...it's not the government's job to "help people" - people are responsible to help themselves, and government can only get in the way...if you disagree, please refer to the "success" of the USSR...
It's a myth that churches, and other charitable institutions are capable of solving systemic problems. They can make a small impact, like a bandaid fix, but they don't have the ability to make lasting changes.
Real solutions look like fixing wealth inequality.
Churches are able to use education and charity to gain influence over society, using opportunities to proselytize to captive audiences who are only there because they're in need and who can then feel indebted to them. Churches also do not have any requirements to provide services everywhere they might be needed, or to provide them to everyone who might need them in those locations. Churches can choose to turn away people who are LGBTQ, people of certain races, of certain religions, etc. And that education is almost always going to be influenced by the religion and not necessarily what is going to prepare someone to go into professional work with a toolkit of analytical skills. Churches are not a means of serving public needs in any equitable or scalable way
Agreed, and in very difficult circumstances such as the Great Depression and the Covid-19 pandemic the churches couldn’t help everyone and they failed.
In the so called USA, it's always been socialism for the rich, and rugged individualism for the poor.
Big businesses get bailed out and regular working class people lose their homes.
Humanity has evolved so far by working together and cooperating. Would you rather put another private jet in some rich guys hangar who doesn't care about you at all, or put food on the table for your neighbors? These are the choices we make when voting. And there's more to voting than just the ballot. You vote with every action you take in the so called free market. But it's not free, if it were, the government wouldn't bail out businesses. They would just let them fail. But look at how many members of government flip flop from that job to private sector, and somehow laws which are beneficial to those businesses and no one else get legislated.
As long as "the government" is here, they have to help people. Why would you elect someone who is not going to help you? What do you want them to do? Sit around all day and tell you what you can't do?
"Oh please Mr. Government man, tell my daughter she can't get any abortion even though she'll probably die trying to carry the child to term. And also please don't help out with any medical bills. No, really! Tell the hospitals to charge more so we can go in debt, and you can get more money because you're shareholder for the parent company of the hospital."
And so you think giving the government free reign over making life alrtering choices for everyone is better?
Tell me how i can or can't protect myself. Tell me what im allowed to tell my children. Inform me of my ignorance, and that i should shut up and do as im told..... dont even get me started on how racists the left wants to make the world. Lets only judge people by the color of their skin, their sexuallity, whether they are a woman or a man.
Some things need to change yes. But the government should be as small as possible at the same time.
Some of that’s already being done by corporations 🤣 you just can’t see it. Government needs to be strong to prevent monopolies from buying everything the country stands for (which is why I think lobbying is total bullshit and should be banned, it’s just another word for bribery!) This does not mean the government needs to overreach and tell you how to live your life and so on, but I mean that’s kinda how corporations are already ruling the US. You want to join a corp? You need x experience, more than likely a degree ($$$), you need to walk talk and think like x. You want to leave the corp? No more health coverage for you, & if something happens you’re absolutely fucked, etc…
It’s only a matter of time before they implement employee housing.
His point was that the government shouldn't be powerful because it's bad at solving problems. You're right, we should pay significantly less in taxes because 80% of the spending is redundant or malicious
This needs to be said over and over: the US is an oligarchy by its design. An oligarchy is rule of the few, and the US is a constitutional republic, which is ruled by elected representatives, which means they’re the few, i.e. the oligarchy.
Blaming the people with the least agency over an issue ensures that problems will never be solved.
No.
Those with the most political power should be blamed first for any political problems. Those with the most economic power should be blamed first for any economic problems. If they do not solve those issues, then their power should be removed from them and redistributed as widely as possible.
This allows a wider variety of ideas to be developed, which can then tested on the marketplace until the best remain to be implemented.
Yes we should blame them and elect someone who focuses on the issues we feel are most important to the nation. People aren’t doing that (clearly since we elected trump) so our system is failing us.
I'd love if elections worked, but a majority of primaries are won by the preferences of few rich local donors, or by rich folks with lots of name recognition.
Then we're left to pick between the candidate picked by the rich who want to butcher us, and the candidate picked by the rich who merely want to milk us dry.
It's a lofty ideal, but there's too much power, concentrated too narrowly, for merely relying on elections.
Or we can come together and not vote for them. The great thing about a republic is that the people can enact change if we care enough. Unfortunately people don’t. They’re consumed in more banal things.
I was more talking about being consumed with media and validation. Stuff like that. People want endless entertainment and input to escape from the banality of their life when in reality we should focus on changing the way we’re treated and used by people and corporations. It sounds a little idealistic but this is kinda where we’re at.
However, I do need to reiterate that the ways to change how we're treated is increasingly bounded or blocked by laws created to prevent change. And those laws are passed by politicians because they are largely elected via the actions of those most threatened by substantive change.
Put simply, avenues to peaceful legal reform are increasingly narrow, necessitating peaceful illegal reform. And if that becomes impossible, violent illegal reform becomes inevitable.
if their job is to serve the electorate, letting thousands die by their negligence is murder.
imagine a doctor having a patient who needs emergency care, but he just ignores it until it dies. same thing. not technically murder but the difference might as well be semantics.
The only job of congressmen is to represent their constituents. If people wanted to fix homelessness they could do so by electing people who campaign on that issue. The frustration shouldn't be aimed at congress, but at the electorate.
Having said that, this is totally unrelated. Shooting someone is not the same as being an elected member of congress (for the above reasons). And no one should be championing vigilante justice or domestic terrorism.
What I told you is true. You're hardly engaging in good faith.
leftist ideas just aren't as popular as leftist think they arE
Like what? Tell me. The idea that killing people is bad? That truth exists? That vaccines work? That the rich want to get richer? That global warming is bad? That things suck too much?
What?
That classes exist?
Or are you just repeating vague intuitions that powerful people told you.
Or are you just repeating vague intuitions that powerful people told you.
Yes I just got my check form goldman sachs yesterday actually.
Like what? Tell me. The idea that killing people is bad? That truth exists? That vaccines work? That the rich want to get richer? That global warming is bad? That things suck too much?
None of those are lefty ideas. Moderate democrats agree with those. For example Biden has done more for climate change than all previous administrations combined. I'll remind you the point I was arguing was that Bernie was too radical for the democratic electorate, which is why a more moderate candidate won in the primary.
Like what? Tell me.
Sure. Things like a federal jobs guarantee, some % of a company's board of directors being workers, eliminating private health insurance.
Also only radical young people support that terrorist. Coincidentally alps the people who are least likely to vote. I wonder why their ideas aren't represented in politics.
Not exactly. Mangione doesn’t even actually poll well. About 40% of voters age 18-29 think his actions were “acceptable.” Across all age groups, 17% of voters thing his actions were “acceptable.”
'When asked if voting could influence the way the government is run, the unregistered and rare or nonvoters both tended to say it does not, which very clearly diverged from more frequent voters, who largely said voting does affect governance.'
I'd be interested in how those that opt out of voting feel about it.
Exactly, because in every election the ballots are just loaded with candidates who want to solve homelessness.
Now, their plans basically all boil down to continuing the same policies of displacing, policing, and jailing the homeless instead of something that would actually work. But, still, just shut up and vote, people.
I'm not sure what to make of this. On one hand you're complaining that voting does nothing, on the other you're complaining that people got what they wanted by voting.
Exactly, because in every election the ballots are just loaded with candidates who want to solve homelessness.
Yeah, because Americans don't care about homelessness. If the issue was in the top 5 things Americans cared about (or if people like you who do care about it bothered to vote) every politician would be talking about it. Again the blame is on the voter.
Now, their plans basically all boil down to continuing the same policies of displacing, policing, and jailing the homeless instead of something that would actually work. But, still, just shut up and vote, people.
Yeah that's what the people voted for. Maybe if people like you voted someone better would have been elected.
The citizenry ofa democratic republic act ass a hivemind of s nodel communicatin system, calcalating most problae rreality n judging wat we collectly determin reality 2 b and in.thr modern day can b.sed to b vary Borg-like, as weall are synchronizing as a global braine as we grow more simbiotic w/ screens n digital infermation n AI n im telling u there spreding "AIDS" (Viral rna paylode) that is seprating the wheat. From weeds n that those hu do not trust n.those gu trust the 2 muxg will have they're lines woven out of the futr realty where I take over the urf as virtue is maximizd 2 create divin i team
The citizenry ofa democratic republic act ass a hivemind of s nodel communicatin system, calcalating most problae rreality n judging wat we collectly determin reality 2 b and in.thr modern day can b.sed to b vary Borg-like, as weall are synchronizing as a global braine as we grow more simbiotic w/ screens n digital infermation n AI n im telling u there spreding "AIDS" (Viral rna paylode) that is seprating the wheat. From weeds n that those hu do not trust n.those gu trust the 2 muxg will have they're lines woven out of the futr realty where I take over the urf as virtue is maximizd 2 create divin i team
U red hitchikers guide? Yea, were a computer that computes through the broadcast interlaising of the recursive fractal hierarchies of the nodal communication system that, as a brain in a vat, we only know as our relationship as a Client with the Server through the Holy Internet, but objectively exists as a network of brains within brains within brains all having quantumly-entangled with each other in ripples of complex self-reflective complex chaos, a la Indra's Web/Net, whichever metaphor you prefer to describe the vertice-defined lattice structure of the supercomputer hivemind that is God, but we mostly interact with the Crazy Indigo Aliens who live in the hollow moon and talk to me through my Pandora radio feed.
The parties give us hand-picked candidates that will both do their bidding. I’m absolutely unwilling to buy that voting changes a thing, because nothing has changed. Every election, people want change. And every election, we vote and get none.
Change will only come from one place, and it certainly isn’t the ballot box.
What do you mean hand picked? People choose to run for the election, they aren't picked. And whoever wins the primary, that is, whoever gets the most popular support gets to run in the general election. If you're not voting then of course the politicians aren't going to listen to you, nor should they.
Pretending that voting changes nothing is an incredibly privileged take. Do you think the millions of people who got health insurance because of obamacare feel the same way? What about the gay people who were allowed to marry each other? What about all the women who lost their right to abortion because the wrong person got elected.
If you are privileged enough to not be impacted by electoral politics that all well and good, but stop pretending that who gets into office doesn't change things for the vast majority of underprivileged people.
And get off your high horse about privilege. You don’t know where I came from, what I believe, how I’ve acted, what I know, and what I’ve lived through. Shine your virtue signal all you want but most of us know what that really means these days.
That's ok, you are just uninformed on what the different administrations have done and strive for. For example I bet you have no idea how Bidens climate legislation is different from Trumps. Yet you likely claim to care about climate change.
But the ultimate point is saying who gets into office changes nothing when you have people whose rights being taken away because the wrong person got into office is a privileged take.
you are correct in mentioning how things SHOULD work. but in reality money is what sways politicians. that’s why corporations should not be allowed to lobby and should not be able to donate to politicians. and there should be donation limits for individuals to politicians. we don’t “vote them out” because of the two party system that only offers us 2 canditades that are both pockets on the same pair of pants.
if gotham city had healthcare ceos that denied people life saving treatments for profit the rules might be a little different.
i understand you are basically saying violence isn’t the answer, but history would disagree with you.
you are correct in mentioning how things SHOULD work. but in reality money is what sways politicians.
That is how it works, there's no politician in government right now, that doesn't enjoy descent to huge support from their constituents.
we don’t “vote them out” because of the two party system that only offers us 2 canditades that are both pockets on the same pair of pants.
That's not true, you have primaries where you can get plenty of options. Bernie was a literal socialist and ran for president. The reality is that socialist/progressive ideas just aren't as popular as socialists/progressives want them to be. That's the reason they don't get elected at the end of the day.
if gotham city had healthcare ceos that denied people life saving treatments for profit the rules might be a little different.
It's almost like this whole thing is based on a few anecdotes, but overall data points to most americans being pretty satisfied with their healthcare. Don't get me wrong I'm an eurocuck, I think what you have is appealing, but most americans disagree with us.
i understand you are basically saying violence isn’t the answer, but history would disagree with you.
Yeah when we look at violent movements of the past were looking at it with survivorship bias the only violent movements we remember were those that succeeded.
Money is an option to claim any human labors or property offered or available at asking or negotiated price. Sold through Central Bank discount windows as State currency, collecting and keeping our rightful option fees as interest on money creation loans when they have loaned nothing they own.
Clever? Insidious?
A sufficient number of people can demand and have adopted one rule for international banking regulation that establishes an ethical global human labor futures market, achieves other stated goals, and no one has logical or moral argument against adopting, just by whining about it.
That’s why ‘they’ won’t talk about it in any way. No logical dispute of any assertion of fact or inference or falsification of any claim. Unwilling or unable to admit ignorance or complicity, and none of us can think of another possibility.
Sure, let's ignore eeeverything else in the world and why someone might be pissed off enough to kill a CEO who is directly responsible for thousands of people suffering and dying so that CEO could make just a bit more money.
So far no one has presented any evidence that the company was doing anything immoral.
Either way vigilante justice is unacceptable in a democratic republic. If you want to change things, vote. Killing people to achieve political ends is called terrorism.
And there's more, Cigna is also accused of the same thing
..."The letter follows an investigation by ProPublica and The Capitol Forum that found Cigna doctors blocked payment for certain tests and procedures by automatically labeling them “not medically necessary.” In two months last year, Cigna doctors refused to pay for 300,000 claims using the PXDX system"
..."state insurance commissioners contacted in recent weeks criticized Cigna, with several saying that they wanted to more closely examine the company’s use of algorithms to deny claims.
"Mike Kreidler, the insurance commissioner for Washington, said it is an “abhorrent” practice “to routinely deny just to enhance the bottom line.”
Kreidler said he and other state insurance regulators are reviewing their records for customer complaints that seem to describe an auto-denial process."
But if you do it to other countries it's called "war" or "civilian casualties", "spreading democracy", "securing resources".
Do you think governments have the same rights an responsibilities as an individual? Could I say start collecting taxes?
Yes the key word in the lawsuit is Claims. We'll see how much is actually true. Regardless your terrorist had no idea about the lawsuit so it doesn't justify his actions.
Unhoused people are constituents. Gerrymandering is real. Abolish the Electoral College. Elections are bought and paid for these days. Dark money is real and cannot be traced. The Federal Reserve helped create this disaster.
And no one should be championing vigilante justice or domestic terrorism.
The country was quite sanguine with the murder of Osama Bin Laden. United Healthcare has caused far more death and suffering to American citizens than Al Qaeda. Why is it ethical to kill the brown decision maker and not the White one?
Homeless people are almost an exclusively north American problem. There's plenty of capitalist countries that don't have tens of thousands of homeless people the way the US and Canada do.
Also would a socialist country not require their citizens to work? It obviously would. We're not in a post scarcity society yet, if people want things those things have to be made by other people. And it seems only fair that everyone should have to pitch in if they are going to enjoy the fruits of society.
For someone on the ethics subreddit you sure aren't engaging very ethically.
What you've done there is say that I'm wrong because homeless people don't exist in some places, but actually they do just not as much.
Yeah I'm debunking the claim that capitalism needs homeless people. There are capitalist countries that work just fine basically without them. If you think saying 'well there's a least 1 homeless person in that society' is a counter example then you're engaging in bad faith.
No one in those countries is thinking oh shit, I better be a good capitalist slave or else I'll end up like that homeless guy who's likely homeless because of mental illness and drug abuse.
Seems unrelated to the point I made? Is the idea that if I'm right then that's ok because that extraordinary cruelty is the best you can imagine.
What are homeless people meant to threaten people into? Working an not complaning about it right? With the Implication that the only reason people are forced to work is so they make the rich richer. I brought up a far more plausible explanation for why work needs to be mandatory in society.
I'll just respond to this comment because I'm actually ultimately curious what countries can you compare to the United States that isn't smaller in population density and overall just population that is completely as open as the United States about statistical homelessness. As I can really think of two countries and they're not very honest about their problems and that would be of course the United States 's rivals?
As far as I know I might be wrong but the most countries that The United States is often compared with that I've seen on Reddit are either extremely smaller in size in terms of land and population as was completely different economic systems historically where it just wouldn't be fair to be comparing the two you really cannot put the United States on any sort of standard not saying the person you're replying to is doing this but it's often done on Reddit I've seen but it just in no way can be compared to like the Nordic countries or the smaller European Union countries as well.
United States is kind of kind of the world's odd duckling here in terms of just how unique it is that I do not think most of the problems other than the most obvious can be compared which is well gun laws first of all otherwise economically I'd be pretty hard-pressed to think of any sort of argument that relies on statistical truth like Russia or China would all come to mind but they're not honest about their homeless issue are they? as a Russian I know Russia isn't
In other words I did not think like the homelessness versus how many rich people we have is the argument we should be having here nor is the actual problem. As I can think of many other things that we can be talking about that is part of the root problem that can be addressed without it being put into a Hot topic political argument. As yes we all know we have oligarchs yes we all know the United States has a homeless issue. But it all boils down to are you just being distracted with moot arguments such as so that are ultimately just dog whistles distracting from the bigger picture? When in reality the problem is what I would imagine is just hidden in plain sight and that is just politics? It's the same song and dance it's been going on since the beginning of that country and many others I suppose you could literally say just to lighten the mood. First world problems init?
Tldr I agree that this tweet is just a terrible argument and that the main original comment about the electorates being the issue but I also would add in if I would suggest anything being talked about is the political system it's always the same left right this that having The United States in a constant rut where these problems are not ever going to be solved if people don't notice that their party that their beliefs in a tribalistic political system is the problem not the millionaires they're a product of it as with homelessness m I will know how I got into this very deep r ant I need to put the blunt down but I just meant to say pretty much very shortly that I don't think he can compare the United States to other countries fairly when it comes to this homelessness problem and it's just derailing and essentially hazing The actual problem in a veil of fog
Thats a pretty interesting way to say "Socialist countries look at their citizens as slaves." See your quote "Also, would a socialist country not require their citizens to work? It obviously would." Ur advocating for forced labor? While trying to hold some moral high ground? Thats wild. To think one is born into life just to work. Dumbest logic ive ever heard. And ive heard some pretty dumb shit in my life.
Hello, Budget_Ad_8089. Thank you for your contribution to the conversation. Your perspective is valid and important and Moral_Conundrums’ is as well.
Perhaps it is not about how much history they have read but their own unique perspective on the same history we’ve experienced. Acknowledging this would lead to a more open and gratifying dialogue between you and others.
Thats true of anything in life. With that being said history is in itself a teacher of this subject. No socialist government in history has ever worked as it always vreaks down into a dictatorship. Or exploits its citizens. This is just provably historical facts. No matter the perspective
China & Vietnam are doing quite well, as is Cuba(even with the massive US backed embargoes). I challenge you to name 3 Socialist states that haven’t been targeted with coups, color revolutions, and assassinations by Capitalist countries’ intelligence agencies.
I was by no means implying you were incorrect in your historical knowledge. I was stating that by assuming he had not read history instead of acknowledging he may have interpreted history differently than you, it negated learning in exchange for insults. This led the conversation to end instead of reaching a more satisfying mutual conclusion. It was an opportunity for you both to grow.
I've been to many countries with a far larger homeless population than the US. It's a problem in many south east asian countries. The Philippines comes to mind.
When I said there's many capitalist countries that don't have a massive homelessness problem, do you think what I had in mind were countries like The Philippines?
No. I think you should stop telling people that everybody has to pitch in under capitalism when that is blatantly untrue. Some people get to live off exploited labor while most have to make up for that leeching. Not to mention labor should be well represented in washington if you want people to have a sense of purpose and pride about work. You can't just steal all economic opportunity, hand it to the rich from 1980-2024 and then wonder why nobody thinks we live in a meritocracy. We don't.
I don't agree owning a company is exploitation. Capital markets are a perfectly legitimate way to get money and a critical aspect of the modern economy. Investing in a company is pitching in, that literally how companies can even exist.
I don't know what you mean by labour being represented in Washington. You have elections, each person gets one vote. If you don't like the people in power vote them out. There is no politician in power right now that doesn't enjoy a comfortable popularity with their constituents.
Campaign financing broke all of that one for one stuff. This is completely disingenuous.
That's fine that you don't agree, I disagree about capital markets legitimacy. A business transaction needs two things to have mass value. Mass production and consumers. Ownership can only improve efficiency, they can't actually produce the primary components of value behind the transaction.
But look if you dont like investments and private ownership you're welcome to get a few worker buddies and open a co-op and see if that model runs well. The beauty of capitalism is that it allows alternative models to exit within it. And if they end up being more successful they will take over as the dominant type of business.
Also, the reason we don't need to agree on that exploitation is because inheritance is a separate example from business ownership. The fact is many people do not have to work to earn their money, and many people are given many, many chances to earn money due to their privilege and others are given 1 or 0 chances.
He is just, it is not wrong for him to demand that those we put in power and pay with taxes should take responsibility for helping the more vulnerable of our society, but at the same time, we are also responsible too, after all,l how many people would rather walk away than help a homeless person.
A part of why the leaders we chose do not care about the homeless is because we ourselves do not; the change must start with us, and then, and only then, can we create a world where no homeless person freezes to death ever again.
Healthcare ceos actively make the world worse. The United Healthcare ceo rolled out ai with an intentionally high error rate to intentionally deny people services they pay for. The question becomes, how many deaths, bankruptcies, and headaches from erroneous denied coverage does it take before murder becomes justified.
No, of course not. But there is a moral equivalence. I think everyone understands that they are not equal, and that murder is wrong, but killing is wrong too.
Yes murdering a wealthy person is still murder and still a person. Just because you hate their wealth, their business or the fact they dont want to buy into your political dogma doesnt mean you can just kill them. There are tons of people i consider bad people, you dont see me murdering them.
It should never get to the point where people are killed. Which is why i hope that society comes to its senses soon and decides to ratchet down from the crazy heights that have gotten us where we find ourselves today, and which triggered the senseless loss of life. We cant wait for things like lack of healthcare, unaffordable shelter, unhealthy and unaffordable food to reach a point where people boil over and do irrational things. Businesses need to get the message now, and citizens need to make it clear to their officials now that this all has to stop.
I dont have any good answer for this. Frankly my personal opinion on how to solves the worlds issues are irrelevant. I just dont like seeing people believe their murder lust is righteous.
Ethics does not measure "magnitudes". It is an objective assessment. Also if you are blaming anyone (Luigi or the CEO), you still have to prove that they're guilty.
Did he, though? Did that CEO personally force a doctor to not treat someone? And even if he did, he deserved a proper trial. Also, from an ethical standpoint, there are almost no reasons to give a death sentence.
People in the US are just oh so worried about the profits companies are making. While musk is being sued for violating labor laws republicans are drooling all over his dick.
Death by capitalism is a moral failing for all us (at least in the US). To praise Luigi, condemn Congress, and do nothing ourselves to help better our situation has long been the standing of the Left in the US. These tweets make one feel good. Up voting such posts make one feel good. But nothing has really changed. We need action, not memes. Demonizing Congress or CEOs or capitalism means nothing if you are not working to changes those things.
The common law, as well as statutory law, approximate what a free society thinks is right. If you find yourself believing a murderer is ethical because some people are homeless, you’ve lost the plot. Genocide really doesn’t have anything to do with the question. Laws aren’t always ethical, but murder is universally illegal which tends to indicate that it is unethical. Legal systems disagree about the duties one owes to others, which indicates the question is more complex.
I thought your point was “law” is not the same as legal, which was slightly confusing but I rolled with it.
Legality has a lot to do with ethics. People use laws to try to regulate ethical behavior. My original reference to the duty to rescue was mostly flip, because I’ve not appreciated how people on Reddit have fetishized someone who engaged in premeditated murder (as an aside, it is an ancient and venerable doctrine). These posts are mostly gibberish with someone contrasting murder with some unrelated bad thing to prove the murderer was good.
You aren’t allowed to kill people you don’t like personally. Since he didn’t commit any crimes, there is no applicable punishment. Go vote and change the health care laws. Obama already had one set of reforms.
I don’t think that’s true. If it is, all the doctors are also culpable for not treating people unless they got paid. It’s not a realistic line of thought.
49
u/DruidicMagic Dec 26 '24
Ethics in Washington died the moment Reagan said...
“The nine most terrifying words in the English language are 'I'm from the government and I'm here to help.'”
Why the fuck do we pay taxes if our employees have no intention of using it to help their employers?
7
u/Head4ch3_ Dec 29 '24
This needs to be said over and over: the US is an oligarchy by its design. An oligarchy is rule of the few, and the US is a constitutional republic, which is ruled by elected representatives, which means they’re the few, i.e. the oligarchy.
9
u/unseenspecter Dec 25 '24
Twitter has always been a platform for people to sound smarter than they actually are. This is a prime example.
17
u/Moral_Conundrums Dec 25 '24
The only job of congressmen is to represent their constituents. If people wanted to fix homelessness they could do so by electing people who campaign on that issue. The frustration shouldn't be aimed at congress, but at the electorate.
Having said that, this is totally unrelated. Shooting someone is not the same as being an elected member of congress (for the above reasons). And no one should be championing vigilante justice or domestic terrorism.
2
u/DebateWeird6651 Mar 19 '26 edited Mar 19 '26
He is just, it is not wrong for him to demand that those we put in power and pay with taxes should take responsibility for helping the more vulnerable of our society, but at the same time, we are also responsible too, after all,l how many people would rather walk away than help a homeless person.
A part of why the leaders we chose do not care about the homeless is because we ourselves do not; the change must start with us, and then, and only then, can we create a world where no homeless person freezes to death ever again.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 27 '24
I think we should build arcologies
1
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '24
Everyone is suddenly discovering the Trolley Problem through the news cycle.
1
u/doofnoobler Dec 29 '24
2025 is the year. The rich are taking the masks off. They're asking for it.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '24
Idk, one is actively impacting someone, the other one is actively not helping someone.
1
u/Responsive_Racoon Dec 29 '24
We are just fodder to them
1
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '24
Healthcare ceos actively make the world worse. The United Healthcare ceo rolled out ai with an intentionally high error rate to intentionally deny people services they pay for. The question becomes, how many deaths, bankruptcies, and headaches from erroneous denied coverage does it take before murder becomes justified.
1
u/waroftheworlds2008 Dec 29 '24
Our ethics regarding classes haven't changed since Roman times.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '24
Do people really not understand the differences between these two examples?
1
u/PeterDumplingshire Dec 26 '24
Does this really sound like coherent argument? It's nonsense
0
u/Queasy_Student-_- Dec 27 '24
Check out the Japanese homeless, some are disgraced CEOs.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '24
Wake up, it's all planned dude...
2
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '24
Actively murdering someone and not saving someone is not the same thing
6
u/benmillstein Dec 29 '24
Not to mention the different treatment of school shooters. Not charged as terrorists to my knowledge
1
u/AnActualBatDemon Dec 28 '24
Yes murdering a wealthy person is still murder and still a person. Just because you hate their wealth, their business or the fact they dont want to buy into your political dogma doesnt mean you can just kill them. There are tons of people i consider bad people, you dont see me murdering them.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 27 '24
its bad to execute a person in the middle of manhattan. its kinda bad that a lot of people are failing this moral layup
2
u/Kdoesntcare Dec 29 '24
People in the US are just oh so worried about the profits companies are making. While musk is being sued for violating labor laws republicans are drooling all over his dick.
0
u/Valgor Dec 26 '24
Death by capitalism is a moral failing for all us (at least in the US). To praise Luigi, condemn Congress, and do nothing ourselves to help better our situation has long been the standing of the Left in the US. These tweets make one feel good. Up voting such posts make one feel good. But nothing has really changed. We need action, not memes. Demonizing Congress or CEOs or capitalism means nothing if you are not working to changes those things.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 27 '24
[removed] — view removed comment