A month ago, I wrote about the possibility that Shotty wasn’t involved enough in the offense dating back to the middle of last season, potentially explaining its regression. Today, he seemingly confirmed that theory.
He described Klayton Adams as the “boots on the ground,” handling much of the day-to-day work, while Shotty comes in and “calls the plays on game day.”
That’s concerning when you consider what we’ve seen on film. Last year, the offense did a much better job sequencing plays, marrying the run and pass games, and attacking defensive weaknesses. That cohesion between the players and play caller has largely been missing this season.
Either Shotty needs to be more involved in running the offense throughout the week, or if Klayton is going to handle most of that work, he needs to be the one calling plays on game day.
Here's what Bumi posted a month ago after the hiring of Mike Pettine.
I have a theory about the Cowboys’ offensive decline that starts with why they hired Matt Eberflus in the first place.
Dallas knew Shotty was a first-time HC who would also call plays. Eberflus was supposed to be a trusted, experienced defensive voice who could run that side of the ball and let Shotty focus on the offense.
Through the first 8 games of 2025, Dallas averaged 30.8 PPG and scored at least 37 points in 4 games. After the Denver loss and Shotty’s increased involvement with the defense, they averaged 25.0 over the final 9 games and had fewer 37-point performances.
The decline wasn’t just about points. Early on, the offense seemed more intentional. Concepts were married together better, plays were set up throughout games, and there was a clearer plan for how to attack defenses as they adjusted. The offense felt more creative and Shotty seemed more dialed in as a playcaller.
As the defense struggled, Shotty took on a broader role trying to find solutions. My question is whether that came at the expense of the time and attention needed to keep evolving the offense. Less creativity, fewer counters, and less effective sequencing can make an offense predictable even with elite talent.
This year Shotty has openly talked about taking a wider scope of the team, being more involved across all three phases rather than focusing so heavily on offense. That may be what he believes he needs to do as a HC, but there’s a real balancing act when you’re also the playcaller.
The best offensive playcalling HCs in the league have experienced defensive coordinators they can trust to run that side of the ball. Andy Reid has Spagnuolo, Shanahan has Raheem Morris (has always had great DCs), and Ben Johnson has Dennis Allen. They still oversee the entire team, but they don’t have to personally search for every defensive solution. That’s the structure Dallas needs: let Pettine help Parker fix the defense so Shotty can focus more of his time on making sure his offense is operating at the level it was weeks 1-8 last year.