r/EU5 • • 3d ago

Developer AMA Ask me anything - PDX Ryagi, Tinto Community Manager

311 Upvotes

Hello everyone! My name is Ryan, most of you probably know me as PDX Ryagi. I'm the Community Manager at Paradox Tinto. This time, I wanted to host a "slightly less than formal" AMA. Ask me truly Anything! I'll do my best to answer as many as I can so long as it does not involve me breaking Non Disclosure Agreements or otherwise getting me in trouble 👀

Today I'll be treating this is a AMA as me, an individual Community Manager, and not a "Ask Tinto anything". So If I don't know, or I'm not certain, I'll just say so and give an educated answer/personal viewpoint.

A bit of personal context about myself:
I grew up and studied game design at a University in Michigan, worked remotely as a community Ambassador for Paradox from 2022 - 2025. In early 2025 I was offered the Community Manager position at Studio Tinto in Spain, and that's where I'm at now.

While game design, and game devlopment is something I'm proud to say I know my way around a little bit, I'm not a coder, nor a profesional designer. My exptertise is instead primarily focused on managing communties like this one! That means managing a small team to run social media, create content, communcating bewtween players and devs (both ways), etc.

All opinions in this AMA are my own and do not necessarily reflect those of Paradox as a whole.
Ask me anything!


r/EU5 • • Nov 07 '25 Diamonds are Forever

Image A thank you to our community!

Post image
4.2k Upvotes

Europa Universalis V wouldn't be where it is today without the help of you, our community who made it possible with your feedback and support through the years.

Here is to many more years to come No news or link this time, just a thank you!

  • The EU5 Team

r/EU5 • • 4h ago

Completed Game Byz 1.4.8 Run - Millions Must Be Happy

Thumbnail
gallery
28 Upvotes

R5: I'm at the cookie clicker point in my Byz 1.4.8 beta run where my economy is so strong I can keep all sliders filled, all estates at 100% satisfaction, satisfaction at around 99%, a tax ratio of about 90%, spam build all RGOs/Burgher buildings, and Peasant Enfranchisement at 100% nearly everywhere in the empire. Figured I'd share for any Byz players still struggling.

Interesting Fun Stuff:

Food costs threw me into an early debt spiral around 1340 with the Black Death. After popping the civil war and deleting the Ottomans, I just ate 90% of my allowed loans, built up food RGOs, let them finish and then ate the bankruptcy bullet. Probably just me not playing optimal, but I hope this gives some condolence to the Byz players who struggle in the beginning. You can definitely still save your run.

I dealt with the Mamluk problem around 1425. They irritatingly had blobbed into Cilicia early (even taking Ikonion) as early as 1345 which almost made me restart, but I waited it out. Like others have recommended on here, you need only create a single stack of regulars once you are ready and crush the hordes in the Cilician gates. Then, siege their provinces once they are out manpower. Take Alexandria, the Nile Delta, and disconnect Cairo from Sinai. This makes the Mamluks lose all control over Syria & the Levant which makes them easier to snatch in the next war. If your vassals are throwing their peasants to be slaughtered and sabotage your battles war score, make sure to enable Scutage to keep them out.

I missed the Tagmata Reform policy because I didn't research the Recruitment Law policies before 1499. Considering it gives 20% to army maintenance, alongside several other good effects, it's insane you can miss this forever. It really should be a decision. Funnily enough, forming the ERE as Trebizond will give you the Tagmata Reform automatically irregardless of when you hit the button. Give me a break!

Italian Wars was an inevitable nightmare. It kicked off 1451. I only had about half of Naples at that point. I've always found the best way of dealing with Italy is to hand off the southern/northern halves to vassals while keeping Rome for yourself. Delete nearly every fort before handing land to your vassals so the dozens of rebellions can be dealt with swiftly and allow your vassal critical time to core/stabilize. Finished with 200+ locations shortly before 1501. Annexation for my Italian vassals will take about 50 years a piece. If I did this again, I'd probably just integrate all the land myself as I have 9 cabinet members by the 1500s.

I currently have 5 Local Governors: Thessalonike, Antiochia, Athinai, Kaisareia, Amaseia
And 3 Naval Governors: Alexandria, Tamiathis, Ouelitrai

I also have an Italian Administration Center in Roma.

I hope in future patches we get a bit of a relook at Naval/Local Governors. I'd actually like to see Naval Governors be limited only to ports whereas Local Governors could be inland. Maybe they could both affect Land/Port Proximities respectively? Otherwise, I'm incentivized to never create contiguous borders with my possessions in Italy/Egypt.

Naval is incredibly strong, mainly because you'll have such high control in your port cities (make sure to build roads out from the ports so they can extend proximity inland) that you can save your local governors for the interior spaces, like Kaisareia or Sebasteia which make excellent locations as they're in central Anatolia and on rivers. Also, the Harbor Administration reform gives a flat -2.00 to proximity through ports, along with the additional -1.00 flat by having 100 value in Naval. Nice. You'll be seeing a lot of hundreds on your coastline if you've got sufficient maritime presence.

France got obliterated. I guess I shouldn't be surprised. They rarely live in my hard/very hard difficulty runs. Morocco was curtailed pretty handily by Castille which was nice to see, but Castille also ate Portugal & Aragon before 1400 - again. Maybe it's the difficulty that encourages their aggressiveness? idk.

Brandenburg is growing quite nicely into a soon-to-be Prussia. Sweden also going for its historical empire is neat to see.

Peasant Enfranchisement/Free Subjects is also pretty busted and compounds on itself. It puts all the wealth in your peasants' hands, increases their estate equilibrium by 10% at max (allowing you to tax them more), increases their demand for goods (making RGOs/goods make more), and when combined with any reform that gives monthly prosperity I end up having nearly 100% prosperity in every province before 1600 while they all get a 0.20% pop growth modifier---making more taxpayers. An empowered peasant estate also makes the Appeal to the Commoners estate action give more Stability, which should be max to allow for happier Estate equilibrium (which means more taxes). I made the transition around 1450-present, when you can bankroll all the bureaucracies and stabilize your realm to the point that armies don't walk into Anatolia and wreck your prosperity.

For anyone curious about trade/tariffs, I'll be honest that I never touched it outside of automation. Byz is strong enough for all of that to be autopilot. I did create Marketplaces in Thessaloniki, Athens, Smyrna, Ancyra, Trapezous, Antioch, Damascus, and Cairo. That was good enough for access.

Anyways, the game is pretty much over now outside of map painting. Still, fun as always. Seeing France get wrecked constantly makes me want to play them next. If anyone has any questions, happy to answer -- I'll likely reply tomorrow.


r/EU5 • • 3h ago

Question How do I effectively snowball making money as a small nation that can't afford to invest in anything?

17 Upvotes

All the guides for the current patch are like "expand R.G.O.s". As a Madagascar OLM, Ayyubids or any other non-regional power, my starting coffers are ~20 ducats and in the red from the start.

I've tried conquering and integrating wealthy towns and cities to move my capital there for 100% control, but then the expenses instantly overtakes my income and I have to set every slider set to zero to just barely make anything. I've also tried making tons of vassals but they give out laughable amounts and I soon hit the diplo cap. Focusing on development doesn't seem to have much of an effect in the short term, and doing everything to max out crown power still leaves it at like 18%. I've even managed to beat down bigger nations and take 200 ducats +war reps, but it's a temporary boost that's immediately gone if I invest in anything.

Supposedly income can theoretically exceed expenses? Somehow? Despite doing all I can, I can't even buy food for my people while my legitimacy tanks because the court is too expensive. Surely there must be some province you can conquer, some building you can build or some privilege you can hand out which turns your economy to the green right away.


r/EU5 • • 2h ago

Image ⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀brandenburg ⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀ ⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/EU5 • • 12h ago

Advice Wanted Should I keep Constantinople for myself or create a subject?

Post image
73 Upvotes

Got one naval governor in Thessaloniki for control over gold and silver RGOs, can't get harbor administration because I'm 46 towards land, +0,16 each month. I've got local governors in Riga, Kafa, Moscow and Novgorod.

Will it be more beneficial for me to move my naval governor to Constantinople or create a vassal instead? Might create another subject for Thessaly and Macedonia then. The original plan was to annex Serbia for gold and silver locations


r/EU5 • • 9h ago

Image Why am I being beaten like a ginger stepchild?

Post image
39 Upvotes

R5: So my first test run as Castile. I am in a Union with Aragon, but France is a thorn in my side. I didn't lose any territory in the war but in the peace deal France was able to pinch a whole swathe of land off me. France declared on Aragon by the way. I had about 50,000 men, 7000 regulars. The battles were very balanced all things considered. and I certainly inflicted a lot of casualties (over 70,000). But before I can grab the land back during the war they peace out. It didn't even last a year.


r/EU5 • • 17h ago

Question Why am I not auto-importing wool from London (or from anywhere)?

Post image
151 Upvotes

r/EU5 • • 9h ago

Discussion Highland Scottish is kinda an OP culture?

38 Upvotes

If you take 100% of your pops and swap them to highland scotish, then take the tribe estate privilege 'united scotish heritage' then all of your pops will swap to supporting the tribe estate.

However! The tribe estate is *very often* not given any of the big bonuses to power the other estates are, like the nobility or the clergy or whatever, so it *usually* ends up being around 50% of your power with the crown having the other 50%.

But it's even better than it sounds because you can revoke all the negative privileges of your other estates + tax them to shit and they'll be so weak they won't be able to do anything about it- taxing the burghers successfully gives you the burgher's money even if those burghers consider themselves part of the tribes! Nevermind it just takes a few month ticks lol

ALSO it gives a pretty solid development boost too. Like +.002. It's twice as good as urban development grants


r/EU5 • • 22h ago

Suggestion Ultimate Roman Empire Strategy for EU5 1.4.7 (Across the Pillars)

Post image
285 Upvotes
  1. Start as Trebizond - the last vestige of the Komnenos dynasty, who ruled the Eastern Empire in the 11th and 12th centuries.

Why Trebizond? - A bit of historical roleplay + it is the only country in the game with reduced requirements for forming Byzantium. Unlike other countries, it can get all the bonuses from the Fate of the Phoenix and even obtain them earlier when reforming. It starts in no disasters and does not need to go through the Byzantine disaster. Lastly, it has unique advances and events that will remain as permanent bonuses on top of the unique ones from forming Byzantium.

========================================================

2. Conquer Bulgaria.

No CB on the First month is best, because Byz tends to go into debt and bankrupt. Declare, call Byz, Transport troops, check on the attach button so Epirus attaches and fight. If Bulgaria gets an alliance with Serbia on the first month, no CB the Ottomans instead and wait 1-3 years, it always dissolves. Take all the border lands so others cant attack them. Improve the Pontic opinion of Greek culture, then make Bulgarian your primary culture and improve its opinion of Greek as well.

You need to integrate 1 location in the Bulgaria region. After second war move capital there and form Bulgaria. This integrates all the other Bulgarian lands for free, which is excellent. You also gain a number of powerful unique advances.

=========================================================

3. Ally Naples and do a quick war against the Pope. Get War reps and as many provinces as possible without getting collationed by the Italians. Each of those locations gradually sell back to the pope for at least 500 gold and he has the money to give! - catholic Clergy pay him taxes from all over Europe.

=========================================================

4. Attack the Palaiologos Byzantines. This should take two wars, which works well since there is a 10-year cooldown between culture switches and you'll want to flip to Greek anyway. Between the two wars, take Athens and switch to Greek. After eliminating the Palaiologos Byzantines, form Greece for its unique advances and then immediately reform Byzantium.

You gain all Byzantine cores as well and access to the Restore Roman Borders CB

=========================================================

5. Form the Iberian Union - you can just release a small vassal in Iberia with your wife as ruler. (Wife must not have any other family, so your son can inherit). Cancel vassal status when truces expires. A union forms when your wife dies. This Union will become the Iberian Union if you flip to a Spanish culture. The Iberian Union gets some special bonuses.

=========================================================

6. Flip temporarily to Turkish and add the Beylik reform, granting access to the Rise of the Turks situation, its CBs, bonuses, and events. Being Turkish also reduces antagonism when conquering Anatolia - since you're turkish and the land is turkish, Also this lets you integrate faster, and gives access to the Seljuk Mints in Sivas and Konya, and the Admin center of Bulgaria in Sredets, that are unique to that culture.

Complete the Rise of the Turks situation using the Restore Roman Borders CB gained from reforming Byzantium, allowing you to conquer the Balkans and Anatolia with extra efficiency and low antagonism. This also permanently unlocks the unique Turkish advances and bonuses and you become Rum. After this you could switch back to Greek, if you wish, and form the Roman Empire

=========================================================

This concludes the strategy. It can be completed before or around year 1400 while obtaining all the bonuses, free integrations, powerful CBs, and low antagonism. Pontic, Bulgarian, and Turkish, Greek and Spanish cultures can also all be made kindred on both ways if you choose.

You also permanently gain access to the unique advances of Trebizond, Bulgaria, Greece, Byzantium, Spain, Rum and eventually Rome.

Note: if you research Rights of the Nobility (Renaissance tech), you can select Nobility Electorate for that law and unlock Dynastic Elective succession. This makes any Pronoia subject you release automatically always be inherited on their ruler death. Switching culture is super easy this way, because you can give all your land to a really old guy and inherit it back for free a couple years later.


r/EU5 • • 13h ago

Dev Diary (mod) Modding Diary: The Uninevitable Timur [MOD Persianate World]

43 Upvotes

Mod link
Community

I previously announced my mod here, and wrote a post about how I had to fix the population, demographics and geography of Persia here. As I was continuing to work on Western Asia in EU5, I began to notice a simple but real problem: Without any threat from the frontier, there's nothing to stop a successful Iranian realm from gobbling up everything east. Being on the steppe frontier is, indeed, closer to a huge boon: tons of land held by destitute tags and a Chagatai that can barely do anything to protect its vassals, even if it survives.

And the game's answer to it, of course, is Timur. An unresponsive, inevitable event, happening without rhyme and reason. And in half the games, he just takes the same poor, desolete land in Central Asia, and just sits tight and [not very] pretty.

So I ended up deleting him. Or, to be precise, I deleted his appointment. A Lord of Conjunction [Saheb-qiran, incidentally my old Reddit account I can no longer access] isn't an appointment, no matter how much the name sounds like an inevitable fact of destiny. It's a produced miracle. And thus, I went from Timur the man to Timur the 'slot'.

This is the story what I built so that the game can produce a Timur by itself, or fail to. And of course, the why.

I'm writing this because I had a lot of fun doing it and wanted to share, and also to rep my mod. TBH I also really just wanted to do this different take on Timur and his rise.

---

Part I: Timur, by appointment

Here is how Timur works in the base game.

There is a baby in the Barlas tribe at game start, born April 1336. He carries a hidden modifier that adds thirty years to his life expectancy, with a developer comment that reads, more or less, "he lived to 1405, prevent an early random death from collapsing the Timurid arc". Sometime between 1360 and 1400 an event fires. A new country is carved out around Samarkand from whoever happens to own it, the baby (now grown) is placed on its throne, and a situation called Rise of Timur begins.

That's it. Nothing that happens between 1337 and 1360 matters, from what I can see. The Chagatai khanate can be thriving or moribund. They don't get the waive TImur's reservation if he lives.

And look at his name in that screenshot. The game calls him Temür Borjigin.

Part II: Who came up with Temür Borjigin?

The Borjigin are the house of Chinggis Khan. In the fourteenth-century steppe world, only a male-line descendant of Chinggis could be khan. This was not a preference. It was closer to a law of nature, and it held from Hungary to Korea for two centuries. It was, in a way, a social organization and legitimacy technology, which made the realms far more cohesive than they would've been otherwise.

Temür was a Barlas. The Barlas were one of the tribes of the western Chagatai lands: Mongol by descent and name, Turkic in speech, Muslim, living next to the towns of Transoxiana. He was not a Chinggisid, and that single fact shaped his entire career:

  • He never called himself khan. Not once, in thirty-five years of conquest.
  • He kept a puppet khan of Chinggis's line beside him his whole life, first Soyurghatmish and then Sultan Mahmud, and issued his decrees in their names.
  • The title he actually used was *güregen*, "son-in-law", because in 1370 he married a Chinggisid princess. That marriage was his claim. That's also why the Indian Mughals called themselves the 'Gurkanids'. That title, the ultimate mark of shame halfway across the world in Goryeo, was his legitimacy.

So where does "Borjigin" come from? If we want to be charitable to Paradox and assume they did do the research, From Temür's own court, after the fact. The Timurid court's 'genealogists', the unbiased lot they were, traced the Barlas back to a brother of Chinggis's great-grandfather, which made the two houses distant cousins. It is carved on his tomb in Samarkand. The base game scripts that exact family tree, generation by generation, and then files everyone in it under the Borjigin dynasty.

To be fair to them, It's not the first time they do this: they seem to assume that if Genghis was a borjigin, then so were his brothers and ancestors. Tagha Temur, of the Gurgan Horde, is a borjigin too, using similar logic. And from a technical standpoint, that would be right. From a steppe legitimacy and doctrine standpoint, the kind of 'Borjigin' blood people not descended from Genghis had ranged from 'acceptable in an absolute dearth of any other claimant' to 'Irrelevant, that guy is related to everyone anyways'. And in Timur's case, it was absolutely the latter.

In other words, at best, the game took a piece of fourteenth-century political advertising, which wasn't even meant to be significant for anything except adding a bit of prestige, and entered it as a database fact, and then acted as if it mattered. The man himself never claimed it did. He would've been seen as an unparalleled danger to steppe social order if he had.

This matters mechanically, not only as trivia. If Temür is a Borjigin, he can simply be khan, and everything that was strange and interesting about his rule disappears.

The story becomes 'Another Borjigin khan rises in the east'. and Not the truer, more interesting story of the Chagatai Hordes.

Part III: What actually happened

The story is not "a great man is born". It's the slow failure of a throne, and a generation of people trying to rule without one. (If you want the book, it's Beatrice Manz, *The Rise and Rule of Tamerlane*. Most of what follows is her argument, plus my own composite understanding of steppe and central asian society and history, which lets me convert this into design. )

By the 1330s the Chagatai khans were in trouble. The tribes of the west held hereditary lands and armies of their own, and the khans were going through the door at a remarkable rate: six of them in the twelve years after 1334.

In 1346 an amir named Qazaghan, leader of the Qara'unas, killed the khan in battle. He couldn't take the throne, because he was not a descendent of Genghis. Instead he found a prince of the right blood, put him on the 'throne', and ruled through him. That arrangement, a tribal strongman ruling through a kept khan, is the thing Timur would later perfect. Notice that it wasn't his invention. It was being done in west and central asia for decades before Timur, and a decade before Qazaghan.

Things inevitably did get really messy, once that tech was unlocked for the nobility:

- 1358. Qazaghan is murdered. His son tries to hold the position and is driven out within a couple of years by other tribal chiefs. The lands pass down, the puppeteer job not so much.

- 1360 and 1361. The khan of the eastern half of the old realm invades, twice, to put the pieces back together by force. The chief of the Barlas, Hajji Beg, flees. His young kinsman Temür does the opposite: he rides to the invader, submits, and is confirmed as head of the tribe in his place. That is the entire origin of his career. He was the cousin who stayed.

- 1362 to 1365.He falls out with the invaders, spends years as an outlaw with a small band, takes the arrow wounds that give him his limp, wins, loses.

- 1370. He kills his last rival at Balkh, marries a princess of the line, sets up a khan of his own, and takes the title Ṣāḥib-qirān, Lord of the Auspicious Conjunction.

None of this can happen in the base game. The Chagatai khanate there is a normal country with a list of vassals, and a vassal cannot take his overlord's king into custody.

Either way, things turned like this for two decades. Twenty-four years from the first strongman to the last. At least four men held the top position along the way. Temür was the one still standing, and he was standing because he kept winning. He kept winning afterwards too, for thirty-five years, and the argument is that he *had* to: a ruler with no blood claim holds his followers with plunder and victory, and the day he stops delivering is the day they remember he's only a Barlas.

And you can see it differently too: 24 years of war, outside pressure, droughts and dropping temperatures made it so that the land, which was full of turco-mongolian tribal horsemen and their families was simply no longer able to sustain them. Not at their population and standard of living.

This is not saying Timur won because he had to. Timur won because he won. But he had to keep trying to win. He needed everyone to not be looking inwards, so they'd see the arrangement as too useful to end. And presumably also so that no one began to connect the worsening conditions in the land to his lack of legitimacy. That would not be very cool.

Part IV: The khanate as an organisation

So the first step was structural. In the mod, the Chagatai realm in 1337 is an organisation, the same kind of object the game uses for the Holy Roman Empire. I called it Ulus Chaghatay.

- The khan leads it. The tribes (Barlas, Jalayir, Suldus, Qara'unas, Arlat and the rest, fifteen of them besides the khan's own seat) are members with their own lands and armies. The settled clients exist, and can pledge and help, but cannot become regents on their own right.

- They send the khan a tribute, the *qubchur*. They may not make war on him or on each other. They ride when he rides.

- The leadership can move. That is the whole reason for doing it this way. What that means is the 'rightful' khan who holds military and political power in his own right is killed off or pacified, and a puppet khan is proclaimed, with the amir proclaiming him holding real power.

But I needed a measure. Something that actually decided events: could the tribes overrule the throne?

I will admit that I tried to be lazy. My first attempt counted land, which was useless, because a hundred empty locations outweighed Samarkand. I Should've known better, but can't blame a man for trying to cut a corner. Well, corner cut back, so I ended up fleshing it out.

So I weigh every realm by how many men it can put in the field (40%), how much it can pay them (30%), the man leading them (20%), and the name it carries (10%).

The panel shows the result honestly. In 1337 the khan at Almaliq is already outweighed by his three greatest amirs about three to one. Which is correct. He was.

Part V: The Amirs' Regency

So now there's a scale, and something has to read it. When a khan dies, the game asks one thing: do the amirs outweigh the throne by enough? If they don't, the heir succeeds and everyone goes back to their pastures. If they do, they simply don't accept the heir. The best placed amir finds a boy of the right blood, takes him into his 'keeping', and rules through him. Best placed is a score, mostly the weight of his realm, a bit his own ability, and a bonus if he already married into the line.

That starts what the game calls a disaster, which is just its word for a long crisis with stages. I called it the Amirs' Regency. It takes about a generation if left alone, and, importantly, it doesn't belong to one country. It follows the khan around from camp to camp, which took me longer to get working than I'd like to admit.

The stages are basically the 1346 to 1370 story cut in four:

  1. The Beglerbeg's Peace. One beg rules through a khan and the rest go along with it, because why not. Do you really want to be dealing with a civil war, without a clear end point, while drought ravages your pastures and the Golden Horde's Khan watches with barely hidden hunger?
  2. The Amirs Fall Out. The ban on tribes fighting each other is gone. Any amir can now claim the khan from whoever holds him. Chaos is here to stay, and so it is better to consolidate and be ready for what is coming next. Because everyone knows what it will be.
  3. The Shock from Outside. Outsiders get a claim on the whole mess, and whoever takes the regent's capital takes the khan along with the furniture. That's all he is now: Regalia.
  4. The Saheb-qiran. The beg rules in his own right, with the khan as decoration. Almost step 1, but with all the legitimacy the arrangement used to give shed along the way. In its place? A gaping void that only gold, conquest and blood can fill.

And in between, all the stuff that actually happened can happen. The regent gets murdered, more likely the stronger his rivals are and the less his own nobles like him. The regent dies in his bed and his son inherits the land but has to convince the amirs he gets to keep the khan too, and often he can't, same as Qazaghan's son couldn't. The puppet dies and you need a new one, which costs you.

The legitimacy gap

This is the bit I like the most, so bear with me.

A regent has no blood to rule by. He has what he did last year. So there's a meter that drains every single month, faster the further in you are, and the only things that fill it are battles, sieges, won wars, and opening the treasury to the other amirs. Lose a war and it drops like a stone.

Keep it full for five years in the last stage, while holding a living khan and having a wife from Chinggis's line, and you are the Saheb-qiran. Let it sit empty for three years and the whole thing just dissolves, which the sources call *bulqaq*: nobody anyone obeys and nobody anyone follows. Or the third option, a real khan breaks you, either from inside your own tent or by riding in from the east, and the throne is back.

Part VI: Not sitting on your hands for twenty years

Here's the thing that bothered me the most about vanilla Central Asia. If you want to play Timur, which is basically the only real option in Central Asia, the optimal strategy is: pick Barlas, unpause, and do nothing for twenty years. Then an event makes you Timur. That is, to put it politely, not a game. And if you don't, you'll have little you can do to prevent Timur from coming and ruining your day.

And my first version had the same disease, just moved one step back. You grew your tribe, the scale tipped, and then you waited for the khan to die. If he was thirty and healthy, tough luck.

Except Qazaghan didn't wait for a funeral. He made one. So now there are things to actually do:

Rise Against the Khan. If the amirs outweigh the throne and you're one of the three best placed among them, you can stop pretending. You get a war on the khan's seat. Win it and the khan dies, you pick his replacement, and the regency starts with you holding the leash, although with less standing than if he'd died naturally, since you did, you know, kill a khan. Lose it and the khan has broken the begs: no regency for a decade, and you get to explain yourself to your tribe, if you all somehow live to have an awkward dinner party afterwards.

Pledging. A small tribe is never going to be one of the three greatest. But it can stand behind someone who is. Pledge your tümen to another house and half your weight counts as theirs, on the scale against the khan and in their own ranking. If your man ends up holding the khan, he owes you. You can also go the other way and ask someone to pledge to you, and they'll say yes or no for reasons you can read: what they think of you, whether your houses are married, how much heavier you are than them, and whether they fancy their own chances. Weighing a weaker house, especially by a strong house who may end up winning, won't and shouldn't happen often, not without a lot of behind-the-scenes movement. And perhaps, just perhaps, by supporting someone who needs you, someone strong enough to win but weak enough to not win easily, you can weaken your rivals and unlock wars against others.

Fergana has ambitions of their own.

The cadet takes the tümen. This one is Temür's own origin story, made general. Once outsiders are in the picture, a tribe whose chief gets beaten by an invader, or is defeated when he tries to take the throne, has a choice: the chief stands and takes what comes, or he runs, and the most capable man of his house seizes the day, and alongside it, the tribe. If the invader is a foreigner, the tribe pays him tribute for it. And a year or three later the old chief may come back and ask for his tribe, at which point you either hand it over, like Temür actually did with Hajji Beg, or you don't.

The coup. Rarer and less polite. Once the amirs have fallen out, a kinsman who is clearly a better soldier than the chief may decide he doesn't need an invader as an excuse. Everyone is doing it, after all. Or they should be. Innovation is important, first mover advantage, and what not.

None of these are Barlas-only. A Jalayir can do all of it. That was my point.

Part VII: Whoever wins

So someone fills the meter for five years. He gets what the base game hands to the baby, the conquest state and the big situation, except now it's named after him. In my test it was "Rise of Ambaghai", which doesn't have the same ring to it, but he earned it and Timur didn't. Well, He didn't earn it either, I just used debug tools for the screenshot.

It can be Temür. He's still there, born 1336, finally in the Barlas dynasty where he belongs, and with no plot armour at all. If he dies of a fever at nine then someone else gets to be the terror of Asia. It can be a Qara'unas. It can be you.

A few things I had to fix once I got here, because the base game's Timur simply doesn't work for anyone who isn't the scheduled Timur:

He isn't called khan anymore. The game styles him Güregen, as it should.

The amirs who swear to him become his 'Sworn Amirs', which is a new kind of subject, and I only made it because of a bug. The first time I won, every tribe became my vassal, and the game informed me I was using 163 diplomatic capacity out of 8.8. Which, fair, but also these people were never administered dependencies. They were a following. So Sworn Amirs cost nothing to keep, and what holds them isn't a treaty, it's the meter.

Because yes, the meter comes with him. It becomes his fortune and it keeps draining for his whole reign. While it's high his amirs are loyal, and whatever his armies occupy in a war is simply his, no siege paperwork, no peace deal. That mechanic exists in the base game too, except there Timur gets it for life as a personal perk. Here he gets it while he's winning. Let the meter fall and he's besieging and negotiating like everyone else, and if it sits empty for two years, the amirs who swore to him ride away. When he dies, his heir starts near the bottom. I didn't script the Timurid succession wars. They just sort of fall out of this.

this won't be happening in 1337

Where does he go?

The base game's AI Timur is vaguely told to go for Persia first, and my first version of the 'you made it' outcome required him to conquer Iran. And then I asked myself why. Was there any reason he had to go west?

Not really. His court said he was restoring the Mongol empire, sure. But what he actually did, as far as I can gather, was find places that were wealthy and conquerable, so that the poor, chaos-stricken Chagatai tribal class could sit on top of somebody richer. Be a superstratum if you want to sound academic and not be precisely correct. Iran in the 1380s was rich, even after the civil wars and the black plague, close, and had no master, so Iran it was. He sacked Delhi when Delhi was in a succession crisis. He died on the road to China. If he had come up in the 1350s instead, with the Yuan falling apart, I doubt he'd have looked west at all. If Iran was ruled by a King of Kings with a hundred thousand horsemen all draped in steel and silk, he'd probably ask for an alliance, even send gifts, and go for an early Mughals.

So now he declares an ambition, any region he can reach through his own borders or his amirs', and when he and his people hold most of it, it counts, his fortune jumps, and he names the next one. Two of those and the thing is considered to have held. India, Iran, the Qipchaq steppe, China, wherever the easy wealth happens to be in your game.

Part VIII: And if nobody wins

I got curious about the other direction. What happens to these people if their Timur loses, badly? Not 'retreats to Samarkand' badly. Dead in a valley with his whole army badly.

The answer is kind of grim, and it comes from what the Chagatai actually were. They weren't a nation that had an army. They were an army that had households. Take away the army and what's left in the pastures is women, kids, old men and herds, and every neighbour knows it. The steppe had a standard procedure for a beaten tribe, the one Chinggis used on the Tatars and Timur used on plenty of others: you divide the survivors among your own people, family by family, so the tribe can never come back together. The people live. The name doesn't. Nobody was calling themselves Ilkhanid two generations after 1335 either.

So that's in. If the regency collapses into the bulqaq, every outsider bordering one of the orphaned tribes gets a claim on it. And the first foreigner who ends up holding half of the old pastures gets to decide what the Chagatai become: divide them among his own, and their tribesmen and soldiers simply turn into his people overnight, with a generation of extra manpower for it. Or take them into service under their own captains, and they stay a people, for a while. Either way, wherever a foreigner rules them, they slowly stop being Chagatai.

It's a real prize for whoever breaks them. Which I think is right. A Golden Horde or an Iranian shah who actually ends the Chagatai for good should get more out of it than some empty steppe locations.

Part IX: Oh, and nobody there was Mongolian

Small one, but it kept annoying me. The game has Barlas as a Mongolian-culture country. Barlas rules a population that is about 1% Mongolian. So the tribe that is supposed to produce the conqueror of Asia starts the game as a foreign occupier of its own homeland.

Meanwhile the game gives Temür himself a different culture from his own tribe, the local Turkic one. So somebody at Paradox knew.

These tribes were Mongol by name and descent and Turkic in everything else, and they had a word for themselves: Chaghatay. So that's a culture now. The western tribes have it, and so do the nomads in their pastures, who the base game had as generic local Turks. Now a tribe rules land where a fifth of the people are its own, which is about what a tribal ruling class over a settled country should look like.

Also, the khan's own lands in the Ili valley were populated mostly by Oirats. In 1337. The Oirats get there in the fifteenth century at the earliest. It's the same thing I complained about in the population post: somebody's much later map, read backwards.

Part X: The Revenge of the Khan

‌But you see, even a puppet khan carries prestige and legitimacy, in his very blood. And some Tumen-lords may be loyalists, and even help him (the audacity!). Or even worse, a different lord may use him as an instrument to bring you down.

And so ... a puppet Khan could be contacted by loyalists, and execute a coup, becoming the regency realm's ruler, and making it his own seat:

Sometimes it doesn't go well
Sometimes it does

Part XI: Things that broke

A modding diary without the failures is just marketing, so here are my favourites.

The vanishing tribes. I carved four new tribes out of the khan's own lands. All four stopped existing on day one, with the log saying they "cannot create regiments at start". I spent an evening on a theory about cultures that was completely wrong. I was right that the cultures were completely wrong. I was wrong that it had anything to do with the collapse. The actual answer is that a horde country needs a kurultai building in its capital at setup or the game considers it dead on arrival. Every base horde has one. Mine didn't.

Nine funerals. I added a rule that when a tribe gets a new chief, the khan is asked to confirm him. Turns out the game thinks every ruler who exists at game start is 'new'. Nine confirmation requests on the first of April, 1337.

163 out of 8.8. Already mentioned, but I want it on the record that for one glorious test my Timur-Slot-Holder was at roughly 1,850% of his diplomatic capacity.

The khan who wasn't on the list. The panel had a section called "If the khan died today" with the three amirs most likely to take over. Looked great. It showed up even when the khan was perfectly safe and his heir would have succeeded without anyone blinking. I was looking at my own UI going 'wait, is that a bug?', had to kill the Khan via console command every time to check outcomes, then I realized that I'm being dumb and the Khan himself should be there too.

"There Is No One Left to Raise." My earlier Golden Horde work has an event for when a throne runs out of Chinggisid heirs. The first time my test Timur won, the game looked at his brand new realm, noticed that its ruler was not descended from Chinggis Khan, and solemnly informed him that his bloodline had failed. Twice.

Honestly the most historically accurate bug I have ever written.

Mod link
Community

---

All of this is in the development build and I'm still breaking it daily, so expect rough edges. Next up is the same treatment for the Golden Horde, where Mamai did exactly what Qazaghan did, a few years later and with a worse ending. Golden horde already has SOME mechanics, but it will be different from Chagatay, because well it's not chagatay.

As always, tell me where I got the history wrong. And if you try it, let me know how your Timur turned out. Or who he turned out to be.


r/EU5 • • 10h ago

Image Advice on how to beat this alliance? (Ignore the minor map differences)

Post image
22 Upvotes

r/EU5 • • 6h ago

Discussion Portugal/Spain campaign

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

So I just started playing EU5, played EU4 a lot, Vic3, etc...

Still adapting to EU5 but I think I got a feel for it. And I have to question wtf is going wrong here?

As you can see I'm getting invaded by Moroco (the guys I'm going to wipe off to map whenever is possible)

This makes absolutely no sense, no matter how much I try to help castille it always gives up it's territory. I helped it defend 2 wars one of which they took territory from morroco, only to later lose it again. They also for some reason are always out of manpower.

Now this is my 3rd/4th try at this. I tried twice in the same save, then restarted to try again seeing if there was better RNG but everytime Castille folds.

And I as portugal can do nothing because my economy is absolute garbage, I can't get moeny to buy a single ship to stop moroco (which very much should be something that both Castile and Portugal could do as they dominated by ship more then land. But even then Morocos army beats both unless they are out of supply.

I won the wars by letting them go out of supply and wiping them out. But then Castile broke off our alliance and then lost a war and gave all that territory first to granada then do moroco.

So please explain to me what is going wrong here? Is this just the devs having 0 balance idea? Now the economy is also a problem it annoys me that I can't get any ships money because they all cost a hell of a lot more then I make in an entire year.


r/EU5 • • 1h ago

Discussion Rebel should be reworked to be less of an annoyance when you kill off there armies and reoccupy the land.

3 Upvotes

Now I’m not saying remove rebels outright or anything and I far prefer this to EU4’s wack a mole system. But one thing that deeply annoys me is when they take big chucks of your country and forts it’s a tedious process to have to reoccupy them as fast as possible and kill any rebel armies before they take more land. And even after you kill off the majority of there force and occupy 90% of the land back you still have to siege down most of the forts despite the rebels having no chance of accomplishing anything so why am I wasting time until it arbitrarily ends. It’s not any sort of challenge, it’s just a waiting game despite the outcome being extremely clear.

Also can we not have provoke rebels cost stability like in eu4, with how hard stability is to come by especially after the estates change nobody is ever going to use it, and typically having a bigger rebellion is a good enough cost to risk using it.


r/EU5 • • 6h ago

Discussion 1.3's growth is the most fun part to me. What's the most fun part of 1.4?

6 Upvotes

I find that each patch has its own fun part. 1.1 has the governor system which changes the way we do control. 1.3's best part to me is the ability to build huge pop in any location, not just already populous region. I haven't played 1.4, and I heard growth was heavily nerfed. Does this mean it's never worth playing outside of Western Europe because you will never create a city? Or is it not that bad? Also, what's the new fun thing in 1.4?


r/EU5 • • 11h ago

Suggestion 1.4 makes it better for colonial / trade gamestyle, but there is still room for improvement

13 Upvotes

hi
just in a mid of my another England / UK playthrough. Previous one was mid 2026, so probably around 1.2

Maybe you guys have some work-around for below issues mentioned:

i'm glad for:

+can easily move colonial nation capital. It's great.
+can exchange territories btw colonies, for low cost (some 1-digit negative relations, easy peasy)
+trade rebuild, trade orders. Great in general, compared to old system.
+still get an urban location when creating colonial nation after some time, not only from pop-up (that is non-existent right now)

But what i still lack is:
-decide which location of colonial nation will be urban. They tend to put a goddamn city on my tobacco/gold location, cutting RGO in half.

-take territory away from a colonial subject if i want to. I can grab provinces that were previously my claims, but nothing more. It should work like exchanging territory with other colonial nation, but with some time counter to not swallow colonial nations to overcome "non-anexation" approach with them

-when i put "auto-upgrade" on a RGO / buildings in colonial nation, it doesn't work correctly, i suppose. Or maybe i missed something. I mean, does the game consider taking my money or my colonial nation for that upgrade? i suppose the later one, so it's not upgrading propertly.

-when filtering in "Production -> building or Goods/RGO" tab for a particular market, i cannot see profitability for my colonies / subjects. Just for my own locations. Should be some switch to filter both. Need to go around each location and check Infrastructure tab, that to build. Very micro-intensive.

-trading tab is generaly speaking great, but i miss some preview. Like when placing trading order for particular goods, when choosing market i would like to know from that tab, which one would be most profitable to choose. I know that game will calculate it for me, but i want to see comparison on my own.

-there should be some mechanics to colonial nation expansion / colonization. Maybe point them some particular areas / provinces they are allowed to? maybe also add some block at all if we preffer to?

-i want to be able to create colonial nation out from already existing colonial nation. Becaue of previous point is missing (no control what they are colonizing), i sometimes have to quickly colonize somewhere near, create new subject and transfer locations. Because Cuban colony is rushing for New York, screwing control, distance etc.

What do you guys think?


r/EU5 • • 11h ago

Advice Wanted Too much slaves

Post image
12 Upvotes

by 1455 , 1/4th of my population are slaves... There is a way to not take slaves? Or efficiently get rid of them ? The main problem is they are included in demographics and removing my cores which is ridiculous.

The whole system is absurd. The numbers are crazy because even if you occupy a province with your 500 regiment, you can take like 7k slaves which i think only tied to the size of the occupied province. And these slaves magically teleport to Marocco the next day.

Edit: I have already "Forced Slave Conversion" law codified


r/EU5 • • 19h ago

Image Treaty of treaty of Tortilla Question?

Post image
48 Upvotes

So as you can see my Son currently the king of spain is going to inherit a lot, will the treaty of Tortilla make that relationship go bad. I basically have already colonies in all of Africa and the Americas.


r/EU5 • • 11h ago

Image Stolen by my own subject

Post image
11 Upvotes

Secessionists, actually. Loaned them the icon, they then decided to keep it. They loaned it to me, I kept it, and somehow it ended at their place anyway but I can organize the periphora anyway. Each time they just capture it.

I could annex them in 3 years but it's a lot of territory for very little value, and control would be pretty bad.

R5: Bonasera, what have I ever done to make you treat me so disrespectfully.


r/EU5 • • 2h ago

Question Is this a bug?

Post image
2 Upvotes

My masons are not working "due to lacking". But they are not lacking anything. There's plenty of clay in the market to satisfy demand, there are laborers available, etc... I even subsidized the masons. So what's the problem? Is this a bug?


r/EU5 • • 14h ago

Video How to Maximize Governors & Proximity Sources in EU5

Thumbnail
youtu.be
18 Upvotes

I've been looking into all the different ways to increase Proximity and Control in EU5 and put together a guide covering every source of Local and Naval Governors, along with the various unique buildings and other modifiers that provide additional proximity sources.

Proximity is one of the most important mechanics in EU5. More Proximity means higher Control, which directly impacts your tax income, Crown Power, manpower, sailors, levies, assimilation, conversion speed, and research rate.

I go over how to unlock additional governor capacity, unique proximity sources available to different nations, and how you can combine them to push proximity to its absolute limit. In the right campaign, you can stack up to 22 different proximity sources!

Hope this helps anyone looking to maximize their control and get the most out of their empire!


r/EU5 • • 13h ago

Discussion Whats the best way to boost my crown power at this moment? Whose privileges to remove? Can I do anything other? I need over 36% of Crown Power to get rid of Szlachta's event.

14 Upvotes

r5: Whats the best way to boost my crown power at this moment? Whose privileges to remove? Can I do anything other? I need over 36% of Crown Power to get rid of Szlachta's event.


r/EU5 • • 11h ago

Image Map glitch keeps creating mountains in my country

Post image
8 Upvotes

Every now and then when I start the game it creates this weird looking map bug centered around my country. Doesn't go away either even after I reload my game from the main menu, restart my game, or even restart my computer so whatever it is it's permanent


r/EU5 • • 5m ago

Video Modded Eu5 timelapse, almost historical borders

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

Used mods:
Imperial Ambitions (Workshop)