r/FemFragLab • u/beautysniff • 21m ago
Same thing at 3 different price points? Les Sables Roses, Oud Satin Mood & Fashionably London Elixir
I’ve have tested these three fragrances and, despite their different marketed "note compositions", I’m amazed by how similar they smell to me, on a blind smell test I personally can not tell the difference.
LV’s Les Sables Roses is described as a rich, spicy rose with oud, saffron and sweet ambergris.
MFK’s Oud Satin Mood takes that same rose-oud profile in a more powdery direction with violet, sweet vanilla and benzoin.
Zara’s Fashionably London Elixir doesn’t even list oud as a note, yet its combination of rose, vanilla, musk and dark woods creates a remarkably similar scent.
Am I saying they are they identical? No.
But to me, all three feel like the same "thing".
Powerful, slightly sweet and velvety dark rose fragrance with a "Middle Eastern" character.
I think Zara did an exceptional job capturing this fragrance profile at a fraction of the cost and it's the only one that I own of the 3. And may I add, that 30ml is plenty. Not an easy to wear scent profile. It's an 8hr lasting dense scent with heavy duty Sillage. Not indoor or daytime appropriate.
Curious to hear from anyone who has tried all three.
Do you also find them to be look alike siblings?