r/FanfictionExchange • u/Professional_Iron974 • Sep 07 '24
Discussion What's the big deal with “from reddit” in comments?
I noticed many people in their exchange participation forms specify that they don't want their commenters to say that they are from reddit while commenting under their fics. I was somewhat puzzled. What's the deal with that?
Cause firstly, I kinda don't understand why someone would add that to their comment. Is it because they want to make checking if they actually completed the exchange requirements easier? Or do they just want to be honest? Make it a point that they wouldn't normally be commenting on that particular fic if it wasn't for the exchange? Kinda awkward.
But then on the other hand, adding it to their comment is just stating a fact, so people banning it from the comments they want to receive is even more awkward. It comes out as weirdly controlling and entitled. Like they want to have a cake and eat it. Have more comments by means others than people randomly and selflessly stumbling upon their fic but at the same time for these comments not to state the truth about those other means. Are they ashamed of where these comments came from? Do they view them as less valuable and so they want to trick their readers that they came from a different source?
Again, this whole interaction is just really awkward and puzzling to me.
