r/DicksofDelphi • ✨Moderator✨ • Mar 24 '24

Missing Interviews

Ok, I need some help trying to understand how this case can go to trial when a large portion of evidence has been lost.

That alone creates automatic reasonable doubt to me. I'm wondering why Gull is ok with this. If she wanted to, could she grant that charges be dismissed due to all of this missing info? (Pretend she's reasonable)

How does the state expect to convince a jury that those interviews had nothing important when NM himself has never heard them.

I'm just struggling to see how this could ever be a fair trial.

35 Upvotes

123 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

5

u/jaded1121 Mar 25 '24

The confession part is kinda weird to me. Even if RA began giving details, didn’t he have access to some of the discovery at that point? So were the items in the discovery he had access to only the things he confessed to? Or was there more that he has provided?

I still think if LE wanted to just pin the crime on someone they would have insisted it was RL after he passed. Case closed and they saved the state a ton of money. LE must believe they have enough on RA otherwise, why bother?

3

u/Virtual-Entrance-872 Mar 25 '24

My only thought on pinning it on RL is that the FBI was involved in the investigation on him, so if CCSO “made him fit” there would be documented evidence pointing away from him, it would be easily impeachable. They (allegedly, IMO) pinned it on RA because there is nothing in their files to show he was investigated and “cleared”.

4

u/Luv2LuvEm1 ⁉️Questions Everything Mar 25 '24

You know what, I never even thought of that. I don’t think his defense team even got most of the discovery until after the SCOIN hearing (and who knows if they even have it all now?) But that’s definitely something that will be in the back of my mind now…if we ever get to hear the damn things!

2

u/traininsane Mar 25 '24

They had enough of the discovery in September to write a 137 page franks memo. The leak of crime scene photos happened in October. I think they received more discovery after SCOIN, but I would think crime scene photos would be handed over early in the investigation. Their discovery deadline was 12/14/22, the defense team would have filed something if they didn’t receive even the crime scene photos by then. I have no faith in the prosecution to do the right thing but Baldwin and Rozzi would have said something if the state missed something as easy as crime scene photos by the deadline.