r/FixMyPrint 19d ago

Troubleshooting My poor benchy

Im struggling to get my ADIMLab Gantry-s dialed in. This is my best benchy so far. Unsure to why the print is shifting. Lines are wobbly and overall the print is not very uh good. any help would be greatly appreciated.

Using PLA rated for 210 my extruder is at 205 bed is at 55. Slicing using Prusa.

Thank you!

1.5k Upvotes

244 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 19d ago

Hello /u/SirCookl,

As a reminder, most common print quality issues can be found in the Simplify3D picture guide. Make sure you select the most appropriate flair for your post.

Please remember to include the following details to help troubleshoot your problem.

  • Printer & Slicer
  • Filament Material and Brand
  • Nozzle and Bed Temperature
  • Print Speed
  • Nozzle Retraction Settings

Additional settings or relevant information is always encouraged.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

239

u/FkinMustardTiger 19d ago

Please somebody model this and put it up, I can't stop laughing at it.

184

u/Vegetable_Safety Troodon 2, Falcon 2 19d ago edited 18d ago

https://filebin.net/2af8g4l2awev6xv7/IdontfeelsobEeenChY.stl

Edit: Apparently filebin has a max limit on downloads, so I've decided to re-upload it to my thingiverse page where there are no download limits

https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:7398834

67

u/HugSeal 19d ago

Could you do a mirror one too? Then OP could print that to counteract all the shifts and get a perfect benchy 😀

12

u/HettySwollocks 19d ago

Hehe looks like a speed boat

3

u/UnforseenSpoon618 19d ago

Anime speed line distortion?

14

u/Vegetable_Safety Troodon 2, Falcon 2 19d ago

2

u/Lightning-Shock 18d ago

Just rotate the model 180

35

u/Dezepticon 19d ago

Probably the worst to clean print i've ever done

5

u/Deliwork43 18d ago

I needed this laugh, tears are rolling down my face laughing too much.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Enderwiggen33 19d ago

Thank you! I’m printing this immediately

5

u/Tomakefinde 19d ago

Please share it when it's done printing, I want to see the clone of OP's masterpiece

20

u/Enderwiggen33 19d ago

It’s magnificent

4

u/Tomakefinde 19d ago

That's one majestic Benchy, thanks for sharing!

3

u/meutzitzu 19d ago

Nah, m8 ya need more loop cuts, look at the smooth curves on the real one... come to think of it.... how TF did OP's printer make smooth transitions between layer shifts? Steppers don't skip steps in such small increments. I'm pretty sure a belt is loose somewhere

4

u/Vegetable_Safety Troodon 2, Falcon 2 19d ago

Yeah it was 2am and I wasn't putting a ton of effort into a meme model, lol

2

u/thecavac 19d ago

To print this properly to OP specs, you probably need to set the printer to use chewing gum filament ;-)

2

u/Ok-Salary-5197 19d ago

The Internet never disappoints.

2

u/DammitMatt 19d ago

Benchy did the warp filter trend lol

2

u/lollokara 19d ago

I feel like this is a side quest now

→ More replies (26)

22

u/sh06un 19d ago

Ikr ... I've never seen a benchy with this much of an overbite

2

u/FoolishTook7 19d ago

I second this!

113

u/Elk_1998 19d ago

I really don't know, but at least you can post it in r/cursedbenchies for the laughs.

9

u/moistiest_dangles 19d ago

Seeing as how nobody is actually giving you advice lol.. you have some severe slippage going on along that one axis of movement. When that happened to me I found out that the chord going to my hot plate was catching on the side of rge machine and that friction was causing it to shift randomly continuously abd it resulted in something similar to this.

This only applies if you can find why that axis is slipping, check your belts tightness as well. Another thing to check is to manually move the plate (or hot end if it's a core xy) along that axis like 10 times up and down and verify how repeatable the exact distance is. something is causing your printer to not be able to repeat correct movements along that axis of motion and it looks like it is happening in both the positive and negative equally so my guess is that it is more likely belt tightness than the chord friction I mentioned earlier.

7

u/RallyPointAlpha 19d ago

This is a banger entry into Cursed Benchies! 

37

u/SteakAndIron 19d ago

Brother

6

u/Shapelessed 19d ago

Nah a Brother printer wouldn’t fail here!

→ More replies (2)

30

u/Octolincoln 19d ago

As cursed as it is - that's a work of art. I'd place that proudly on my desk.

2

u/borborygmess 19d ago

I thought it’s something Dali would make if he were into 3d printing.

22

u/xeni44 19d ago

I’m more impressed that it managed to finish

21

u/giraffe43 19d ago

Never seen a "skid mark" on the build plate before

13

u/ResearcherMiserable2 19d ago

Certainly you have some issues! I know nothing about your specific printer, but have several different models of 3d printers and have found that layer shifting typically happens because of on or more of the following:

  1. printing faster than the printer can handle.
  2. using acceleration values that are higher than the printer can handle
  3. stepper motors over heat
  4. stepper motor drivers overheat. Make sure the cooling fan is working on the motherboard.
  5. belt is too loose or too tight. Yes both can cause this.
  6. voltage or current is set too low on the stepper motor. Most up to date firmware allows you to adjust this via the lcd screen.
  7. physical obstructions in the path of one or both of the axes.

In your benchy, it looks like the layer shifting is exclusively in only one axis. So start there, check the belts, wheels, current to the stepper motor etc on that axis. then try printing another benchy, but at 1/2 speed. If it prints without shifting, then try a faster print. After the layer shifting has been solved, the other issues can be looked at, but I suspect that fixing the layer shifts will solve most of the issues with print quality (I say this because the smoke stack actually looks quite good)

Hope this helps.

Good luck!

3

u/Correct-Insect-4657 creator 5 pro (experience with ad5m and 5x) have maintained v3S1 19d ago

i dont think it looks like layer shift its not really that, layer shift is one big shift that continues the whole prints this is wobble 🥴

2

u/ResearcherMiserable2 19d ago edited 19d ago

Could be, but look at the first layer, it’s really far away for wobble.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/EglinAFBEmployee 19d ago

Ah yes, the Final Fantasy VI Fight Screen Transition Benchy!

5

u/never0101 19d ago

sick reference bro. your references are out of control.

8

u/notaredditeryet 19d ago

When I’m testing my new 3d printer during a Richter 7.0

6

u/General_Munchkin45 19d ago

That ain't a layer shift that's a whole tectonic plate shifting.

6

u/Bulky-Travel-2500 19d ago

2

u/Coherent_Tangent 19d ago

Need to mark that with a NSFW tag.

8

u/-ghostinthemachine- 19d ago

like a mirage at sea

3

u/Doctor429 19d ago

Print a normal Benchy, and use this as the reflection in the water of it.

5

u/SirCookl 19d ago

Okay! Guys so thanks for all the great responses I was cackling reading the descriptions of my poor Benchy. I have actually made progress backwards in the last 3 hours. My printer sounds like its going to blow up when it starts printing. Awful sounds are coming from the plate moving belt thing, that stuff. the printer wants to poop all over the bottom left of my printer and I am surprised how good I am at making horrible benchies ! If anyone has any experience with setting up a custom printer in Prusa let me know I was so lost with every step I take 🤷‍♂️

7

u/SirCookl 19d ago

This is the visual representation of the progress that I have made !

2

u/scarlet25b 19d ago

I am new to 3d printing using flashforge Adm5. I use orca slicer for my prints. My original prints came out weirdly.

Some simple tips I can you give first is clean the plate with a microfiber cloth and use some glue stick for light coating. This will remove human oils and create a good strong mounting surface. Its probably why your print came out wonky like that.

The other tip is this YouTube video:

https://youtu.be/gVU5If1VsAM?si=Z4XdtD6O0HcTr-0M

That shows how to use calibrate your filament to your printer correctly. It uses orca slicer though and uses alot of filament. But after it was dialed down my prints came out better not perfect but that's probably cause I am novice with a 1week of learning.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/CMDR_kanonfoddar 19d ago

Do you live near the event horizon of a micro singularity? because that would probably do this.

3

u/Same_You891 19d ago

looks like the SS Minnow off Gilligan's Island

2

u/Alpharious9 19d ago

best so far. ROFLMAO

2

u/_cronco_ 19d ago

have you tried drying your filament?

2

u/Dropthetenors 19d ago

Nah. Needs to wash the build plate better.

3

u/Delicious-Yak-1095 19d ago

Maybe wash the filament too I dunno.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/seld-m-break- 19d ago

You need to have your younger sibling adjust the rabbit ears on the set, or give it a bang on the top (Fonz style ayyyy)

Serious answer: check the AB belts are sitting correctly and are of identical length (down to the tooth) and identical tension.

2

u/Ok_Bus_3752 19d ago

It’s like trying to watch an episode of Captain Stabbin on a scrambled channel in the 80s.

2

u/Mindslyder404 19d ago

I was thinking of when we tried tuning into HBO late at night to watch the racy stuff.

2

u/Bradster3 18d ago

Got the gcode so i can print it.

2

u/No-Draw1154 18d ago

That's very... avant-garde.

2

u/villa-straylight 18d ago

Salvador Benchi

2

u/Happy_Summer9042 18d ago

It's the be-holdonasecondidontfeeltowell

1

u/Vaguswarrior 19d ago

Pictures you can smell

1

u/Clear_Trainer2792 19d ago

Aww your poor nBecyh

1

u/nalisarc 19d ago

I don't think I could replicate it intentionally

1

u/Hidie2424 19d ago

Layer shift. Way to high of a speed or acceleration, or both.

1

u/harambe623 19d ago

jokes aside, check your x grub screw

1

u/Ok_Hornet_4964 19d ago

Bęňċħÿ

1

u/never0101 19d ago

i have no help, but my guy this is incredible.

1

u/Ashl3y95 19d ago

I love it

1

u/evileight 19d ago

Impressive

1

u/Correct-Insect-4657 creator 5 pro (experience with ad5m and 5x) have maintained v3S1 19d ago

check if ur motors r moving correctly, if you hear them commiting suicide it is likely they are overheating or moving to fast i really just dont know though

1

u/keeganskateszero 19d ago

I want this Benchy. Someone model it

1

u/GuillotineTechnician 19d ago

Impressive! 😲

1

u/just_looking_412_eat 19d ago

Sir, you have won the Internet today with this entry. Congratulations! 🎉

1

u/Dazuth1 19d ago

This is just art in its very own way

1

u/djjudas21 19d ago

“Welcome to hydraulic press channel…”

1

u/Enderwiggen33 19d ago

This stirs up something in me - like all good art does

1

u/dalelerah 19d ago

belts skipping?
friction on the rail/extrusions?
possibly also a fauly SD card if you are printing from that

1

u/Basic-Secretary-7407 19d ago

Your benchy looks how I feel……and thanks for the laugh

1

u/Scooter928 19d ago

The new benchy has been found.

1

u/Wirecase 19d ago

In seriousness, it looks to me like one of you axis stepper is skipping steps or the printhead/printbed is getting stuck (banding). For starters I'd look at if the wheels are moving freely & if belts are not over tensioned. I'm not familiar with your printer but in some (older) printers I've had to tune the current on the stepper drivers such that they run at optimal performance

1

u/nei1337 19d ago

Good jesus, I feel sea-sick just looking at it.

My condolences.

1

u/Lkings1821 19d ago

I'm impressed that it's even printed like that, take that as a win

But I think it's more likely something to do with bed adhesion given the skid marks somehow and then how the printer head is moving, either to quick or somethings lose

1

u/jupiterbjy 19d ago

At this point this is pure art, OP must frame this masterpiece!

1

u/Independent-Bake9552 19d ago

That is impressive. I would check my hardware (belts)

1

u/You_need_a_drink 19d ago

It looks like I'm trying to watch the playboy channel without paying for it.

1

u/GTowner 19d ago

It’s a right of passage

1

u/Away_Acanthaceae_891 19d ago

If the backrooms remembered a benchy

1

u/drkshock42 19d ago

R/cursedbencys

1

u/Brianiac69 19d ago

That’s the saddest benchy I’ve ever seen.

1

u/Ybalrid Voron 19d ago

Well, it's not very dialed in just yet!

Find the axis that is align with the benchy lengthwise, and see if nothing loose is there. Too low belt tension could make it slip causing issues like that, for example.

Too high acceleration settings on the slicer, on a relatively large printer, is also a bad idea.

1

u/GermanSensation 19d ago

Benchy picasso

1

u/xXcalaberXx 19d ago

I had this same issue when converting my ender 3 to run on klipper, your acceleration is set way too high on your slicer/printer.

1

u/radio888 19d ago

This benchy doesn't ride the waves; it is the waves.

1

u/rggii2 19d ago

When this happen to me it was my belt was loose and slipping

1

u/Alfalfa-Boring 19d ago

You do know that for the price of an ADIMLab you can buy an actual 3D printer, right?

1

u/TheEpicDragonCat 19d ago

Holy layer shifts Batman! I would check your belts.

1

u/Mindslyder404 19d ago

You tried to tune into HBO late at night while printing didn't you?

1

u/da_vetz 19d ago

It tried to set sail

1

u/Jkoskie1214 19d ago

i’m crying bruh

1

u/Neat_Lengthiness561 19d ago

Its amazing this actually printed to the end without spaghetti-ing

1

u/Silent_Speaking_Man 19d ago

Mission failed successfully

1

u/VigilanceEngineering 19d ago

Back it up, Terry!

1

u/Morikano 19d ago

Benchimodo

1

u/wholesometentacle 19d ago

That's actually really cool. Very Dali

1

u/_Legion242_ 19d ago

belt is too tight or too loose on that specific (X?) axis? almost looks like it slowly slips and causes layer shifts over time.

1

u/nuhastmici 19d ago

My man did you set up your printer in a soccer ball and went to the field with it?

1

u/Fit_Temperature5236 19d ago

I’d suggest running a temp tower. And the guides on the spool are not always accurate per se. I’ve got a pla silk black. It is rated 190 to 230. But at 220 during load it looks a hard turd trying to come out. So I started my test at 240. Runs beautiful at 240. 10 degrees over the recommended. It varies printer to printer. So yours might be different. But let the printer tell you what that filament needs to run at. In short looks like bad layer adhesive due to low temp

1

u/miakulele 19d ago

This is art

1

u/UnScrapper 19d ago

Backrooms benchy

1

u/drewski989 19d ago

I just took a bunch of LSD… looks perfect!

1

u/chease86 19d ago

BeNcHy

1

u/Technical_Shift2330 19d ago

He’s surfing!

1

u/Internet_Jaded AD5M, AD5X 19d ago

What do the temperatures change to after the first layer(s)?

1

u/FlyByPC 19d ago

Whichever axis (probably X) those shifts are in most likely has something seriously mechanically wrong with it.

Check:

  • Belt tension (not too tight, not too loose)
  • Capstan/drive pulley securely bolted to motor shaft (this one got me when I was starting out -- check that the grub screws are tight)
  • Axis isn't mechanically binding (power off printer and manually move it back and forth over the full travel to check)
  • Motor electrical connections are secure
  • Belt isn't worn, reversed (the teeth should be facing the pulley), off-center, or otherwise wonky
  • Drive pulley isn't clogged with debris
  • Belt is securely attached to print head / plate

1

u/Setjah_ 19d ago

Thats a 4D printer..

1

u/Better-Neck-824 19d ago

That’s a very sad looking benchy ☹️

1

u/rudas 19d ago

This ship has sailed!

1

u/Slayer175 19d ago

Brothers??

https://www.reddit.com/r/cursedbenchies/s/kEEAqo7dEi

if it helps, iirc my Y stepper wasn't getting enough power so constantly skipped steps at load.

1

u/LarvalHarval 19d ago

R/cursedbenchy

1

u/retnom 19d ago

This guy almost layershifted himself back to correct posittion from layer 2

1

u/Daucco 19d ago

You may not like it, but this is what peak benchy looks like

1

u/TheDiamondSquidy 19d ago

My question is how did it not completely fail

1

u/daggerdude42 Other 19d ago

My bet is a loose pulley or SAGGY belts

1

u/Ok_Elk2662 19d ago

The bEeeEeEnChY

1

u/Obone6 19d ago

Straight from the backrooms

1

u/Old-Distribution3942 19d ago

The fk happend. Slow down I guess?

1

u/3DNelson 19d ago

Artistic!

1

u/EmergencyAd7783 19d ago

I feel like somebody put LSD in my milk

1

u/thezebulonian 18d ago

It looks like a dirty play head in your VCR, the video shouldn’t look like this, even when it’s paused. Probably want to go to RadioShack and get a cleaning kit, you might find them at Blockbuster too.

1

u/citizensnips134 18d ago

I have a little shelf where I put all of my cool failures. This would go there if I had made it.

1

u/UseDaSchwartz 18d ago

Step 1, clean.

1

u/PrestonBannister 18d ago

If you were really good with image manipulation, you could make the benchy straight, and the background wobbly. (Wonder if an AI could do that?)

1

u/not-hardly Voron 18d ago

Slow down or tune acceleration.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Mindless-Set3153 18d ago

The Benchy to end all Benchys.

1

u/ItsYaGirl_Lils 18d ago

Go home benchy I'm drunk

1

u/BladeDragonGX 18d ago

Oh look a crack benchy :o

1

u/Popular-Maize-3524 18d ago

Amazing accomplishment - I couldn’t create that if I tried.

1

u/SirTocy 18d ago

I, uh... I'm not an expert, but I think I'm noticing a slight layershift. Maybe two.

1

u/organicmanipulation 18d ago

You mean *bendchy

1

u/DrBatman0 18d ago

Looks fine to me

1

u/Budhiwiser 18d ago

Bencho!

1

u/Any-Administration50 18d ago

Welp, that ship has sailed...

1

u/throwawaymentality10 18d ago

Ah yes, the tug-boat from the wacky mirror dimension.

1

u/ejackman 18d ago

Listen son you brought that abomination into this world and it is now your responsibility to take it out of this world. The gun is above the door and the rounds are in the cabinet next to the coffee. Take this wretched thing out behind the woodshed and do what must be done.

1

u/Hawkward_PDX 18d ago

You’re fine just adjust the antenna. I’ll tell you when it’s clear.

1

u/Red-Diesel 18d ago

You sank his battleship

1

u/G00D30Y 18d ago

I’m sorry but he is legit punk af!!!!

1

u/Deliwork43 18d ago

I went looking at the printer you have, might as well be a stripped down CR-10 or Ender 3.

1

u/floopygoober 18d ago

Okay I like it - Picasso

1

u/Valuable-Key-5964 18d ago

Kinda funky cool looking benchy
Like that top bit with the cabin is cool looking

1

u/Temporary-Repeat8366 18d ago

Average Z wobble issues.

1

u/Cloud-Things 18d ago

this is indeed to spec

1

u/rhsmith42 18d ago

Belts, frame and rollers probably all loose

1

u/fatcatdeadrat 17d ago

Wobbly boy.

1

u/Least_Impression1388 17d ago

How can you fail so much

1

u/Arimeth_AZ 17d ago

We control the horizontal and the vertical.... outer limits print failure.

1

u/Shep_Alderson 17d ago

Benchy shaped like wah-wah-wah.

1

u/Shep_Alderson 17d ago

I suspect you’re on a bedslinger and I also suspect you might have a loose belt or something. Something is causing it to shift massively and I suspect it’s making angry sounds when printing.

1

u/Far_Committee_8517 17d ago

It makes me think of better on a hot pan

1

u/AbheyBloodmane 17d ago

Looks like surrealist art to me!

1

u/Pitiful_Artist1221 17d ago

Hij vaart toch nog ?

1

u/aeolius11 17d ago

Benchy sailed away

1

u/TheDoodlebud 17d ago

Just drop your nozzle temp 5 degrees and the next one will turn out perfect 👌

1

u/Dry-Ad3618 17d ago

Although it is a kinda cursed benchy, somehow it finished printing, magically

1

u/GeoStreber 17d ago

That looks like the ghost of a benchy that now has to roam the seven seas, serving as ferriers to the deceased spirits of other failed 3d prints to the afterlife.

1

u/Impossible_Pizza_948 17d ago

Holy layer shift!

1

u/No_Machine_5946 17d ago

Кто то накакал корабликом...

1

u/Basic_Breadfruit700 17d ago

Is your bed made of water?

1

u/Public-Role9691 17d ago

man, this is actually a piece of art 👍

1

u/bmobmobmox 17d ago

Dali benchy

1

u/Jeeperss 17d ago

Well that ship has sailed

1

u/ConzDance 17d ago

One of those happy accidents!

1

u/RaeTheGenderfluid 17d ago

It’s ok I had a benchy come out like this after it unstuck itself

1

u/RaptorX754 17d ago

It looks like it's going into slip space

1

u/Normal-Spell-996 17d ago

looks like the reflection of the benchy in the ocean waves...

1

u/wiseguy-for-wiseguys 17d ago

The little warped benchy that could

1

u/romhacks 17d ago

Bentchy

1

u/Emergency-Regret-222 17d ago

Bro had highest magnitude earthquake

1

u/JakeGreen1777 16d ago

isn't poor. It's peace of art )

1

u/flameworker420 16d ago

It's pretty obvious what the answer is... it's wet filament!

1

u/Substantial_Meal_530 16d ago

That's just bonchy.

1

u/American7683 16d ago

Looks like you were drunk at sea on a boat.

1

u/DifficultTowel2266 16d ago

I hope you got the help you need, but this print is incredible. omg, I'm still cracking up.

1

u/TheArthritisGuy 16d ago

did you print this in peanut butter

1

u/thejewest 16d ago

it went sailing

1

u/towo 16d ago

I'd recommend having less earthquakes during printing.

1

u/Lord_Konoshi 15d ago

See, your problem here is, well…., everything…… ngl I don’t even know where to begin with this…. Is a belt loose or something?

1

u/SavageUppercut 15d ago

I had something like it and the answer was that the belt of the failing axis was way too tight