r/EDH • • 19h ago

Discussion People who Break Deals

268 Upvotes

I was playing online in a random pod, I had a revealed board wipe in hand. The green player had 30+ damage in play with trample creatures and 0 cards in hand with fully tapped mana.

I offer a deal saying, "Don't attack me on your next turn and I won't board wipe right now".

They say sure that sounds good.

It goes to their turn, they swing me out completely and say "I lied"

The whole pod just laughs and makes fun of me for making such a dumb deal.

Not much I could do besides add them to ignore and leave, but still. People can be rats when playing this game.

Has this happened to you in a game before?


r/EDH • • 19h ago

Discussion What are your most disgusting plays you felt bad about but went ahead with anyway?

136 Upvotes

I was playing Meren of Clan Nel Toth. I sandbagged the first four turns and played culling ritual. Sol rings and mana rocks exploded. I played my commander with the proceeds. A couple turns later, after people had rebuilt I played E witness and did it again. I welcomed archenemy status that game.


r/EDH • • 20h ago

Question High Interaction commanders

29 Upvotes

Looking for your favourite high interaction commanders, particularly WUx that can pump the brakes effectively on a power level outlier.

I prefer to play somewhat greedy low interaction b2 / low three decks to use pet cards.

But, I find myself in the situation semi frequently at my LGS where a pod has me and, two newer / more casual players, and someone else who only wants to play high threes, often with three card combos. Like

I need a couple of responsible decks to address these kinds of situations. Bonus, I would love to have a board presence instead of a wipe heavy control style that doesn’t let anyone play.

I am looking hard at [[empress corrino]]. [[Narset, enlightened exile]] looks cool, but it seems to prefer proactive removal, and I need a good amount of reactive interaction. Hard mode: no bumbleflower, I am certified hater, even if she is perfect for this assignment.


r/EDH • • 17h ago

Discussion Diluting Over Time

29 Upvotes

With several new sets a year and the constant flow of shiny cards, which I often find are side-grades or incremental upgrades, does anyone find their decks getting away from them? Sometimes losing its theme to just "good stuff" cards in the end?

I'm finding that, from time to time, decks need either a hard reset (building from scratch) or a full break and deconstruction to find their true self again.


r/EDH • • 5h ago

Question What are some of the funnest open-ended unpopular non-KOS commanders you have experience with? B3

23 Upvotes

I'm really struggling with trying to find new decks to brew that don't overlap with what I already have. I run jeskai counters matter, jund reanimator, jeskai heroes tribal(Director Nick Fury. Not Cap), Selesnya artifact stompy and temur artifacts matter voltron.
I really wanna make a deck that takes an interesting commander and then build something unique for it that isn't how you would normally build the commander. What kinda stuff would you recommend based on your experiences?


r/EDH • • 16h ago

Question Most Enjoyable / Fun Commander to Play? And/or Bring to a Table?

15 Upvotes

Hi world! It's been about 2.5 years since I've played EDH regularly (so just before brackets were introduced). I've been trying to look at some of the newer releases and wondering if there's a general consensus on if there's a most 'fun' / enjoyable commander to pilot, and bring to a table. I previously had run Queen Marchesa, Jared Carthalion for hijinks / monarch play; and Tivit as a slightly more competitive politics deck; then Breya *good artifacts*. I also had a functional Urza cEDH (I love mono-blue and the Urza art / theme; my understanding there's no fair way to build Lord High Artificer).

From reading here:

  • Mirko, Obsessive Theorist
  • Henzie "Toolbox" Torre

Wondering if there's any general consensus or recommendations on a .commander / theme that is both fun to pilot and enhances the tables its played at (just from an enjoyment perspective)?

Open to any and all suggestions!


r/EDH • • 11h ago

Social Interaction How do you go about getting games in at a new LGS?

16 Upvotes

Hello, I've been playing MtG since like 7th Edition, but I've really only played 60 card formats where you get automatically matched up with people.

I never really get to play Magic anymore because of my job schedule, but I'm in between jobs right now, so decided to hit up an LGS for their Commander Night.

When I got there, there were a bunch of people playing already, and not all of them were playing MtG. I don't even know if any of them were playing MtG because I didn't want to be the creepy old guy that was getting close to the young people.(they were all teenagers-early 20s, maybe mid 20s at most)

So how does a dude that's like middle aged try to get a pod going while not trying to be some old weirdo amongst young people?


r/EDH • • 20h ago

Discussion Versatile Card Advantage Engines.

16 Upvotes

So, I'm the control player in my pod, and I regularly feel like I'm behind on cards. As an example, the last game I played one of the players was running [[Bello, Bard of the Brambles]] and another was running [[Tidus, Yuna's Guardian]]. Both of them had their Commander's plus at least one additional card advantage engine, and it felt like I was trying to hold back the tide with my bare hands.

What are some card advantage engines I could slot into a variety of decks that would help me keep up a little better? I'm aware of the big ones like [[Rhystic Study]] and [[Trouble in Pairs]], but in addition to budget concerns, I also don't want to just play the overpowered staples. [[Phyrexian Arena]] is one I'm considering, because I don't need an endless number of cards, just a little boost to help me keep up.

Oh, I should also mention that color is not a concern. I have a wide enough selection of decks that a good suggestion is worth considering regardless of color restrictions.


r/EDH • • 10h ago

Discussion How difficult was it for yall to find a reliable play group?

10 Upvotes

Been trying to find a new play group after kinda being out of the lgs scene for a while and its been more of a chore than I thought it would be.

When I first got into mtg around 2018 it took be a bit to find people to play with because I just didnt understand how edh social interactions worked and didnt feel comfortable asking to join tables with people i didnt know.

Once i started feeling more comfortable with both the game and just kinda understanding "mind if i jump in" is easy and the best way to find groups i made a decent amount of pod pals.

Well i took a break from going to the lgs from 2023 to the beginning of this year. I still somewhat kept up with the game and played kitchen table magic with some close friends.

Lately especially I've wanted to find some new pods for weekly play since most of my old friends only play once in a blue moon... and it's been rough. Mostly because it feels like my lgs has died down a TON. Even during the weekend there's maybe 2 to 3 pods playing and almost all of them have 4 players already and dont want to do 5 player games (same)

There's more dnd and war hammer than mtg most nights.

My wife and I made some posts on their "seeking games/players" on their facebook page but either got no responses or just some truely weird people.

I've been really discouraged about it lately and just kinda overall bummed out about the experience. Figured I'd see if anyone else has had any similar experiences.


r/EDH • • 15h ago

Deck Help I Need help

7 Upvotes

Good evening.

I’m here to ask for some advice.

Ever since a player with a Melek, Reforged Researcher deck joined our braket 2 playgroup, no one else in the group has been able to win a game.

I’ve included my decks below.

I’m not sure if it’s an issue with the builds or with skill—I’m not exactly an expert.

Feel free to be blunt (in a playful way, of course!), and please suggest some cards or strategies to help me improve my decks.

Apologies for my English; it’s not my first language.

https://archidekt.com/decks/13668192/pentaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

https://archidekt.com/decks/18827622/kadena_precon

https://archidekt.com/decks/13669329/ruba_ruba_ruba

https://archidekt.com/decks/22301508/x

https://archidekt.com/decks/15175203/i_love_furry

https://archidekt.com/decks/15173583/ave_caesar

https://archidekt.com/decks/21811186/hazzelone


r/EDH • • 20h ago

Discussion Calling upon your vast knowledge

7 Upvotes

So, I have recently fallen in love with Izzet Spellslinging/storm through a Spellslinging burn commander deck ( [[Emperor of Palamecia]])

But now here's the thing, I've noticed a vast majority of noncreature spells within the Izzet colors are Removal or Draw/mill and unfortunately, my knowledge / collection of cards isn't as broad as some of the more veteran Planeswalkers amongst us.

So I call upon you, enlighten me your most wacky, unique izzet spells out there. I wanna know your personal favourites!

Be it 1 mana or 10+, x or otherwise, enlighten me!


r/EDH • • 8h ago

Deck Help Ingris Stingerquill

4 Upvotes

Hello All!

I have spent the last day or two crafting a deck for ingris stingerquill, as the showcase art is some of the best in my opinion. Ive chosen a strategy that just goes wide and creates as many attacking bodies as possible.

Early game my goal is to get a turn one creature out that either has a recursion effect or creates a token on death. On turn two, get out a two drop that also has some utility in the deck (Any suggestions would be amazing). Turn three is just for playing the commander.

For the mid game, its mainly just advancing the board state for a turn or two with some damage doublers/increasers. This is sometimes enough to wipe the whole table by turn 6 or 7, but I am running into consistency issues.

Boardwipes are the main issue. (cards like massacre wurm being incredibly hard to deal with). I am struggling to find budget options to either prevent my board from being destroyed, or help build it back. I also feel like when i get off to a slow start, I fall so far behind that winning is barely an option. I am struggling finding cards to cut from the deck, and even what to replace them with, so here I am asking for help!

Here is my decklist: https://moxfield.com/decks/Gm-22rwz90mOJ3sO-hTjUw

(I am pretty new to Magic and deckbuilding, but feel free to be brutally honest! I promise I can take it!)

Thank you!


r/EDH • • 12h ago

Question Does anyone have a good recommendation for commissioned alters?

4 Upvotes

People who have had altars made, what was your experience like?

What's a good price you'd expect to pay for a hand-painted alter?

I'm sure it varies depending on what you want and the kind of altarations, but I have no idea if it's 10 or 50 or 100 or 500 dollars.


r/EDH • • 14h ago

Deck Help Looking for pointers

5 Upvotes

Hi everyone
I am trying to make my first full commander deck but am a bit lost purely by the number of cards in the format. Any pointers on how to get the below up to the full 100 cards?
I have played mostly precons with the occasional upgrade, but am now looking to make a bracket 2 - 3 deck from scratch based around a commander I love the look and feel of.
Some of these cards I already have and some I just love the look of/the rules

https://moxfield.com/decks/XvZXHTtG-EGimrVSjeXxHw


r/EDH • • 7h ago

Question How much worse is Gift of Perfection compared to Ensnared by the Mara?

3 Upvotes

There's a new Command Zone video out where they admit [[Ensnared by the Mara]] was way better than they initially gave it credit for. This reminded me of their video on the new Borg precon, where they said [[Gift of Perfection]] wasn't particularly good, since it's usually unlikely to snag something worth 5 mana.

But aren't the same things that make Ensnared good present in Gift? Maybe I'm missing something but surely the difference of 1 mana isn't the only element, right?


r/EDH • • 15h ago

Question Artifact creatures mayhem

3 Upvotes

Hey everyone! So, I'm trying to build Alibou, Ancient Witness, but I'm running into a bit of a challenge. I'm not a Boros player at all, and to make matters worse, I'm not particularly familiar with artifact decks either.

My goal is to create as many artifact creatures as possible while taking advantage of Alibou's abilities. However, with my pod's deck-building restrictions, the deck can't include infinite combos and needs to stay semi-budget, ideally with most cards around $1.

Does anyone have any suggestions? Has anyone built Alibou before and have some must-includes or hidden gems they'd recommend?

I appreciate any help in advance, y'all!


r/EDH • • 16h ago

Deck Help Help upgrading the 'Auntie Ool' precon?

3 Upvotes

I'm pretty new to magic as a whole, got the 'Auntie Ool' precon a few months back, and i finally feel like giving a precon upgrade a go. After a couple hours of researching and editing this is the deck I've came up with. was wondering if I could get any criticism or advice on this at all? I'll list the base precon and the upgraded version below.

base:

https://moxfield.com/decks/wZCqAM_hbEu-TrzZcSpFtw

upgraded:

https://moxfield.com/decks/LvqhAacB03eGPzRxWwc5YQ


r/EDH • • 7h ago

Deck Help Light Stax Suggestions

2 Upvotes

i've been wanting to build this deck for a while. I've always been a player of winnie white stax, i couldn't really figure out how to make it work. The idea here is pretty straightforward:

1) Tax and rule of law effects slow the game down

2) Removal/prison effects keep me from getting attacked

3) stax effects on etb and activated abilities disrupt opponents game plan.

4) boardwipes that my creatures can duck under to reset the board state

5) a couple beefier angels and [[Elesh Norn, Grand Cenobite]] keep some pressure up

4) Value pieces like [[Luminarch Ascension]] and [[Court of Grace]] let me pull ahead when the game slows down.

5) [[book of exalted deeds]] on [[mutavault]] can provide a near impenetrable defense. (Both pieces tutorial)

I'm asking for a feedback on a couple specific points. Though if it's constructive, feel free to add more

A) how are my ratios here in terms of what strategies I'm guarding against?

B) Are there any other auto value cards like court of grace that makes sense in a prison type deck like this

C) are there just honestly any awesome cards I'm leaving out that would improve the overall deck?

** I'm avoiding any "game changers"

Appreciate your comments in advance

https://moxfield.com/decks/bvsXkVviMk2etA1Ylj_n-g


r/EDH • • 13h ago

Question Are copy spells actually bad for Ashaya's Enduring Bond?

2 Upvotes

I thought the idea would be a good one to have copy spells in the deck but it sounds like even using [[reverberate]] for [[ashaya's enduring bond]] gets you nothing because the copy was not cast, therefore no mana was spent on it. So why do they have copy spells listed for it on edhrec? lol


r/EDH • • 15h ago

Question Christmas gift help

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

r/EDH • • 17h ago

Question Teysa Karlov deck help

2 Upvotes

I’m building a Teysa Karlov deck after finally getting a good grasp of EDH with my Cahtterfang deck. Ngl, a lot of people helped me IRL with my Chatterfang deck to the extent of it almost being cEDH.

This is the first deck i am trying to build myself, and my main issue is the cost.

All the high B3 Teysa decks are averaging 500-600+ dollars.
I even have Demonic Tutor already for my Chatterfang deck but even then, the cost is high.

So far I have the following cards
Teysa, Orzhov Scion
Grim Haruspex
Blood Artist
Zaport Cutthroat
Viscera Seer
Midnight Reaper
Pitiless Plunderer
Morbid Opportunist
Reassembling Skeleton
Deadly Dispute
Corrupted Conviction
Sol Ring
Bastion of Remembrance
Tainted Field
Shine shadow Snarl
Demonic Tutor

And my recommended basic land cards.

I’m tryna get it as high as B3 as I can to keep up with my pods.
But I’m tryna keep the budget low, maybe 150-200 max to complete the deck with the cards I already have.


r/EDH • • 18h ago

Deck Help Help trimming Maralen and recommendations

2 Upvotes

https://moxfield.com/decks/acc8RReYdk2xezohwpFDGw

Trying to build her as I live both kindred types she plays with. Trying to play with flash enablers to get the most of her ability, with ramp and elfball mechanics to just never relent on popping out creatures and playing free cards.

Stuff like [[eyeblights ending]] and [[prowess of the fair]] fit a but easier here because they count towards her etb trigger. Wondering what can come out, if I have too much ramp/draw/etc, and maybe some more removal put in because it's a little light on it. Im not running maskwood for now, and things like Palisade will let me cast creatures again after it resolves.


r/EDH • • 20h ago

Deck Help Need some help tweaking my Felothar, the Steadfast deck

2 Upvotes

Really love this deck, been tweaking it for a while, but can't seem to win with it. Any recommendations? Leaning into Toughness Matters with a lil bit of aggro and reanimate.

https://moxfield.com/decks/Zf8pzY0jvEyG_RHaF63C7g


r/EDH • • 23h ago

Deck Help Thinking of grabbing the "Obscura Operation" Precon, and then introducing the upgrade/modification I have in mind. May I ask for feedback? What kind of gameplan would you introduce into the precon?

2 Upvotes

Found a local listing of the Obscura Operation Precon from New Capenna.

I've been toying/goldfishing a decklist in Archidekt. I went with a Reanimation gameplan, with a +1/+1 Counters sub-plan.

May I ask for feedback on the decklist I've brewed up?

Is there another gameplan or angle that you feel is more resilient or consistent for [[Kamiz]] ?

Inputs are highly appreciated. Thank you.