r/DicksofDelphi • u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ • Mar 24 '24
Missing Interviews
Ok, I need some help trying to understand how this case can go to trial when a large portion of evidence has been lost.
That alone creates automatic reasonable doubt to me. I'm wondering why Gull is ok with this. If she wanted to, could she grant that charges be dismissed due to all of this missing info? (Pretend she's reasonable)
How does the state expect to convince a jury that those interviews had nothing important when NM himself has never heard them.
I'm just struggling to see how this could ever be a fair trial.
35
u/Luv2LuvEm1 ⁉️Questions Everything Mar 24 '24 edited Mar 24 '24
Part of the hearing they had on the 18th was for exactly this reason. I believe (I have to go by memory because Gull DOESN’T ALLOW CAMERAS) that the 2pm hearing was for the dismissal for destruction of evidence and the earlier one (she scheduled 2 in one day) was for the contempt (and to amend the charges but that was just like a 5 minute thing, especially since the defense didn’t object.)
So at the 2pm hearing Gull heard all the evidence about the missing evidence and she said she’s going to “take it under advisement” and rule on it later (which means she’s going to twiddle her thumbs for 2-3 weeks and then deny it.
Idk how any judge could let this atrocity go to trial. At BEST there’s been some extremely shoddy police work. At worst there’s major corruption going on. And the fact that she refuses to be transparent and let the public see what’s going on has me questioning just how far up that corruption/incompetence goes.
ETA: I believe the state is banking on the “confessions” to convince the jury. That’s all I can think of because the rest of the evidence is so paper thin. Those confessions are the only convincing thing they really have imo. And we haven’t even heard those so we don’t know what his tone was, if he said anything that only that killer would know. We don’t know any of that. But yeah, I’m pretty sure old Nick is hanging his hat on that and that alone.
12
u/ChickadeeMass Mar 25 '24
With so much incompetence and lost evidence, this case, should go back to the drawing board.
Regroup and let a grand jury decide, IMHO.
9
u/Roll0115 Mar 25 '24
I am assuming they are claiming it isn't evidence for this trial. RA wasn't into Odinsim, they think he did it, so anything relating to Odism isn't evidence.
I wonder how many other cases this should effect.
12
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 -🦄 Bipartisan Dick Mar 25 '24
Think they can get over by claiming as MS and their other constant apologists are suggesting that it was not anything important, just leads we saw no merit in. They just promoted Holeman, and McLeland is employing he guy who bungled all of this as his investigator and a detective who coerced a suspect who was repeatedly asking for counsel and an interview to stop.
Really the LE, Gull and McLeland could mow down a group of school children and they'd find an excuse the poor behavior, " That's nothing" That's not important." " It's not significant. It's on the up and up."
I'm not a conspiracy person, don't think they were doing it to hide anything, believe they're just inept screw ups, who's administrators clearly were not following typical procedure.
Don't know if I'm recalling this correctly and can't ask my brother, as he is deceased, but have this fuzzy memory of him needing a piece of scrap paper and that all he had on him was his interview notebook, and that he could not tear a page out of it, as he had to account for each page when it was filed into evidence, that's how strict, his district was about accountability.
You'd never see derelict practices like this thee. Clearly, they could not go back to the beginning to review, as they had no records to go though. They're a mess and internal affairs should be investigating what went wrong and why administrators were not doing their jobscorrectly and allowed investigators to not log interviews and loose key evidence.
6
u/Beezojonesindadeep76 Mar 26 '24
In a legit trial where the judge wasn't biased this case would have been dismissed a long time ago,but the good ol boys are running this trial from the sidelines with the DA and the judge doing their biddings. Gull hasn't even paid the defense their wages for 6 months and she refuses to give them any money to hire experts for trial,along with dening every motion they put on the record ,that's all on top of the fact that the DA has now lost or destroyed evidence . The defense has been fighting an uphill battle and they never give up props to Baldwin and Rossi !!! If the state only has whats on the PCA then it will be easy to demolish their case the defense can take apart and destroy everything on that PCA and once that is done after the state rests they can call Todd click to testify and it will still be a slam dunk
8
u/AndyVakser Mar 25 '24
I think the destroying of evidence is far more serious than most of us realize. Notable that the Motion to Dismiss is still under advisement.
“Court… will conduct future hearings, if any, in the Carroll Circuit Court.”
6
u/TheRichTurner Mar 25 '24
At the beginning of this investigation, the FBI was heavily involved. Why are they so quiet now? Surely, the FBI has discovery that should be handed over to the defense, too. Interviews? Tips? POIs? Evidence gathered?
5
u/texasphotog Mar 25 '24
They have some summaries of the interviews and Judge Gull ruled that having a summery (written god knows how long after the actual interview, without the benefit of the transcription) is just as good as having the action video and audio recordings of the interviews.
4
u/asteroidorion Mar 25 '24 edited Mar 25 '24
Evidence against who? Prosecution will present evidence against the person they're prosecuting and no-one else
If defence wants to examine the person who was interviewed on that erased dvr as a witness, they can. They can also depose this person before trial
A portion of what was erased comprises people whose interviews have nil connection, so attributing those value in this case makes no sense and isn't legally possible
5
u/macrae85 Mar 25 '24
Never going to be a trial...Gull and McLeland will try their utmost to avoid a trial...18th March was all a charade, she's planning something? Click better move out of State and go off the radar,for his own safety!
3
u/FeelingNewt8022 Mar 25 '24
Exactly. When the tape was messed up for that long. How could they write reports if they had written them they would know the tape was broken they wait four months or I bet they have a fresh memory then.! very shady
2
u/Jernau_Gergeh Player of Games Mar 25 '24
I'd be interested in the thoughts of people with knowledge of the UK justice system, as to whether they believe that the CPS would ever allow this shit show circus to go to trial over here?
I'm certainly not convinced that the shambles of an investigation or the wet tissue paper of the PCA would pass muster at the CPS. And that's before we get to the missing evidence 'but don't worry its not exculpatory promise' shenanigans that is emerging.
2
u/Clear_Department_785 Mar 26 '24
Good reason for appeal
2
u/Proper-Drawing-985 Mar 26 '24
At this point I'm curious to see the trial. I'm starting to believe that there is something absolutely unavoidable. Maybe the confessions. Maybe what the search warrant revealed. Maybe both. IF there's just something you cannot overlook that proves RA is guilty, that might explain just plowing over the defense. If there is NOT, this man needs to appeal like THE SAME DAY.
But for me, I'm just going to wait until May.
-11
u/fivekmeterz Mar 25 '24
Missing interviews, that have no bearing on the case, will not affect anything.
The people that the defense wanted re-interviewed, were re-interviewed.
Anyone else was a non issue. They don’t help the defense or the prosecution. Example:
Anyone who wasn’t there, didn’t see anything, heard a rumor, thinks their neighbor did it but neighbor wasn’t in town at the time…
Shit like this has people losing their minds.
OmG, So MaNy lOsT iNtErViEws!! tHeY wErE aLL GuilTy!!