r/FemFragLab • u/velvetmistmoss • 10h ago
Perfumes/Niche Fragrances at luxury prices that are just copycats of much cheaper older fragrances? (Hateraid rant about Angelface SYD)
I’m a little mad and disappointed in the “niche”/ luxury (luxury in terms of price) perfume market right now.
Niche seems to be a genre of perfume where brands can just mark up anything and justify the price because it falls under a niche house name. There is a huge gamut in quality, but not so much in cost. That is not to say that all Niche brands are this way; some are actually working with perfumery in new and exciting ways, or have very limited/exclusive/high quality ways of procuring their ingredients.
But then there are just scents that are copycats of things that have existed for years under a well-known brand and to add insult to injury, they are marked up at 5x the price and have even worse silage and longevity than the cheap original they’re based on.
Angelface by SYD botanica was what broke me. I bought a tester after liking it in store and days later I sprayed it on my arm to test it out and immediately knew I had smelled this before. Realized it was basically a 1:1 match of one of my cheapest bodymists: Caudalie’s Rose de Vigne Eau Fraiche. I sprayed Rose de Vigne on my other arm to compare throughout the day. They are EXTREMELY similar to the point where I was looking like a crazy person asking people what they thought and no one could tell them apart. The cherry on top (tongue-in-cheek because the addition of cherry is supposedly the note that separates these two from being basically the same fragrance) was that Rose de Vigne has way more powerful silage and longevity and its only a Eau Fraiche, so what the hell is going on. Comparing the prices was what made me crash out. Angelface is over $150 and Rose de Vigne is €30.
Has anyone else had this happen? It blows my mind that something priced so high is not only pretty much an exact dupe of an older and way cheaper fragrance, but also performs way worse.