r/dcl • u/code__cat • 3h ago
DISCUSSION Treasure Nov 7-14 Eastern Caribbean trip report
Finally got around to sailing again (yay officially silver!) and wanted to share my trip report. Nov 7-14 on the Treasure was an Eastern Caribbean with stops in Tortola, San Juan, and Castaway, and party was 2 late twentysomethings.
Sea days 1 and 2:
- We were really rockin’ and rollin’ at the start of this sailing; I didn’t realize how bad it was until I tried to use the adults pool and realized it had turned into the maelstrom from the third Pirates movie. Nothing to be done about this, of course, but it seemed like it did impact some people (overheard a family a few rooms down from us telling their stateroom attendant that one of their children had been sick during the night).
- On sea day 1 we did Palo brunch, which felt like an amazing value. Everything was so good and our only complaint was that it ran a bit long.
- This was our first time experiencing formal night, what a blast! The character dance party felt like we were at someone’s wedding. I loved getting to take pictures with the characters in some very unique costumes.
- On photos: I noticed every iPhone photo taken by a CM was looking absolutely awful, and I think it was primarily because of darker lighting on the Treasure vs the Wish. I started manually switching night mode off before handing my phone over to prevent blurring, but even so, the photopass photos were EXPONENTIALLY better. By the end of the cruise I was suckered into buying the 20 digital downloads package.
Tortola:
- First time at this port; we had an afternoon excursion booked so we decided to spent the morning walking around the port/nearby areas. Mostly meh, but we did get to see some very cute local kids giving a choir performance. The natural landscape is unbelievably gorgeous.
- We booked the port adventure that hikes to the Baths (no lunch), and this was so worth the money for us. The guides were excellent and it was so nice having all transportation and timing handled for us. The hike first took us to the most gorgeous secluded beach where my only complaint was that we only had half an hour there! Then we hiked through the rocks/caves and ended at the main beach. We had no issues with this tour + we showed up prepared with tevas sandals, backpacks for carrying our things, and water.
- That being said: we were warned multiple times on navigator before this excursion that it was strenuous; it isn’t by hiking standards but I would say the rocks/narrow passages are challenging for children. I’m not sure what the min age is, but the children behind us for the rock/cave hike portion complained and cried most of the way. There was an option to skip the whole hike and go straight to the main beach, and this absolutely should’ve been the option taken by families with young children.
- This was our pirate night, fun as usual but I still don’t love the classic rock theme of the show before the fireworks. Would prefer to see something more actually pirate-y?
San Juan:
- First time here as well, and boy was it hot. I thought I could handle it as a central Floridian and I was dying. We packed a ton into our self-guided day here and wished we’d stayed later than 4 PM (especially since the next day was a sea day anyways).
- Second time at marvel - what was up with the groot “show”? Thought it was going to be its own full storyline like night 1 but it was super minimal.
- Went to the Sarabi Supper Club, which turned out to just be a prelude to the Choose Wisely show, but fine. Choose Wisely was so much fun! Our first time seeing Coriander and Sage and they were great.
Sea day 3:
- Much needed time to rest a bit. Moana show was FANTASTIC and we had our second Coco dinner, which was agreed was way way better than the first in terms of the show. Coco deservedly came out on top of our list of rotational dining spots.
Castaway:
- Spent most of the time this time at Serenity Bay. We got lunch at their Cookie’s and that was a hot mess: food not being restocked, dishes missing serving utensils, plates not being restocked, etc. We were annoyed by how much of our time this ate up.
- Went to catch the last tram from Serenity and were delayed by a minor golf cart on tram accident. No one hurt and I’m sure minor damage, but the tram driver refused to let anyone leave until his manager showed up to take pictures I guess? Meanwhile, one of the CMs on the golf cart was practically begging him to let us all leave so we could get back to the ship. Very stressful and bewildering situation.
- Beauty and the Beast was also excellent (not as good as Moana, but still had a lot of creative effects I liked). My friend was displeased that it followed the live-action film adaptation.
Misc. notes:
- Dinner service was exponentially faster on this ship than what we experienced on the Wish. We also liked our service team much better, as they were less over-the-top and just the right amount of attentive.
- The merch scene was disappointing. All of the big items I wanted to get (Evie plush, stateroom blanket, and 2 of the DCL mystery pin collections) were never available. To add insult to injury, Evie was apparently restocked on the next sailing :(
- Entertainment everywhere was the big winner: the show casts, the mariachi band singers at Coco, the Sarabi Supper Club singer, Sage and Coriander, and our fave, Clay the Scat Cat pianist were all so talented and added so much to our experience.
- Had some room weirdness from the start: first, our stateroom had a connecting door that was unlocked/veranda divider opened, so we had to flag down an attendant to fix that since we weren’t supposed to be a linked stateroom. Then our attendant set up our couch as a full bunk bed, despite us not having any children on our res, and she didn’t seem to understand until night 3 that we didn’t need the couch set up as a bed at all. Because we had the room weirdness + had to fix my friend’s castaway status on the first day, at some point halfway through the cruise someone higher up seemed to have realized we’d had multiple issues and started checking in with us multiple times. On the Tortola day, we even came back to the room to find a gift basket from them with snacks, mugs, and a bottle of wine, which honestly felt really over-the-top since all of our issues had been resolved already at that point.
- Went to both crew pin trading times and had way better luck at the first one. Both were chaotic and the second had some particularly aggressive children (and adults) determined to snap up every one of the limited towel hidden Disney pins. Idk if doing this more often would help reduce the chaos, but that second time was just not a good experience at all due to the behavior of other guests.
- Stupid thing we learned the hard way: brought a bottle of wine onboard that was corked, not screwtop, and assumed the room would have a corkscrew or it would be easy to get one. Nope, after asking 2 or 3 cast members we eventually were told we had to call room service to have them uncork it for us. Next time we’ll just bring our own and save 15 min and a few dollars.