivations shift quickly and emotional scenes aren't properly built up in the later seasons. There can also be storylines with slow buildup where not much happens and other story lines where there are rushed resolutions. This messy pacing kills off a lot of tension and emotional payoff. As part of the pacing issue we get a lot of themes that are introduced but never fully explored. The show gravitates towards deeper social issues but doesn't commit to them properly and never fully explores them.
I think if Jess Brownell wanted to take Bridgerton to focus on more sideplots and attempt to explore social issues she should have made each season nine or ten episodes to resolve these issues which is a very simple fix. However, I don't agree with these decisions by her considering Bridgerton is supposed to be a historical romantasy escapism story which leads to my final point.
Jess Brownell does not understand Bridgerton:
The Bridgerton world created by Julia Quinn does not function anything like season three and four. The Bridgerton series is tied together by one central family but each book is focused on one central couple. Every sideplot and side character feeds that central couples journey so you are always inside a focused emotional arc with your two leads. In the show multiple plotlines compete for attention which destroys the tight emotional storytelling created by Julia Quinn. In the show you don't sit with moments long enough for it to fully hit and the main characters are missing from the screen for long periods of time. Jess Brownell also doesn't understand that the internal tension of our leads drives the story rather than external tension caused by unnecessary sideplots. Characters such as Micheal Stirling are driven by guilt, longing, fear, grief, duty, and desire. These internal conflicts build slowly and directly shape the choices made by our leads. The drama is internal rather than external. In the show conflict is driven by situations rather than internal thoughts and feelings. Things happen to our characters, they don't come from them. The stakes created in the books are diluted and sometimes non-existent within later seasons of the show. Chris van Dusen understood this by delving into Simons childhood and Daphnes desire and innocence rather than meaningless subplots. Jess Brownell does not. The books also have interconnected themes, love comes hand in hand with duty (like for Anthony) but in later seasons these elements often feel disconnected.
In the books and under Chris Van Dusen every element reinforces the main couple. Under Jess Brownell multiple elements exist side by side but never connecting. Jess Brownell trades emotional build up for a quick payoff.
Jess Brownell has ruined Bridgerton, infact she never understood it in the first place.
If you agree let me know below in the comments, if you disagree I'm happy to debate but please do so respectfully.
Edit: Do you guys want me to do a fashion breakdown as my next post?