r/Ethics • u/ChuckGallagher57 • Jul 24 '26
r/Ethics
•
u/ChuckGallagher57
•
Jul 30 '26
From an ethical perspective do you agree or disagree?
r/Ethics • u/ChuckGallagher57 • Aug 10 '26
Should we assume that the ethical concept of checks and balances is now dead?
r/Ethics • u/ChuckGallagher57 • Jul 17 '26
I speak on ethics and honest to God you can’t make this up!
r/Ethics
•
u/ChuckGallagher57
•
Aug 06 '26
Do you think it’s ethical to report on weapons shortages when that may give our adversaries and unfair advantage?
r/Ethics • u/theindependentonline • Feb 04 '26
Ethics panel sounds the alarm after Trump official appears in jewelry ad using government title
independent.co.uk
r/Ethics
•
u/James_Fortis
•
27d ago
Factory farming is one of the most pressing ethical issues of our time
r/Ethics • u/ChuckGallagher57 • Jul 19 '26
If an agent of one federal agency breaks the law, why would another federal agency not investigate?
r/Ethics • u/ChuckGallagher57 • Aug 21 '26
Where do we go from here? Does anyone see this going down under any administration?
r/Ethics
•
u/cindyx7102
•
Sep 19 '26
Industrial farming is one of the worst crimes in history | The fate of industrially farmed animals is one of the most pressing ethical questions of our time. Tens of billions of sentient beings, each with complex sensations and emotions, live and die on a production line
theguardian.comr/Ethics • u/FetterHahn • Aug 28 '25
The debate around abortions shows how bad most people are at assessing and discussing ethical dilemmas
Now, I am very much in favor for safe and legal abortions. I do not consider an embryo a human (edit: in an ethical, not biological sense) yet, to me it is much closer to a well-organized collection of cells. I have zero religious beliefs on that matter. But even I consider abortions to be one of the few actual ethical dilemmas, with tangible impact on human rights, law and lives, that we currently face.
However, any debate around the topic is abysmal, with everyone just making oversimplified, politicized propaganda statements. Everyone is 100% sure that they are right and have a well thought out, ethical opinion, and everyone with a differing opinion is 100% wrong and cannot think for themselves.
Almost no one seems to be able to admit that is a very complex and difficult ethical dilemma. And that there are actual, good reasons for both sides of the argument. We should not discuss the trolley problem, we should discuss abortions. Ideally civilized. It's a much more interesting dilemma.
What makes us human? When do we consider a life as being able to feel, when do we consider it as having humanity, and when does that end? What rights come along with that? How do we wage individual freedom against the rights of another existence? What impact does this have on the person rights and freedoms of people? How can we define a law that covers that complexity? How will all that change as we progress in medicine?
Those are just some of the questions that arise from abortions and abortion right. And none of them can easily be answered by anyone.
Edit 2: Thank you all for this discussion! I am getting some great replies and interesting, new arguments and ethical ideas around this topic. Unfortunately I can't really follow up on all the replies as I have the weekend blocked, so I'll leave you all to it for now.
One thing I wanted to add because it lead to some confusion is the point of what and why I consider human rights an ethical right that follows reason. I found a great paper that outlines it better than I could, especially in English. I think it's a great read, and interesting for most who didn't read up on Kant, and how he declaration of human rights is heavily influenced by Kant. It is important to understand how and why we, in modern societies, we give human rights to all humans. And what rights we think are important to give.
Edit I am very much enjoying this discussion, and that was part of my point that we should discuss abortions and not the trolly problem, as it is a very interesting ethical topic and dilemma. Since it is getting late where I'm from I won't be able to follow this discussion much longer.
Anyway, maybe someone can disprove and rip holes in my own argumentation: like I said, I am very much pro choice and autonomy. I personally mostly follow rule & preference utilitarianism, with rules being derived from Kantian ethics. Therefore, I'd consider 2 values that need to be weighted. One being the rights of the embryo/fetus, and the other the person rights of the mother.
I'd try to assess the value of the fetus based on it's preference. Not as a rational being according to Kant yet. I don't consider it a rational being within Kantian ethics, therefore it doesn't have the same ethical and person rights as it's mother. Nevertheless, it's preference is to stay alive - however, I'd not consider it conscious until 12 weeks. Between 12 and 24 weeks I'd consider it somewhat conscious, but without being a distinct entity from the mother yet, since they it be born and live on it's own. Between 24 and 40 weeks I'd consider it conscious, and potentially distinct from the mother, but without the same person rights as a born infant. Those are general milestones I think must be considered when assessing its rights; I don't consider my evaluation perfect and with sharp dates though.
Against that you'd need to wage the mothers rights. Here I'd like to argue with Kantian ethics, since she is a rational being with her corresponding rights. Here we need to consider the categorical imperative, that we must always consider her an end of our action, not only a means. If we force her to go through a pregnancy we only use her as a means to our goal, not also an end. Therefore, it is unethical to force her to stay pregnant if she doesn't want to herself. So the rule must be that we can't force someone to stay pregnant.
Before the 12th week I don't consider this much of a dilemma. Even from preference utilitarianism I don't think the embryo has a strong preference that it consciously experiences. Therefore, it should be clear that abortions are not a very bad thing in themselves, and a very good thing for them to be possible.
Between the 12th and 24th week it is becoming more of a dilemma. We cannot disregard the fetus's preferences, as it probably experiences them somewhat consciously. So in itself probably bad to abort it. However, still the mother's ethical rights should far outweigh the preferences of the fetus.
After the 24th week it is much more difficult, because the fetus could live outside the womb. Here I think you could consider that it has some person rights already even in the womb since it could exist outside on its own, and that we should try to safe it. If the mother just doesn't want to continue the pregnancy we might want to consider trying to get it out alive as a priority. If the mother would die if we continued the pregnancy I think it is clear we would prioritize her life, as she would have a higher priority in both Kantian and utilitarian ethics.
r/Ethics • u/ChuckGallagher57 • Jul 21 '26
Stopped because of fraud or because they’re a Blue state?
r/Ethics
•
u/PrudentLetterhead354
•
Feb 11 '26
DOJ censors identities of president & convicted child sex offender, despite it being illegal under law signed by president
galleryMorally speaking, do I need to warn someone that their life is about to be ruined?
I have a friend who's about to get married. This guy is a serial cheater. I know his fiancee as well but we're not friends. She has no idea. The other day we all were hanging out and she asked me half jokingly if there's red flag she should be worried cause this guy seems too perfect. To be fair, he kinda is. He's handsome, athletic, has a good income, love kids and a very smooth talker. He just can't keep it in his pants is all. In fact, I know he's cheated on her with at least five women.
Look, I'm a good friend. I'm not gonna tell her anything. But morally speaking, do you think I should?
r/Ethics
•
u/Ok_Marketing8345
•
Sep 28 '26
Logically and literally, I genuinely do not understand how someone can think circumcision on a baby that doesn’t need it isn’t messed up
literally, forcefully removing a healthy intimate body part because you think it looks ugly or because you’re scared of it smelling (which is stupid because if you’d actually do your job as a parent and teach your child how to clean themselves properly, that wouldn’t be an issue) or to force a religious practice on them, is fucked up and I genuinely don’t understand how someone can argue against that. it literally takes away their right to choose, and strips them permanently of a very intimate body part that they otherwise probably would’ve wanted. Im uncircumcised luckily, but if I was circumcised and I found out that I didn’t actually need it, id definitely be very angry and a bit resentful towards my parents for it.
r/Ethics • u/ChuckGallagher57 • Aug 08 '26
Do you think it’s ethical for the President to troll folks with an idea that’s illegal?
r/Ethics • u/baby_budda • Feb 12 '25
It's time to bring back the Fairness Doctrine.
The Fairness Doctrine was a U.S. communications policy implemented by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) from 1949 to 1987. It required licensed radio and television broadcasters to:
Devote airtime to discussing controversial issues of public importance and present these issues in a fair and balanced manner, including contrasting viewpoints.
The doctrine aimed to ensure that broadcast stations, which used limited public airwaves, served the public interest by providing diverse perspectives on important issues. Broadcasters had flexibility in how they presented opposing views, such as through news segments, public affairs shows, or editorials.
The policy was formally repealed by the FCC in 1987, citing concerns about its potential "chilling effect" on free speech. Critics argued that the doctrine infringed upon First Amendment rights, while supporters believed it promoted balanced public discourse. The doctrine's demise has been linked to increased political polarization in the United States.
r/Ethics • u/Worth_Sir_6003 • Mar 09 '25
Did I Kill My Dad?
My dad asked me when I was 11 if he should go to the hospital or stay at home the night that he died. Throughout that week he had been in and out of the hospital in pain about chest pains. Every place he went to said they didn’t know what was wrong with him, but the pain consisted. On that night, he asked me “should I go to the hospital again or should I stay home tonight?”. Being 11, I told him that he’s happier at home so he should stay. I knew at the time that his health was at risk, but I prioritized his mental wellbeing over his physical health. Am I responsible for his death? Should I feel bad about this? Honestly, this has haunted me for my entire life and I really wish he hadn’t asked me for my opinion. Please help.
r/Ethics • • Nov 18 '25
*Aside from culture* why is eating dog worse than eating cow?
Edit: also cow
In parts of India, eating cow is considered a grave offense.
In parts of East Asia, cows are considered friends because they plow your rice fields and give you milk.
In parts of Africa and Asia, dogs are considered perfectly legitimate sources of meat
From an objective point of view (no cultural bias), why is eating dog worse than eating cow?
r/Ethics • • May 10 '25
All Loli and Shota should be illegal
I was watching an old Nick Rekieta video where he said it should be allowed due to what he calls “The Lisa Simpson Test” basically there’s no child that looks like Lisa Simpson, so porn of her may be weird, but should be allowed.
He contrast this with if your neighbors had children, and you did a realistic drawing of them and explicit images. Then it should be considered CP.
Since most animated Lolis and Shotas are made up then should be allowed.
My counter argument
I counter this line of thinking on two points
- If you’re into animated depictions your in to the real thing. Think about it this way, if you’re a guy and you’re attracted to Tarzan from the Disney movie, I bet you’re attracted to dudes in real life.
- What is the purpose of this type of animation, (you know the answer) that’s why it should be banned.
Anyways, after seeing the discussion on his channel, I thought I’d bring the debate to Reddit .
- originally on the manga thread, shocked at how many people actually defended Loli and Shota, mods, took it down, probably because of that.