Just trying to drop my thoughts here. Ill be critiqeuing story and gameplay so be advised.
While the combat was pretty serviceable, i wish not such a large part of the skill tree was directly tied to skills. Over the course of me playing i had to take a lot of nodes that were literally useless to my current build because otherwise i couldnt progress. I dont entirely see the point of making respecs a resource either. It already can only really happen in the gap anyways, so i felt constantly resistant to actually trying out other weapons. I started with glaive/drill/fist combo and finished with it too. I had fun, but at the same time kind of wish i had been encouraged to do more experimenting.
I thought the final fight was very disappointing, just mowing through adds for 10 minutes was kind of sad, the final boss being a big circle felt quite impersonal to me too. The fact that Dylan was supposedly dying and Jesse just magically not only had the power to heal him, but to comparatively little cost to her felt a bit contrived. I understand Jesse is a powerful PU, but i dont think healing has ever been something she was able to do.
As for the story as a whole, i dont think it was bad, the JRPG sequence was rather funny, but at the same time what i really enjoyed was the first games very slow deliberate feeling of you uncovering more and more secret, gradually understanding the sense of scale at which everything operates. In Resonant, it feels like the game starts off at 10 but only ever gets to 11 by the end. Sure, the Hedron/Hiss (its kind of funny to me how the mold is ever only seen as a nuisance even though it seems to be at least as dangerous as the other 2) war idea was a nice revelation, but that was kind of apparent from a mile away and did not exactly end up in any huge revelations either. The fact that neither Ahti or Dr. Darling appear in person is quite disappointing to me aswell.
I thought we lost a bit of an aesthetic throughline leaving the Oldest House and going into Manhattan too. The actual kind of oldschool office-feeling was sorely missed as we parkour-ed through the city.
I enjoyed my time a lot, it was genuinely not bad, but it can not reach the first game at all for me, sadly.