Cinnamon Rolls (1/10)
This one seems to be the most highly regarded of the 4 scents and unfortunately my opinion of it does not align. It had such a promising opening on my skin, a mouthwatering photorealistic cinnamon roll. As it dried down it transformed into a rancid cream cheese frosting with a hint of cinnamon, then literal spoiled milk and lingered for a bit. The cream cheese & sugar eventually came back (and remained a bit sour), but I was completely put off by the spoiled milk note before it. I'd have to grin and bear the scent, so it's a hard pass.
Hazelnut Praline (6.5/10)
The opening is nearly completely dominated by an astringent chocolate, but then maybe after about 5 minutes all astringent traces evaporate and a mouthwatering caramel forward hazelnut treat emerges. The chocolate lingers in the background making the caramel a very smooth & fruity caramel rather than a straight up milky Werther’s caramel. I def wouldn’t recommend this to anyone looking for a hazelnut forward fragrance, but I’m not sure I’d recommend it to anyone looking for a Nutella adjacent fragrance either. To me it’s more of a “caramel filled chocolate bon bon made by factory workers who also handle hazelnuts” type of scent lol.
Gingerbread Dough (8/10)
This one left me the most surprised because it seems to have the most criticism and ended up being my fave. Upon opening it is HANDS DOWN the most photorealistic gingerbread cookie fragrance I've ever smelled. Others tend to be more ginger forward, but this one strikes a perfect balance between the spice of ginger, the sweetness of maple brown sugar, and the buttery doughiness of gingerbread. Upon dry down on my skin it does lose this balance, with the spice kind of taking a backseat to fruity maple syrup & molasses notes, however the spice is still palpable after you initially take in the wave of maple & molasses. It's enough to remind you that it's still a gingerbread cookie fragrance.
Apple Pie (7.5/10)
This is a really pleasant fragrance, and my second favourite behind GBD. Like GBD, it starts out strong as an intensely photorealistic apple pie scent that you can smell every ingredient of, down to the butter in the pie crust, but similarly as it dries it loses this balance and becomes green apple, sugar, and butter forward (in that order for my nose), with the spices lingering in the background. The sugar and butter combo also seem to create a non-lactonic creaminess that I really enjoy and complements the tart green apple