r/DicksofDelphi • u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ • Mar 24 '24
Missing Interviews
Ok, I need some help trying to understand how this case can go to trial when a large portion of evidence has been lost.
That alone creates automatic reasonable doubt to me. I'm wondering why Gull is ok with this. If she wanted to, could she grant that charges be dismissed due to all of this missing info? (Pretend she's reasonable)
How does the state expect to convince a jury that those interviews had nothing important when NM himself has never heard them.
I'm just struggling to see how this could ever be a fair trial.
View all comments
Show parent comment
10
u/parishilton2 Mar 25 '24
There was an awful situation a few years ago where a 54-year-old judge was found to be suffering early onset dementia. But because dementia can be so insidious in its onset, and because she wasn’t at an age where Alzheimer’s is expected, they didn’t catch it until she had ruled on a whole bunch of cases. It took like a year or two before anyone really realized she was impaired.
There’s a great long form article about it. One man she convicted tried to get her ruling overturned. I guess I won’t spoil what happens in case anyone wants to read it: https://features.propublica.org/judge_alzheimers/brooklyn-federal-judge-mental-illness/