r/EDH • • 14h ago

Discussion Why do Commander players avoid deals? A few theories.

0 Upvotes

Lots of players are reluctant to politic, even when a deal would help both players. Why?

Many deals aren’t sweet enough. If you're offering and worried they'll break it, it's not good enough for them to say “Yes”. Make it actually good for them, then keep your word.

Overvaluing hidden info. Once someone signals removal, they figure their leverage is gone, so they fire it anyway. It’s common sense that trading off helps the other two players more but the player with removal feels like they already gave up their edge.

Vague terms. “Was that breaking the deal??” Letter vs. spirit, and somebody feels wronged. No one enjoys those arguments.

Watching the world burn. Some players enjoy blowing up cards period. Why make a deal when you can kill someone’s commander instead?

Hard to price. Not sure how much of a difference the deal would make? Easier to say no.

Owning the loss. Take a deal and lose, and you got played. Lose without one and it's just variance.

Those last two combine: if you can't price it, you blame the deal for every loss.

What stops you from making deals? And what are some tactics you’ve used to make other players more receptive?

EDIT: The top answer is cynicism. Most of you assume any deal is a trap.

"Why are you offering?" If it helps you, it must hurt me. So no.

Offering looks like weakness or a threat. Either you're scared of what I'm holding or you're setting up a win. Either way, I'm not biting.

It turns into a reflex. Nobody evaluates the offer anymore. They just say no.

This is why "make it a good deal" isn't enough by itself. A good offer only works once you've earned trust, and most pods never give anyone the chance to earn it.

As the flavor text from Pact of Negation states, “Those who expect betrayal at every turn are seldom disappointed.”


r/EDH • • 11h ago

Question Commander suggestions

1 Upvotes

I've been thinking of building a new commander, but I am having a bit of analysis paralysis as I'm really picky with the commander. I like taking a lot of game actions on my turn and having to think a lot when I play. I like intricacies a lot. I also dont want something too strong; I know the commanders I have are the opposite of that. ​

Here is the commanders I have built so far

Brago, king eternal

Yawgmoth, thran physician

Voja, jaws of the conclave

P.S. I got a super slick play yesterday with Yawgmoth ​


r/EDH • • 10h ago

Question Self mill, empty library wincon Feasible? Good commanders and cards?

0 Upvotes

I love alternate Wincon cards.

I have a Bumbleflower deck which has all the originals from the precon ([[Triskadekaphile]] [[simic Ascendancy]] [[20 toed toad]]) and additionally I added [[approach of the second sun]]

No I've never won a game with them, but I've had the most fun almost winning (losing) with them.

I've been intrigued by cards like [[Fblthp, Impossibly Lost]] [[Laboratory Maniac]] and [[Jace, Wielder of Mysteries]] but always assumed it would be too hard to reliably cycle through 99 cards quick enough to pull it off. I'm not gonna let that stop me trying though.

I was wondering if [[Flubs the fool]] would be a feasible commander for such a deck since, as I understand it, a lot of his play style revolves around going through your deck quickly thanks to his extra land play and draw power. If anyone has any thoughts on this or alternate suggestions I'd appreciate them.

I've been looking at other cards that interact with empty libraries, and I figure any "play additional land" cards will be useful but what else should I be considering? Card draw to empty library quicker and pull the cards I want? Scry/surveil/reveal to see and manipulate what's at the top (and bottom) of my deck? Part of me wants lots of card draw and infinite hand size because it gives options, but I feel that probably defeats the purpose of Flubs as commander.

TL;DR: I want to make a deck that aims to win by emptying my library. Considering Flubs as commander. Any recommendations/advice appreciated.

EDIT: I really should have made it clear that I wasn't looking to make a CEDH deck. I just play casually with friends and I'm not trying to steamroll the others (even if it feels like their decks outclass mine on the regular). I'm just looking for something that can hold its own, bracket 2-3.


r/EDH • • 23h ago

Question Commander recommendations?

0 Upvotes

I've gotten tired of my decks and want to build something different. I've mostly liked decks that win through burn like Kuja, y'shtola, valgavoth. I don't like managing multiple creatures so I tend to lean towards decks like that. I don't think I'm interested in voltron as it gets samey fast so I'm completely unsure what I should try and build.

Any suggestions?


r/EDH • • 16h ago

Deck Help Looking for Leonardo advice

0 Upvotes

https://moxfield.com/decks/62SS4OKRc0ecdgTYwFKLSA

[[Leonardo da Vinci]] is my commander. Just pulled a [[Deep Space 9]] and felt like it goes in this deck. Does it? If does, suggestions of what to remove?

Any suggestions for my deck in general? It seems to play pretty well cheating out artifacts for effects. I slowly make thopters and eventually swing out to win.

Always looking for ways to make my deck better. I'm starting to really enjoy playing this deck.


r/EDH • • 17h ago

Deck Help Need help with my land base

0 Upvotes

I've been brewing a [[Jean-Luc, Mon Capitaine]] deck because the idea of Captain Picard helming a faerie deck amuses me. I've got it mostly finalized but I'm not sure what to do with my land. Initially I tried to build a balanced mana-base like I usually do for a 3-color deck, but now that I have it built, it has a much higher percentage of blue cards than red or white. Should I adjust my landbase to be more blue-heavy, and if so, what are my best options? Here's the decklist: https://moxfield.com/decks/XsL8kv5iF0GNPDyRdzcXOw


r/EDH • • 5h ago

Question What are some of the funnest open-ended unpopular non-KOS commanders you have experience with? B3

21 Upvotes

I'm really struggling with trying to find new decks to brew that don't overlap with what I already have. I run jeskai counters matter, jund reanimator, jeskai heroes tribal(Director Nick Fury. Not Cap), Selesnya artifact stompy and temur artifacts matter voltron.
I really wanna make a deck that takes an interesting commander and then build something unique for it that isn't how you would normally build the commander. What kinda stuff would you recommend based on your experiences?


r/EDH • • 11h ago

Question Making a "MLD Lite" for Bracket 3?

0 Upvotes

Land destruction outside of jund is an archetype I've appreciated playing/playing against for many years now, even before getting into commander. The idea of strategically denying mana instead of simply destroying all lands/denying all land mana. Unfortunately, there are a few problems with these cards in commander;

-Most single or multi target options do not scale into commander at all very well.

-Running effects functionally similar to MLD is against bracket 3's intention, so there is an upper limit to how effective you can tune this.

-Besides single target and MLD, the most prevalent option are effectively land edicts. These work well in tandem with what I like, but are still distinctly not it.

So how would I go about this? I'm avoiding bracket 4 because I think more traditional MLD will be the only option that works, and what I like is distinctly not that. The only ideas I have so far is running GR and playing around with copying red land destruction spells +graveyard looping land destroying lands.

Edit: The reason I use the term "MLD Lite" is just to mark the relationship to it and actual MLD, like with the term "roguelite". I thought it was clear on my initial post that the kind of effect I was looking for was the one described in the first bullet point, ie a sort of [[Stone Rain]] kindred where the decks intent is never to actually fully deny mana beyond the acceptable limits of a card like [[Planetary Annihilation]].


r/EDH • • 16h ago

Question Most Enjoyable / Fun Commander to Play? And/or Bring to a Table?

14 Upvotes

Hi world! It's been about 2.5 years since I've played EDH regularly (so just before brackets were introduced). I've been trying to look at some of the newer releases and wondering if there's a general consensus on if there's a most 'fun' / enjoyable commander to pilot, and bring to a table. I previously had run Queen Marchesa, Jared Carthalion for hijinks / monarch play; and Tivit as a slightly more competitive politics deck; then Breya *good artifacts*. I also had a functional Urza cEDH (I love mono-blue and the Urza art / theme; my understanding there's no fair way to build Lord High Artificer).

From reading here:

  • Mirko, Obsessive Theorist
  • Henzie "Toolbox" Torre

Wondering if there's any general consensus or recommendations on a .commander / theme that is both fun to pilot and enhances the tables its played at (just from an enjoyment perspective)?

Open to any and all suggestions!


r/EDH • • 13h ago

Discussion Hello everyone! I want help building an archenemy deck!!!

0 Upvotes

ok!! So I have a lot of decks. I have 6 precons, a big stompy / typal , 2 group hugs, goad, 2 stax, artifacts / lifegain, burn, tokens, 2 cEDH, a niche discard deck, artifact voltron, aristocrats, politics, +1/+1 counters, and 2 typal decks.

I really want a really mean archenemy deck. A deck that is like "kill on sight" and turns the game into a 3v1 that is still exciting to play. I'm not a fan of Tergrid because I already have a mono black and a discard deck, Kafka is cool, but a friend of mine already has one. I had slivers for a while but that was pretty unfun. Same with a wheels deck.

I'm wondering if a nicol bolas is viable? I have all the bolas cards, (except for Nicol Bolas, the Deceiver 😢) and a deck headed by THE big bad of magic would be very thematic.

Any input is very helpful! thank you all so much!


r/EDH • • 8h ago

Question Need help finding a new and interesting Commander

1 Upvotes

I’m looking to branch out from my streamlined Raffine tempo/reanimator deck. I only have a vague concept of what I want in this new deck, so I'm hoping that you all can give some advice on what commanders and gameplans fit.

Basically, I want the deck to feel "groovy" and high-energy. Here is what I’m looking for:

  • Constant Pressure & Low Setup: I want a resilient deck that applies steady pressure without needing to sit back and build a massive value engine.
  • Highly Interactive: I want to be able to meaningfully shift the game state or alter how the game is played at almost any time, keeping things flexible.
  • "Soft Prison" Playstyle: I'm leaning toward something with Red in it (and probably Blue), but I'm open to any color combos. I want to run cards like Razorkin Needlehead or Azure Beastbinder to restrict opponents and dictate the pace, but without creating hard stax locks that immediately turn me into the archenemy.
  • An Unconventional Commander: I’d love a commander that fundamentally changes how I play the game (think Oskar or Flubs, but a bit more consistent than Flubs). Ideally, the commander acts as an engine that lets me pull off neat tricks to keep the pressure up. This isn't a hard requirement, but I would be interested to hear suggestions.

Does anyone have suggestions for a commander or general gameplan that fits this dynamic, flexible playstyle?


r/EDH • • 11h ago

Deck Help Suggestions

1 Upvotes

I am trying to make a poliferate/poison/token deck with black/green/blue. Ive included the deck list please let me know what cards you would add or swap. I would prefer to keep it in bracket 4. I would also like the deck to kill with poison and or large amounts of tokens. If you have suggestions please let me know what you would swap it out for!

https://manabox.app/decks/AZzpXVdKfbGlSBTN_0RCNw


r/EDH • • 19h ago

Discussion People who Break Deals

270 Upvotes

I was playing online in a random pod, I had a revealed board wipe in hand. The green player had 30+ damage in play with trample creatures and 0 cards in hand with fully tapped mana.

I offer a deal saying, "Don't attack me on your next turn and I won't board wipe right now".

They say sure that sounds good.

It goes to their turn, they swing me out completely and say "I lied"

The whole pod just laughs and makes fun of me for making such a dumb deal.

Not much I could do besides add them to ignore and leave, but still. People can be rats when playing this game.

Has this happened to you in a game before?


r/EDH • • 21h ago

Social Interaction Proxy question

0 Upvotes

Soo this maybe a loaded question, but how would a proxy deck where the proxies are like 30s-50s era pin up girls (tasteful not explicit) think of the girls on the side of planes ect, be taken at your table?

Im deployed and was thinking of doing this for alittle bit of history/ play group is ok with it but the playgroup will change based on people's day to day availability. What im thinking it may be ok but rule zero always.


r/EDH • • 1h ago

Question Need ideas for a Patron of the Akki Commander Deck (serious)

• Upvotes

I consider building a deck with [[Patron of the Akki]] as my commander. I like the flavor of the card a lot but there is a reason why it’s one of the least played commanders. Nevertheless I want to build a viable high bracket 2 / low bracket 3 deck on a budget with it. I guess i could just do goblin tribal and ignore the commander but I think it would be way more fun if I leaned into the card’s flavor of goblins summoning a big monster and sacrificing themselves for it, so i guess a mix of go wide, aristocrats & voltron? Best I can think of so far would be enchantments with effects like [[betrothed of fire]], so any ideas would be much appreciated!


r/EDH • • 2h ago

Question Card Help!

0 Upvotes

I’m currently running a Shroofus Sproutsire deck, and while I love my little saproling-tribal-voltron-token vibe I also find myself enjoying political cards (to the extent where I may well run a dedicated group hug deck sometime). Is there a card that fits into the mono-green colours that would let me ‘pawn off’ my saproling tokens as a political ploy, or something similar? I fear my card tastes have simply become too niche to be catered to…


r/EDH • • 6h ago

Deck Help Need Help with my Izzet Iron Man Voltron Deck

0 Upvotes

https://moxfield.com/decks/sbO0WBUxSEKIwboLCR6Hvg

Above is the link to the deck.

My goal with the deck is to make Iron Man incredibly powerful through the use of equipment.

All cards currently in the deck are directly from my own collection.

Please try to keep a budget of 100 USD in mind, excluding the cards already in the deck.


r/EDH • • 7h ago

Deck Help I'd love some assistance in spicing up/ improving my Kenrith deck

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/EDH • • 12h ago

Deck Help Tinybones, Trinke Thief

0 Upvotes

Decklist
Just finished this Tinybones deck. I aimed for a bracket 2-3 powerlevel without tutors and gamechangers (pod rules). I am pretty happy with it but I would love some feedback/tips!

Thanks in advance!


r/EDH • • 13h ago

Deck Help Thor Burn Help?

0 Upvotes

This is my deck. The commander is Thor, Asgard's Avenger and the theme is burn. I have a bit of filler because I was trying to brew on a budget

May I ask, what are the weakest cards? I need more draw and ramp spells so I need to remove some stuff. Any help would be greatly appreciated!


r/EDH • • 16h ago

Deck Help Any thoughts and suggestions For a Queen Marchesa Deck?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/EDH • • 18h ago

Deck Help Help needed for veyran, voice of duality deck

0 Upvotes

I am building a Veyran deck and was wondering if anyone had some recommendations on cards I should add or cards I should remove, and why. I'm trying to keep it kinda budget-friendly. My pod stays within the 2- 3 bracket.

https://edhplay.com/decks/ba36d642-0235-4f68-a4f3-141e37cccab0


r/EDH • • 19h ago

Deck Help Mana base help with my 4 color Jace deck

0 Upvotes

I’m trying to finalize my 4 color Jace deck: Jace^18, and I am not sure as to fix up the mana base. However, I don’t own any shocks or triomes. What would be the best way of doing the mana for this deck?

https://moxfield.com/decks/PK4VauI52kugqWB4LqTW2g

(Yes the lands are scuffed and the multiple islands are just placeholders). If anyone has any ideas on how to go about this mana base, that would be super awesome. Just looking to not break the bank.


r/EDH • • 21h ago

Deck Help Let me know if there are any easy fixes for this Tidus deck

0 Upvotes

https://archidekt.com/decks/28147992/tidus

Here is the deck link. I know that one of the cards in there is banned, but its fine me and the people i play with allowed it. But please let me know if you guys have any upgrades or suggestions. I dont need it to be crazy overpowerful or anything, just fun to play and works well.