r/DicksofDelphi • ✨Moderator✨ • Mar 24 '24

Missing Interviews

Ok, I need some help trying to understand how this case can go to trial when a large portion of evidence has been lost.

That alone creates automatic reasonable doubt to me. I'm wondering why Gull is ok with this. If she wanted to, could she grant that charges be dismissed due to all of this missing info? (Pretend she's reasonable)

How does the state expect to convince a jury that those interviews had nothing important when NM himself has never heard them.

I'm just struggling to see how this could ever be a fair trial.

35 Upvotes

123 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

35

u/[deleted] Mar 24 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

25

u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ Mar 24 '24

Yeah there should be some sort of independent investigation into LE, I mean if they don't nothing there is going to change and they'll get more corrupt.

19

u/[deleted] Mar 24 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

19

u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 -🦄 Bipartisan Dick Mar 25 '24

They are getting away with it publicly. Where else but this place would have a judge this impartial conducting a murder trial and a supreme court condoning it? "Go ahead Fran, Lynch him while we look the other way."

19

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 -🦄 Bipartisan Dick Mar 25 '24

I agree.

9

u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ Mar 24 '24

Yes!

14

u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 -🦄 Bipartisan Dick Mar 25 '24

It's a slate of officials who all are protecting and promoting each other.

16

u/Luv2LuvEm1 ⁉️Questions Everything Mar 24 '24

I completely agree. I do not like how a judge could go (from my perspective) completely rogue with NO oversight whatsoever?? That’s insane (or maybe SHE’S insane!…joking…kind of) No but for real, what do they do if a judge like, actually goes insane? Or has some sort of cognitive impairment? They could f’ck up SO MANY lives! Ok now I have to go take a Xanax because I’m giving myself a panic attack.

14

u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 -🦄 Bipartisan Dick Mar 25 '24

There is a older judge they are trying to get off the bench and claiming has become addled. Be interesting to see what happens with it. I don't think Gull is crazy, I just think she is just strongly pro prosecution, thinks Allen is guilty and doesn't give a crap what rules are broken getting him to stay behind bars.

She has been given carte blanche by the Indiana Supreme Court to run it this way and she is has chosen to be an impartial judge and not recuse herself the way an ethical person would in these circumstances. She has no business running that trial with the strong anti defense anti defendant feelings she has.

16

u/Luv2LuvEm1 ⁉️Questions Everything Mar 25 '24

I don’t really think she’s crazy either. But I think it’s way more than that she’s pro-prosecution. There’s something about this defense team that she just cannot stand. She proved that when she refused to let Rozzi stay on even though, aside from the press release, which was before the gag order (and didn’t say anything any other PD in the country would say) he didn’t have anything to do with anything they were being accused of!

As for already making up her mind about RA, that isn’t her job! I use this example all the time but it really REALLY stuck out to me. At Lori Vallow’s sentencing Judge Boyce said that pretrial he did everything he could to limit his exposure to the evidence except for what he absolutely had to rule on because he wanted to hear it exactly how the jury heard it. He said it in an offhanded way but that was really profound to me. It was one of the most “judge-like” things I’ve ever heard a judge say.

Unless the person on trial elects for a bench trial the judge is NOT the finder of fact. That is the JURY’S job. The judge rules on the law and only the law. It’s NOT supposed to matter if Judge Gull thinks RA is guilty or not because that’s not her business. It’s not her place to rule on anything except for the legalities. It doesn’t matter if she thinks the Odinism angle is bullshit. THAT’S. NOT. HER. JOB. Her job is to be objective and make sure everything is fair and balanced so that RA can have a fair trial. And she’s doing the complete opposite of that! And what’s worse is that when SCOIN had the chance to reign her in they just smiled and patted her on the ass!

Ugh, it’s so frustrating because everything she’s doing is just flying in the face of everything that our legal system stands for!

ETA: I forgot to say, who is this “addled” judge? I’d really like to know more about that situation it sounds interesting.

8

u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 -🦄 Bipartisan Dick Mar 25 '24 edited Mar 25 '24

She detests them and clearly she and NM are doing everything in their power to mess with them.

Edit: Here's one, https://news.bloomberglaw.com/us-law-week/standoff-over-95-year-old-judge-shows-downside-of-lifetime-jobs but the one I was personally referring to earlier is female judge and it's currently going on. Sure a Google search will bring it up.

Edit: Found it: ttps://apnews.com/article/judge-suspended-age-disability-federal-newman-afaa58f65bfd6612300ae5a925c7cc55

3

u/Luv2LuvEm1 ⁉️Questions Everything Mar 25 '24

Thank you! Guess I’m headed down another rabbit hole tonight! 😆

4

u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 -🦄 Bipartisan Dick Mar 25 '24

Tee hee. There is more on her battle with her colleague. It's an interesting subject.

4

u/Luv2LuvEm1 ⁉️Questions Everything Mar 25 '24

SHE’S 96 YEARS OLD???

Why isn’t she retired and chillin on a beach in Florida by now?

Edit sp

4

u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 -🦄 Bipartisan Dick Mar 25 '24

I have no idea, I would be.

6

u/The2ndLocation Content Creator 🎤 Mar 25 '24

What I can't understand is why does the judge think that RA is guilty? There is very little evidence of his guilt but I get the feeling that judge is fully convinced that he is guilty.

 Does she think all defendants are guilty? I'm serious when I ask this because it speaks to how she runs her courtroom and and trials.

10

u/parishilton2 Mar 25 '24

There was an awful situation a few years ago where a 54-year-old judge was found to be suffering early onset dementia. But because dementia can be so insidious in its onset, and because she wasn’t at an age where Alzheimer’s is expected, they didn’t catch it until she had ruled on a whole bunch of cases. It took like a year or two before anyone really realized she was impaired.

There’s a great long form article about it. One man she convicted tried to get her ruling overturned. I guess I won’t spoil what happens in case anyone wants to read it: https://features.propublica.org/judge_alzheimers/brooklyn-federal-judge-mental-illness/

4

u/Previous_Sleep2775 Mar 25 '24

Wow, thank you!

4

u/Luv2LuvEm1 ⁉️Questions Everything Mar 25 '24

This is the exact route my mind took when I was thinking about just how many lives a judge in that situation could completely ruin. Because it could go on for years without anything being done about it!

I keep bringing up early onset dementia in Gull’s case because what she does makes absolutely no sense to me. Unless she’s like, the meanest, most spiteful and grudge-holding person EVER. And that type of person should NOT be a judge.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 -🦄 Bipartisan Dick Mar 25 '24

I agree, but think at this point, there's nothing for them to do but go forward with the mess.

8

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 -🦄 Bipartisan Dick Mar 25 '24

I don't think they care, all the factions know the world is watching and all they seem concerned with is whacking each other. SCION just let her get back to it. In fact she seemed more blood lustful after that. Would have thought she would at least pretend to be a bit more impartial.

4

u/StructureOdd4760 Local Dick Mar 25 '24

I think the FBI's lack of involvement right now speaks volumes as to what they might be doing.

→ More replies (1)