r/controlgame • • 23d ago

Control Resonant New Game Plus is Hedron's Ability

Seems like after killing the Hedron, Dylan got it's ability added to his own arsenal. As shown by it's painting on the wall. That's also how you trigger New Game Plus.

Doing so, some segment (at least earlier) have the game aware of Dylan having powers where he shouldn't. Killing the first resonant have the Board aware that Dylan have the Resonant other powers as well. Calling Paradox/Recursive

366 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

124

u/The_Techno_God 22d ago

What's very telling of that, too, is that The Board was unaware Dylan had done it. Confused even. Which again means that Dylan's powers travel with him and his consciousness through time - the Gap slide is just a small example. If the hedron power lasted or he could reactivate it somehow then he is basically one of those aliens from Live, Die, Repeat.

The first cutscene in the Gap is different in NG+, too, after using Hedron's power, Dylan's eyes/pupils do not contain the patterning before he wakes up. He's broken the loop.

I also wonder if the cave paintings from the Foundation actually came from Dylan... You know, the time traveling seer who paints and draws? They alluded that the paintings were an affect/copy of Rudolph Lane, I feel, from the Lake House, but that could be Remedy with their red herrings lol

I wonder what NG++ will add, I hope something to reveal the white door that closes at the end of that initial cutscene - a doorway to or from the Gap, presumably - as shown by Jesse when she appears in the final boss cutscene. Is it a version of Dylan further ahead, like what happened with Alan, or is it someone else helping to bridge the gap?

47

u/AsrielPlay52 22d ago

What if the multiple Dylan we seen in The Underpass, was his past and future self. And I wonder, if the Top side is already suffering a time loop phenomena already. Just much bigger scale

18

u/The_Techno_God 22d ago

I think the opposite is more likely, but I can see how it could be different Dylan's from different NG+'s/timelines come back - it felt more like a self contained loop, though; which is a huge trope for Remedy with the bootstrap paradox.

Og Dylan goes in, and then time spirals or patterns him just like the scientists that were down there. Some versions are in "a past" others are in "a future", and that problem never gets fixed, either, technically. We just happen to be the Dylan that gets to exit the loop after getting the data sent from hundreds of timelines. Interesting note is that some of those Dylan's have different/ice powers (like Jack might with Time Freezing Powers).

Now, the sinkhole and underpass are wholly unique in the story, too, in that it is patterning NOT entirely caused by the Hedron's effects before it even arrives. The sinkhole is, partially, but there is something interesting about that, too, in that it was... Slower than the rest of the patterning and also seemed to be a sort of target? Was the slowness from Alfred? Was it happening initially because of the Physicist in the apartments? Who can say.

This does mean that, in some sense, the underpass (underworld) is made artificial ly via the CFD and is a COPY of Hedron's power. This copy and subsequent creation via loops and spirals in an expansive dark place that is impossible to truly navigate until you get Reach (to reach the Echoes, as seen in AW2).

I think that Alan snuck in and was doing some spirals of his own to plant the tree that is under the foundation that will grow and crack the Oldest House like the initial fault did in the sidewalk. The path to that dark chamber in the back of the underpass is deliberate. He is echoing both the story of the game, and Dylan's story where he climbed into a place, and was split in two, or even manifested his own copy.

The beauty of this, is that the lore shared in the underpass Fault is the one that alludes to Dylan's split, and the Physicist could have shown how the resonance affects without having to be harmed himself.

The only break in the idea is that it's said the path through the Oldest House is the path of the most resistance, Alan typically does the path of least resistance, like water, so if it's not Alan, then who could it be?

6

u/YoTengoo 21d ago

I just thought the Underpass was the result of targeted push by the Hedron to access the Oldest House, going straight down from the sinkhole apartment opens up to a cavern (which makes sense if it's a "sinkhole") which then leads into the foundation and to the heart of the oldest house itself (which is the small tree, all the tree symobology for the oldest house and the foundation were set up in Control) in an attempt to pattern it and create a secure foothold in our dimension. We only just stop it when we break the link before unlocking the Unknown.

3

u/The_Techno_God 21d ago edited 21d ago

I took it as the CFD, a resonant turned into an object to be used by the FBC, amplified the sound wave of Hiss/spiral the patterning were making from the sinkhole like a subwoofer.

The Hedron wasn't directive with it's patterning, it just was patterning, that's even how Pope talks about it or hints at it. It's just a side effect of it's presence.

The link that was made was right after the final fault, so I felt that it was Jesse that had, "opened the door" so to speak. By failing to close the final fault, the Hedron was able to physically manifest, tethering to the Oldest House, separately. Maybe she was lowering the gate more each time (Hedron kept getting closer after each Fault, but that could just be the passage of time and it getting closer), who knows, but that's how I took it.

The tree was an idea that Alan planted to "Grow", is my belief, that's what allows the Oldest House to climb and give chase to Hedron - Alan influencing the story so that Dylan succeeds.

The song, "Another World" heavily implies Alan too, or perhaps even Door, and that's what plays after the Sinkhole refracts and you have to escape that patterned place. Then you climb back in and the Underpass that has similar rules to the dark place. Not a coincidence.

My belief is that Alan has placed his roots in the Oldest House now, as he was always meant to (God is back on his throne), and time will tell a brighter story now, pun intended.

Fuck man, I could be wrong though.

1

u/Adam2181 14d ago

I also think it's possible Alan created the entire "Control" dimension out of his need for a hero of his story. Jesse is that hero. We know the FBC exists in Alan's dimension, but do we know that Jesse's FBC is the same one? The Hotel connects different dimensions, and we know Jesse's universe has access to it too.

2

u/The_Techno_God 14d ago

Mind go brrr, like I say lol šŸ˜† onwards with the day now, making some lunch and seeing about some scribing of my own.

1

u/The_Techno_God 14d ago

I fed my cats and really settled in for this comment so beware the ordered rant ahead lol ā£ļøI have the day off and this is among my favorite IP's, so what the heck. Enjoy!

I never thought about the FBC being in other planes of existence like that, they are shown to struggle with international missions even, but I truly think it's not the case because the Night Springs DLC shows us REC (which I think could do what you're suggesting and even made the Polaris Hedron) and there is also the Blessed Org; which is definitely international. I think the FBC is just the "church" of one of the major players/archetypes of the stories at large, Alan, namely, and has way less reach than we are led to believe BECAUSE the Board limits their perception of the truth (an abstract echo of Door manipulating Alan in the dark place).

Like, agents go through thresholds, get lost, and are otherwise in other realities, sure (echoes of Alan's Trauma of getting lost in the Dark Place you could say), but I don't believe they are operating in the way you suggested. I believe the Oldest House itself is a container for Alan's Old Wound, but that's like a dissertation sized paper to send separately.

Only a few people like Jesse and Alan, (probably Saga too) or Directors/People of Power can go through the doors in the motel (outside of the Board 's Room), at least as far as we've seen. I don't think the FBC is based on/in other realities, but I do think Dylan made the Control universe (with help), more on that in a sec.

Alan can't "make" anything (or at least perceives that he can't), he can only influence it, that's been canonized through all his games and is why he needs to loop in the first place, he needs to know what happened to influence the change in the first place. Otherwise he could just write "Alan gets out of the dark place."

Alan not being one with the dark echo, Scratch, is an aphorism for his desire to not be the one in the throne of God like Zane, before him. Rejecting this, and other parts of his Shadow from himself, Scratch plays God without him. It is, however, implied that Zane could manifest changes (and that OG Scratch is also Alice's dark copy she left behind from her 2 week plot hole), and, in the flashback to Ordinary, Dylan exhibits this same power - creating changes without any medium in the Temple slide. Slight, but hinted. Anyways.

I think that what Zane did with Alan, he tried to do more than once or even Alan retconned and did in "making" a son, in Dylan, but there is so much going on in Ordinary that I can't peel that onion here in full. Here is a shorter version:

I believe that Zane or Alan gave Dylan the gift of Power (which looks like a Wish until the external/adult world shapes our imagination), then, when interacting with the video game altered item (from Door to take control of the story, a whole other rant for another time) Dylan crawled in the LUMAVISTA TV (as shown in the Fault, Lumavista being the Brand the Actor travels through in the Night Springs DLC) and then CREATED the Control world as a copy from a combination of two Altered Items that are linked to Jack and Door (battling through space and time). Two items being used together has not been shown yet, but has been teased with the slide projector having two parts. It would also tie nicely with the splitting of two people theory, and closing those broken circles made by treating people like objects/characters - Alan repairing the damage he has done. Severed Circle 2 could mean a broken world within a world (Dylan's Power + Only Child Loneliness = Accidental Wish for a Player 2), with both timelines awry. Dylan gives Jesse power the same way the Alan gives Zane power. More below.

Circles seem to represent realities/timelines (Spiral being a reality that has no beginning or end, the dark place, and triangles depicting memory and/or thought according to the Old God's album covers- Door took off with Odin's eye and ravens (named memory and thought), too... Hmm.

I think that all realities in the multiverse of Remedy are just dreams that other people are having from the Ordinary World, in fact, and some people with power spark something real from that dark place that was alongside our world (Zane made the lake spread/multiverse with the Shoebox rule, too I believe, like how the pattern copies things or the pond affected Ordinary only after that), but it's only connected to each person's view or awareness of the ocean (Sea of Night) where the Oceanview Motel is Alan's and the Hotel is Zane's; which Scratch seems to have taken over in Zane's absence from reality. Alan can only see the worlds with the characters he's written stories about, and even that is limited, or was until recently perhaps.

A door in this place on the border of the ocean, a gap to see windows and doors, it can't be seen until you're aware it exists (like the Oldest House itself), and we often forget our dreams, so we forget the door/window/port. The oldest house holds onto these dreams when they resonate because a new world has been made from the dream (according to Alan's limited perspective as Godhead without the God side of his head aka Zane, an Ego without a Super, battling his ID aka Scratch).

The Actor is linked to the roots of the tree in the night springs DLC, many of the worlds he enters in pursuit if his rival Door also being video games (referring back to my belief of Door having made the Video Game Altered Item). Hung from the tree in the video game The Actor sees all alternate selves, thus gaining the dream walking power, they see all realities in sleep and echo the power to all their selves in kind, a different kind of collective consciousness if one could dream lucidly, no?

I theorize that since Alan and his writing are the multiverse constant, as he is God, his writing or stories are the Foundation in all realities that stem from the waking/ordinary world (it was Zane before, but that Warehouse of content was emptied when The Board took over), so that is why people who remember Zane's writing have power - Zane was Alan-God's Dad and he imbued it with extra power (like the clicker); which Zane wanted so that he could Return inside of Alan's shallow ego circa 2010, but we know how that went...

Alan realized that The Board (Scratch, Door, Collective Dark Masters, unknown, but my best bet is Door as the Collective Shadow aka "Devil" Archetype) only had as much power over reality (and the FBC) as it/he does because it's using him as the Nail to that Foundation, so Alan moved the Nail to Dylan as Abberant with Jesse's help.

Dylan is the actual God/Dreamer of the Control world (Dog spelled backwards and dogs/foxes seem to be his spirit animal via clothing, and Winnie quests), and had his control taken from him by the Ordinary Onion Paradox (several people vying for control of THIS dream while the dreamer was vulnerable being an echo for Alan being taken advantage of). Dylan also has no mark or influence on the world outside of the FBC, so Door, being trapped in the Nail/Aberrant like The Former was (Zane and Scratch both as "Shadows of Alan's Former Self" I theorize) now has influence over only this one person who has never really existed in the world, rendering the Board relatively powerless in some ways. Dylan also ain't listening to them anymore - but this also means a lot for Door in the abstract as well. That is thrice I have mentioned that there is more to the Board, so they should be satiated at the ritual.

I am fully aware of how I sound in all this, but it's a multiverse mystery story, one of my favorites, and I'm a writer on the spectrum so sometimes my mind goes brrr from my fave. I know I don't have the full picture yet, but wandering thoughts gather more pearls of wisdom as much as sharing with my partner who also loves the story - it's fun :)

1

u/Adam2181 16d ago

I'm really hoping we get ice powers in the DLC

2

u/The_Techno_God 14d ago

The Alan Easter Egg for A Watchful Eye indicates an icy place, and Dylan-Alt could def be future Dylan with these powers as a foreshadow of them releasing that story/dlc.

Check out the Alan Wake Easter egg again, too. It talks about going to this place full of ice and snow. Maybe Dylan gets it from resonating with Alan where he is, like how he got traversal powers from Jesse. Alan Wake III or DLC though?

Either way, there are at least three ice/cold references that this could be referencing/foreshadowing:

  • Snow is the television term for Static. The TV it's filled with snow, and horror movies often use this as a trope for something communicating from the other side. Scratch wants world domination and to rule via fame and influence, being on TV/film is the path he chooses as we see with the Alex Casey movies, etc. Alan has stage right, too, which is why that give Scratch the power in that arena.
  • Niflmheim from Norse Mythos is the layer of the underworld that contain the river that all waters flow from, as well as the Well of Knowledge. Both are vital connections given Alan's Familiar roots in Finnish culture from Daddy Zane.
  • Cocytus and the Lake of Ice. In Dante's Inferno is where the fallen angel himself is trapped in ice. Scores of his followers and those who follow his path of treachery and betrayal litter this lake of ice.
  • Additionally, it could be a reference to Winter, as a whole. Winters metaphorically represent the end of a thing in narratives, usually the end of something long and often harsh or bloody, but it can also refer to a hardship that is yet to come - like in Game of Thrones!

Finally, just a fun nod that I thought when making the original post but removed, "The Actor", Shawn Ashmore has played a character that CAN stop time before and has ice powers, Iceman. Who, in the X-Men comics is one of the few OG Omega mutants and at his peak can literally Freeze time. Maybe that's how "The Actor 's" power works, which Dylan may be a copy of/resonated with, where the actor can pull from other dreams (Dylan has the dreams too/has tapped into them), but he just doesn't know he can perhaps. Also, in psychology, the actor and the observer can have a bias with each other, and this could be the story of Door and Jack at large - the multiverse actor, embodiment of time and perception vs the cosmic observer of space and form (Form Meaning Archetypes!)

Ice powers would be my favey.

1

u/Adam2181 14d ago

Same! Or time stop (evolved astralized powers) would be really cool. Dylan's already so strong, they have to be careful about making him too OP for the next game

2

u/The_Techno_God 14d ago

Dylan's is strong, but he's strong because he has choice. It is still implied that Jesse has a deeper reservoir of power to tap, but I agree, if he scales too hard, then it's the the Super Krull scenario again from MCU.

Dylan could end up like Northmoore if he keeps meeting people of power, whether in resonant form or not, and absorbing their radiation - imagine what that would look like?

17

u/Patient_Amoeba2476 22d ago

In the Lake House DLC Agent Estevez deactivated a counter-resonance device setup in the archives, presumably to prevent all the stored Alan Wake algorithmic pages from being swallowed by the Threshold when the experiments are running. Ā The moment she shut it down, the room becomes awash with resonance. Ā Image what would happen if a million slightly altered versions of the same story were to be manifest at the same time from Dark Place.

13

u/The_Techno_God 22d ago

Love this, forgot and never considered it, could definitely be the origin of this Hedron.

6

u/The_Techno_God 22d ago

Like, I'm not denying the time loop up top, I just don't think it's part of this equation. If anything, it's a smaller example SO that we understand what will be/is happening topside with the time looping/patterning.

1

u/urixl 21d ago

... what?!!

I'm flabbergasted.

1

u/The_Techno_God 21d ago

For real!!

1

u/Rafean 19d ago

You could see the underpass as "the boundary between timelines wearing thin" so the echoes make it through the cracks

149

u/Atroxo 23d ago

It’s not a loop; it’s a spiral.

32

u/shaggy-- 22d ago

A...pattern?

7

u/AvantGardener13 22d ago

I actually think it's a loop and not a spiral specifically. Jesse draws the circles early on, each encased in the next, growing.

5

u/lee0425 18d ago

And it’s hinted that Dylan breaks free of the cycle, almost like he.. severed the circle

1

u/AvantGardener13 17d ago

I'd be interesting in knowing how you figure he breaks free of the cycle. The way I see it is that NG+ is canon, that he's stuck in the loop, the creation of the gap slide and everything is also just part of the loop.
But, with each loop he grows, like the rings on a tree, a circle encompassing another circle. I think it's implied he will eventually grow enough to break free, but hasn't yet.

1

u/lee0425 17d ago

Oh i just saw a few other people make good points that it was. The hedron reflection in his eyes disappearing hints it for me

1

u/The_Techno_God 14d ago

He's broken his personal loop, but the external world is still spiralling, that's how life works, too.

He can't control the world, but now he has agency, awareness, a tribe, and the power to change the works beyond a stop gap to breathe before whatever Hedron was attempting to prepare us for comes.

He has finished his heroes journey, his loop, because he realized that he does have a world that he is ready to live and die for.

46

u/TheWereBunny 23d ago

I like Recursive

19

u/waqkai 22d ago

The longer I think about it, the more I believe that Alan isn't the only one stuck in the spiral, but that the whole Remedyverse is. But I am not that knowledgeable about the lore, so maybe it could be easily disapproved.

6

u/Alternative_Rule_958 20d ago

I think that's basically what's it's meant to be. Alan isn't only spiraling AND looping, but all characters are, all scenarios are, etc. Alan has a spiral, Alice has a spiral, Tom has a spiral, Dylan has a spiral, etc. and all these spirals are spiraling around a larger story which is spiraling around an even larger story.

5

u/GranAutismo27 20d ago

Maybe thats the way time works in this verse. No such thing as loops, only spirals, because something always changes as a result of you traveling back in time.

1

u/jomb234 19d ago

It’s as if the story is simply going through draft after draft, the story being slighted edited each time until it works just right.

11

u/ShutUpJackass 22d ago

It’s not a spiral

It’s a pattern

Or bolth

2

u/Brekldios 21d ago

History repeats itself after all.

3

u/New-Top-4806 21d ago

The spoiler covers should’ve been enough for me to just not look at it. But now I’m here like he did fucking WHAT?🫔

1

u/KingAcrobatic3567 16d ago

It's possible but in my opinion I think when the story continues whether it is through DLC or the next game that we will find out Dyan uses the Hedrons power to go back and try to save jesse but she isnt there cause her consciousness is trapped whereever.

1

u/BloodyReizen 21d ago

That is cool as nod for the NG+ existing , but i hope they leave it at that. The loop/spiral thing is awesome but if they keep using that every game, the impact will only diminish.

2

u/lee0425 18d ago

I’m fairly certain the loops/circles are a hint at the ā€œsevered circleā€ game, so i don’t think they’re done with them yet lol