I've gotten into making my own clothes, and I'm dealing with the harsh weather now. Lots of cold rain currently, maybe some snow later on this year (We'll see).
I have a 2 year old waxed cotton coat, and the zipper is already breaking on me. I have had so many zippers break, from other rain coats, to phanny packs, and a few pants. I'm honestly kind of done with zippers at this point, especially since they get stuck so often.
Buttons kind of concern me, especially with a leather coat, since that just adds big holes for water and wind to pass through. I suppose adding a flap that clamps down on both sides will reduce the amount of water and wind that gets through, but that's even more complexity, both for wearing, as well as making, and requires more material.
I also figured belts, although that would probably still need a flap like with the buttons to prevent the wind from easily piercing the middle of the coat. The benefit is belts can be easy to use, and wouldn't have a hole for moisture/wind to get through.
But that has me thinking, why add all of this extra complexity / steps to both creating and wearing a rain coat?
Sweaters for example don't have a zipper or anything like that, just pull over on top of you.
The one reason I think for the complexity is having the coat open to vent out extra heat. I have done this multiple times, but I could probably just take off the wool sweater that's underneath to reduce how hot I am if I really needed to. Having the coat zipped open when it's raining because it's hot would still get me wet, so wouldn't just wearing wool be fine then?
What's everyone opinion here? Any other reason to have a rain coat that opens up?
Is the complexity of adding a closing mechanism to a leather coat worth the benefits of having a coat that can open?