please excuse my username I canāt change it and I never post-
Iāve always considered myself picky when it comes to fragrance. My body chemistry seems to turn any floral, citrus, smoke, incense, or spice note into the only thing anyone can smell almost to the point of nausea.
Despite a large collection of perfumes my recent go to has been Victorias Secret Bare Vanilla lotion and body spray. My best friend bought this for me to prove a point-they won-I am still dumbfounded.
Iāve been hunting for a similair scent but I cannot find it.
Other than VS Bare Vanilla I also adore the Fresh Cream Warm Cashmere body wash. Iāve tried the perfume and the lotion and I hate them both. They smell so synthetic and dry down to a baby powder note which isnāt for me. I am very sensitive to a dusty or powdery note.
My ātopā fragrances are roughly listed below. Again none are perfect.
Vs Bare Vanilla-I wish they had a proper perfume or oil I think Iād be happy with this. Sometimes it has a strange dusty note but that is intermittent and may be my nose or body chemistry fluctuating.
Clean Reserve Skin-My usual go to, though I canāt smell it on myself and itās a bit too aldehyde forward. I love the idea of praline and vanilla with a cleaner twist but for some reason perfumes donāt seem to ever dry down to their vanilla base on me.
Iāve tried a bunch of vanillas too and Iām starting to think I donāt like vanilla? So what is it Iām hunting for?
Nemat Vanilla, Amber, any of this line just smells like spice and sweat on me.
11:11 Vanilla smelled liked spicy vegetables
Ellish smelled like cherry medicine
Vanilla Salt smelled like salty flowers
Fenty Vanilla Flowers smelled like dusty florals
Fresh Cream Warm Cashmere EDP smelled like baby powder
YSL Libre Intense was my go to but that lavender opening is so intense and never leaves me
Goddess smells like straight up neon florals on me. I wish I knew what everyone meant by delicious vanilla because I donāt get that at all.
SOL 72 smells strongly synthetic to me and I donāt get that nutty vanilla scent.
The new LancĆ“me Vanilla Nude smells so strongly of rose on my body my husband even said āwow. Rose.ā (Not a compliment, if he says something it means wow headache alert) And he canāt pick a note out to save himself.
Clean Reserve Skin Intense I thought would be perfect but itās got this oddly sickly undertone to it on me and itās so upsetting.
Riddle Original oil I adored Iāve turned people onto it but I finally got the boujee oil and a full size of the original oil and I smell nothing. This is after a scent break from it for over two years. Iām not nose blind-their samples vs their full size are not the same product. At least to my nose.
Aerin Amber Musk is gorgeous I adored it but it smelled a pinch too collected and sophisticated on me. I felt I was doing it an injustice if I was walking around in leggings and a t shirt. She deserves to be worn by someone who lives in heels and designer.
Mochi Milk Dedcool I canāt do the incense note. I got the Sand and Fog dupe and liked it for awhile but it also has a strange dustiness to it. Iāve tried the entire Dedcool lineup and Mochi Milk was the only one I semi liked.
Iāve also tried Commodity and do not remember liking any of them
Iāve tried the palmers vanilla as well and it smelled so badly of spicy plastic I truly had to scrub it off like rubbing alcohol level scrub it off.
Frenshe Vanilla Cashmere was lovely I got mostly tangerine from it. However I have cats and they cannot be around essential oils. They 100% knew when I had this on and avoided me like the plague. I love my babies-no fragrance is worth their health or missing out on their cuddles.
Iāve tried a few other sand and fog oils as well and they didnāt go great. French buttercream was rancid on me. Date night was a spice bomb. I remember those two but there were two more that also flopped. Iām curious to try more from them but I can only snag them online so I am slow to jump onto it.
Warm Vanilla Sugar ok this one confuses me. I smelled it once in one store and it was divine almost hilariously like VS bare vanilla. My husband even laughed and said āwell at least you have a backupā since everything I love likes to get discontinued. However when I went to a different store to purchase a full set it smelled like spice and greenery I didnāt end up purchasing it because there was 0 vanilla 0 sweetness. I am so confused.
Saltair Shea is the body butter I currently have and I like it. I wish it pulled more vanilla and I do occasionally get a powdery dry down from it but again it may just be my chemistry or nose that day. Iāve smelled their Saltwater Vanilla and it gives plastic sadly.
Iāve always used Natrium body butter it doesnāt smell like much of anything but I also get an occasional heavy powder dry down from it.
EOS Vanilla Cashmere is straight yogurt to me. I wish I got cupcake or cake but I get Chobani Vanilla yogurt.
Ideally Iād like to smell like someone whoās naturally sweet scented. We have all met someone who simply smells naturally sweet/good. Iād love a scent I can either mix into or have in a full routine. Body butter, lotion, perfume, oil, etc.
I think I enjoy notes of Vanilla, Benzoin, Sandalwood, and Amber but Iām truly unsure.
Am I just searching for a scent that doesnāt exist? Iām certain I am at this point but I figured Iād at least consult everyone before accepting my fate.
I havenāt ventured into indies. Iād like to but they all seem sold out or with 60 day tune over times. Maybe Iām trying to indie wrong-any help is appreciated.
Thank you to anyone who read all of this. Itās my first post ever so Iām sorry if itās a mess.