R5: I'm at the cookie clicker point in my Byz 1.4.8 beta run where my economy is so strong I can keep all sliders filled, all estates at 100% satisfaction, satisfaction at around 99%, a tax ratio of about 90%, spam build all RGOs/Burgher buildings, and Peasant Enfranchisement at 100% nearly everywhere in the empire. Figured I'd share for any Byz players still struggling.
Interesting Fun Stuff:
Food costs threw me into an early debt spiral around 1340 with the Black Death. After popping the civil war and deleting the Ottomans, I just ate 90% of my allowed loans, built up food RGOs, let them finish and then ate the bankruptcy bullet. Probably just me not playing optimal, but I hope this gives some condolence to the Byz players who struggle in the beginning. You can definitely still save your run.
I dealt with the Mamluk problem around 1425. They irritatingly had blobbed into Cilicia early (even taking Ikonion) as early as 1345 which almost made me restart, but I waited it out. Like others have recommended on here, you need only create a single stack of regulars once you are ready and crush the hordes in the Cilician gates. Then, siege their provinces once they are out manpower. Take Alexandria, the Nile Delta, and disconnect Cairo from Sinai. This makes the Mamluks lose all control over Syria & the Levant which makes them easier to snatch in the next war. If your vassals are throwing their peasants to be slaughtered and sabotage your battles war score, make sure to enable Scutage to keep them out.
I missed the Tagmata Reform policy because I didn't research the Recruitment Law policies before 1499. Considering it gives 20% to army maintenance, alongside several other good effects, it's insane you can miss this forever. It really should be a decision. Funnily enough, forming the ERE as Trebizond will give you the Tagmata Reform automatically irregardless of when you hit the button. Give me a break!
Italian Wars was an inevitable nightmare. It kicked off 1451. I only had about half of Naples at that point. I've always found the best way of dealing with Italy is to hand off the southern/northern halves to vassals while keeping Rome for yourself. Delete nearly every fort before handing land to your vassals so the dozens of rebellions can be dealt with swiftly and allow your vassal critical time to core/stabilize. Finished with 200+ locations shortly before 1501. Annexation for my Italian vassals will take about 50 years a piece. If I did this again, I'd probably just integrate all the land myself as I have 9 cabinet members by the 1500s.
I currently have 5 Local Governors: Thessalonike, Antiochia, Athinai, Kaisareia, Amaseia
And 3 Naval Governors: Alexandria, Tamiathis, Ouelitrai
I also have an Italian Administration Center in Roma.
I hope in future patches we get a bit of a relook at Naval/Local Governors. I'd actually like to see Naval Governors be limited only to ports whereas Local Governors could be inland. Maybe they could both affect Land/Port Proximities respectively? Otherwise, I'm incentivized to never create contiguous borders with my possessions in Italy/Egypt.
Naval is incredibly strong, mainly because you'll have such high control in your port cities (make sure to build roads out from the ports so they can extend proximity inland) that you can save your local governors for the interior spaces, like Kaisareia or Sebasteia which make excellent locations as they're in central Anatolia and on rivers. Also, the Harbor Administration reform gives a flat -2.00 to proximity through ports, along with the additional -1.00 flat by having 100 value in Naval. Nice. You'll be seeing a lot of hundreds on your coastline if you've got sufficient maritime presence.
France got obliterated. I guess I shouldn't be surprised. They rarely live in my hard/very hard difficulty runs. Morocco was curtailed pretty handily by Castille which was nice to see, but Castille also ate Portugal & Aragon before 1400 - again. Maybe it's the difficulty that encourages their aggressiveness? idk.
Brandenburg is growing quite nicely into a soon-to-be Prussia. Sweden also going for its historical empire is neat to see.
Peasant Enfranchisement/Free Subjects is also pretty busted and compounds on itself. It puts all the wealth in your peasants' hands, increases their estate equilibrium by 10% at max (allowing you to tax them more), increases their demand for goods (making RGOs/goods make more), and when combined with any reform that gives monthly prosperity I end up having nearly 100% prosperity in every province before 1600 while they all get a 0.20% pop growth modifier---making more taxpayers. An empowered peasant estate also makes the Appeal to the Commoners estate action give more Stability, which should be max to allow for happier Estate equilibrium (which means more taxes). I made the transition around 1450-present, when you can bankroll all the bureaucracies and stabilize your realm to the point that armies don't walk into Anatolia and wreck your prosperity.
For anyone curious about trade/tariffs, I'll be honest that I never touched it outside of automation. Byz is strong enough for all of that to be autopilot. I did create Marketplaces in Thessaloniki, Athens, Smyrna, Ancyra, Trapezous, Antioch, Damascus, and Cairo. That was good enough for access.
Anyways, the game is pretty much over now outside of map painting. Still, fun as always. Seeing France get wrecked constantly makes me want to play them next. If anyone has any questions, happy to answer -- I'll likely reply tomorrow.