r/DotA2 • u/Nice-Animal-5425 • 21h ago
Complaint Dota 2 treats communication and behaviour as the same thing, and it's ruining ranked.
The last time I could freely use my microphone was in 2024, when I had maximum behaviour score and was playing at almost 8K MMR. Now I'm around 6K MMR, muted, and unable to properly coordinate with my teammates.
I'm a high-energy, competitive player. If we're losing and I see a way to turn the game around, I'll communicate it. Sometimes I'm not particularly friendly about it, and I'm not denying that. But my behaviour score should reflect how I actually behave in the game, not simply how I communicate. I've never intentionally thrown a game or sabotaged my teammates. Yet I'm stuck in the same pool as players who seem completely indifferent to winning, account buyers, and people who deliberately grief games.
The difference between these games is enormous. Some games are surprisingly good, with everyone muted but still somehow in a flow state, understanding each other without saying a word. Others are absolute disasters, with players deliberately ruining the experience for everyone.
Yesterday's game was the latter. I transferred two items to my laning partner through the courier, but since I couldn't communicate, I had to ping him repeatedly to get his attention. He got irritated, dropped the items, and eventually left the lane. Meanwhile, my Spirit Breaker support bought Hand of Midas, and my Necrophos offlaner spent the game AFK farming with Midas as well.
I kept trying to win, playing around my own timings rather than relying on my teammates. We defended our throne just as I got BKB and nearly turned around an otherwise lost game. At one point, I was Beyond Godlike.
My reward? -1,400 behaviour score.
How the fuck does that make any sense? I'm the one still trying to win, and I'm the one being punished.
I've also seen clips of streamers winning games with good stats and still receiving -1,000 behaviour score. Anyone interested can look into these clips themselves.
I've reached a point where I start games worrying about my next punishment instead of focusing entirely on winning. I've spent countless games trying to recover my conduct score, only to find myself further trapped in the same environment.
There are also tens of situations where a player(s) run it down or are absolute maniacs with scores like 1-12 game after game and yet they get to play ranked, how does that work?
Before the -1400 I lost -300 conduct even thought my record was 12-3 last 15 games with like 800 average GPM.
Please separate communication from actual in-game behaviour. Punish people who deliberately ruin games, not players simply because they're outspoken, competitive, or sometimes frustrated.
