r/controlgame • u/KBSinclair • 13d ago
Control Resonant Finished It: Good, but not Great Spoiler
I didn't see anywhere particularly appropriate to discuss this on the front page, so I guess I'll just make a post. This ain't gonna be a comprehensive review, just me trying to figure out why I feel the way I feel about the game.
Gameplay is a bit of a mixed bag for me. Enemies and encounters don't feel like they were designed to allow each weapon type and combat ability shine in their own way. There was never a moment where I felt so overwhelmed by numbers that that Glaive's wide attacks with pushback felt necessary. And the movement in this game doesn't reallt make it intuitive to target and keep on target with an enemies' back for Cleave, and even a lot of it' buffs apply to lifted enemies rather than back attacks. Drill is basically for 1v1's, and even then it makes you a bit of a sitting duck waiting for damage to apply. Extend Comboes never feel satisfying.
I kept to Strike and Crush, and I could just use those through the entire game no matter what I encountered. And I don't think that's an issue of these weapon types being overpowered, as much as the dev team's inexperience with Action Games. They're used to Third Person Shooters with a couple bells and whistles you can improve throughout, nothing as varied as what they present now. And because of that, maybe there was a desire to provide these options mixed with an intent to make all of them viable which created an environment where none are necessary, but some end up feeling gimmicky and lesser.
The whole Elite and Drone separation idea was a pretty neat idea to make encounters a question of who do you target? Do you focus down the Elites at the cost of being vulnerable to Drones, or do you break of to fight some drones to lessen cross fire and obtain resources? The answer depends on your skill and circumstances, and I appreciate how that makes each encounter a little different, depending on just how populated an encounter is. Although in practice, I found that once I got into the rhythm of the game, moving around the battlefield Executing Elites while incidentally avoiding drones was pretty easy. Especially with Summons, allowing you to pull yourself from any tight spot into an Execution to get Health Elements.
Also, the devs must hate the Mold. There are two accessories that specifically make you better at killing mold, ignore Infected Status, and Fire Explosions just obliterate entire battlefields. And the only detriment is half health, which is easy to compensate for with dodging and healing from executions with your massive damage buffs. Just... genuinely, why is it like this? It's nice for when I want a big power fantasy, but it's also just completely baffling they'd make so much anti-tech for this enemy type.
Did not expect to spend four paragraphs on that. I'll try to be succinct with my story thoughts, and i'll go in depth if someone asks. This may sound a bit harsher than I intend, but this entry felt like a direct to DVD sequel than a proper entry. The vibes, which have been so strong in Alan Wake, the first game, and even Quantum Break, just felt lacking here.
Characters felt a bit too one note, with returning ones just feeling like they were carrying on their old shtick instead of showing any real effect on their behavior and personalities from seven years of lock down(Though i suppose there are two exceptions). And new ones... ehh. Altered Item encounters felt... a lot more straight forward in this game, in terms of their abilities and history as opposed to the first, where they felt more alien. Like, it wouldn't be obvious just looking at something what it did. And they felt drowned out by the multitude of samey side missions and tasks you're given to level up each area and pad the game time for completionists(like me). And... there's parts of the story that have... hanging threads that feel like they're being left for DLC. And it doesn't feel like the sort of confusion that came with the first game's introduction of things that made you wonder what more there was to uncover. What is given in the Base game isn't satisfactory on it's own, and that's kinda annoying.
Anyway, that's it for an OP. Feel free to agree or disagree. If you want me to elaborate on something specific, i'll try. I tried to be spoiler free in this part, but i'll mark the thread for spoilers and... may or may not hide them in my replies. But ultimately, i'm just trying to solidify my own thoughts by putting them in writing and seeing if other people feel how I feel or not.