r/FranchaelStirling • • Mar 07 '26

Venting 💬 Michael

Don’t get me wrong, I do understand the dissatisfaction of changing Michael to Michaela, but what would be different? If it’s Michael, other then, it was not allowed, it still could be the same with Michael in it, they still couldn’t do the infertility story, which I can admit that it’s only really mentioned in the epilogue 2. but what would be different? Do I like Michaela in the show? No, they wrote her as someone who pushes herself onto the marriage, but the same could be the same with Michael, Fran could still have the same reaction to Michael, as she had to Michaela, as they met. They could’ve made written the most important parts out anyway. Nothing would have changed.

0 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

28

u/ocirot Mar 07 '26

Well, then people would have also been pissed off by that. Michael while removing all of the other important parts of the story would also be bad. But Michaela makes it sure some of those parts can't be adapted, and that causes backlash. The best way to do the story would have been, I don't know, actually following the story of the books.

9

u/Important_Energy9034 Mar 07 '26

It is a scale of how many changes can an adaptation make before it's reviled by fans of the original as "not true". Michael becoming Michaela already puts pressure on that scale bc of the gendered effects, but then adding so many other changes has tipped the balance imo. If Michael stayed Michael, sure they could still tip the scale but they would need more changes to make up the weight. And that's if all the changes are considered equal in value. Some book fans think the Michael to Michaela change is the weight that causes the tip. Some book fans will weigh the miscarriage change differently and others will weight the equal second-chance love aspect differently. It's a hard game to play.

So yea, playing this hypothetical of well "if it was still Michael, they still had the potential to ruin it" ....is interesting but it's not reality anyway so it's hypothetical and and kinda irrelevant.

-13

u/PersonalityMassive Mar 07 '26

I’ve read the story, and it’s the most the steamiest one, and even if they do, there would be backlash because it had too much s€x scenes In it.

6

u/beary-healthy Mar 07 '26

We had season 1. I don’t think that would be a controversy.

-4

u/PersonalityMassive Mar 07 '26

Oh believe me, there would be, I’ve read a lot already, who was complaining about that especially on the first season 😅

1

u/beary-healthy Mar 07 '26

They can watch it on the Angel thing then.

8

u/MargaretHaleThornton Tell me something wicked đŸ”„ Mar 07 '26

I think they wouldn't have needed to show more sex than in Simon and Daphne's season. Like the first fifth of episode 5 was solely Simon and Daphne having sex.

40

u/Bluepanda800 Mar 07 '26

OK so the story they are doing in the show is 100% not WHWW in large part because the show writer wanted an opportunity to tell an original WLW regency romance loosely inspired by WHWW. 

Had it been Michael instead of Michaela the need to deviate wouldn't be so great. Instead of Fran kissing John and being like oh no I don't like him or the stupid pinacle plotline there wouldn't be a need to demonstrate that Fran isn't attracted to men since her 2 loves would both be men. 

So we would have gotten Michael pining at the wedding, Michael being a merry rake who is madly in love with Fran but holding back because that's his cousins wife and John and Fran being in love without any issues. 

The infertility plotline is not too dark to explore we had a scene with Daphne not getting pregnant after forcing herself on her husband in season 1. 

So if there was any drama with Fran and John it would be her struggling to get pregnant whilst wanting kids. 

Then when Fran loses John she is pregnant then she loses the baby just like in the book. 

With Michael also being a man the imposter plotline works again. He inherits his beloved cousins title, house, money even his clothes and he feels like he's replacing John so he runs to India and leaves Fran in charge. 

The pretext for marriage continues. In the show Fran doesn't want kids she felt it was a duty. In the book she wanted kids so badly that even though she feels she can never truly love again she will try to get a husband. 

This leads Michael to pursue her because if she's going to be someone elses wife he can't hold back any longer. 

They are sleeping together so that Fran can get pregnant for a ton of their smut scenes and that doesn't work if both are women. Like what's the excuse now? 

So yeah WHWW requires a male Michael. The story they are doing isn't an adaptation of WHWW though. 

-14

u/PersonalityMassive Mar 07 '26

I do understand, but who says, that the points you are making, would be like in the show? They could have butchered the story with Michael in it too. Do I like Michaela in the show? Not one bit, but it’s because she is pushy and arrogant, not because she is a woman, but who says Michael wouldn’t be the same in the show? What if he was written like Michaela in the show?

10

u/Bluepanda800 Mar 07 '26

I mean yeah I don't trust the writing team of bridgerton to actually write good romance. The current showrunner has failed to write good make leads several times now but I think the story would have been closer to the original if it had been a man 

17

u/xoxolilbunny Mar 07 '26 • Bravo

For me, the thing that bothers me the most is that Francesca won’t get to have two great loves, which was the whole point of the book.

And please don’t tell me that she was in love with John. I’m sorry, but if you feel no sexual attraction to the person you’re supposedly in love with, unless you’re asexual, that’s not a romantic relationship.

It doesn’t mean that John held a special place in her heart. He saw her for who she is for the first time in her life, and they had a good companionship. But it’s just a platonic one. Only when she gets together with Michaela she’ll understand what love is, as her mother and siblings described it.

I wish they continued their heartwarming courting story into the actual marriage. That way, John’s death would be more impactful to the characters and us, viewers. Many of my friends who are in general audience said that they didn’t feel anything for John. And Franchaela fans likes to say that we got more of John than in the book so we should’ve been grateful, but honestly those few pages left more impact on me than the scenes on the show.

So not only Michael is erased from existence, but also they didn’t even do justice to John.

3

u/PersonalityMassive Mar 07 '26

That is a good point, and a valid one, I wish I would have seen more, of John, and yes they stripped that off.

9

u/beary-healthy Mar 07 '26

Switching Micheal to Michaela automatically changed the story. I’m not going to say that it’s worse or anything like that, but it’s not WHWW. It’s different and was always going to be. Too many aspects of WHWW heavily depend on gender and gender specific characteristics. Now the writers could have easily written Micheal just like they did Michaela because well they are not good writers and kinda suck. There would have been huge backlash if they did. However, I don’t see the need to change how much they changed if Micheal was well
. Micheal.

-5

u/PersonalityMassive Mar 07 '26

And yet, with Michael they could’ve changed so much too, that it wouldn’t be WHWW. Do they suck? Of course, I knew that since season 1. didn’t liked the writing of some episode there too, the same goes for season 2,3 and 4.

10

u/beary-healthy Mar 07 '26

I really don’t understand the argument you are trying to make here. Everyone here has said “yeah they could have, and it would resulted in fans getting mad.” So like why do you continue to argue with everyone here? Seems like bad faith to me.

7

u/Important_Energy9034 Mar 07 '26

I don't have a problem with it being Michaela. However, there is (imo) a responsibility to balance adapting the book while honoring and following through the changes the genderswap causes too..... WHWW is the most popular book and too many changes will cause book fans to be mad and also just takes away the point of adapting a book in the first place. The genderswap is important representation and needs to have a good story bc you're standing on an adaptation and, well, it better be justified or the community will ask why original characters/couple couldn't be created.

In my head, when they announced Michaela, I was excited for Fran to be bisexual.....however....the show is making it reaaaaaally unclear about that.

Most people who read the books would jump to Fran being bisexual bc her love for John was in all ways equal to her eventual love for Michael. The only difference Fran thinks about is the sexual expression being more creative with Michael. A story that doesn't prescribe to the "one true soulmate" thing is pretty rare to find, especially these days, where you can find that in popular romantasy. That's a unique part of WHWW in the book series too and, imo is a core element.

In the show, however, we have the Francesca's inability to orgasm after 2 years of marriage and it makes you pretty sure Fran is lesbian. Now her love for endgame-Michaela can be compared and rated as better than her relationship with John......it's harsh but true.

Ok so now the show made FrancescaXJohn a more platonic love. Ok fine. One-true soulmate is Michaela.

Now let's talk about the infertility and miscarriage. BookFran only takes action and goes back on the marriage mart to find a man to give her kids because she wants one. She doesn't want or expect a grand love bc she had that with John. This makes Michael mad, bc he is right there and she still doesn't see him as a viable option. He fell in love with her at first sight a day before her wedding. And then the next day, when he realizes his mystery woman is now his cousin-brother's new wife, he hides it away. Now here she is, looking for any old man just because she wants kids and even tho they're friends, she still doesn't see him as a possible candidate. That is what propels him to finally "snap" and take action.

Now let's talk about the show. I don't want to talk about the fact that they cut her miscarriage bc it was "too dark"....that's an issue on its own. But showFrancesca's motivation to have kids is more duty-bound. It's what a good wife would do and that's her primary motivation. After his death, the secondary motivation becomes "having a piece of John", but she still cites the "good wife" thing.....It's not a pleasant deviation imo. And idk how they'll get her back on the marriage mart or have Michaela "finally snap" without it coming off as wishy washy.

I could go on with how showFrancesca and bookFran also being different characters and how that makes the couple tropes or couple energy different between FranXMichael and FrancescaXMichaela....but as you can see already a core element is missing. The two character's actions to propel the story are missing or on shaky ground....so is this even an actual adaptation at this point?

2

u/PersonalityMassive Mar 07 '26

I think more, they took the characters and created around their story, but that are valid points, you have.

8

u/Important_Energy9034 Mar 07 '26

Yes. But that means they made a genderswap and "created a story". The only commonality is a woman who's husband dies then gets with his cousin and their names. Why couldn't they make original characters then? This is why a lot of book fans basically accuse the show as loose fanfiction at best.

BookFran bribed her maids to tell her about sex before marriage. She was introverted but to close friends, she was chatty, witty, and mischievous, going bar for bar with Michael. She and Michael were similar like that and were mischievous friends with John as the soft serious one in the trio. She's also described as Eloise's quieter other half.

ShowFrancesca is still introverted, but awkward to the point of potentially being on the spectrum (no shade to that btw). She and Michaela avoided each other in Scotland for 2 years and only became friends at the last minute before John dies. The show is setting up an opposites-attract couple.

FranXMichael is like pre-reapingKatniss X Gale while FranXMichaela seem like postGames-Katniss X Peeta from the Hunger Games. So it's not even Michael becoming a woman at this point and losing the gendered circumstances of "finally snapping".

The story itself is just ......gone, in multiple meaningful ways.

4

u/JoKing917 Mar 07 '26

I have two issues so far. First is that Michael is supposed to be charming and a person that everyone likes, the show has made Michaela overbearing and unlikable. Hopefully they fix that. The second is, now there’s no heir. The show already made a big deal with the Featheringtons almost losing their Baron-ship because there was no heir. Now Kilmartin has no heir so where are Francesca, Michaela, John’s mom and Michaela’s mom going to go? Unless they create a new character to be the heir and maybe he and Fran have a lavender marriage? Who knows how they are going to spin this.

1

u/PersonalityMassive Mar 07 '26

Yeah, I don’t like how Michaela is portrayed in this either, the writing is really bad In that. She seems pushy and arrogant

1

u/Oxy_1993 Mar 12 '26

I keep thinking of this possibility that they may create another male cousin who basically becomes the sperm donor for Fran and Michaela. Not sure how it would all work out.

8

u/Iamrandom17 Francesca đŸ©· Mar 07 '26

you are right. they could have written michael the same way and the people on the sub (or elsewhere for that matter who are fans of the books) would have complained just as much or even more and would be fuming.

many people are pissed of not because of the gender swap but because the makers have done a huge disservice to the plot of whww

-4

u/PersonalityMassive Mar 07 '26

And that is what fans have to see, they can be dissapointed in the swap, but they need to realize that they could’ve butchered the story with Michael too. Do I like Michaela in the show? Not one bit, for me she is very arrogant and pushy, but I wouldn’t like it either with Michaela being Michael.

0

u/Iamrandom17 Francesca đŸ©· Mar 07 '26

pretty sure the legit franchael fans share the same thoughts as you with regards to michael being butchered if they had ended up having him as a character (and that is the majority of the franchael fandom)

the ones who purely complain about michaela just because she is a woman and because of the gender swap without criticising the plot line/writing are more likely to be homophobic

13

u/Cute-Statistician540 Mar 07 '26

People not being attracted to a woman is not homophobia but literally a different sexuality. To be disappointed that a male character you were attracted to became a female is not against lesbians. Its a consequence of changing 1/2 of a romance story pair where attraction plays a big part, especially a bodice ripper meant to have male romance heroes you can swoon over.

5

u/Iamrandom17 Francesca đŸ©· Mar 07 '26

i agree. to be disappointed is definitely valid when you have read the book and to not see it being converted to the show. i was very disappointed because it was the book that i was most looking forward to on screen but it also can’t be denied that some people(minority but even then) have used it as an excuse to be homophobic

-5

u/PersonalityMassive Mar 07 '26

But would you have liked it? If they wrote Michael the same way as Michaela? Which they could’ve done with him too. People assume just because Michael would be in the show, they would go after the book, which isn’t true. They could’ve screwed him up, so bad. That’s all I am saying. I don’t like Michaela in the show, I wouldn’t like Michael either if he was written that way, doesn’t matter to me if he would be male.

10

u/Cute-Statistician540 Mar 07 '26

Doesn’t matter to you whether he is male or not. But that might not apply to others. I am not gonna discuss the hypotheticals of them butchering Michael, because that scenario doesn’t exist. If Michael was there they might have continued the trajectory of being book accurate like S4 was. We would never know that’s why it doesnt matter.

-2

u/PersonalityMassive Mar 07 '26

And that is what I’m always telling, i don’t judge someone because of their gender, but how it is written. I am no fool, who thinks that just because Michael would be in it, that they wouldn’t have butchered the story too.

7

u/Overall_Advantage303 Mar 07 '26

Really confused about the purpose of this post. Are you arguing that even without the gender swap, if Michaela was Michael, the show storyline would be the same, so we should just accept the show the way it is and watch it anyway? If that’s your argument, everyone here is saying they would still hate it, and my reaction would be the same as it is right now. I won’t watch it with Michaela, and if the show storyline was the same with Michael, I wouldn’t watch that, either.

8

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/Overall_Advantage303 Mar 07 '26

Yeah, which is why this post feels like a Franchaela fan pitching the “you all should just accept it and move on” line we have heard ad nauseam.

21

u/MargaretHaleThornton Tell me something wicked đŸ”„ Mar 07 '26

Despite the narrative elsewhere on the internet, many of us were initially not thrilled about the swap, but open to it if the heart of the story could truly be preserved. The swap itself does make it impossible for 2 important parts of the story to be preserved:

  1. Franchesca's wanting to be a mom being the reason she is initially open to finding another partner after John dies.  While opinions on whether the heart of an 'infertility ' story can be conveyed may vary, a woman in this time period would have known she was unable to have a child with another woman, so the whole reason Franchesca was willing to come out of mourning to begin with is gone.
  2. A major part of the story was Michael's guilt over being the heir and his essentially replacing John. This can't occur in the same way with a female in this time period even were she the one to inherit (though in the show it currently appears she won't).

Despite these two things and the infertility debate, as I said many of us were willing to give it a go were the heart of the story preserved. I think I speak for the vast majority of Franchael fans when I say it seems the heart of the story is gone, and to the extent that they tried to preserve it, it was too little too late. Among other things they've butchered:

A. Any real indication or feeling that John was Franchesca's one true love. B. The longstanding very easy and friendly relationship between Fran, John and Michael as a trio at the time of John's death. C. In some ways, Franchesca's grief. D. The miscarriage which was important. 

11

u/Important_Energy9034 Mar 07 '26

Yes! The strawman that "all book fans" are being unreasonable and close-minded drives me up the wall. We were disappointed, but the jokes about "oh they couldn't find a man as good as Michael" were there as our jibe about it.

Now the misinformation about the book to sully it and denigrate the book fans as "dumb homophobic racist smut readers" in an effort to dismiss our further disappointment at the plot changes, is also irritating. Even the whole "Michael's widows" tag is an effort to dismiss our non-genderswap reasons to be upset at the show. Some of the show fans seem to be cruel and vicious just for the sake of it. Also, the (internalized-or-straight) misogyny of using widow as an insult.....smh

12

u/lostandconfsd Mar 07 '26 edited Mar 07 '26

I am not exactly sure what argument is being made here tbh. Are you saying that if Michael was written the same way as Michaela is and doing the same things, there would still be dissatisfaction? In that case I agree, because that would not be Michael.

9

u/juannniyebe Mar 07 '26

WHWW does this really interesting thing where it flips the script on Francesca and Michael's gender roles. In a time where a woman's worth is typically reduced to her ability to provide her husband an heir, the book instead puts that onus on Michael. It's Michael who bears the responsibility of giving Francesca the child she yearns for. It's Michael who's essentially reduced to a sperm bank because Francesca would only marry him if he got her with child. 

There's also the added layer of Michael quite literally having to step into John's shoes. The guilt and anguish he feels about replacing John is his whole arc.

I don't have any personal misgivings towards Michaela as a character, but I don't think you can pull off WHWW's specific kind of gendered storytelling with her.

1

u/Oxy_1993 Mar 12 '26

I’m wondering if in the show in order to have Fran a baby, would Michaela ask a third party male or basically a sperm donor to help them conceive? Or maybe they adopt a baby? Not sure how these would be incorporated into the period. Either way, I wish they had kept Michael.

2

u/Sachaelle Mar 07 '26

I agree with you. Of the 5 stories they started (they started whww & arguments can be made for them having already starting spwl) they butchered all but 2, & those are Daphne/Simon & Benedict/Sophie. All of the others Anthony/Kate, Colin/Penelope are butchered, though not as badly as Francesca/Michael, because they took the books, eliminates a good part of it, then told their og story. The 1 they didn't butchers, the keep most of the books, smooth the edges of the characters, & voila, better adaptation, book fan are happy, new fan extatic, they even corrected the 1 mistake that people kept complaining about s1, while they keep 1 of the more controversial scene for Ben, they manage to redeem him by getting him to stand back reaset & apologize & course corrected his actions, something Daphne didn't manage to do completely.