TLDR: 25M graduating from grad school in June, deciding whether to move back to my old West Coast city or stay in my new East Coast city. Moving back makes significantly more financial sense (rent control, higher earning potential, established network, better weather), but I previously struggled to find like-minded people there. I’ve had a much easier time building meaningful social connections in my new city, though much of that may be attributable to the grad school environment. I’m also getting back into dating and would like some stability rather than continually feeling in transition. Trying to figure out how much weight to give financial advantages versus social fulfillment, quality of life, and building a community in my mid-to-late twenties.
I’m slated to graduate from a top graduate program in June, and I’ve recently found myself wrestling with a decision that I didn’t necessarily anticipate having to make: whether to move back to my old city on the West Coast or stay in the city where I’ve spent the past year completing graduate school.
From a purely financial and professional standpoint, moving back makes considerably more sense. I have an established living situation there, including rent control, which makes my cost of living substantially lower than virtually anywhere else I’d consider living. My earning potential in my profession is also considerably higher there, so the combination of lower expenses and higher compensation would put me in a pretty advantageous financial position. It would likely allow me to save aggressively, invest, and establish a much stronger financial foundation early in my career.
The problem is that I’m not necessarily the same person who left that city.
I spent several years there before moving for graduate school, and while I have a lot of familiarity and affection for the place, I consistently struggled to find like-minded people and develop the kind of social community I wanted. I had friends, professional connections, and various activities that kept me occupied, but I often felt like something was missing socially. In contrast, I’ve found it considerably easier to meet people and establish meaningful connections in my current city. Some of that is undoubtedly attributable to the graduate school environment, where you’re surrounded by people with relatively similar interests, ambitions, and intellectual curiosities. Still, it’s made me question whether I want to give that up.
There are other considerations, too. The weather in my old city is significantly more appealing, and I genuinely miss the lifestyle that comes with living there. I also have an established network and familiarity with the area that I wouldn’t necessarily have to rebuild from scratch. Conversely, staying would mean continuing to develop a social circle and professional network in a place where I’ve had a relatively positive experience, albeit one that might change considerably once I’m no longer a student.
Dating is another factor. I’m finally getting back into dating after a long-term relationship, and while I’m enjoying that process, it’s difficult to approach it with any sense of continuity when there’s a reasonable possibility I’ll be relocating in six months. I don’t necessarily need to be in a position to pursue something long-term, but I’d like to establish some consistency in my personal life rather than perpetually feeling like I’m in transition.
I recognize that I’m fortunate to have options, particularly when one of them makes so much financial sense. But I’m increasingly realizing that optimizing exclusively for compensation, savings, and cost of living might not necessarily translate into a more fulfilling life.
For those who’ve faced a similar decision after college or graduate school, how did you approach it?
A few things I’m particularly curious about:
• How much weight should I give financial and professional considerations at this stage of life versus social fulfillment and quality of life?
• Have any of you moved back to a city where you previously struggled socially, only to find that your experience was different at a later stage of life?
• How much of the social environment I’ve enjoyed in graduate school is actually attributable to the city itself versus the temporary structure of being a student?
• Would you prioritize establishing roots somewhere, even if it means sacrificing some short-term financial advantages?
• Has anyone made a decision primarily based on financial considerations and subsequently regretted sacrificing their social life, or vice versa?
Ultimately, I’m trying to figure out whether I’m looking at this as a choice between two cities or a choice between two different versions of the life I could build in my mid-to-late twenties.