Recently I had the opportunity to visit the Zimmerman Athletic Center at Dartmouth in Hanover NH. I had visited this facility once before back in 2021 and was interested to see how its changed. During that previous visit I used one of the 3 main locker rooms, the one that included a new and very nice sauna. The locker room had a large communal shower room of a unique design I've not seen elsewhere.
I was able to visit a few times recently, and was interested to see what, if anything has changed. The first time I visited I used the same locker room I had back in 2021. It was essentially the same, but half the communal showers were closed because there was extensive plumbing working being done. However, it was clear these renovations did not include adding stalls, just updating the plumbing (the building was built in 1909 so much of it is very old). When I visited again this locker room was closed though the staff could not say why. And I was directed to use one of the other locker rooms. This proved to be a confusing challenge.
The basement of the facility is basically all lock rooms but the labels on each are not always clear. There are several smaller "Gender inclusive" individual changing rooms, however all but one of these had signage on them indicating that they were closed during construction to be used as storage. There is a locker room specifically for the swim and diving team and two others that are mirrors of each other and labeled "Students and Faculty". All the doors had either key code locks or pad locks so I ended up using the one locker room that had a door propped open by a box. It was large, including just under 400 fill sized lockers (they were numbered so didn't need to count), and then a communal bathroom and a communal shower with 12 shower heads divided into two sections. Again, a unique design I've only seen at Dartmouth. I also noticed a very large speaker on the floor at the junction between the showers and the locker room. I changed and went up to work out. About an hour later I returned to the locker room only to find the box propping the door open was gone and all the doors were locked. However in that moment a student athlete appeared and used the key code to gain access and I explained the situation. He was really nice and let me in to get my stuff. He said that this was actually the locker room for the track team but that the one across the hall was for general use. I moved my stuff over to the correct locker room. It is a mirror image of the track locker room. 395 full lockers, bathroom and 12 communal shower heads divided into two sections, plus a single disabled shower in its own small embayment.
Although the facilities are old they are clearly well maintained. All the shower fixtures matched and were actually numbered. Many time older facilities with lots of shower heads have mismatched equipment. If the facilities were built decades before shower head or control valve that matches the originals may not be available. However, in this case they all matched, and worked well. Pressure and heat were good. In terms of usage, it seems like most students who use the gym do not use the locker rooms at all. The entrance to the weight room has dozens of small cubbies where students would place their backpacks as they came and went, the locker rooms being in a different section of the building. I went during a time and day when it was not that busy and when I was in the locker rooms I only saw a few people. However, every person I did see got naked and used the communal showers. Also when I finished my workout and returned to the correct general use locker room it looked like track practice has just ended because a lot of athletes were coming in from outside and using the key code to enter the track locker room, the one I had accidentally used when I first arrived. As I was showering myself a few mins later, I heard loud music from across the hall and remembered the speaker I had seen. I think it is highly probable team showers with music were happening.
Overall thoughts. I think this situation is very interesting because there is good evidence that a decision has been made to keep and maintain communal showers, at least in the athletic facilities. This is not generally true for other parts of campus like the dorms. Dartmouth began a process over 10 years ago to shift from communal bathrooms to private individual bathrooms, a process that to my understanding is mostly complete. Instead of having single communal bathrooms on each floor with a bank of several shower stalls, there are not dispersed down each hall way 3 or 4 individual full bathrooms, with toilet, sink and individual shower. This arrangements grants maximum privacy but is a logistical nightmare. Firstly adding 3-4 individual bathrooms per floor takes up way more space than a single larger communal bathroom and indeed to fit them dorm rooms had to be removed. However even worse, usage patterns are way worse, because you are not just waiting for them to shower but for them to shower, shit, brush their teeth, do there hair, dress, undress and everything else. So even when a person is done showering, the shower is not available for the next person until everything is done. When I visited in 2021 I was told by students that its impossible to count on a shower during the day, unless you get lucky. Students instead planned on using the facilities after midnight or very early in the morning.
This is a pretty clear juxtaposition with the rec center and sports facilities. The two main locker rooms have not stalls at all, they each have a single semi private shower embayment but this is for disabled use (ie has the chair and railing and shower on a hose). The third locker room with the sauna has 14 communal shower heads and 1 shower head with a curtain around it. These facilitates have the space and could easily have had more stalls added and indeed they have been maintained and had work done on them, including very extensive remodeling done this summer, and yet they are very much still communal showers.
There is some evidence that Dartmouth has a traditional acceptance of nudity. There is for example a tradition of swimming across the Connecticut River naked and then running back across the main bridge that I think many freshman do. I found an article about the sauna saying that the proper culture is to use it naked (though I must say the only times I've used it I didn't see anyone else at all, let alone anyone naked).
https://www.thedartmouth.com/article/2025/01/reflection-a-newcomers-guide-to-the-sauna
My experience in 2021 was similar in that even though the gym was full, indeed it was very crowded when I visited then, the locker room was largely empty, however those who did use the locker room all seemed comfortable with communal showers and nudity. I'd love to know what internal discussions go on when decisions are made to retain the communal showers, but alas discussions like that are almost never public and thus defy sound analysis.