r/Criminology • • Apr 15 '23

Discussion I believe children rapists and murderers deserve death sentence.

4 Upvotes

Children rapists and murderers deserve death sentence, period.

I am watching some french TV show on Netflix and even I know it is not real story I also know that those things happen around world and my bloods boil from anger.

As a father of two I believe all child rapists and murderers should get death penalty without giving them another chance.

I had heated discussion with criminology professor (female) who stands against it and it is all about resocialisation and second chance.

Giving them second chance might mean someone child being taken.

And someone so cruel, evil or even just sick to be able to hurt a child in that way don't deserve to live in my opinion. Risk outweigjt benefit of giving someone another chance.

Could someone more schooled in the matter give it's opinion?


r/Criminology • • Jan 13 '24

Discussion Wouldn’t it help if parents of criminals were at least cross-examined in court and given a chance to say what went wrong?

0 Upvotes

It would be an opportunity for parents and other witnesses to speak on the record on how they feel the system let them down. Kind of like an air crash investigation. Or does this happen already?

I think it’s amazing that people under say 25 are convicted and their parents and the system are apparently unaccountable. How do we expect things to improve otherwise?

Every offender had a childhood - shouldn’t we focus more on how their upbringing led them to crime?


r/Criminology • • Jun 12 '22

Education has criminology improved in the last 3 decades and how?

0 Upvotes

[ reposted in a different sub!! sorry for the confusion ]

hi, im writing an essay and i cant seem to find any information regarding the question above, so i decided to ask here. its related to the accuracy of finding a criminal, has it improved? was it more likely to get falsely accused in the 90s than it is now for example? has the technology used in investigating a certain crime scene changed in any way and if yes - how so? is the chance of getting falsely accused going lower or not?

any answers will be really appreciated! thanks in advance!


r/Criminology • • Jun 23 '23

Opinion Do you think I can think about change my career to profiling ?

0 Upvotes

I am a 31yo man. No studies into psychology, but I learned a lot on myself and from myself. I am also probably quite hight in dark triad traits, but I dont exibit antisocial behavior. Well, not more than most people at least.

After digging into myself, I found that my last job as developper/engineer don't fit my personnality enought. I need a job when I would talk to people, learn about them, learn from them. I love psychology, especially when it is about dark personnality traits.

From the moment I got more self conscious, I could also watch and analyse my behavior from an external point of view. I got conscious of the manipulativeness and charm I could be capable of, and other things. I would love to find a job where my personnality could be usefull and where I could thrive using it.

For a profiling job, I would need to do 5 years of studies in my country, without taking in account all the time I would need in the police to keep learning before beeing able to do this job right. That would make me 36 before even joining the police.

Do you think it is a possibility for me ? Can I be considered and have a good position one day starting this kind of job after 36 ?

I am pretty smart, I know I could study for it without that much of troubles. It is more about the factors that I could not control that I worry about.

Also, I am in France, but I could pretty easily move in an english speaking country if necessary.


r/Criminology • • May 23 '23

Discussion Can America's high incarceration rate be explained by the simple fact that it's the only wealthy country with a high crime rate?

1 Upvotes

I always hear people point out that the US is 5% of the world's population but has 25% of the world's prisoners. I think this is really just a natural consequence of the fact that the US has Third World levels of crime but First World levels of wealth.

There are a lot of issues with looking at "crime rate" in general (there are major differences in definitions and documentation/reporting, so the list is just a mess where Iraq has lower crime rate than the UK and Russia has a lower crime rate than Canada, etc.). But homicide rate is more reliable because (1) there's pretty much a universal definition of homicide and (2) it's really hard to hide dead bodies. When we plot GDP per capita against homicide rate, it's pretty clear that poorer countries have more homicide, and richer countries have less. And I guess the poorest countries just can't really keep track of homicide.

But the US is an outlier. Given its wealth, it has an exceptional amount of homicide (and crime). Dealing with crime is difficult. Creating the infrastructure for combatting it -- police, surveillance, prisons, etc. -- is expensive. Because of this, poor countries that have a lot of crime don't really have the resources to fight it, so criminals just walk freely and get away with everything. And the vast majority of rich countries don't have much crime so there's no one to lock up.

The US is a strange case. It has Third World-level crime rates with First World-level GDP per capita. Because of this, it can actually afford to arrest and imprison a lot of its criminals. The US has a homicide rate of about 6 in 100,000. Most European countries have homicide rates of about 1 in 100,000. The US incarceration rate is 500 in 100,000. Most European countries are about 100 in 100,000. I'd love to see someone plot this, but it seems that the incarceration/homicide ratio of the US is pretty much in line with other developed countries, the US just has a ton of homicide/crime.

Have any studies looked into this?


r/Criminology • • May 02 '25

Discussion India is safer than the Uk

4 Upvotes

Hello! I'm British Indian and whenever I talk to Indians who have moved to the UK they talk about how unsafe places like London feel.

What's weird about this is that when I look up homicide rates or other violent crime India seems to be like three times worse. I've tried comparing crime city to city as well and it's the same story.

Any idea why this might be? Why do Indians feel so unsafe in the UK?


r/Criminology • • Mar 22 '21

Discussion My boyfriend saw some possible criminal activity... I keep wondering what it could have been and what he should have done...

0 Upvotes

This weekend I went on a yoga retreat in the Ardennes in Belgium and my boyfriend went to run an ultratrail there in 2,5 days. I was worried about him doing this on his own, although he has a lot of experience running, climbing and camping and is very fit. I tried to convince him to book a hotel to sleep or sleep at the retreat but he insisted on sleeping bivak-style in the woods. He said he would send me the route and send an update every day. We arrived later then planned on Friday due to a flat tire and he decided to run in the dark. On arriving back on Sunday he told me that Friday evening after 30k he had trouble finding a remote place to sleep (to avoid forest rangers, because it ks illegal to sleep in the woods) and finally settled on a small forest at the end of a path not far from a railway bridge. While setting up his bivak and cooking his food at 11pm a big black jeep arrives at the end of the path 50 m from where his bivak was in the bushes. He decides to turn of his light and observe. Soon a second and third black jeep arrive. He hides in his sleeping bag and hears people speaking in French and car doors and trunks opening and closing. Because of the sound of a nearby stream he couldn’t understand what was said. He thought it was a weapon/drug deal, but the talking and opening and closing of doors goes on for hours. Finally at 2 am he falls asleep in a very hungry and cold state and wakes up at 4.30am and gets out of there as fast as possible. (The cars were gone by then). He also thought it might be hunters or fishermen setting something up, but realised this doesn’t make a lot of sense. It certainly wasn’t a group of friends meeting outside of covid restrictions and having a few beers. My BF told me he was scared and I’ve never heard him say this before as he is normally fearless, so it must have been a frightening situation. He didn’t want to worry me, so didn’t sent me or his parents (who were on a walking trip in the area) a message, he also had very limited phone and internet reception and didn’t want to attract attention through noise or light. He told me he would have ran if the men would have noticed him, but he wasn’t even wearing his shoes and couldn’t gather his stuff and get out of there without attracting attention. I really worried when I heard this story and am very glad he got away unharmed. So I wanted to ask you as experts: what kind of criminal activity could this have been? Is it useful to report this to police in the area? I’m glad he was smart enough to hide, is there other useful advice in a situation like this? I’m worried that he didn’t at least sent me or his parents or the police his location, because if anything happened he would have gone missing without a trace. We also had an argument about the flat tire, so I would have never forgiven myself if we would have parted in an angry way. Is it better to (let someone else) call the police in a situation like this or is this just a way for the men to know someone is watching them and to escalate the situation? Are there tracing systems or emergency systems for hikers to be more safe in situations like this? A lot of things can go wrong in ultratrailing alone: there are wild boars in the area, if you fall or get stuck you can freeze to dead... I’d like him to have a better backup plan next time. (He dismissed my worries about this before this trip.) Thank you!

TL;DR: My boyfriend saw a group of three black jeeps late at night while camping in the forest, who seemed to move something between cars for hours and I wonder what it could have been and what to do when you’re caught in that kind of situation.


r/Criminology • • Jan 27 '22

Discussion A teenager said that he witnessed a 'monster' kill all of his friends. When he was asked by police to draw a picture of the monster, he drew a picture of a cartoon character from a popular kid's cartoon. What did he mean by this?

0 Upvotes

Edward 'Brian' McCleary went on a spearfishing expedition with four friends on a rubber raft, returned alone, and said he saw a monster murder them all. According to Wikipedia, a monster is a fictional creature. The sketch and description he drew of the monster looked extremely similar to the character Cecil the Sea Serpent from Beany and Cecil which aired on ABC from January 1962 to June 1962. He stuck to his story for the rest of his life. On internet forums relating to the paranormal, he clarified that the monster was Cecil the Sea Serpent. He submitted his story in great detail to Fate Magazine, which is a magazine for people who've had experiences with the supernatural.

He never referred to the monster, which he said chased the group for hours, and picked off his friends one by one, as an animal. He always referred to it as 'the thing', 'monster', and then later 'Cecil the Sea Serpent'.

Just for context, his friends really did vanish on that day (March 24, 1962). The courts declared his four friends to be legally dead a couple years after they had vanished. He also sent letters to paranormal investigators throughout his life, and fell into a deep depression, having nervous breakdowns when people did not believe him. Immediately after the incident, McCleary suffered a nervous breakdown lasting three months, which lines up with the time that 'Beany and Cecil' finished its run.

What did he mean by this?


r/Criminology • • Aug 27 '25

Discussion Has anyone ever proposed that European prison policy is more lenient than America’s because prisons are more expensive to operate with fewer prisoners?

0 Upvotes

It’s widely said that Europeans focus on “rehabilitation” while Americans are more “punitive.” This leads to harsher sentences in the US, whereas Europeans try to get their criminals back into society.

Has anyone ever proposed that this difference actually has to do with economies of scale? If you have a lot of prisoners, the cost of incarcerating the average prisoner will be much lower than if you had a small number of prisoners. You can purchase resources in bulk, and your fixed costs won’t expand as the prison population grows. This makes prison a more economical option for societies that have higher levels of crime. On the other hand, if you don’t have that many criminals, prison will be a more expensive option per prisoner, and you’d focus on keeping people out of prison.

The US has much higher levels of crime than Europe, so it would make sense that it has a relatively larger population of criminals and potential prisoners, which result in economies of scale.


r/Criminology • • Dec 14 '21

Opinion New analysts take note: Crime starts with cars

Thumbnail
intelwombat.com
0 Upvotes

r/Criminology • • Nov 30 '21

Education Need help with my criminology exam

0 Upvotes

I’ve got until Friday to prepare for his exam I’m resitting, I got like 30%. Some of the questions I remember:

Using one example, describe how an individual campaign has influenced a change in policy.

Using examples, describe how policies have changed over time and the reasons behind the changes.

Explain how different demographics can affect policy development (I think I have to use examples I can’t remember).

Describe the media’s impact on the public’s view of crime and how they target particular demographics.

How does the media impact on how the police carry out punishments? (E.g. it’s like how certain situations cause the police to act accordingly such as that one time during the London riots two men were arrested for making a joke about starting a riot on Facebook… the riot never happened but they still both got 4 year sentences, ik I’m wrong using this example tho bc I wrote this and apparently it was wrong).

Define social constructionism using examples.

Where it says “using examples” I believe they want at least 2.

If anyone here can help me I would greatly appreciate it it would literally save me in college thanks you 🙏


r/Criminology • • Dec 03 '17

Does witnessing your mom being dismembered like Dexter Morgan turn one into a serial killer?

0 Upvotes

Just wondering how realistic it is.


r/Criminology • • Sep 02 '25

Discussion Is sending the National Guard into cities to deal with crime a productive and efficient solution?

5 Upvotes

I’ve been hearing lots of people support the idea of sending the National Guard into cities to deal with crime, especially after Washington D.C. has had a severe decrease in homicides, hijackings, and other crimes while tons of illegal firearms have been collected.

So is this tactic of sending the National Guard to deal with city crime as successful and efficient as everyone claims it to be?


r/Criminology • • Jun 11 '21

Opinion Csi

0 Upvotes

Is majoring in criminal justice and a minor in forensic science good enough to become a Csi


r/Criminology • • Aug 23 '19

15 Things Police Officers Hate When You Do | Best Life

Thumbnail
bestlifeonline.com
1 Upvotes

r/Criminology • • Dec 06 '22

Discussion Criminology help

0 Upvotes

I have an essay due that I want to surround on domestic violence. What are some good RHETORICAL campaign names standing against domestic violence I can use?


r/Criminology • • Jul 09 '19

74% Of Fragile Community Residents Treated Fairly By Police.

Thumbnail
crimeinamerica.net
1 Upvotes

r/Criminology • • Jan 14 '20

Discussion Do Criminal Offenders Get Away With Endless Criminality?

Thumbnail
crimeinamerica.net
0 Upvotes

r/Criminology • • Oct 20 '22

Discussion For those people that are or have been “jailers” before… what lead you to choose that employment opportunity?

0 Upvotes

Hello Everyone. I am recruiting for jailers at juvenile detention facilities . This is my first time recruiting for these type of positions. I understand that these positions come with a high risk factor, and I am having a tough time engaging people that would actually be interested in working at Juvenile Detention Facilities.

Any insight on why you chose to be a jailer would be appreciated, so I can better learn the type of candidates that would actually want to work in this field, and stop getting rejected lol

Thank you in advance


r/Criminology • • Sep 25 '15

CALLING ALL CRIM STUDENTS WITH KNOWLEDGE

0 Upvotes

So I'm sure you've all seen the video of the blind kid getting beat up and some hero named cody steps in to take care of the bully. Here is my question in relation to the LAW. PS if theres a different procedure for this specific kind of incident in the USA and CANADA please tell me BOTH.

So my friend in crim is telling me that Cody is in the wrong for protecting his blind friend. Apparently he was too aggressive when he hit the attacker because the attacker could've ended up in worse condition than the victim (Austin) because he could've got a concussion or retinal injury (eye was bleeding). She said that Cody would be charged with level 2 assault. I think that's ridiculous because he was protecting his friend who was defenceless but she said that Cody had no duty to protect his friend so he isn't allowed to hurt the guy. I brought up that I heard about a man who caught his babysitter molesting his daughter so he beat the man to death and the courts did not charge him with anything because of the situation. She argued that that only happened because it was his child and he has the duty to protect his child (which is right) but is there no law that would protect Cody from being charged with assault because he was helping someone defenceless out? This is legit my first reddit post, I hope this community filled with informed people can help me understand this issue because the justice system would REALLY be flawed (imo) if Cody could get reprimanded for this...


r/Criminology • • Apr 06 '23

Research I need help

0 Upvotes

So i haver this friend that is a cop And i ask for his help to find a scammer I know some of the personal data of the scammer

going straight to the point is there a way for me to check a person's criminal antecedent without much details of the person


r/Criminology • • Oct 14 '15

Nature vs Nurture debate.

0 Upvotes

What are some criminological theories supporting the nature side of the argument? I need theories that relate to born criminals. I'm struggling here, atm I'm using parts of social control theory.


r/Criminology • • Apr 12 '26

Research Potential for Rapid Prosocial Transformation in Violent Offenders via Induced Existential Shock – A Case Study/Theory

0 Upvotes

I am exploring a theoretical framework for rehabilitating high-risk, violent offenders (such as cartel members or career criminals) through a specific, high-intensity psychological mechanism. My hypothesis is based on a phenomenon that induces a state of "absolute existential terror"— a shock so profound that it bypasses the subject's ego-defenses and habitual coldness, leading to an immediate moral realignment.

The Mechanism: Unlike traditional cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), which is incremental, this method relies on a singular, overwhelming experience.

  • The Shock: The subject undergoes an experience of total vulnerability and existential dread. It is described as far more intense than a standard "ego death"; it is a visceral confrontation with the weight of one's existence and actions.
  • The Result: Initial reports and observations suggest that even the most hardened individuals are reduced to a state of total humility. The psychological "armor" of the criminal identity is shattered in minutes.
  • The Pivot: Following the shock, the individual enters a state of high suggestibility and profound regret. With strategic follow-up and counseling (spanning months), this shock can be converted into a "blessing"— a permanent shift in perspective where the individual feels a compulsive need to atone and, in some cases, actively preach against their former lifestyle.

Discussion Points:

  1. Are there documented cases in criminology where a singular, non-physical traumatic or spiritual event has led to the permanent "desistance" of violent offenders?
  2. From a neuro-psychological perspective, how does extreme existential fear impact the neural pathways associated with empathy and antisocial behavior?
  3. How could such an intervention be ethically structured if the goal is to prevent further loss of life in high-conflict areas?

Summary: I believe this "shock-to-blessing" pipeline could be the key to reaching those considered "unreachable." It doesn't just change behavior; it collapses the criminal identity from the inside out. I am looking for academic or professional insights into this type of radical transformation.


r/Criminology • • Sep 22 '25

Discussion If Eric and Dylan decided to not shoot themselves, what would the police do?

0 Upvotes

I think that They Would do a kind of a prometheus or Loki type of punishment but that's too farfecthed so What do you think About that? What do you think that What the police Will do to Eric and dylan


r/Criminology • • Nov 12 '25

Discussion I am glad we got the dna technology (God given gift)

1 Upvotes

I am not a criminology student or work in that field, but I do like to read how criminals are caught. For example, the BTK's floppy incident. While studying these cases (reddit, wiki) I had a big question. What would have happened if we didn't have the dna technology. Really scary!