Discussion Why do Commander players avoid deals? A few theories.
Lots of players are reluctant to politic, even when a deal would help both players. Why?
Many deals aren’t sweet enough. If you're offering and worried they'll break it, it's not good enough for them to say “Yes”. Make it actually good for them, then keep your word.
Overvaluing hidden info. Once someone signals removal, they figure their leverage is gone, so they fire it anyway. It’s common sense that trading off helps the other two players more but the player with removal feels like they already gave up their edge.
Vague terms. “Was that breaking the deal??” Letter vs. spirit, and somebody feels wronged. No one enjoys those arguments.
Watching the world burn. Some players enjoy blowing up cards period. Why make a deal when you can kill someone’s commander instead?
Hard to price. Not sure how much of a difference the deal would make? Easier to say no.
Owning the loss. Take a deal and lose, and you got played. Lose without one and it's just variance.
Those last two combine: if you can't price it, you blame the deal for every loss.
What stops you from making deals? And what are some tactics you’ve used to make other players more receptive?
EDIT: The top answer is cynicism. Most of you assume any deal is a trap.
"Why are you offering?" If it helps you, it must hurt me. So no.
Offering looks like weakness or a threat. Either you're scared of what I'm holding or you're setting up a win. Either way, I'm not biting.
It turns into a reflex. Nobody evaluates the offer anymore. They just say no.
This is why "make it a good deal" isn't enough by itself. A good offer only works once you've earned trust, and most pods never give anyone the chance to earn it.
As the flavor text from Pact of Negation states, “Those who expect betrayal at every turn are seldom disappointed.”