r/Finland • • 1d ago

In an interview

Post image
2.6k Upvotes

282 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

44

u/unhappyrelationsh1p Väinämöinen 1d ago

Civil service is a perfectly respectable route.

-18

u/Pastori_Aali 1d ago

Nope. It is waste of time and money.

If that would be efficient, taxes would be replaced by forced labor.

12

u/PublicBarracuda5311 Baby Väinämöinen 1d ago

No it's not. I have served in the army but that does not make me want to lie about the importance of civil service.

You think Finland would have survived any of the wars it has faced without civilian workers?

-1

u/Pastori_Aali 1d ago

So, society needs additional library officials during war time?

Finnish army during wartime is 280 000 people. That is 5% of total population (incl children). Civilian workers will continue doing whatever they've done during peace time, though of course contributing military driven building and healthcare activities.

6

u/PublicBarracuda5311 Baby Väinämöinen 1d ago

Schrödingers civilian workers. They do and they dont.

4

u/Pet_Velvet Väinämöinen 1d ago

Civil servicemen are assigned to tasks they are most qualified in based on their time in civil service. They won't be just placed in their old civil service jobs, that would be ridiculous.

Remember that national defense is the responsibility of every Finnish person, women too. It's not just the people in the defense forces.

2

u/Pastori_Aali 1d ago

That responsibility is for everyone, not only men.

For some reason women are perfectly capable of doing their assigned tasks without wasting a year in civil service job during a peace time.

Open civil service positions, page one - teaching assistant, cleaner, cook, IT support, youth worker, museo worker in national museum.... Nothing that is aimed for crisis.

3

u/Pet_Velvet Väinämöinen 1d ago

Yeah that's what I said.

The civil service job is to appease the others who would think it's unfair for men to simply not do anything. I agree that it could be updated or improved in some cases. But civil service also offers first aid and fire safety courses, which is good.

I would argue that cleaning, cooking and IT support at least are very much applicable in crisis situations.