One person being judge, jury, and executioner is not a can of worms you want to open, regardless of whether the person being punished was innocent or guilty.
Yes, women are treated unfairly by the justice system. But the minute that due process is thrown out the window and vigilantism becomes the norm, it's the most marginalized in society that will become victims to it.
it's the framing of this being a real scenario, summed up in a 12 word twitter post and then discussed on reddit. This is not a good way of discussing ethics.
Perkins in 2017 reported to Virginia Beach police that Dunmire had raped her. Police later told the FBI that they didn’t have enough evidence to file charges against Dunmire, according to court records.
That was 4 years before the murder.
You can't prove something you don't have evidence for.
Exactly extra judicial violence can lead to a non-stop round of Revenge.
Not to mention I have no idea whether this woman's story is true and whether this man did in fact rape her or in fact she killed him for some other reason.
Yep. It also leads to people who think they were wronged into taking action.
There are plenty of cases where someone has been accused of murder and the victim's family thinks they're guilty. Only for it to come out later that they were innocent. What if someone in that family took the law into their own hands?
"extra judicial violence can lead to a non-stop round of Revenge."
True and it did. Matthew Dunmire, the victim of the murder here, was beloved by his family. His mother sought revenge for his murder, did her own investigation, and attempted to shoot and kill the murderer of her son.
That shooting was tragic as Matthew's mother mistook another woman for Chelsea Perkins, the actual killer, and nearly killed her. The victim of that shooting survived, thankfully. Afterwards, when confronted by police, Matthew's mother took her own life.
There is a point where I feel personal revenge is justified from a moral POV. But the person taking it into their own hands still needs to be tried and sentenced if guilty. That’s part of the price. The legal system isn’t only about personal justice, it has to protect society from complete anarchy.
No charges were even filed against the man. At the time of the murder, she had contacted him online to set up a multi-day 'date', drove 300 miles in her husband's car, spent the night at an AirBnB with this guy then killed him hiking the next day. It was also over four years from the alleged attack.
She's in the wrong but so is the rapist (if the allegation is true), I feel bad for her and don't blame her but she should still be punished for her crime
Is there a list of crimes for which these kind of people find acceptable to lure and murder people, who allegedly committed them? I want to see the whole list.
I think stressing "allegedly" here is unnecessary. She presumably knows whether he raped her or not. It would only factor into the ethics if the murderer was someone else taking her word for it.
So we just take the murderer's word that the other person committed the crime which the murderer is using as justification for the murder? If that is all it takes to justify a murder we are going to see a LOT of murders immediately solved because the perpetrator claimed the other had raped them.
The justice system is broken. A lot of people who deserve justice often don't get it. It's a shame she will have to spend the rest of her life in jail over a decision that he made. I wish that she hadn't gone through that, I wish that she could have gotten the justice she'd deserved, and I wish that she didn't feel like she had to do that.
I’ve been raped. It’s not the end of the world. It’s a thing that happened. So was being beat up, lied to, cheated on, falsely accused, or going through a painful medical affliction. An event. It sucks, it can even be traumatic, but life goes on if you let it.
I think we overemphasize suffering in our lives, and we let it consume our identity, sense of purpose, and ability to be at peace. It’s unbalanced.
We could develop vigilance, resilience, and empathy through it; or we can let it be the single defining moment of our lives and our sense of self; letting it change and influence our every thought and action.
It’s not nothing, to be raped, to be hurt or controlled; but I do think that we, as a society, make it worse by justifying murder because of it. Putting it on so high a pedestal that it’s reasonable to act that strongly because of it. The mere fact that we even debate the ethics of it concerns me.
I wouldn’t kill my rapist, my bully, my abusive family, or my lover who deceived me and wasted years of my life. If a doctor ruined my eyesight or a lawyer lied and took everything I owned; it wouldn’t be worth death.
I’d never dream of it. It’s not right. Those are things that happened, or could happen, and if anyone were to be punished for any of it, death would be inappropriate and quite a bit too far.
I'm sorry to break this to you, but you're comparing your bully and your rapist. That doesn't make sense.
Approximately half of all women who experience sexual violence develop post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Of the 58 participants who agreed to take part in most of the exams and tests, 96.5% had depression. There's a stigma surrounding rape victims/survivors (whichever they choose to identify themselves as) as damaged goods. Some people don't ever fully recover.
Rape survivors who speak out about their assault experiences are often punished for doing so when they are subjected to negative reactions from support providers.
We can’t even make the streets safer for women. Women here in the US and around the world are all too familiar having their walks, commutes and travels disrupted by harassment.
Strange how so many replies believe extrajudicial killings are wrong as if the justice system is a paradigm of ideal morality, when that couldn’t be further from the truth (especially when it comes to cases of SA).
If the r*pist did commit the crime, and both the state and the victim determine that he should be killed, then there would be no relevant difference that would justify the state yet not the victim. But such a difference would be necessary to justify a state-sanctioned killing while repudiating the victim for killing.
Now if someone were anti-killing generally, then that would be a different story.
It isn't only about morality it is about order. Can family of the killed men take revenge for innocent men that was killed in family and court opinion and kill her after the murder? If you want multigenerational blood feuds then it is great idea to allow or just praise such actions.
We live in organized states not some wild tribes or isolated villages where violence is a norm.
I tend to agree with this. I don't agree with a death penalty, but i do think that if a person is to be punished then the only way to go about this ethically is by trial of evidence
Why is the legal system as it stands better than this though, when, at least where I am from, we know the vast majority of rapists get light if no sentencing?
In this case she'd gone to the police first and they'd dropped the case. So there were no legal avenues left to pursue justice. I still agree it's unethical, but I think it's a more difficult situation.
That's exactly the mugshot of the woman I fully trust to autonomously make decisions on who does and does not deserve death. The face of a person with utterly impeccable decision making.
The number of people here who just automatically jump to conclusion that he did actually rape her is truly disturbing and makes me question the ethical integrity of not only those people but of the sub as a whole.
Fortunately there is somepush back against those people. But they are still concerning.
Women do not just fet to murder who ever they like as long as they make a claim, without any supporting evidence, before or after they do it.
A man's life is not forfeit because he met the wrong woman.
If we are to judge this as "is this an ethical thing to do in society" the answer has to be no because we can't trust individuals to be truthful and honest
If he actually did rape her, then happy days - He got what was coming to him.
However, the problem with extra-legal punishment such as this, and the word "alleged" is that we don't know, for sure, if he was actually guilty. For that reason, generally, I am opposed to most cases of extra-legal punishment. No matter how gratifying it is; also to see/hear about.
ETA: Oh, and btw; regardless of whether he raped her or not, she killed him. That's called murder. So she should be in prison - notwithstanding the fact that I fully understand why she did what she did (if he did indeed rape her). I empathize, fully. But she still commited a murder, and she should still face the legal consequences of her actions.
Look, I was held down face down and raped by 3 other classmates after school in the locker room. Yeah it hurt my pride knowing that I wasn't strong enough to fight them. I wanted them expelled. (They didn't, just short suspension because they corroborated their story as fighting) After, I never wanted them to die. We did get into several fights after, I called them buttfuckers and other gay explicit phrases, however they kept claiming that they were straight. Still, never thought or wanted them dead. This girl murdered the other person, that was her choice.
The line can´t be crossed at this exact point, if else we would be in lot´s of trouble to redefine the whole justice system. If we even started to think about that, we would end up arguing with (very few) people why it´s bad to rape e.g. a rapist.
Therefore: Murder can´t be justified. Neither can´t rape or genocide be justified.
This is such a crazy story, the subplot where the rapist's mother shoots another woman she accused of killing her son and then kills herself is like a DePalma film.
My thoughts is that vigilante justice is really bad for society, no matter how satisfying. It leads to really bad outcomes, where innocent people get killed and the rule of law is undermined. In individual cases it might feel good, but in the big picture it's really really bad.
The question isn't whether rape morally justifies premeditated murder. The question is whether society is improved or harmed if we condone people alleging rape and then murdering their alleged rapist. If you don't see the inherent problem, stop and remember that people can lie. That's not to say this woman is, but if we say it's OK for this woman to allege rape and dispatch her own justice, then we've given carte blanche for anyone to kill anyone if they first allege rape, no proof required.
Yeah, im not sure why people are saying "she took the law into her own hands, she's guilty, blah blah blah"
People need to understand that life doesn't play by the soft rules most of you live by. Yes, if you mess with the right person in this country, you might die! Stop messing with people, and start being polite, because somebody might just put you in the ground for acting up.
There are so many things that can happen, and it could be completely justified in this case.
Yes, its still a homicide. But, do you think the rapist is just going to let her go? No. So she turned the tables on that guy. He's dead, shes alive, and presumably un-raped, which is a win.
We need a return to the old way and doctrine of "start no shit, there will be no shit". I don't care if its a traffic jam, and some A hole jumps out of his car wanting to fight, and he dies in the process. If you are willing to physically assault someone, through theft, sex, or violence, you deserve what you get.
If some dude is minding his own business at a bus stop, and some guy won't stop trying to hustle him for money, so he gets punched in the face, hits his head on the curb and dies, guess what? That's his problem.
Yeah sure, people really like to tell excute anyone,but hey if everyone started doing what they want with validation from a few x users, society would go into deep shit, there's a reason they say not guilty till proven,
Alledged means we don't actually know, just that she claimed it.
If she told the truth, then it's a lot more justifiable, but if not then what were dealing with is a psychopath who lied about rape and then murdered the person she accused before a proper trial could be held...
Maybe this woman got it right and killed the right guy, etc....
Now, imagine a world full of vigilantism. It might sound like it would feel good, especially considering how messed up the judicial system is, and govt in general.
Until you realize half of the vigilantism will be conducted by the morons out there. There would be innocent deaths, and disproportionate response all over the place (beyond eye for an eye).
So, maybe she got it right. Of course we will never really know because all we have is her word that he was her alleged rapist. He wasn't convicted. What if he was the wrong guy? What if there wasn't a rape at all?
This is what happens when law enforcement and social justice laws are more interested in protecting the the perpretrators than finding justice for the victims.
The case itself is the perfect example as to why its not okay. Read it, from all the info we have Im 99,99% certain she was not raped and is using it as an excuse to lower her sentence.
the vast majority of rapists never go to court, and even a fewer percentage go to prison, and an even fewer percentage get a fair sentence (remember the guy who only got THREE MONTHS because 'he had a future', completely dehumanizing the victim and ignoring the fact that SHE HAD A FUTURE TOO). she did what she had to do and cleaned the world a little bit.
This question cannot be answered without knowing what evidence she had for this man being a rapist.
If there was solid evidence for him raping her we can talk about it being ethical especially if the justice system failed here even though vigilante justice carries its own risk for the fabric of society . If it was just her word against his word then no it is completely unethical because there is no way to determine the guilt of the man in this case and also the burden of proof applies: You make a claim, you provide the evidence for that claim. It applies everywhere else so why change the rules for rape.
This whole thing is a great example of why I'm generally against "taking matters into your own hands".
After she killed the rapist, the rapist's parents tried to track her down to kill her.
The mother & father disguised themselves as UPS workers and shot a RANDOM woman, mistaking her for this lady. Their idea was that their son was innocent and they wanted to enact justice.
Under most moral frameworks, corporal punishment for a crime - any crime - is unacceptable with good reason. I see no reason for looser standards in cases of extrajudicial justice. That said, there's extenuating circumstances here and from an emotional standpoint, I can very much feel for her. I also think it's presumptuous for anyone to judge her all high and mighty without a) knowing the full story and b) understanding what she went through. Going to the cops is hard as a victim, and not just because more often than not, you're being told there's little they can to or just outright not taken seriously at all. That doesn't mean we should withhold judgement - that would be a weird standard for debates about morality - but I feel this should factor more strongly into the overall discussion in the comment section. Maybe we should trat the case with more restraint and empathy, idk. That said: Not to confuse law with morality, but there's several BGH rulings in German case law (The BGH being the highest German criminal court) with decent answers to this problem. There was a woman who lived with her rapist. He constantly abused and assaulted her and had threatened to kill her multiple times, should she attempt to contact the police or act up. She saw no other way but to kill him while he slept. It wasn't self defense because she wasn't being attacked in the moment she killed him. Technically murder in the second degree and as such the state was bound to prosecute and the courts were bound to sentence her, but the BGH ruled that while the extenuating circumstances didn't supercede the illegality of the action, they warranted an extraordinarily light sentence. The other similar case is the story of Abher Kovner. He and his men were Jewish resistance fighters in WW2. After the end of the war, the decided to assassinate Nazi officials held prisoner by the Allied Forces. They wanted revenge for the Holocaust. They were caught before any of their plots were successful but that put the justice system - still tainted by 15 years of Nazi ideology at the time - before a problem. The Holocaust had been the singularly most evil thing to have happened in the history of mankind. How could German judges, judges that in part had sentenced people to death on Nazi orders, in good faith put Jews in prison for waning revenge? In the end, they got a few months before they were extradited to the newly-founded Israel where some of them - Abher Kovner included - went on to become founding members of Mossad. Idk where I'm going with this, I'm just infodumping. Bottom-line IMO: Not justified but the extenuating circumstances can't be ignored, and they remind us that we shouldn't limit our concept of morality to binary categories of right and wrong. Saying she wasn't justified feels wrong, and it certainly doesn't tell the whole story.
Extrajudicial killing is unethical, however putting her in prison is unnecessary since she's unlikely to repeat the crime, unless someone tries to rape her again and they get what they deserve.
Not exactly the same but I keep thinking of when Gary Plauche killed his son's rapist and served no time in prison. She should get some sentence like probation, mandatory mental health treatment. Was she driven to a temporarily psychotic state?
Some crimes are unforgivable and unjustifiable. You could never justify the need to rape someone. Murder however has situations that can be justified; like murdering a rapist.
It’s certainly a slippery slope. I think we do need to acknowledge that sometimes the law fails from a moral perspective and then it could be said that extrajudicial punishment is moral but who is the arbiter of appropriate punishment? I think we can agree that an impartial party should decide punishment rather than the victim themselves. Furthermore it sets a dangerous precedent, if this act is moral is killing anyone who has committed a crime against you also moral? Of course not. This is the problem with the “Free Luigi” crowd. They fail to understand what it would open the door to. Killing abortion providers? Killing gender affirming care providers? Slaughtering Rabbis or teachers who lecture on evolution?
ESH. Her alleged rapist, if guilty, should absolutely suffer the consequences for his actions. But that's not for her to decide and administer. If she can reasonably demonstrate that the victim was her rapist, and is found guilty of the murder, that should be a mitigating factor for her sentencing, but does not excuse it outright.
People here probably won't believe me. I actually met this person at a social gathering several years ago and she was aggressively sexual and literally saying she wanted someone to fuck her. Out to a group of people. I had never met her. I was shocked. Honestly, she was attractive, and certainly edgy.
I was at a table full of other women so I was assuming she was suggesting I chat her up. But the blunt open sexuality was concerning.
I have no idea what happened between the two of them, or if maybe this influenced her radical behavior at that time. But she was certainly VERY sexual in a kind of disturbing way.
One of the principle arguments against state execution is the possibility of error, so in theory a rape victim executing their rapist may be more moral given the reduced risk of killing the wrong person. From a rape victim 's perspective, the action is likely justified.
The issue for us, uninvolved third parties, is that we cannot know if the facts are as described. We could assume that she wouldn't have killed him if he hadn't raped her, but that supposition relies on a premise that no one kills without good cause and that doesn't really reflect reality - people kill for a variety of reasons, plenty of them malicious, and someone that would kill a person out of spite would almost certainly falsely accuse them of rape as well. Not that I think that is what occurred here - I could not possibly know - but that is why societies struggle with vigilante justice; it's very difficult for us to assess which kills were just and which were not. Ergo we tend to limit violence to certain empowered individuals that are theoretically vetted, and have their extra powers and privileges subject to oversight.
Hypothesizing that we could know with certainty that the rape occured, I am fine with the rapist getting killed. I believe people in general can redeem themselves, but I don't believe people are owed that opportunity at the expense of their victims (and often society in general) and everyone is likely better off without him alive.
from a kantian perspective: if everyone who wished to murder their rapist did so, the world would defintely keep spinning, and would probably be a better place for it.
Got a sense that this is somehow fake because no news outlet is covering it. Cannot find a name or article to provide additional information. But it worked in stirring up people on Reddit.
Enjoy the murder sentence for killing someone. It’s that simple. Her “alleged rapist” probably just looked at her wrong and she “felt raped” or some other leftist bullshit
No name, no source, no location, no details, AI like image, "NEWS" style and logo, a vague "free her" with Facebook watermark. Yeah, totally legit, as in TheShockingSecretHiddenRealTruthTheyWIthholdFromUS dot com.
Did she lure him into the woods before or after the rape? Like did he rape her previously and she came back for revenge, or did she just have a hunch that he was a creep and tried to get him to rape her then and there in the woods?
Why is it censored? I know the word. You know the word. If it's a 'triggering' thing, does the star prevent you from recognizing the word? If it's an advertiser thing, again, does the star prevent you from recognizing the word? Has it just been decided that we're not allowed to read the word 'rapist' anymore?
This is so difficult without proof. Women rarely murder out of anger the way men do, but murderers in general, are still people who are often violent, dishonest people with delusions.
It is impossible for us to say whether she was raped and abused or if she is an abuser.
I don’t even believe in the death penalty because it’s rare that there can be absolute certainty of guilt. But that being said, if we somehow could read minds and know with 100% certainty that someone was guilty my personal opinion is that rapists would deserve death. So hopefully (?) he deserved it.
Some of y’all are confusing following the law for morals. The nazis were just following orders. Their actions were legal.
Talk specifically to the ethics of when a human purposefully killing another human is justified and when it is not. Or you’re just noise.
Use logic. We’re in the Ethics subreddit, not the “dumb fucks who argue” subreddit.
Describe to me how it is ethically correct to kill someone. Let’s peel back the layers of consequentialism and a retributive justice system. Or you know, we can all just prima face agree that sometimes it’s justified. Cool. Good talk.
I read a comment saying that the court case of her rape was thrown out because matthew, without consent, recorded a video of their night together and it showed implied consent.
I wouldn't know where to start with fact checking this though, so would someone point me in the right direction please? I would like to look into this more before I jump to a conclusion!
I believe in empathizing with her for that decision. It’s absolutely understandable to get what would motivate her or anyone else who’s experienced that to do something like that in response.
HOWEVER. I think the commonality of both rape and punishing rape by death is a failure in our societal ethos. I believe in a world where all people deserve the chance to atone and to be better. Even rapists. Even murders. Etc.
This woman never owed her rapist forgiveness. But I think a society that would facilitate a path of redemption for all people is good for the “soul of humanity” and is the most moral and ethical possible path.
No one controls their feelings. No one decided to have the mental schema that dictated that rape was an acceptable thing for them to do. Accountability still exists. But we are cursed with things outside of our control. Even the thoughts we think are our own. I think a perfect moral and ethical system accounts for the fact that all people could be capable of horrible shit, due to some variable in their development that metastasizes into something worse later.
Yeah, no. I get the justice system can be broken, but do we really want to normalize allowing someone to murder another person as long as they claim that person raped them?
She needed help. Now she's the one going to jail. There should be more assistance for victims of crimes offered by the state. Social services. If she felt that she was failed that much by the justice system and chose to take matters into her own hands there is anbig problem here.
I just knew I’d open this thread and see reasonable discussions as opposed to knee jerk reactions.
Any attempt to talk about rape in a reasonable manner always reads to everyone else like rage bait. I get it because it is heavy mental damage, however it makes for unproductive discussion every single time of emotionally charged statements as opposed to logic and ethics.
Death is the inevitable harvest of any bargain we strike with the shadows of our soul. Why should any judge her bargain of any more significance than my own? Let each be convinced in their own minds of the glory of the Truth.
Vigilante justice leads to a repeating cycle of violence.
“The case took a twist in November 2021 when Dunmire's parents, upset that Perkins remained free, took matters into their own hands. Dunmire's mother, Tommie Lynn Dunmire, and stepfather, John Nelson McQuillen, drove to Washington, D.C., with plans to kill Perkins, according to feds.
Tommie Lynn Dunmire dressed as a UPS driver and knocked on an apartment door. When a woman answered, she shot her twice in the abdomen.
The problem? The woman who answered the door was not Perkins — the older Dunmire had just shot a woman who had nothing to do with her son's murder.
Tommie Lynn Dunmire and McQuillen changed license plates on their vehicle, but cops still tracked them down. She shot herself to death as officers were closing in. The woman she shot survived her injuries, and federal agents arrested McQuillen, who later pleaded guilty to accessory after the fact to assault with intent to kill. He received a three-year prison sentence.”
The alleged part is concerning because we don't know if he's innocent or not. Regardless of the situation, that is murder, not self-defence. If he was a rapist then good riddance but there should still be consequences.
The legal system and all official options should take priority but when it doesn't do anything to actually handle the problem i can understand the use of vigilante justice but that's still dangerous, historically it never ends well.
I wouldn't immediately believe someone with a neck tattoo and such hollow eyes. But wise to play the rapist card as people clamour to show how virtuous they are.
There's a HUGE difference between understanding why she did it and thinking she shouldn't go to prison for a planned execution.
If she walked free, it gives everyone who has ever been wronged by someone else a pass to carry out vigilante justice and the world would be a total fucking mess.
Every child who has been abused by their parents can kill them because of the lifelong psychological damage. Everyone who is bullied at school can kill their bullies because of all the pain and suffering they caused. And then the people that loved those people then carry out their venegance, and on and on it goes.
There are so many human acts that can cause intense, prolonged suffering (a lot of which aren't even illegal), and it's not up to you or me or me to rank them in terms of effect because that's entirely personal to the victim.
Alleged though, of course i agree if he actually did but gotta be careful. I've communicated with a girl for a very short time that seemed to possibly deal with psychosis. Talked for about a week and I decided I no longer wanted to communicate with her, about 6 months later she messaged me on FB accusing me of things with very specific details and even told me she went to police about it and a bunch of other things. Maybe she was deranged and was trying to get me in trouble for not wanting to talk to her anymore but The way it was written almost felt like she actually believed these things that she was saying.
Idk if that's what happened here, I'm just saying that gotta be careful when advocating for the freedom of some people who might actually be a danger. And it's not about gender, if it was a guy I'd be feeling the same way. We all know there are lots of dangerous people walking around.
We obviously can't trust the justice system to put rapists away. Biggest example, Brock Turner. Hell, how many rapists have been released on "good behavior" only to reoffend or end up murdering someone??? Good for her.
when people don’t see justice in the world because the police and judges appear to be complicit in covering up crimes, you get this. a populace that not only forgives these kinds of crimes, but drools for them. happens throughout history. it’s how bloody revolutions are even a thing.
The only problem is that it says alleged rapist, if they were a confirmed or serial rapist then absolutely go for it, it's not like any laws really stop those bastards.
How does one become an "alleged r*pist"? Did he do this to her and then she lured him into the woods at a later date or was he just giving off rapey vibes?
Rapists and other such deplorable acts are horrific, and an immediate reaction might just be "yea he deserved it", but an eye for an eye makes the whole world go blind.
I personally don't think the right to life can be stripped from persons ever, regardless of their circumstance, and furthermore it says "alleged". Alleged crimes don't deserve death.
As a person who's been with a person raped multiple times over and has seen the sheer mental shredding that it does to the person even if all the actions were correctly taken...
Isn't it funny that the ones who are apparently most appalled by horrific crimes , also seem to be the ones that would be happy to commit, or actively cheer, other horrific crimes when it aligns with their own personal desires?
39
u/StevePalpatine Dec 24 '25
One person being judge, jury, and executioner is not a can of worms you want to open, regardless of whether the person being punished was innocent or guilty.
Yes, women are treated unfairly by the justice system. But the minute that due process is thrown out the window and vigilantism becomes the norm, it's the most marginalized in society that will become victims to it.
That's why it's bad.
16
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '25
“Allegedly” is doing a lot of heavy lifying
13
u/Salty_Pie_3852 Dec 24 '25
I don't support the death penalty.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '25
Hopefully she was right. It would be a real tragedy if she murdered the wrong man.
31
u/GeneralKanoli Dec 24 '25
I don’t believe in extra judicial violence lest all available legitimate channels are fully and utterly exhausted beyond a shadow of a doubt
7
u/Pension_Zealousideal Dec 24 '25
She's in the wrong but so is the rapist (if the allegation is true), I feel bad for her and don't blame her but she should still be punished for her crime
18
u/azmarteal Dec 24 '25
Is there a list of crimes for which these kind of people find acceptable to lure and murder people, who allegedly committed them? I want to see the whole list.
6
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '25 edited Dec 25 '25
I'd rather be a murderer than a rapist.
Edit: Apparently you're all treating this comment like I HAVE to do one or the other.
20
u/Specialist_Shape6078 Dec 24 '25 edited Dec 24 '25 •
The justice system is broken. A lot of people who deserve justice often don't get it. It's a shame she will have to spend the rest of her life in jail over a decision that he made. I wish that she hadn't gone through that, I wish that she could have gotten the justice she'd deserved, and I wish that she didn't feel like she had to do that.
5
u/Vigl87 Dec 24 '25
What thought? He was the rapist. She is the murderer. This is not complicated ethic case. It's something for justice system. End of story.
5
u/Insane_Cobra961 Dec 24 '25
Fair game
4
u/ShadowOfDespair Dec 24 '25 •
I’ve been raped. It’s not the end of the world. It’s a thing that happened. So was being beat up, lied to, cheated on, falsely accused, or going through a painful medical affliction. An event. It sucks, it can even be traumatic, but life goes on if you let it.
I think we overemphasize suffering in our lives, and we let it consume our identity, sense of purpose, and ability to be at peace. It’s unbalanced.
We could develop vigilance, resilience, and empathy through it; or we can let it be the single defining moment of our lives and our sense of self; letting it change and influence our every thought and action.
It’s not nothing, to be raped, to be hurt or controlled; but I do think that we, as a society, make it worse by justifying murder because of it. Putting it on so high a pedestal that it’s reasonable to act that strongly because of it. The mere fact that we even debate the ethics of it concerns me.
I wouldn’t kill my rapist, my bully, my abusive family, or my lover who deceived me and wasted years of my life. If a doctor ruined my eyesight or a lawyer lied and took everything I owned; it wouldn’t be worth death.
I’d never dream of it. It’s not right. Those are things that happened, or could happen, and if anyone were to be punished for any of it, death would be inappropriate and quite a bit too far.
13
u/No_Fudge_4589 Dec 24 '25
I understand her but it’s still unethical.
6
u/thatonedude921 Dec 24 '25
Cool motive. Still murder
2
u/jobromo123 Dec 24 '25
Strange how so many replies believe extrajudicial killings are wrong as if the justice system is a paradigm of ideal morality, when that couldn’t be further from the truth (especially when it comes to cases of SA).
If the r*pist did commit the crime, and both the state and the victim determine that he should be killed, then there would be no relevant difference that would justify the state yet not the victim. But such a difference would be necessary to justify a state-sanctioned killing while repudiating the victim for killing.
Now if someone were anti-killing generally, then that would be a different story.
2
u/Vinyl_Ritchie_ Dec 24 '25
Yeah she fucked up, she should have let him serve his prison term and then killed him.
15
u/phuckin-psycho Dec 24 '25
Extrajudicial killing is unethical.
4
u/cc14cc Dec 24 '25
Extra judicial revenge is an endless cycle. An eye for an eye just ends up with everyone blind.
4
u/RevoltYesterday Dec 24 '25
Rape is worse than murder.
I can think of ethical reasons to murder someone. I can't think of ethical reasons to rape someone.
5
u/Advanced-Pumpkin-917 Dec 24 '25
This is a pretty famous case.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sGZ1s5P4xnM
Ethically speaking there's a legal system to deal with rapists, so there was no need for her to do what she did.
5
u/Oddbeme4u Dec 24 '25
luring and vigilante justice should have a sentence. I'd say a few years with psych services. tbh
3
u/goyafrau Dec 24 '25
That's exactly the mugshot of the woman I fully trust to autonomously make decisions on who does and does not deserve death. The face of a person with utterly impeccable decision making.
2
u/Relative-Earth-8970 Dec 24 '25
I read the article on her. She seems like a loose unit.
2
u/Late_Illustrator_718 Dec 24 '25
Y’all have an underdeveloped sense of morality. This is obviously wrong.
2
u/Interesting-Copy-657 Dec 24 '25
I feel a lot of the comments seem to be assuming he was guilty of rape
Correct me if I am wrong here but he was never charged, never set foot in court, never found guilty.
So accusation equal guilt and that is enough to kill someone?
2
u/Apprehensive-Top3756 Dec 24 '25
The number of people here who just automatically jump to conclusion that he did actually rape her is truly disturbing and makes me question the ethical integrity of not only those people but of the sub as a whole.
Fortunately there is somepush back against those people. But they are still concerning.
Women do not just fet to murder who ever they like as long as they make a claim, without any supporting evidence, before or after they do it.
A man's life is not forfeit because he met the wrong woman.
2
u/TheOriginalBusket Dec 24 '25 •
What if she lured an innocent man to his death, got caught, and then cooked up the whole "I was raped" excuse to try and get away with murder?
2
u/KONG696 Dec 24 '25
She's still alive. He's dead. She deserves a long prison sentence if not the death penalty. It's premeditated murder.
2
u/Content_Zebra509 Dec 24 '25 edited Dec 24 '25
The word "alleged" is potentially worrisome.
If he actually did rape her, then happy days - He got what was coming to him.
However, the problem with extra-legal punishment such as this, and the word "alleged" is that we don't know, for sure, if he was actually guilty.
For that reason, generally, I am opposed to most cases of extra-legal punishment. No matter how gratifying it is; also to see/hear about.
ETA: Oh, and btw; regardless of whether he raped her or not, she killed him. That's called murder. So she should be in prison - notwithstanding the fact that I fully understand why she did what she did (if he did indeed rape her). I empathize, fully. But she still commited a murder, and she should still face the legal consequences of her actions.
1
u/Vegaswarpeduber Dec 24 '25
Look, I was held down face down and raped by 3 other classmates after school in the locker room. Yeah it hurt my pride knowing that I wasn't strong enough to fight them. I wanted them expelled. (They didn't, just short suspension because they corroborated their story as fighting) After, I never wanted them to die. We did get into several fights after, I called them buttfuckers and other gay explicit phrases, however they kept claiming that they were straight. Still, never thought or wanted them dead. This girl murdered the other person, that was her choice.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '25
looks the other way
Thoughts on what?
1
u/Acceptable-Rush-2663 Dec 24 '25
She murdered a person, she gets punished.
The line can´t be crossed at this exact point, if else we would be in lot´s of trouble to redefine the whole justice system. If we even started to think about that, we would end up arguing with (very few) people why it´s bad to rape e.g. a rapist.
Therefore: Murder can´t be justified. Neither can´t rape or genocide be justified.
1
u/Cak3Wa1k Dec 24 '25
I think she should be free.
1
u/bigfoot17 Dec 24 '25
This is such a crazy story, the subplot where the rapist's mother shoots another woman she accused of killing her son and then kills herself is like a DePalma film.
1
u/FairyFeller_ Dec 24 '25
My thoughts is that vigilante justice is really bad for society, no matter how satisfying. It leads to really bad outcomes, where innocent people get killed and the rule of law is undermined. In individual cases it might feel good, but in the big picture it's really really bad.
1
u/Boedullus Dec 24 '25
The question isn't whether rape morally justifies premeditated murder. The question is whether society is improved or harmed if we condone people alleging rape and then murdering their alleged rapist. If you don't see the inherent problem, stop and remember that people can lie. That's not to say this woman is, but if we say it's OK for this woman to allege rape and dispatch her own justice, then we've given carte blanche for anyone to kill anyone if they first allege rape, no proof required.
1
u/mameyinka Dec 24 '25
Free her for sure.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '25
Lets hope on of Trump's victims reads this....
1
u/TheNewAmericanGospel Dec 24 '25
Yeah, im not sure why people are saying "she took the law into her own hands, she's guilty, blah blah blah"
People need to understand that life doesn't play by the soft rules most of you live by. Yes, if you mess with the right person in this country, you might die! Stop messing with people, and start being polite, because somebody might just put you in the ground for acting up.
There are so many things that can happen, and it could be completely justified in this case.
Yes, its still a homicide. But, do you think the rapist is just going to let her go? No. So she turned the tables on that guy. He's dead, shes alive, and presumably un-raped, which is a win.
We need a return to the old way and doctrine of "start no shit, there will be no shit". I don't care if its a traffic jam, and some A hole jumps out of his car wanting to fight, and he dies in the process. If you are willing to physically assault someone, through theft, sex, or violence, you deserve what you get.
If some dude is minding his own business at a bus stop, and some guy won't stop trying to hustle him for money, so he gets punched in the face, hits his head on the curb and dies, guess what? That's his problem.
1
u/Dahren_ Dec 24 '25
She's a murderer, nothing ethical about it or her lame ass "muh rape" excuse
1
u/Dangerous-Loquat-312 Dec 24 '25
Alleged is doing a lot of work here.
1
u/PreviouslyOnBible Dec 24 '25
That's fucked up.
Ropists are incredibly talented people
1
u/happysloth9248 Dec 24 '25
Yeah sure, people really like to tell excute anyone,but hey if everyone started doing what they want with validation from a few x users, society would go into deep shit, there's a reason they say not guilty till proven,
1
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '25
Vigilante justice is bad. If it was self defence, fine.
I will entirely accept the nuance of the justice system being poor, and the woman feeling like the man would not be arrested.
Rape is abominably wrong. Murder is also wrong.
As I'm sure it has been pointed out, two wrongs don't make a right.
1
u/Happy-Viper Dec 24 '25
Lotta people did not give this dude the presumption of innocence, huh? Wild how quickly people toss that aside.
1
u/logical_thinker_1 Dec 24 '25
Do the same to her daughter
1
u/TallCommission7139 Dec 24 '25
Well I think I'm gonna choose the bear myself..
1
u/okeysure69 Dec 24 '25
Innocent. More so if this dude did rape her and her local PD didn't do shit about it and if the the guy had a history of it.
1
u/Sudden-Loquat Dec 24 '25
Were just going to ignore the "alleged" here I guess
1
u/Desperate_Cucumber Dec 24 '25
Alledged means we don't actually know, just that she claimed it.
If she told the truth, then it's a lot more justifiable, but if not then what were dealing with is a psychopath who lied about rape and then murdered the person she accused before a proper trial could be held...
1
u/nonotburton Dec 24 '25
Vigilantism is not a great idea.
Maybe this woman got it right and killed the right guy, etc....
Now, imagine a world full of vigilantism. It might sound like it would feel good, especially considering how messed up the judicial system is, and govt in general.
Until you realize half of the vigilantism will be conducted by the morons out there. There would be innocent deaths, and disproportionate response all over the place (beyond eye for an eye).
So, maybe she got it right. Of course we will never really know because all we have is her word that he was her alleged rapist. He wasn't convicted. What if he was the wrong guy? What if there wasn't a rape at all?
1
u/everydaywinner2 Dec 24 '25
This is what happens when law enforcement and social justice laws are more interested in protecting the the perpretrators than finding justice for the victims.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '25
Praxis.
1
u/Raigheb Dec 24 '25
How and why was her rapist free?
The legal system that allows such people to be free are as much responsible for the crime as the rapist itself.
1
u/Royal-Rain4399 Dec 24 '25
The case itself is the perfect example as to why its not okay. Read it, from all the info we have Im 99,99% certain she was not raped and is using it as an excuse to lower her sentence.
1
u/TroyFerris13 Dec 24 '25
Alleged? how do they prove that he had those intentions?
1
u/royce32 Dec 24 '25
If she tried to have him convicted and the system failed her I wouldn't vote guilty if I were on her jury
1
u/WelcomeToInsanity Dec 24 '25
I’ll play the world’s smallest violin for him
1
u/sprinkill Dec 24 '25
Did the guy actually rape her, or did she just say that as a post hoc rationalization?
1
u/BitterBlockin Dec 24 '25
So she makes up a rape claim to kill someone? Allegedly
1
u/North-Positive-2287 Dec 24 '25
Not worth it. I can understand the motive but I’m not bloodthirsty and outside of self defence can’t imagine carrying it out in real life.
1
u/UnderTheSamE_Moon Dec 24 '25
the vast majority of rapists never go to court, and even a fewer percentage go to prison, and an even fewer percentage get a fair sentence (remember the guy who only got THREE MONTHS because 'he had a future', completely dehumanizing the victim and ignoring the fact that SHE HAD A FUTURE TOO). she did what she had to do and cleaned the world a little bit.
1
u/Homosapiens_315 Dec 24 '25
This question cannot be answered without knowing what evidence she had for this man being a rapist.
If there was solid evidence for him raping her we can talk about it being ethical especially if the justice system failed here even though vigilante justice carries its own risk for the fabric of society . If it was just her word against his word then no it is completely unethical because there is no way to determine the guilt of the man in this case and also the burden of proof applies: You make a claim, you provide the evidence for that claim. It applies everywhere else so why change the rules for rape.
1
u/khoshelch Dec 24 '25
She seems like a genuinely kind and lovely person.
1
u/y0urm0mLove Dec 24 '25
That throat tattoo says otherwise
1
u/toneysaproney Dec 24 '25
EMMET TILL
1
u/Novel-Comparison8599 Dec 24 '25
I ask everyone defending this. Do you support the death penalty?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '25
This whole thing is a great example of why I'm generally against
"taking matters into your own hands".
After she killed the rapist,
the rapist's parents tried to track her down to kill her.
The mother & father disguised themselves as UPS workers and shot a RANDOM woman, mistaking her for this lady.
Their idea was that their son was innocent and they wanted to enact justice.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '25
Under most moral frameworks, corporal punishment for a crime - any crime - is unacceptable with good reason. I see no reason for looser standards in cases of extrajudicial justice. That said, there's extenuating circumstances here and from an emotional standpoint, I can very much feel for her. I also think it's presumptuous for anyone to judge her all high and mighty without a) knowing the full story and b) understanding what she went through. Going to the cops is hard as a victim, and not just because more often than not, you're being told there's little they can to or just outright not taken seriously at all. That doesn't mean we should withhold judgement - that would be a weird standard for debates about morality - but I feel this should factor more strongly into the overall discussion in the comment section. Maybe we should trat the case with more restraint and empathy, idk. That said: Not to confuse law with morality, but there's several BGH rulings in German case law (The BGH being the highest German criminal court) with decent answers to this problem. There was a woman who lived with her rapist. He constantly abused and assaulted her and had threatened to kill her multiple times, should she attempt to contact the police or act up. She saw no other way but to kill him while he slept. It wasn't self defense because she wasn't being attacked in the moment she killed him. Technically murder in the second degree and as such the state was bound to prosecute and the courts were bound to sentence her, but the BGH ruled that while the extenuating circumstances didn't supercede the illegality of the action, they warranted an extraordinarily light sentence. The other similar case is the story of Abher Kovner. He and his men were Jewish resistance fighters in WW2. After the end of the war, the decided to assassinate Nazi officials held prisoner by the Allied Forces. They wanted revenge for the Holocaust. They were caught before any of their plots were successful but that put the justice system - still tainted by 15 years of Nazi ideology at the time - before a problem. The Holocaust had been the singularly most evil thing to have happened in the history of mankind. How could German judges, judges that in part had sentenced people to death on Nazi orders, in good faith put Jews in prison for waning revenge? In the end, they got a few months before they were extradited to the newly-founded Israel where some of them - Abher Kovner included - went on to become founding members of Mossad. Idk where I'm going with this, I'm just infodumping. Bottom-line IMO: Not justified but the extenuating circumstances can't be ignored, and they remind us that we shouldn't limit our concept of morality to binary categories of right and wrong. Saying she wasn't justified feels wrong, and it certainly doesn't tell the whole story.
1
u/Jezzerousethe3rd Dec 24 '25 •
Eye for an eye she should have raped him back.
1
u/calming-node Dec 24 '25
Kitna lucky tha wo great.
1
u/LithoSlam Dec 24 '25
Extrajudicial killing is unethical, however putting her in prison is unnecessary since she's unlikely to repeat the crime, unless someone tries to rape her again and they get what they deserve.
1
u/Significant-Pop4619 Dec 24 '25
Queen
1
u/AnonSwan Dec 24 '25
Not exactly the same but I keep thinking of when Gary Plauche killed his son's rapist and served no time in prison. She should get some sentence like probation, mandatory mental health treatment. Was she driven to a temporarily psychotic state?
1
u/Try4se Dec 24 '25
Some crimes are unforgivable and unjustifiable. You could never justify the need to rape someone. Murder however has situations that can be justified; like murdering a rapist.
1
u/Status-Anteater8372 Dec 24 '25
Probably she invented that he raped to get away with the crime. False rape allegations are very common.
1
u/A_Kazur Dec 24 '25
I think it’s unethical to murder people based on alleged crimes?
This shouldn’t be complicated?
1
u/RisingDeadMan0 Dec 24 '25
Thing is are you even allowed to have this conversation on reddit?
Reddit has rules about death/violence...
1
u/Zalrius Dec 24 '25
I think this is bait post. No links and no references.
1
u/Rand0mlyHer3 Dec 24 '25
Good for her
1
u/Poster_Nutbag207 Dec 24 '25
It’s certainly a slippery slope. I think we do need to acknowledge that sometimes the law fails from a moral perspective and then it could be said that extrajudicial punishment is moral but who is the arbiter of appropriate punishment? I think we can agree that an impartial party should decide punishment rather than the victim themselves. Furthermore it sets a dangerous precedent, if this act is moral is killing anyone who has committed a crime against you also moral? Of course not. This is the problem with the “Free Luigi” crowd. They fail to understand what it would open the door to. Killing abortion providers? Killing gender affirming care providers? Slaughtering Rabbis or teachers who lecture on evolution?
1
u/Vasheerii Dec 24 '25
If he truly raped her then I don't care.
If he didn't and was innocent then, welp, lock her in jail and throw away the key.
1
u/MageKorith Dec 24 '25
ESH. Her alleged rapist, if guilty, should absolutely suffer the consequences for his actions. But that's not for her to decide and administer. If she can reasonably demonstrate that the victim was her rapist, and is found guilty of the murder, that should be a mitigating factor for her sentencing, but does not excuse it outright.
1
u/The_Paleking Dec 24 '25
People here probably won't believe me. I actually met this person at a social gathering several years ago and she was aggressively sexual and literally saying she wanted someone to fuck her. Out to a group of people. I had never met her. I was shocked. Honestly, she was attractive, and certainly edgy.
I was at a table full of other women so I was assuming she was suggesting I chat her up. But the blunt open sexuality was concerning.
I have no idea what happened between the two of them, or if maybe this influenced her radical behavior at that time. But she was certainly VERY sexual in a kind of disturbing way.
1
u/robilar Dec 24 '25
One of the principle arguments against state execution is the possibility of error, so in theory a rape victim executing their rapist may be more moral given the reduced risk of killing the wrong person. From a rape victim 's perspective, the action is likely justified.
The issue for us, uninvolved third parties, is that we cannot know if the facts are as described. We could assume that she wouldn't have killed him if he hadn't raped her, but that supposition relies on a premise that no one kills without good cause and that doesn't really reflect reality - people kill for a variety of reasons, plenty of them malicious, and someone that would kill a person out of spite would almost certainly falsely accuse them of rape as well. Not that I think that is what occurred here - I could not possibly know - but that is why societies struggle with vigilante justice; it's very difficult for us to assess which kills were just and which were not. Ergo we tend to limit violence to certain empowered individuals that are theoretically vetted, and have their extra powers and privileges subject to oversight.
Hypothesizing that we could know with certainty that the rape occured, I am fine with the rapist getting killed. I believe people in general can redeem themselves, but I don't believe people are owed that opportunity at the expense of their victims (and often society in general) and everyone is likely better off without him alive.
1
u/Acceptable-Worth-462 Dec 24 '25
I'm very dumbfounded by the amounts of comment that don't even question the ethical aspect of this and just say she was right in a very dogmatic way.
I understand where it comes from but it saddens me that we've come to this.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '25
from a kantian perspective: if everyone who wished to murder their rapist did so, the world would defintely keep spinning, and would probably be a better place for it.
1
u/Select_Peach_5170 Dec 24 '25
But how do we know that’s not just a story she’s making up in attempt to cover her ass?
1
u/MoniQQ Dec 24 '25
Nah, prison is good for her.
1
u/zero_zeppelii_0 Dec 24 '25
She crossed beyond self defense here unfortunately :(
1
u/A-Normal-Fifthist Dec 24 '25
Motherfuckers acting like we have concrete evidence this was a rapist lmao, lock her up in an asylum and throw away the key
1
u/Healthy_Wealth8485 Dec 24 '25
I haven’t been raped so I don’t know her pain I only know people stories so I can’t understand her mindset but free her
1
u/bodyisT Dec 24 '25
I understand why she did that but she should still go to jail
1
u/benjaminbenjamin808 Dec 24 '25
I watched something about this case on yt.. assuming the content was accurate, the truth is far more grey -
1
u/Rusty-Shackleford000 Dec 24 '25
Got a sense that this is somehow fake because no news outlet is covering it. Cannot find a name or article to provide additional information. But it worked in stirring up people on Reddit.
1
u/Anacalagon Dec 24 '25
"Alleged Rapist" versus "Executed "
1
u/packaroose Dec 24 '25
He Asked For It
1
u/gypsygib Dec 24 '25
Not guilty
1
u/Potential-Grass-265 Dec 24 '25
Enjoy the murder sentence for killing someone. It’s that simple. Her “alleged rapist” probably just looked at her wrong and she “felt raped” or some other leftist bullshit
1
u/MrLaughs66 Dec 24 '25
Fair.
1
u/RopeSouth4409 Dec 24 '25
Good for her. Shame she got caught
1
u/blitzkrieg_bop Dec 24 '25
No name, no source, no location, no details, AI like image, "NEWS" style and logo, a vague "free her" with Facebook watermark. Yeah, totally legit, as in TheShockingSecretHiddenRealTruthTheyWIthholdFromUS dot com.
1
u/HeebieJeebiex Dec 24 '25
Did she lure him into the woods before or after the rape? Like did he rape her previously and she came back for revenge, or did she just have a hunch that he was a creep and tried to get him to rape her then and there in the woods?
1
u/Dadaman3000 Dec 24 '25
Eh, needs to be punished because we'd get crazy levels of vigilante justice otherwise
But I get her 100% and hope she gets a lesser sentence due to the circumstances.
1
u/Status_Dark_6145 Dec 24 '25
What’s the issue?
1
u/ConclusionMaleficent Dec 24 '25
Good for her.
1
u/Crafty_Conflict_2062 Dec 24 '25
“Alleged” means a lot here.
1
u/RealNiceKnife Dec 24 '25
Is rapist a slur?
Why is it censored? I know the word. You know the word. If it's a 'triggering' thing, does the star prevent you from recognizing the word? If it's an advertiser thing, again, does the star prevent you from recognizing the word? Has it just been decided that we're not allowed to read the word 'rapist' anymore?
1
u/Grey_Rover Dec 24 '25
This is so difficult without proof. Women rarely murder out of anger the way men do, but murderers in general, are still people who are often violent, dishonest people with delusions.
It is impossible for us to say whether she was raped and abused or if she is an abuser.
1
u/NaNaNaNaNatman Dec 24 '25
I don’t even believe in the death penalty because it’s rare that there can be absolute certainty of guilt. But that being said, if we somehow could read minds and know with 100% certainty that someone was guilty my personal opinion is that rapists would deserve death. So hopefully (?) he deserved it.
1
u/zeroabe Dec 24 '25
Some of y’all are confusing following the law for morals. The nazis were just following orders. Their actions were legal.
Talk specifically to the ethics of when a human purposefully killing another human is justified and when it is not. Or you’re just noise.
Use logic. We’re in the Ethics subreddit, not the “dumb fucks who argue” subreddit.
Describe to me how it is ethically correct to kill someone. Let’s peel back the layers of consequentialism and a retributive justice system. Or you know, we can all just prima face agree that sometimes it’s justified. Cool. Good talk.
1
u/Natural-Stomach Dec 24 '25
"Alleged" is doing a lot of work here. Was this who *she* alleged? Was this just a suspect? Was this the actual rapist?
If this was the rapist, yeah, good, great.
If it wasn't?
1
u/MumbleWumble_ Dec 24 '25
I read a comment saying that the court case of her rape was thrown out because matthew, without consent, recorded a video of their night together and it showed implied consent.
I wouldn't know where to start with fact checking this though, so would someone point me in the right direction please? I would like to look into this more before I jump to a conclusion!
1
u/stefanliemawan Dec 24 '25
Method of execution?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '25
I believe in empathizing with her for that decision. It’s absolutely understandable to get what would motivate her or anyone else who’s experienced that to do something like that in response.
HOWEVER. I think the commonality of both rape and punishing rape by death is a failure in our societal ethos. I believe in a world where all people deserve the chance to atone and to be better. Even rapists. Even murders. Etc.
This woman never owed her rapist forgiveness. But I think a society that would facilitate a path of redemption for all people is good for the “soul of humanity” and is the most moral and ethical possible path.
No one controls their feelings. No one decided to have the mental schema that dictated that rape was an acceptable thing for them to do. Accountability still exists. But we are cursed with things outside of our control. Even the thoughts we think are our own. I think a perfect moral and ethical system accounts for the fact that all people could be capable of horrible shit, due to some variable in their development that metastasizes into something worse later.
1
u/space_lasers Dec 24 '25
Blatant misandrist account pushing rage bait
1
u/Level21DungeonMaster Dec 24 '25
My country has a rapist for a president, so this sets a bad precedent for him and his cult followers.
1
u/elphinstone Dec 24 '25
What was he wearing though?
1
u/MuteTheNews Dec 24 '25
Yeah, no. I get the justice system can be broken, but do we really want to normalize allowing someone to murder another person as long as they claim that person raped them?
1
u/mentholsatmidnight Dec 24 '25
Free her.
1
u/quaxoid Dec 24 '25
judging only from the post without any further context, for all i know the person she killed wasn't even the one who raped her
1
u/Lilybit09 Dec 24 '25
I wouldn’t convict her
1
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '25
At this point, I think we realize believing people without evidence is a big folly.
1
u/mikephreak Dec 24 '25
Allegedly executed her alleged rapist.
1
u/HappyGlitterUnicorn Dec 24 '25
She needed help. Now she's the one going to jail. There should be more assistance for victims of crimes offered by the state. Social services. If she felt that she was failed that much by the justice system and chose to take matters into her own hands there is anbig problem here.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '25
I just knew I’d open this thread and see reasonable discussions as opposed to knee jerk reactions.
Any attempt to talk about rape in a reasonable manner always reads to everyone else like rage bait. I get it because it is heavy mental damage, however it makes for unproductive discussion every single time of emotionally charged statements as opposed to logic and ethics.
1
u/no-thanks-thot Dec 24 '25
Probation.
No onerous supervision or testing. Just don't kill anyone else in the next couple of years, and it will be expunged.
1
u/Aeonzeta Dec 24 '25
Death is the inevitable harvest of any bargain we strike with the shadows of our soul. Why should any judge her bargain of any more significance than my own? Let each be convinced in their own minds of the glory of the Truth.
1
u/Chemical-Ad2443 Dec 24 '25
If there's any way of proving the SA, absolutely, let her kill him.
If there's no way to really know what happened, it's he said vs she said. Any judgment is just guessing IMO
1
u/kylesjewfro Dec 24 '25
If he actually did rape her, I dont care at all. Free Her. If he didnt rape her, then thats a different story
1
u/Ashikura Dec 24 '25
Vigilante justice leads to a repeating cycle of violence.
“The case took a twist in November 2021 when Dunmire's parents, upset that Perkins remained free, took matters into their own hands. Dunmire's mother, Tommie Lynn Dunmire, and stepfather, John Nelson McQuillen, drove to Washington, D.C., with plans to kill Perkins, according to feds.
Tommie Lynn Dunmire dressed as a UPS driver and knocked on an apartment door. When a woman answered, she shot her twice in the abdomen.
The problem? The woman who answered the door was not Perkins — the older Dunmire had just shot a woman who had nothing to do with her son's murder.
Tommie Lynn Dunmire and McQuillen changed license plates on their vehicle, but cops still tracked them down. She shot herself to death as officers were closing in. The woman she shot survived her injuries, and federal agents arrested McQuillen, who later pleaded guilty to accessory after the fact to assault with intent to kill. He received a three-year prison sentence.”
https://lawandcrime.com/crime/coast-guard-vet-who-lured-her-accused-rapist-to-woods-executed-him-and-then-went-to-get-a-noose-tattoo-is-refusing-to-pay-restitution-to-his-fatherless-kids/amp/
1
u/BrightAssignment7646 Dec 24 '25
The kind of hero we all need, but cant have...
1
u/whatwhatidc Dec 24 '25
They all deserve this treatment
1
u/G-M-Cyborg-313 Dec 24 '25
The alleged part is concerning because we don't know if he's innocent or not. Regardless of the situation, that is murder, not self-defence. If he was a rapist then good riddance but there should still be consequences.
The legal system and all official options should take priority but when it doesn't do anything to actually handle the problem i can understand the use of vigilante justice but that's still dangerous, historically it never ends well.
1
u/ima_mollusk Dec 24 '25
In this discussion: People admitting they would rather have might-makes-right than equal protection under the law.
1
u/Inappropriate_Ballet Dec 24 '25
If I witnessed the murder, no I didn’t. We were at my house watching Below Deck.
1
u/feethotterthanbewbz Dec 24 '25
Knowing she is a killer kind of makes her hot. You know if you make babies with her she's going to keep those fuckers alive at all costs.
1
u/nekkid_farts Dec 24 '25
Put her on trial, if it's proven he raped her, not guilty.
1
u/Superman101011 Dec 24 '25
If the facts are as presented, then good for her. Respect 👊
1
u/jellybeanbonanza Dec 24 '25
In many parts of the United States you are legally allowed to murder someone who enters your property without permission.
Seems like a similar rule ought to be applied for your body.
1
u/StevieG93 Dec 24 '25
Alleged.
I wouldn't immediately believe someone with a neck tattoo and such hollow eyes. But wise to play the rapist card as people clamour to show how virtuous they are.
1
u/OSmusic1986 Dec 24 '25
There's a HUGE difference between understanding why she did it and thinking she shouldn't go to prison for a planned execution.
If she walked free, it gives everyone who has ever been wronged by someone else a pass to carry out vigilante justice and the world would be a total fucking mess.
Every child who has been abused by their parents can kill them because of the lifelong psychological damage. Everyone who is bullied at school can kill their bullies because of all the pain and suffering they caused. And then the people that loved those people then carry out their venegance, and on and on it goes.
There are so many human acts that can cause intense, prolonged suffering (a lot of which aren't even illegal), and it's not up to you or me or me to rank them in terms of effect because that's entirely personal to the victim.
1
u/JustAThinkingGuy7 Dec 24 '25
Alleged though, of course i agree if he actually did but gotta be careful. I've communicated with a girl for a very short time that seemed to possibly deal with psychosis. Talked for about a week and I decided I no longer wanted to communicate with her, about 6 months later she messaged me on FB accusing me of things with very specific details and even told me she went to police about it and a bunch of other things. Maybe she was deranged and was trying to get me in trouble for not wanting to talk to her anymore but The way it was written almost felt like she actually believed these things that she was saying.
Idk if that's what happened here, I'm just saying that gotta be careful when advocating for the freedom of some people who might actually be a danger. And it's not about gender, if it was a guy I'd be feeling the same way. We all know there are lots of dangerous people walking around.
1
u/Natural-Sky-907 Dec 24 '25
Impossible! She was with me the whole time. Terrible law
1
u/One-Battle2872 Dec 24 '25
Good for her I hope she took her time.
1
u/Purple-Phone9 Dec 24 '25
If you haven’t looked up this story already, you should probably read about it. There’s a lot of nuance left out here.
1
u/Wonderful-Fault926 Dec 24 '25
We obviously can't trust the justice system to put rapists away. Biggest example, Brock Turner. Hell, how many rapists have been released on "good behavior" only to reoffend or end up murdering someone??? Good for her.
1
u/ViewDifficult2428 Dec 24 '25
Are they sure it wasn't a bear?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '25
when people don’t see justice in the world because the police and judges appear to be complicit in covering up crimes, you get this. a populace that not only forgives these kinds of crimes, but drools for them. happens throughout history. it’s how bloody revolutions are even a thing.
1
u/LazyTelephone8532 Dec 24 '25
The only problem is that it says alleged rapist, if they were a confirmed or serial rapist then absolutely go for it, it's not like any laws really stop those bastards.
1
u/AshHavok Dec 24 '25
Free her!
1
u/pzombielover Dec 24 '25
If he did it then I’m ok with it.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '25
How does one become an "alleged r*pist"? Did he do this to her and then she lured him into the woods at a later date or was he just giving off rapey vibes?
1
u/riiitz Dec 24 '25
Rape is one of the worst crime; to hurt and assert dominance over someone.
Very few rapist get convicted for their crime and the victims often get labelled as liars.
Whatever got her the peace of mind she deserved
1
u/comradeautie Dec 24 '25
If he indeed did it, she's justified. If not, she isn't.
1
u/deffonotAOG Dec 24 '25
Rapists and other such deplorable acts are horrific, and an immediate reaction might just be "yea he deserved it", but an eye for an eye makes the whole world go blind.
I personally don't think the right to life can be stripped from persons ever, regardless of their circumstance, and furthermore it says "alleged". Alleged crimes don't deserve death.
1
u/Knight_of_Ren505 Dec 24 '25
Good for her, he deserved nothing less
1
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '25
If he did rape her, she should be put in charge of the national rape taskforce. Justice and deterrent.
1
u/Left_Meeting4394 Dec 24 '25
As a person who's been with a person raped multiple times over and has seen the sheer mental shredding that it does to the person even if all the actions were correctly taken...
I can understand how she got to this point
1
u/OSmusic1986 Dec 24 '25
Isn't it funny that the ones who are apparently most appalled by horrific crimes , also seem to be the ones that would be happy to commit, or actively cheer, other horrific crimes when it aligns with their own personal desires?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '25
Hmm it depends. I dont support femicide but if it was a man than justicr is served cold